Jump to content

Tejas

Banned
  • Posts

    553
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Tejas

  1. For some very useful comments see post #140 (too much info. there to update below).

    UPDATE from previous posts (see Vietnam): We are talking about alternative where you can "live well" on a monthly income of US$1000 - 1800. The focus is on low-middle income pensioners because these are the ones being hurt most by Thailand's crazy retirement system. Pensioners with big money can retire anywhere. To include them would mean to include all countries. Healthcare, retirement visa system, infrastructure are critical for pensioners (need more info. on these items below). Also, it would be nice to get comments about Western type comforts (food, malls, etc).

    Cambodia: massive annual GNP growth, looks like Thailand; friendly people; English spoken widely; more expensive than Thailand but some say less expensive than Thailand; don't want to get sick there but close to Thailand so if it is not an emergency situation you can go to Thailand for medical care; infrastructure improving but long way to go); best visa situation in Asia and good Western food in PP and SR and SNVL. SNVL could, eventually, become the next small version of Pattaya after the international airport opens there.....lots of development plans for SNVL. Same water and sunset view as you find in Pattaya, but far fewer people.

    Philippines: safe and unsafe areas; beautiful beaches; storm problem; most people speak English; easy visa system; some possible retirement destinations are Boracay, Dumaguete, Panglao Island, Puerto Galera (avoid Manilla); one poster said this: having lived in the Philippines for 7 yrs as an expat......I can add a few comments about the place. Baguio City is one of the most livable areas in the Phil. High elevation summer capitol with moderate temperatures....but is still prone to the many typhoons that aim at the Phil every year. Weather is never boring there. Down south, there are many nice areas (the islands) that have small expat communities. Camiguin, Cebu (outside the city), Dumagetti, Bohol.....7,100 island to choose from. some 'jewels in the China seas, but lots of ruined enviornment and poor and crumbling infrastructure. Friendly people....sometimes too friendly, but always smiling like Thais. Poverty is much more obvious and the local food is swill. most violent crime is confined to the cities. Local transport is basic, but cheap. roads are the worse i've ever seen and road manners are worse than here.

    Immigration is much easier than LOS and I think cheaper.

    Malaysia: have a retirement program to attract foreigners that makes things a lot easier than it is in Thailand; you can own your own house; Malaysia would be easier for many expats (in terms of language, certain kinds of convenience, etc.) There are many more places than Penang to check out; one poster said this about Malaysia: Malaysia probably won't fall into your 1,000-1,800 criteria. For persons over 50 a deposit of $42,500 and monthly income of $2,850 (about 92,000 baht) is required. If you have a government pension of $2,850/mo or more then the deposit is not required. The official program MM2H (Malaysia My 2nd Home) is not bad if you can afford it. I have watched this program change every couple of months for the last two years - mostly good changes. You can import a car duty free (one time) oh, does not apply to motorcycles - sorry Harley. You can buy any number of homes but price has to be above $75,250 each.

    Vietnam: long coastline; storm prone; developing rapidly; health care in Hanoi reported to be excellent but not good in hinterland; one poster said "not as friendly" as Thailand; one poster said no set visa policy for retirees (think need more info. here); Retirement visa - I don't think they have one, all retirees are said to be married to VN and get 5 year resident visas (5 year resident visa is a big improvement over Thailand); one poster said: ...will be moving to live in Vietnam in a few months.I would say from my previous visits there that Vietnam certainly fulfils most if not all of the above criteria.The only difficult thing might be to find one city or town that has them all.For instance Saigon has good medical facilities but it's relatively expensive for housing and its not cool or particularly clean.Hanoi has good medical facilities,but it is quite dirty,however for part of the year it's actually cold,it certainly was when we were there in January.I've just come back from a 6 week tour of Vietnam,from Hanoi/Ha Long Bay to Hue/Da Nang/Hoi An/Nha Trang /Saigon and the Mekong Delta inc Phu Quoc island.I've been many times before and am married to a Vietnamese girl,we have a 1 year old boy as well.Out of the main tourist areas it's cheaper than Thailand,certainly housing,food and drink.Unfortunately though the medical facilities out in those places leave a lot to be desired,but then transport in Vietnam is relatively good,and if you live reasonably close to a regional airport,its cheap and easy to fly to Saigon/Hanoi.I wouldn't say English is widely spoken, but in the main tourist areas a fair number speak it.It's a lot easier to learn Vietnamese than Thai,the alphabet is similar to ours, the words are shorter and although it is a tonal language,the version of Vietnamese written today was basically invented by the French last century.The visa situation is easier there(for me anyway).Because I am married to a Vietnamese,I have a 5 year visa EXEMPTION,it's not a visa,just a sticker in my passport saying I don't need a visa.The only thing is that I can't stay in Vietnam more than 90 days at a time,so I will have to leave every 90 days(very similar to the Non O here).It may well be that I can get some sort of residence visa when I am there,I will have to find out,or maybe someone there knows the answer to that?). more on visas by one poster: Update on the visa situation for VN. I visited the immigration office in Ha Noi last week and was told by the lady that says she issues residence visas that there is no such thing as a retirement visa for VN, you can only get a 6 month visa uless you are there for work or an investor. Also being married or dependent only entitles you to a 6 month visa that can be renewed continually. If you have a visa exemption that entitles you to a 3 month stay this can be renewed continually at a cost of $10 per renewal. This is what the Immigration Officer TOLD me and did not show any written regulations to support this. I know that one TV member has managed to get a 1 year visa after completion of his work in VN but guess that may have been with the help of some $$?

    Indonesia: visa system is not that easy; Bali in expensive in some areas and not so expensive in others; Lombok has been mentioned as one other possibility; certainly Indonesia has thousands of islands; earthquake problem

    Lao PDR: Unsure if cheaper than Thailand; can be pleasant according to one poster; one poster added this about food: lovely breads and bakeries widely available and delicious

    China: Kunming is the City of Eternal Spring (sounds like cool weather); China is huge and difficult to generalize about; Zhuhai across from Macau is a popular retirement destination (nice city in my opinion). NEED RETIREMENT VISA POLICY

    Panama: Panama sensed an opportunity and developed a retiree incentive program that International Living calls the world's best. One retirement opt is based on showing a pension (or social security) of only 500 USD plus 100 USD per dependent (somebody check for accuracy). Retirees get discounts on travel, entertainment, shopping, services. But like Costa Rica so many have moved in that the country is having growing pains. Like Thailand most of the country is very hot and humid. The highland town of Boquette has a very nice climate and has been heavily promoted by International Living. And it's First World prices reflect that.

