Robins
-
Posts
71 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Downloads
Posts posted by Robins
-
-
15 minutes ago, Wake Up said:
During my 30 plus years in business I bought thousands of lunches. To buy these guys lunch and eat with them would have been worth your time and money. Ask for their card when you say goodbye and one day who knows they may be able to help you when you need it. They don’t make any money. Buying a lunch would have benefited you and your wife more than you know. Assuming you can afford it. ????
Like having a stack of donuts and a pot of coffee to welcome an American cop, and yes, I was one.
- 1
-
On 7/9/2019 at 5:02 PM, dbrenn said:
I would have bought them lunch. It pays off in the long run to be hospitable.
Or at least have a fresh pot of coffee made. You're so right, be polite and welcome them in, they're just doing their job.
- 2
- 1
-
On 3/29/2013 at 10:39 AM, Langsuan Man said:
Also tell your folks to never use one of the private carriers, such as FEDEX, UPS, DHL etc. again. Regular post mail is unlikely to attract Royal Thai Customs scrutiny, where these private carriers are a Customs magnet
Unfortunately, now that you are in the loop you will have to have FEDEX solve the problem
Regular mail goes through a different office in Lak Ai Bangkok.
-
22 hours ago, DrJack54 said:
That's exactly what I do. When you say retirement visa do you O-A? If so the money can remain in au bank. If non O visa based on retirement..that is a 90 day visa and you apply for you 12 month extension based on retirement. If non o is applied for outside of Thailand no need to show where money came from. If a conversion from say a tourist visa to non o is done inside los you will need to show money came from abroad.
You don't need to show where it came from here either, the 800 k balance is all they look at. It's bureaucratic horror stories like that which have made this change worse than it needed to be.
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
2 hours ago, from the home of CC said:and you can thank all those posers that went before you...
Anyone who reads some of the horror stories on TV and actually believes them will become paranoid or go home.
- 3
-
^ It's redundant for anyone who has foreign medical insurance that covers them here. You can only collect ones, more than that is fraud.
-
8 hours ago, Rally123 said:
I didn't argue. I just told him and another officer, that butted in, that I wasn't going to pay the 500 baht, no receipt, pure and simple. They then just said 'okay' and did it free of charge. Also the farang who went after me went for the same reason as me but was not asked to pay. They just did his.
It would have been nice if that info was available. I've Googled high and low trying to find when it was introduced. By not knowing, my monies in the bank for my next visa/extension has had no time to season. The officer gave me 2 choices. First, get a 60 day visa/extension which would sort out my dilemma. Second, was to pay 30,000 under the table. Guess which one I took?
Now if only other farangs will stand their ground when visiting immigration. May be all this corruption siht would fade away?
Get off your moral high-horse. I personally like having an option to a bureaucratic nightmare even if that means petty-corruption. I don't know what rights you think you're protecting because you have none here.
-
Just renewed my retirement at Jomtien and they were not at all interested in seeing the health insurance I had. Suggest anyone concerned about whether or not they'll be asked for it renews early and before they spend money on redundant health insurance locally.
-
On 2/6/2019 at 2:38 PM, jacko45k said:
Any mention of when you do the 90 day report you will need to prove you still have the 800,000 baht?
Haven't they ever heard of the concepts of auditing and using telephones? Select retirees at random and checking to see if they have the 800,000 Baht correctly deposited, If there's any question, call the bank instead of making the expat run back and forth with one of those silly letters.
Signing a document giving Immigration blanket permission to check with your bank by phone at any time would be more efficient for them and easier for us.
- 1
-
Does pulling at least 65,000 a month out of a Thai bank through a Thai ATM machine count as having money in a Thai bank?
They just don't seem to get it, many pensions will not deposit benefits directly into a foreign bank.
Unfortunately those thermal printed slips most ATM machines spit out fade and become unreadable within a few months.
Whether here or at home there is nothing worse than trying to deal with a god damned government bureaucracy.
-
On 12/26/2018 at 3:47 PM, bbi1 said:
I guess you don't live under Jomtien Immigration then. Apparently Jomtien is fining everyone they can. I've seen it in person and lots of reports have been mentioned here as well. A 1,600 baht fine to the tenant (foreigner), not to the owner of the condo.