    Argentina: Argentina became the single best bargain in Latin America, possibly the world, after their monetary crisis of 2002. Literally overnight after their peso was devalued costs were 75% less in American Dollars. Unfortunately while the exchange rate has hovered around 3.8 Pesos to the Dollar rampant inflation has brought costs back up close to where they were pre-crisis. However outside of Buenos Aires there are many choices with a good quality of life that are reasonably priced. And as one of the world's largest countries there's climate and scenery that suits about anyone. They have some nice beach towns but winter weather on the coast is pretty raw. Some cities popular with expats are Mendoza, Bariloche, Salta, and Cordoba. But Buenos Aires is the big draw for foreigners, world class city if you are an urbanite; great beef. A reminder about Argentina, there is no bank account method to qualify, you must have a permanent income, or no go for the retirement visa (maybe too expensive for the pensioners in question.....not sure); Many expats make border runs on tourist cards for many years. Argentina has no problem with that. Google Buenos Aires Expats Forum for tons of info. Many Argentines speak English. The Buenos Aires Herald is an excellent newspaper in English. Still, once there you'd want to take classes and get up to speed. I think the inflation issue is serious, but it may lead to another crisis. Might be worth moving there for a few years if the Peso is devalued again. Can always plan your next move while enjoying the best steaks in the world at near giveaway prices!

    According to one poster who has been there, there are reports of Argentina hassling people doing too many tourist card runs, it isn't predictable; Living there on tourists cards means you won't get a DNI number, you can never settle there very well without one (bank accounts, utilities, perhaps even health insurance (not sure)), in any case it is an important thing for many aspects of living there and a passport number doesn't replace it; Another great thing, overstays are not criminalized. People deal with it by flying out and paying a small fine, then returning and starting all over again; Expats mostly learn Spanish, yes it is easier than Thai, but there are functional reasons. For example, go the websites to do things there (businesses, etc.) and it is all Spanish, no translations. Unlike Thailand where English has almost become a semi-official second language. That definitely is not the case in Argentina. Of course there is some English media, and an English expat forum; Yes the peso can change, and the country has a recent history of economic volatility; If you do have a verifiable retirement income stream, the amount required is quite low, probably all US social security recipients can qualify, but all of the required money must be imported into a bank there annually; It certainly is a great place to visit, best steaks and excellent wine, very interesting people (very high per capita rates of both psychotherapy and cosmetic surgery!

    Argentina, between rising costs and hassles, isn't worth it (according to one poster). The hassles are endless red tape and systemic corruption. I've read many times that get away from the biggest cities and the people are some of the most genuinely friendly in the world. If the most beautiful women in the world is what you are after then Argentina is definitely in the running. Go to Google Images, search Argentinian babe, holy Toledo! Some other things about Argentina...97% European heritage. 50% Italian, 30% Spanish, substantial English, Irish, French, German, Welsh and other minorities. Argentines like to camp, campgrounds in most towns. You'll find cineplexes in most small cities and large cities have multiple choices. Most American movies play there, usually in English with Spanish subtitles unless childrens' movie. Actually American owned cineplexes are in most of Latin America now, especially Cinemark. Argentina is slightly smaller than India but only has about 44 million people. It's one of the few countries that produces everything it needs but is so poorly managed it struggles financially. The gov't confiscated the national retirement fund last year to pay for it's socialist programs. Buenos Aires has far and away the best bookstores in Latin America. It's a very literate population. COOL WEATHER: Bariloche es AWESOME! This place really does have it all. It is absolutely beautiful, the Andes provide an almost unbelievable backdrop for this mid-size ski town. Bariloche sits about 10-15 km from Cerro Catedral, which is actually the most prominent ski area in South America; has change of seasons

    Chile: Chile is easily one of the most corruption free and stable countries in the Americas, and also one of the most amicable to foreigners looking to relocate or retire.; Puerto Monte in the south has is a European-like town overlooking the ocean and Andes Mountains; has change of seasons

    Costa Rica: sort of the Thailand of Latin America. It was the top expat location but so many foreigners moved in that the government ended most of the great retiree incentives it offered. Crime and costs have soared. Still, many expats there but also many moved out, especially to Panama; Pensionado required income USD 1000/mo, and not so good - rentista USD 2500/mo--must show money was converted to colons; getting expensive; housing costs have doubled in top areas; now required to join country social security; armed robbery and carjacking now a daily event; Costa Rica is nice but the benefits are going down at a rapid rate

    Mexico: gorgeous coastline overlooking Pacific; great food; one poster added the following: Favorite place is San Cristobal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico. Go to Google Images to see pictures. City is about 140,000, has multiplex playing American movies in English, best English language bookstore in Mexico, Walmart and Sam's club are opening stores there, has beautiful pedestrian only streets in the center, can be comfortable there on $700 a month, live very well on $1200. Unlike northern Mexico these days, San Cristobal is safe, with much to see and do. Single biggest drawback is wet season with alot of rain. But at 7000' overall it's mild most of the time, but nights can get chilly.

    Colombia: gone a long way towards fixing it's problems. Terrorist groups have been marginalized to remote areas and drug cartels are no longer threatening stability. Bogota's north side looks like a prosperous American city. Security is everywhere, people go out there. The city that's attracting alot of expats is Medellin. It has a year'round spring like climate and is very clean; Colombia officially requires a substantial pension to live there, but doesn't enforce it. Expats are living comfortably there in smaller cities for much less than $1000 a month. Definitely a place you need Spanish though to truly enjoy it. I think the Group is called Colombia_Expats, not certain.

    Chile: most expensive country in Latin America as well as it's most prosperous with excellent infrastructure; stunning views of the ocean and mountains; can get very cold is the south; lots of Europeans have already retired there in so-called "little Switzerland" areas

    Ecuador: good retirement visa system; one city in particular, Cuenca, that is very beautiful, mild but cool climate, all the amenities; does have crime issues. Somebody mentioned Esmeraldes which is the most crime ridden area of the country. Cuenca in general is safe, using common sense; one poster said: Regarding Ecuador Visa, your best bet should be STUDENT VISA, which 's easy&cheaper and easy to be extended tax free, just start searching a spanish language school now in quito or other small town in ecuador. and obtaining that letter for admission to an Ecuadorian language school; another poster concerned about visas and crime: It is clear their retirement visa is easily obtainable if you have a provable pension of a "certain amount" which I think isn't much. However the other alternative options are very unclear to me. If anyone understands what they mean exactly on how to qualify without a pension, let us know.

    http://www.ecuador.org/immigrantvisas.htm Also the dollarization there is attractive to Americans, no exchange rate worries.

    I have begun to plan trips there a few times, but every time I do, reading about the horrible crime situation in Quito has put me off; once you arrive in quito, you'll have plenty of time to find the a resonably-priced agent which can arrange your retirement visa package hassel free; another poster: Last I read Ecuador will give permanent residency by either buying real estate worth at least $25,000 or depositing $25k in an Ecuadorean bank. That gives you all the rights of citizens except right to vote or hold office.

    Uruguay: Google UruguayLiving.com for an excellent forum. Uruguay has low violent crime but serious property crime. You have to be vigilant to live there. A British couple went out to eat their first day there to take a break from unpacking. Came back 3 hrs later to find everything gone! It's a serious problem there. One place I like is Colonia del Sacramento, possibly the prettiest colonial town in South America and Portugese colonial to boot. Interesting thing is it's about 1.5 hrs by ferry across from Buenos Aires. It's where B.A. expats go to renew their tourist cards.

    Belize: according to one poster, it is the most expensive country in Central America (find hard to believe and would like more information on cost of living) and yet has minimal infrastructure. It's real draw is beach living and it's islands. However crime, especially in Belize City, is very high; great lobsters; scuba diving; Belize pegs it's money 2:1 to the American Dollar. That, along with most items are imported as little is produced locally, keeps things fairly expensive. If you live like a local, living in a simple wood house and eating mostly beans and rice and chicken you can live cheaply. That also means no air conditioning, no car, limited electricity. If you want an American lifestyle you'll pay alot, and still have to do without things like modern supermarkets. There are 2 paved 2 lane highways in the country, one north-south, one east-west.

    Please add your first hand observations to the list above.........thanks.

  2. so, do these protesters have the support of the regular people? to me they just look like a bunch of rowdy farmers. if some go to far some will die, doesnt mean they are a legitimate bunch.

    If you drive to Issan, or virtually any location outside of the big cities, you find that "regular people" do support them on a large scale (of course not all people support them but large numbers do in rural Thailand).

    They have reason to be pissed off (bad economic situation).........but, unfortunately, they have placed the wrong guy at the top of the totem pole.

    And they do not seem to be interested in a peaceful solution via the democratic process.

  3. So, basically what you are saying is they are just breaking the law and abusing the system? I see and I have no sympathy that's why the law is getting stricter because of these people.

    No.......actually, among other things, I was hinting that "breaking the law and abusing the system" are relative concepts that change overnight.

    In the past, these people were not considered "breaking the law or abusing the system." They were, in fact, encouraged by the police to do visa runs (and the police were making money off of the entire system).

    The visa changes came after a known terrorist was found hiding in Thailand. After that, the visa rules changed for "security reasons."

    Well, that morphed into a "quality tourists" campaign, underpinned by xenophobia.

    The changes had nothing to do with security.........never actually did.

    You can believe a myth perpetuated by those who are xenophobic, or encounter reality.

    The same law breakers and abusers you talk about, are considered outstanding visitors in other countries like Cambodia and the Philippines.

    And they were once considered outstanding visitors in Thailand.

    The current system is nuts beyond imagination.

    It is too bad that so much attention has gone into social engineering.......if they are concerned about security they should drop the social engineering function and focus on security.

    That is precisely what Cambodia and the Philippines do.

    Whatever, have a nice day. :) Thailand is going to hel_l and we are talking about this...........seems inappropriate at the moment.

  4. Pattaya is like a mirror, it reflects the person looking into it.

    If you go looking for sleaze it will appear, if you go looking for more wholesome attractions they will appear. What you look for you will find and reflects the person you are.

    If you look in the bathroom mirror and don't like what you see do you smash the mirror?

    This post should come up automatically any time some eejit tries to bad mouth Pattaya (our home) on this forum, well put Phil! :)

    It is liberal-cultural-relativistic-poetic-psycho babble.

    It suggests that there is nothing called "reality."

    I reject that philosophy.

    Many scientists reject it also.

    Your perception does not change reality.

    Reality is reality........no matter what color your glasses are.

  5. Thailand offers (probably) the best package in the world for 'retired' people on a low to medium income..

    I may add the word heterosexual in the mix..

    But it's a dead end for people under the age of 50, who want to live here,have a family, work etc

    It punishes 'immigrants'..so this pushes people like me to seek alternative destinations ie Cambo,Phils and they all suck ,in my books.

    So we are stuck here for the time being.

    UPDATE (with above comment)

    For some very useful comments see post #140 (too much info. there to update below).

    This thread is for people who are looking for an alternative to Thailand. It is not about Thailand.

    UPDATE from previous posts: We are talking about alternative where you can "live well" on a monthly income of US$1000 - 1800. The focus is on low-middle income pensioners because these are the ones being hurt most by Thailand's crazy retirement system. Pensioners with big money can retire anywhere. To include them would mean to include all countries. Healthcare, retirement visa system, infrastructure are critical for pensioners (need more info. on these items below). Also, it would be nice to get comments about Western type comforts (food, malls, etc).

    Cambodia: massive annual GNP growth, looks like Thailand; friendly people; English spoken widely; more expensive than Thailand but some say less expensive than Thailand; don't want to get sick there but close to Thailand so if it is not an emergency situation you can go to Thailand for medical care; infrastructure improving but long way to go); best visa situation in Asia and good Western food in PP and SR and SNVL. SNVL could, eventually, become the next small version of Pattaya after the international airport opens there.....lots of development plans for SNVL. Same water and sunset view as you find in Pattaya, but far fewer people.

    Philippines: safe and unsafe areas; beautiful beaches; storm problem; most people speak English; easy visa system; some possible retirement destinations are Boracay, Dumaguete, Panglao Island, Puerto Galera (avoid Manilla); one poster said this: having lived in the Philippines for 7 yrs as an expat......I can add a few comments about the place. Baguio City is one of the most livable areas in the Phil. High elevation summer capitol with moderate temperatures....but is still prone to the many typhoons that aim at the Phil every year. Weather is never boring there. Down south, there are many nice areas (the islands) that have small expat communities. Camiguin, Cebu (outside the city), Dumagetti, Bohol.....7,100 island to choose from. some 'jewels in the China seas, but lots of ruined enviornment and poor and crumbling infrastructure. Friendly people....sometimes too friendly, but always smiling like Thais. Poverty is much more obvious and the local food is swill. most violent crime is confined to the cities. Local transport is basic, but cheap. roads are the worse i've ever seen and road manners are worse than here.

    Immigration is much easier than LOS and I think cheaper.

    Malaysia: have a retirement program to attract foreigners that makes things a lot easier than it is in Thailand; you can own your own house; Malaysia would be easier for many expats (in terms of language, certain kinds of convenience, etc.) There are many more places than Penang to check out; one poster said this about Malaysia: Malaysia probably won't fall into your 1,000-1,800 criteria. For persons over 50 a deposit of $42,500 and monthly income of $2,850 (about 92,000 baht) is required. If you have a government pension of $2,850/mo or more then the deposit is not required. The official program MM2H (Malaysia My 2nd Home) is not bad if you can afford it. I have watched this program change every couple of months for the last two years - mostly good changes. You can import a car duty free (one time) oh, does not apply to motorcycles - sorry Harley. You can buy any number of homes but price has to be above $75,250 each.

    Vietnam: long coastline; storm prone; developing rapidly; health care in Hanoi reported to be excellent but not good in hinterland; one poster said "not as friendly" as Thailand; one poster said no set visa policy for retirees (think need more info. here); Retirement visa - I don't think they have one, all retirees are said to be married to VN and get 5 year resident visas (5 year resident visa is a big improvement over Thailand); one poster said: ...will be moving to live in Vietnam in a few months.I would say from my previous visits there that Vietnam certainly fulfils most if not all of the above criteria.The only difficult thing might be to find one city or town that has them all.For instance Saigon has good medical facilities but it's relatively expensive for housing and its not cool or particularly clean.Hanoi has good medical facilities,but it is quite dirty,however for part of the year it's actually cold,it certainly was when we were there in January.I've just come back from a 6 week tour of Vietnam,from Hanoi/Ha Long Bay to Hue/Da Nang/Hoi An/Nha Trang /Saigon and the Mekong Delta inc Phu Quoc island.I've been many times before and am married to a Vietnamese girl,we have a 1 year old boy as well.Out of the main tourist areas it's cheaper than Thailand,certainly housing,food and drink.Unfortunately though the medical facilities out in those places leave a lot to be desired,but then transport in Vietnam is relatively good,and if you live reasonably close to a regional airport,its cheap and easy to fly to Saigon/Hanoi.I wouldn't say English is widely spoken, but in the main tourist areas a fair number speak it.It's a lot easier to learn Vietnamese than Thai,the alphabet is similar to ours, the words are shorter and although it is a tonal language,the version of Vietnamese written today was basically invented by the French last century.The visa situation is easier there(for me anyway).Because I am married to a Vietnamese,I have a 5 year visa EXEMPTION,it's not a visa,just a sticker in my passport saying I don't need a visa.The only thing is that I can't stay in Vietnam more than 90 days at a time,so I will have to leave every 90 days(very similar to the Non O here).It may well be that I can get some sort of residence visa when I am there,I will have to find out,or maybe someone there knows the answer to that?

    Indonesia: visa system is not that easy; Bali in expensive in some areas and not so expensive in others; Lombok has been mentioned as one other possibility; certainly Indonesia has thousands of islands; earthquake problem

    Lao PDR: Unsure if cheaper than Thailand; can be pleasant according to one poster; one poster added this about food: lovely breads and bakeries widely available and delicious

    China: Kunming is the City of Eternal Spring (sounds like cool weather); China is huge and difficult to generalize about; Zhuhai across from Macau is a popular retirement destination (nice city in my opinion). NEED RETIREMENT VISA POLICY

    Panama: Panama sensed an opportunity and developed a retiree incentive program that International Living calls the world's best. One retirement opt is based on showing a pension (or social security) of only 500 USD plus 100 USD per dependent (somebody check for accuracy). Retirees get discounts on travel, entertainment, shopping, services. But like Costa Rica so many have moved in that the country is having growing pains. Like Thailand most of the country is very hot and humid. The highland town of Boquette has a very nice climate and has been heavily promoted by International Living. And it's First World prices reflect that.

    Argentina: Argentina became the single best bargain in Latin America, possibly the world, after their monetary crisis of 2002. Literally overnight after their peso was devalued costs were 75% less in American Dollars. Unfortunately while the exchange rate has hovered around 3.8 Pesos to the Dollar rampant inflation has brought costs back up close to where they were pre-crisis. However outside of Buenos Aires there are many choices with a good quality of life that are reasonably priced. And as one of the world's largest countries there's climate and scenery that suits about anyone. They have some nice beach towns but winter weather on the coast is pretty raw. Some cities popular with expats are Mendoza, Bariloche, Salta, and Cordoba. But Buenos Aires is the big draw for foreigners, world class city if you are an urbanite; great beef. A reminder about Argentina, there is no bank account method to qualify, you must have a permanent income, or no go for the retirement visa (maybe too expensive for the pensioners in question.....not sure); Many expats make border runs on tourist cards for many years. Argentina has no problem with that. Google Buenos Aires Expats Forum for tons of info. Many Argentines speak English. The Buenos Aires Herald is an excellent newspaper in English. Still, once there you'd want to take classes and get up to speed. I think the inflation issue is serious, but it may lead to another crisis. Might be worth moving there for a few years if the Peso is devalued again. Can always plan your next move while enjoying the best steaks in the world at near giveaway prices!

    According to one poster who has been there, there are reports of Argentina hassling people doing too many tourist card runs, it isn't predictable; Living there on tourists cards means you won't get a DNI number, you can never settle there very well without one (bank accounts, utilities, perhaps even health insurance (not sure)), in any case it is an important thing for many aspects of living there and a passport number doesn't replace it; Another great thing, overstays are not criminalized. People deal with it by flying out and paying a small fine, then returning and starting all over again; Expats mostly learn Spanish, yes it is easier than Thai, but there are functional reasons. For example, go the websites to do things there (businesses, etc.) and it is all Spanish, no translations. Unlike Thailand where English has almost become a semi-official second language. That definitely is not the case in Argentina. Of course there is some English media, and an English expat forum; Yes the peso can change, and the country has a recent history of economic volatility; If you do have a verifiable retirement income stream, the amount required is quite low, probably all US social security recipients can qualify, but all of the required money must be imported into a bank there annually; It certainly is a great place to visit, best steaks and excellent wine, very interesting people (very high per capita rates of both psychotherapy and cosmetic surgery!

    Argentina, between rising costs and hassles, isn't worth it (according to one poster). The hassles are endless red tape and systemic corruption. I've read many times that get away from the biggest cities and the people are some of the most genuinely friendly in the world. If the most beautiful women in the world is what you are after then Argentina is definitely in the running. Go to Google Images, search Argentinian babe, holy Toledo! Some other things about Argentina...97% European heritage. 50% Italian, 30% Spanish, substantial English, Irish, French, German, Welsh and other minorities. Argentines like to camp, campgrounds in most towns. You'll find cineplexes in most small cities and large cities have multiple choices. Most American movies play there, usually in English with Spanish subtitles unless childrens' movie. Actually American owned cineplexes are in most of Latin America now, especially Cinemark. Argentina is slightly smaller than India but only has about 44 million people. It's one of the few countries that produces everything it needs but is so poorly managed it struggles financially. The gov't confiscated the national retirement fund last year to pay for it's socialist programs. Buenos Aires has far and away the best bookstores in Latin America. It's a very literate population. COOL WEATHER: Bariloche es AWESOME! This place really does have it all. It is absolutely beautiful, the Andes provide an almost unbelievable backdrop for this mid-size ski town. Bariloche sits about 10-15 km from Cerro Catedral, which is actually the most prominent ski area in South America; has change of seasons

    Chile: Chile is easily one of the most corruption free and stable countries in the Americas, and also one of the most amicable to foreigners looking to relocate or retire.; Puerto Monte in the south has is a European-like town overlooking the ocean and Andes Mountains; has change of seasons

    Costa Rica: sort of the Thailand of Latin America. It was the top expat location but so many foreigners moved in that the government ended most of the great retiree incentives it offered. Crime and costs have soared. Still, many expats there but also many moved out, especially to Panama; Pensionado required income USD 1000/mo, and not so good - rentista USD 2500/mo--must show money was converted to colons; getting expensive; housing costs have doubled in top areas; now required to join country social security; armed robbery and carjacking now a daily event; Costa Rica is nice but the benefits are going down at a rapid rate

    Mexico: gorgeous coastline overlooking Pacific; great food; one poster added the following: Favorite place is San Cristobal de las Casas, Chiapas, Mexico. Go to Google Images to see pictures. City is about 140,000, has multiplex playing American movies in English, best English language bookstore in Mexico, Walmart and Sam's club are opening stores there, has beautiful pedestrian only streets in the center, can be comfortable there on $700 a month, live very well on $1200. Unlike northern Mexico these days, San Cristobal is safe, with much to see and do. Single biggest drawback is wet season with alot of rain. But at 7000' overall it's mild most of the time, but nights can get chilly.

    Colombia: gone a long way towards fixing it's problems. Terrorist groups have been marginalized to remote areas and drug cartels are no longer threatening stability. Bogota's north side looks like a prosperous American city. Security is everywhere, people go out there. The city that's attracting alot of expats is Medellin. It has a year'round spring like climate and is very clean; Colombia officially requires a substantial pension to live there, but doesn't enforce it. Expats are living comfortably there in smaller cities for much less than $1000 a month. Definitely a place you need Spanish though to truly enjoy it. I think the Group is called Colombia_Expats, not certain.

    Chile: most expensive country in Latin America as well as it's most prosperous with excellent infrastructure; stunning views of the ocean and mountains; can get very cold is the south; lots of Europeans have already retired there in so-called "little Switzerland" areas

    Ecuador: good retirement visa system; one city in particular, Cuenca, that is very beautiful, mild but cool climate, all the amenities; does have crime issues. Somebody mentioned Esmeraldes which is the most crime ridden area of the country. Cuenca in general is safe, using common sense; one poster said: Regarding Ecuador Visa, your best bet should be STUDENT VISA, which 's easy&cheaper and easy to be extended tax free, just start searching a spanish language school now in quito or other small town in ecuador. and obtaining that letter for admission to an Ecuadorian language school; another poster concerned about visas and crime: It is clear their retirement visa is easily obtainable if you have a provable pension of a "certain amount" which I think isn't much. However the other alternative options are very unclear to me. If anyone understands what they mean exactly on how to qualify without a pension, let us know.

    http://www.ecuador.org/immigrantvisas.htm Also the dollarization there is attractive to Americans, no exchange rate worries.

    I have begun to plan trips there a few times, but every time I do, reading about the horrible crime situation in Quito has put me off; once you arrive in quito, you'll have plenty of time to find the a resonably-priced agent which can arrange your retirement visa package hassel free; another poster: Last I read Ecuador will give permanent residency by either buying real estate worth at least $25,000 or depositing $25k in an Ecuadorean bank. That gives you all the rights of citizens except right to vote or hold office.

    Uruguay: Google UruguayLiving.com for an excellent forum. Uruguay has low violent crime but serious property crime. You have to be vigilant to live there. A British couple went out to eat their first day there to take a break from unpacking. Came back 3 hrs later to find everything gone! It's a serious problem there. One place I like is Colonia del Sacramento, possibly the prettiest colonial town in South America and Portugese colonial to boot. Interesting thing is it's about 1.5 hrs by ferry across from Buenos Aires. It's where B.A. expats go to renew their tourist cards.

    Belize: according to one poster, it is the most expensive country in Central America (find hard to believe and would like more information on cost of living) and yet has minimal infrastructure. It's real draw is beach living and it's islands. However crime, especially in Belize City, is very high; great lobsters; scuba diving; Belize pegs it's money 2:1 to the American Dollar. That, along with most items are imported as little is produced locally, keeps things fairly expensive. If you live like a local, living in a simple wood house and eating mostly beans and rice and chicken you can live cheaply. That also means no air conditioning, no car, limited electricity. If you want an American lifestyle you'll pay alot, and still have to do without things like modern supermarkets. There are 2 paved 2 lane highways in the country, one north-south, one east-west.

    Please add your first hand observations to the list above.........thanks.

  6. khaosan is just hundreds meters from the protest site - anything can be happening there anytime. It's not a safe area anymore.

    protesters (and soldiers) might be retreating in any direction, wherever they will feel safe, khaosan might be such place

    The entrance to Khao San road is only about 30 meters from the action. The Reds were are all over the surrounding area (don't know about now).

    It is not surprising that to avoid being arrested/killed many Reds would retreat (maybe 30 meters) down the street to Khao San road proper.

    Then the police and military would follow..........

    Listen........it is not a good idea to be out and about right now........especially tonight.

    This is a Thai fight.........not a farang fight.

    Don't get caught up in it. It is not a movie........it is real.

    Don't wear RED or YELLOW clothing.

    Good luck!

  7. Instead of just saying it's wrong why don't you enlighten me and tell me why.

    I tried earlier but the internet keeps stopping.

    Why? Because:

    1) most of the people doing visa runs have far more than 10000 baht

    2) some are actually rich and don't want to bother with things like a marriage visa

    3) some actually enjoy taking a break to Cambodia or Lao (not me)

    4) attaching negative attributes to a person on a " tourist visa" is not universal........the Philippines and Cambodia, just to take two examples, don't have the same concept at Thailand does

    5) even Thailand had a much different concept of "visa runners" in the past........was not negative at all

    The "quality tourist" concept/plan has failed.

    All they have to do is scrap the entire system and implement something sane (basically a pay to stay system) like they have in Cambodia and the Philippines..........tourism would get on track again.........they would not come across and xenophobic and borderline retarded (the latter refers to the quality tourist plan).

    No more border runs.....you just walk down to any immigration office and tell them how many months you want: 3, 6, 9, 12.

    Security? Most expats would happily pay for a security background check if that allows them to attain a simple, long term visa solution.

    Will they do it? No. Because it is Thailand, they will do the precise opposite.........avoid a simple solution and pour petrol on the visa system fire they have created.

    No matter, Vietnam, Cambodia, the Philippines and even Malaysia are starting to look better and better.

  8. Thailand's infrastructure and business support is still far superior than that of Laos, Cambodia, and even the Phillipines. Vietnam is the only serious competitor and it's still a ways off from being a true regional player. It won't effect the big industrial players at all because the factories will still run hel_l or high water. Plus Thailand is an export driven economy..those things being produced in Thailand are still being shipped overseas without any issues.

    The protests impact domestic Thai companies a lot more. The central and "The Mall corp" department store monopolies will take a hit as the protesters have shut down some of their main stores. The government will be wasting lots of resources which impacts taxpayer dollars.

    Actually Malaysia, Vietnam and Cambodia have all been doing much better than Thailand for several years in terms of annual GDP growth rate.

    Infrastructure development is taking place in all three of these countries--especially Vietnam and Cambodia.

    I also believe education is far better in all three of these countries, so the workforce is better educated.

    Why invest in Thailand when you can invest in Malaysia, Vietnam or Cambodia?

    I certainly would not invest in Thailand. It does not make any financial sense.

    OK- Malaysia sure it has better education- its a very developed country. But Vietnam ad Cambodia are well behindThailand in infrastructure and education (just check out any of the stats from any source you care for Un, World Bank, CIA fact book etc).

    In terms of investing in thailand- i have been making a tidy profit on the thai stock exchange even in the last 2 weeks- in the last week i made the following returns from selling stock i bought in january- Thai air stock 40% return, KBANK 20% profit, Lanna up 10%. If this is thailand's investment situation in a 'worst case scenario', then im sticking around:)

    Making money in stocks is not going to produce many quality jobs for Thailand. Thailand needs real investment in small and large scale businesses.

    I strongly disagree with you with regard to your placement of Cambodian and Vietnamese students behind Thai students. I think Cambodia and Vietnam have done a much better job than Thailand in terms of producing an educated workforce.

    The stats may or may not show something different. I am talking from experience and not stats.

    Give me a Vietnamese or Cambodian worker any day..........

  9. It is easy to get caught up in semantics. "Civil War" or not, it is clearly a major conflict between two opposing sides: rural vs urban.

    It is a longstanding, evolving conflict.........this did not happen overnight.

    This is not crystal clear to some because the Reds do not yet have weapons on the scale that would make it crystal clear.

    We had a Civil War in my country. It was largely a rural vs urban war. It was horrible. Both sides had weapons. It was an economic war that decided whether America would be primarily a rural or urban economy.

    If, in my country, an American equivalent of the Reds suddenly invaded Washington DC and stormed Congress..........all hel_l would break lose.

    The solution to the problem, I am sure, would be a violent solution imposed by the military and police,

    Thailand is different. They do things their own way.

    It is clear the Reds are trying to produce conflict with the police and military who have been extraordinarily tolerant of activities that in virtually any other country would not be tolerated.

    I think it is sad that a certain leader is paying for all of this to get himself back into power (or to get his $$$$$ back).

    I think it is sad that he has been chosen by the Reds as their leader (surely they can find another, better person to represent them........one who is not a convicted criminal and one whose international reputation is not lower than a snakes belly).

    If they get what they want, Thailand will be ruined for decades to come. But they can't grasp this simple fact.

    I predict the military and police will clean all of this up soon and a temporary calm will surface.

    As is often the case in Thailand, what happens next depends on what the military decides to do.

    Good luck Thailand!

  10. Thailand's infrastructure and business support is still far superior than that of Laos, Cambodia, and even the Phillipines. Vietnam is the only serious competitor and it's still a ways off from being a true regional player. It won't effect the big industrial players at all because the factories will still run hel_l or high water. Plus Thailand is an export driven economy..those things being produced in Thailand are still being shipped overseas without any issues.

    The protests impact domestic Thai companies a lot more. The central and "The Mall corp" department store monopolies will take a hit as the protesters have shut down some of their main stores. The government will be wasting lots of resources which impacts taxpayer dollars.

    Actually Malaysia, Vietnam and Cambodia have all been doing much better than Thailand for several years in terms of annual GDP growth rate.

    Infrastructure development is taking place in all three of these countries--especially Vietnam and Cambodia.

    I also believe education is far better in all three of these countries, so the workforce is better educated.

    Why invest in Thailand when you can invest in Malaysia, Vietnam or Cambodia?

    I certainly would not invest in Thailand. It does not make any financial sense.

  11. Thaivisa have three categories.

    1. The wannabe

    Been here as a tourist and wants to move here, always positive posts.

    2. The expat

    Living here and have a balanced view of the kingdom.

    3. The looser

    Lived here but lost everything to a BG, always negative posts.

    4. The one time loser who is now a winner

    Lived here, lost everything to Thai "wife," posted negative stuff, then got back more money than he had, lives a single life now on a sailboat with a dog and no wife, and now post even more negative stuff because he understands the reality of Thailand :)

    Almost as well as the dog!!!! :D

    Dog never complains...........smiles all the time :D

  12. Thaivisa have three categories.

    1. The wannabe

    Been here as a tourist and wants to move here, always positive posts.

    2. The expat

    Living here and have a balanced view of the kingdom.

    3. The looser

    Lived here but lost everything to a BG, always negative posts.

    4. The one time loser who is now a winner

    Lived here, lost everything to Thai "wife," posted negative stuff, then got back more money than he had, lives a single life now on a sailboat with a dog and no wife, and now post even more negative stuff because he understands the reality of Thailand :)

  13. Prices depressed? wait another year and you'll see diving boards outside all condo buildings,their owners taking a backward flip to heaven.

    Prices here are going to half and half again in next to no time,and building goes on apace,unbelievable.

    Go to the SS camp in Jomtien,they'll give you one for free,just to get the damned place filled,plus a dolly bird or two.

    I agree. The entire real estate market is going to pop in thailand what with protests political instability and even a possible civil war. Can you imagine what a full on stouch between the reds and yellows would do with the military and possbily the police involved?

    This would be a nightmare scenario for Thailand and investment. The Thai baht is also way over valued and when it pops which it surely will, watch out for real estate prices as they plunge.

    Wait 3 years at least possibly 5 then buy.

    I agree (and, for the record, saw it coming as far back as 2005).

    It would be "crazy" to buy anything now if you intention is to make money of it within the next ten years.

    The exception, I think, remains top floor front ocean view concrete coffins--they are still in demand.

    What surprises me most is the optimism that some real estate hounds express.

    I think it is not possible for them to see reality.....perhaps because it is too emotionally difficult to accept.

    There will no doubt be cue cards to take that leap off the top floor boards.

    And, believe it or not, I am an optimist. :)

  14. Actually, it was much more of a "cesspool" twenty years ago with drug dealers on Beach Road selling heroin fairly openly (or at least claiming to) and much dirtier than now. Pattaya has mostly changed for the better since then. :)

    :D :D :D

    You are certainly predictable.

    I never saw any person selling heroin on beach road back then (illegal drug problems are far greater today).........it was not that much dirtier than now.

    Did see lots of people selling fake gems.

    Yes, the water around beach road was filthy due to dumping sewerage in the water.....but it is still a cesspool and smells like urine and crap in many places.

    Positive changes?

    Maybe you are talking about more condo coffins? More crap restaurants? More violent crime? More racism/xenophobia? More crap malls? Significant rise in the cost of living (is that positive?). More crap for brains people? More people in general? More traffic jams? More air pollution?

    Anyway.....if you decide to sell copies of your rose-colored glasses, you will make a fortune.

  15. I just looked up Mood's for a definition, looks like Thailand is on the slippery slide unfortunately. "Moody's judges obligations rated BBB+ as speculative and "subject to high credit risk", and have "generally poor credit quality."

    I see a bunch of people saying Thailand tourism only accounts for 6% or 8% of the economy, who am I to disagree, but how much of your tourist dollar is cash dollar, Yes you may get a scribble 'check bin' so they can log how many beers you have had, do you really think it gets declared? That Pad Thai you had for lunch? Think your tuk tuk driver is declaring how much he ripped you off? I think the average tourist would dispose more money each day in cash than many rice farmers put together gross wage. Also, foreign investment is running, I know of 3 companies that have directly effected family members or close friends, that have shut down Thailand operations and opened up in near by countries, leaving hundreds of non tourism related jobs behind and leaving a lot of corrupt tea money collectors looking for their next victim. 'mai pen rai'

    I feel that pulling tourism in Thailand, would make more than a 8% impact on the country, it's an experiment I think they are trying by the looks of it unfortunately. :)

    The 6-8% figure is bogus like most official figures. Why? Too many reasons to talk about here and who cares anyway...the figure is way too low and does not reflect reality on the ground and the network of businesses impacted by tourism.

    On another note:

    TAT Governor Suraphon Svetasreni is optimistic that despite the disappearance of Asian tourists during the water festival, long-haul tourists, particularly from Europe, would continue to come to Thailand.

    Tourism and Sports Minister Chumpol Silapa-archa was also adamant that the impact was not as severe as claimed by private operators. He was upbeat because tourist arrivals through 30 immigration offices totalled 4.5 million in the first quarter, compared to 3.6 million in the same period last year. In the quarter, tourism spending rose 29 per cent on year to Bt178 billion.

    Despite the political chaos, the number of international tourists during April 1-8 also rose 5 per cent on year to 200,231 from 190,812 visitors in the corresponding period last year.

    "The overall tourism business is still growing despite the unrest," said Chumpol. He flatly denied reports of massive cancellations during the Songkran Festival.

    How do they come up with this nonsense? Does any person really believe this? I think they are smoking something over there.

  16. after a short while the novelty wears off and you realize the whole area is nothing but a cesspit, ,most especially, the ocean. You didn't really swim in it did you? :)

    That was my precise reaction to it: cesspit/cesspool.

    But it is an interesting cesspool.

    If you have money, really nice ocean-front condo........it can be OK.

    Basically, the money will give you more options, including the option of leaving frequently to refresh your mind.

    A lot of the negative social ills you can either accept as "part of the game" or ignore as "part of the game."

    The "game" can be fun, but even that gets boring to some people who want more in life (e.g., genuine relationship, family).

    I would not want to live in Pattaya-Jomtien if I had kids to raise.........no way.

    It is a place for single males to become..............whatever.........good, bad, ugly.

    Unfortunately, the cesspool has increase in size over the past ten years.

    The good days of the past are gone forever.

  17. Thanks..........I have seen the wikipedia stuff already. What I have not seen are extremely detailed maps of both the Irrawady and Chao Phraya.

    You directed me to the most detailed map I have ever seen of the Mekong..........here:

    post-99053-1270857407_thumb.jpg

    That map shows a very elaborate, extensive riverine system, extending far beyond the main river.

    That "extension" made me think that there might be a connection at some point between the Mekong and Chao Phraya.........also, the Irrawady and Chao Phraya which both, no doubt, are elaborate with branches reaching far beyond their main rivers.

    The information you presented on dams (proposed, under construction, existing) on the Mekong was interesting. But my main concern is how these three rivers are being impacted by global warming and climate change. That is why I keep focusing on "source" and "connections."

    With that in mind, I would like to know more of what you know about the source of water for these systems.

    Please correct the following:

    1) MEKONG: source: glaciers (%) and rainfall (%)

    2) CHAO PHRAYA: source: rainfall (100%)

    3) IRRAWADY: source: glaciers (%) and rainfall (%)

    If that is correct, I really would like to know these things:

    a. the percentage of water in the Mekong and Irrawady that comes from glaciers and rainfall (please fill out the above %)

    b. your view on what will happen to the Mekong and Irrawady riverine systems if the glaciers that feed them completely melt (under this scenario all of the water will come from rainfall)

    c. your view on what will happen to the Chao Phraya, Mekong, and Irrawady if rainfall patterns are disrupted (which appears to be happening right now)

    d. your view on what will happen to the economies and social structures in Southeast Asia if the worst case scenario materializes (i.e., melting glaciers and significant warming with droughts and insufficient water for agriculture)

    As far as I know, using existing models of climate change, it is not possible to say with precision whether rainfall will increase or decrease as global warming and climate change intensify.

    That is the scary part about it........nobody is sure, so we are "playing with fire."

  18. Thanks..........I have seen the wikipedia stuff already. What I have not seen are extremely detailed maps of both the Irrawady and Chao Phraya.

    You directed me to the most detailed map I have ever seen of the Mekong..........here:

    post-99053-1270857407_thumb.jpg

    That map shows a very elaborate, extensive riverine system, extending far beyond the main river.

    That "extension" made me think that there might be a connection at some point between the Mekong and Chao Phraya.........also, the Irrawady and Chao Phraya which both, no doubt, are elaborate with branches reaching far beyond their main rivers.

    The information you presented on dams (proposed, under construction, existing) on the Mekong was interesting. But my main concern is how these three rivers are being impacted by global warming and climate change. That is why I keep focusing on "source" and "connections."

    With that in mind, I would like to know more of what you know about the source of water for these systems.

    Please correct the following. At this point, I am not that concerned about the location of the source (s), but if you want to add that info. again, feel free to do so:

    1) MEKONG: source: glaciers (%) and rainfall (%)

    2) CHAO PHRAYA: source: rainfall (100%)

    3) IRRAWADY: source: glaciers (%) and rainfall (%)

    If that is correct, I really would like to know these things:

    a. the percentage of water in the Mekong and Irrawady that comes from glaciers and rainfall (please fill out the above %)

    b. your view on what will happen to the Mekong and Irrawady riverine systems if the glaciers that feed them completely melt (under this scenario all of the water will come from rainfall)

    c. your view on what will happen to the Chao Phraya, Mekong, and Irrawady if rainfall patterns are disrupted (which appears to be happening right now)

    d. your view on what will happen to the economies and social structures in Southeast Asia if the worst case scenario materializes (i.e., melting glaciers and significant warming with droughts and insufficient water for agriculture)

    As far as I know, using existing models of climate change, it is not possible to say with precision whether rainfall will increase or decrease as global warming and climate change intensify.

    That is the scary part about it........nobody is sure, so we are "playing with fire."

  19. 1. Are you saying that most of the water Thailand's farmers use is not originating in China or territories effectively controlled by China?

    2. That, in fact, most of the water comes from Lao and mountainous areas inside Thailand? True?

    3. If I understand you, you are not minimizing the impact of melting glaciers on the Mekong riverine system.........you are simply adding that more water comes from other sources in Lao and within Thailand. True?

    4. Also, you are pointing out that Thailand (like China) has constructed dams and is controlling the flow of water into places like Cambodia.......true?

    Interesting stuff.

    1. Yes; that's correct. I wrote earlier in the link below:

    http://www.thaivisa.com/forum/China-Denies...87#entry3414187

    "You can see that the Mekong water supply is for 16% from China and the rest (84%) indeed from the other countries: from Myanmar: 2%, Laos: 35%, Thailand: 18%, Cambodia: 18% and Vietnam: 11%. This water is coming from thousands of small streams and smaller or larger rivers, all ending up in the Mekong."

    Map of The Mekong River Basin's water supply with %'s : post-13995-1270742178_thumb.jpg

    2. yes; see # 1

    3. Several studies, by foreign- as well as Chinese scientists have found that the glaciers in Qinghai Province in China as well as Tibet are decreasing. Qinghai is the origin of the Lancang/Mekong river. Combined with the extreme droughts since August 2009 (!) in SW China and parts of Thailand and Laos it is no wonder that the Mekong levels are extremely low; lower than many decades before.

    4. Of course. The Pak Mun Dam near the Cambodian border (5,5 kms away) shows that Thailand is taking care of it's own water supplies (own soil) first, before letting the oversupply run into the shared Thai/Cambodian bordered Mekong, running further south from there.

    5. What's more: It is odd that the MEKONG RIVER COMMISSION - MRC- supplied the following facts of Mekong water levels:

    Measured on April 8, 2010 !

    http://ffw.mrcmekong.org/north.htm

    Where one can see that the water level up north in Thailand is -1.84M Chiang Saen*** and even 3.23M at Luang Prabang/Laos -!!!- but decreases further and further, running along the Thai/Laos border....and THAN......going up again at the Cambodian water checkpoints Stung Treng/Cambodia 2.22M and Kratie/Cambodia with 6.58M !!!

    see here: http://ffw.mrcmekong.org/central.htm

    Now, who's using that water between the inflow from China/Burma/Laos borders and the lower Mekong ? :)

    *** In Chiang Saen, the Mekong enters Thailand, coming from the Burma/Lao bordered river)

    LaoPo

    Hi LaoPo.......as I said, "good post."

    The data clearly show that glaciers are melting and negatively impacting the main rivers in Southeast Asia.

    The data also show that the Mekong "system" is undergoing more "stress" (i.e., lower levels over time) as it makes its way along the Thai-Lao border.

    This no doubt has to do with agricultural production in eastern Thailand. Farmers are, in essence, draining the river. There are, no doubt, other factors involved.

    It is interesting to see a detailed map of the Mekong, from its origin to end point. There are so many maps, but the one you directed me to is the most detailed I have ever seen.

    There are, of course, two other rivers: the Chao Phraya and Irrawady. The Irrawady clearly originates near the same place as the Mekong--thus, melting glaciers will have a serious impact on both of these rivers.

    You presented information stating that 16% of the Mekong's water comes from China.

    I wonder if all three of the major rivers are connected at some point (e.g., point of origin).

    I can't find extremely detailed maps for all three rivers.

    My guess is that they are connected--at least the Irrawady and Mekong. Most people say the origin on the Chao Phraya is inside Thailand....something I find hard to believe....although some maps show that.

    Because some people don't understand the significance of what we are talking about (or trying too if the spammers allow us to do so), I would like to post the following quote:

    Southeast Asia's few dense population clusters are relatively small and lie separated from one another by areas of much sparser human settlement. Reasons for population clusters are three favorable natural environments. They include the valleys and deltas of Southeast Asia's major rivers such as the Irrawaddy, Chao Phraya, Mekong River and the Red River-Tonkin Basin--most densely populated basin in SE Asia; volcanic soil; and regions that were once part of colonial plantation-Malaya. Large scale invasions from other regions have not occurred historically because physical obstacles hinder overland travel along routes into SE Asia-rugged mountains and limits to agricultural pursuits due to densely covered tropical rainforests with their attendant soils leaded by heavy monsoonal rains.

    What does that mean? It means that people have historically settled around these rivers. Economies (particularly agriculture) are in large part guided by these rivers. Food production depends on these rivers. The sources of the rivers are melting.

    What will happen to these economies as the glaciers melt away?

    At the minimum, what will happen will not be good. No doubt social chaos will result......famine, water wars, economic problems magnified.........etc.

    If you think the Reds are mad now, imagine a future where it has become increasingly difficult for them to engage in agriculture.

    Well, right now the future is here on a small scale--rivers are drying up....ponds are drying up.......small fish are being removed and eaten (thus negatively impacting future fish stocks).

    I will leave it at that for now.

  20. Maybe the China-blamers will now understand that the problems of the low-leveled Mekong river isn't just a problem caused in or by China but part of a far greater problem.... :)

    EXTREME AND SERIOUS DROUGHTS in SE ASIA..the most extreme since 50-100 years

    "Bhumibol Dam power output peaks as mercury soars"

    Its reservoir now holds just 1.53 billion cubic metres of usable water - only 15.8 per cent of its maximum capacity, he added.

    from: http://www.thaivisa.com/forum/Thailand-Rea...18#entry3479018

    BTW: the Bhumibol Dam's reservoir* has NOTHING to do with water coming from sources in China; it's water origins from the Ping River in Thailand itself (feeding the Chao Phraya river) and comes from Chiang Mai province and the dam's reservoir is now at a dramatic low level of just 15%...

    Apart from that, I never read anything on this board about all the other dams in Thailand like the controversial and immense Pak Mun Dam/reservoir** Thailand has, blocking and controlling it's own rivers just before they flow into the Mekong at the Thai/Cambodia border......

    Do the Cambodians like it that Thailand control it's own rivers, just before they flow into Cambodian territory also ?

    Next to that, most people seem to forget that the inflow of water from the Lancang (later Mekong) river is minor to the large inflow of water coming from streams in Thailand itself but for an even greater part coming from Laos (which is a LOT more mountainous area than Thailand).

    * http://maps.google.nl/maps?f=q&source=....817261&z=8

    ** http://maps.google.nl/maps?hl=nl&q=pak...mp;t=h&z=12

    LaoPo

    Hi LP........interesting post.

    Certainly, the problem is more complex than most people realize.

    The point about severe droughts is important.....the data (which I don't need to show.......take my word for it) show a clear pattern: severe weather events have increased substantially just over the past 30 years.

    This is directly related to global warming and climate change........no.........I don't care about what the nuts (who have no understanding of science) have to say about this.

    Are you saying that most of the water Thailand's farmers use is not originating in China or territories effectively controlled by China?

    That, in fact, most of the water comes from Lao and mountainous areas inside Thailand? True?

    If I understand you, you are not minimizing the impact of melting glaciers on the Mekong riverine system.........you are simply adding that more water comes from other sources in Lao and within Thailand. True?

    Also, you are pointing out that Thailand (like China) has constructed dams and is controlling the flow of water into places like Cambodia.......true?

    Interesting stuff.

    I read that Cambodia is presently constructing a dam that will be used to generate hydroelectric power.........that should, if true, impact the flow of water from Cambodia to Thailand.

    The rivers and ponds near where I live are all drying up now........I have never, ever seen weather like this.

    As an aside, I talked with a man who has lived here for 46 years. I asked him what the weather was like 46 years ago. He said that 46 years ago at this time of the year it was much cooler and wetter than today.

    I asked him if he thought all elderly Thais think this........he said "yes." I asked "are you sure about this?" He said, "totally sure."

    This is a proxy measure (qualitative measure) that simply lends support to the hard quantitative data.

    In science, that is the best evidence that something is actually happening in terms of climate change.

    Put differently, when both quantitative and qualitative data are in agreement, there is a strong probability that what you are seeing is actually happening and not a product of random events.

  21. Since you live in Vietnam, and because it is so close to Thailand, you might want to view this movie:

    A report on the effects of climate change in Viet Nam

    http://asiapacific.unfpa.org/public/

    Unfortunately for the spammers, it presents information on how the melting glaciers are negatively impacting Vietnam.

    This link is also useful if you know how to interpret scientific data (spammers don't even need to look at it):

    http://www.unfpa.org/swp/2009/en/ch1.shtml

    It is clear global warming and associated climate change are happening now.

    As stated earlier, I think the main problem with the Mekong is the glaciers melting...over time this will lead to no water.....no Mekong.

    This will, obviously, negatively impact agriculture, causing massive social chaos.

    I also don't necessarily blame the Chinese for acting in their own self-interests.

    Nobody has told me why they should share water that has its source in China and Tibet.......why?

    Would Saudi Arabia share its oil with Yemen? Would South Africa share its diamonds with Zimbabwe? Would the USA share its oil with Mexico? I think not.

×
×
  • Create New...
""