I am, but I probably won't be for long. I've had enough of this xenophobic crap. The biggest thing keeping me here is a couple of 10 year old dogs I could not bring myself to abandon and which will be hard to ship elsewhere.
- 1
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
The hell with it, i'm not going to worry about it. I'm not a criminal on parole and wont tolerate being treated like one. The first time some petty bastard tried to fine me for going away for the weekend it would be time to find another place to live.
- 3
- 1
-
Are you American? I ask because the FATCA legislation passed a few years back imposed ridiculous reporting requirements on foreign banks that deal with Americans. Many responded by refusing American clients.
Some banks have decided to comply and will accept Americans now. I opened an account with Krung Thai Bank with no problem when this nightmare started 2 months ago.
Google FATCA for mire information, it's so absurd as to deny belief.
- 1
-
11 hours ago, LomSak27 said:
Come on, if you are putting money in seasoning for R, you don't make mistakes, you don't pare it down to save a quid or two ................. ????
Just as absurd, they could have let him go to the bank, deposit 100 Baht then come back. When someone in authority behaves in the manner claimed by the OP it has little to do with the requirements. If a cop cites you for 26 in a 25 zone, there's something wrong with the cop, not you.
- 2
-
- Popular Post
3 hours ago, ocddave said:The only way I could see that working would be the same way I had to verify my marriage certificate from the US, which is extremely time consuming and costly. Obviously you have to have the document notarized in the US, then the Secretary of State from the US State has to verify the local notary, then you have to send that to the US Federal Secretary of State to verify the Local State Secretary, then to the Thai Embassy to verify the US Secretary of State, then finally bring that document to Thailand and have the Thai MFA certify the Thai Embassy verification. Let me tell you, that took forever, but thats pretty much the only way you are ever going to "definitively prove" any US Income document to Thai officials. Yes, you can say someone might accept whatever document you give them, but really, how the heck can anyone prove it "definitively"?
The embassy staff could stand you in front of a PC and watch every keystroke while you log into your home country bank account and the source of your pension and examine the contents of each with your permission to see that they match the documents you're submitting. Pretty hard to fake that. Might take 10 whole minutes or so, and they could even charge a ridiculous price for it if they wanted. Sad for guys who have been here many years to suddenly have to leave. If they cared they would find a solution as easily as I just did.
- 1
- 3
-
9 minutes ago, yannee4u said:
Yes, that's true but while exit from suwarnbhumi airport immigration officer didn't any cancellation stamp on my passport.
Sorry, just an opinion but that sounds pretty weak. I expect they pay more attention to the information in their computer than what's on paper in your passport. Good luck to you.
- 1
-
- Popular Post
Sorry you are under such stress. You might try contacting the bank in your home country that processes your pension every month and see if they will give you a loan of any type to cover some of all or the requirement. After all they know exactly what your income is and where it comes from. I had the same problem with a government pension that would only deposit into an American bank and my bank surprised me and approved an online signature loan application in 2 hours.
Government pensions are actually the most stable form of income a person can have. You can't get laid off or fired from a pension.
Whatever you do, good luck to you.
- 3
-
Politely no, thoughtful would be reaching some agreement with Thai Immigration to at least examine pension statements and American bank account statements and certify that they at least appear to be in order and are reasonable for the person presenting them.
I always took pension 1099 firms, bank statements and my last tax return when getting an income verification and they had no interest in seeing them. Has anyone ever been prosecuted for perjury for lying on an affidavit? Of course the Thais got sick of this nonsense. Asking Thai Immigration to examine these documents would be like asking an American to examine Thai documents, absolutely pointless.
Frankly the Embassy just don't give a damn and this small effort is a show.
- 1
- 1
-
On 11/15/2018 at 5:46 PM, Swiss1960 said:
On the day you go and get the letter from the bank, you have to do a withdrawal (I do 1000 Baht and put it back immediately), otherwise Jomtien does not like /accept the account.
The 2 transactions are the only ones I do on this account all year long, as it is my "immigration account".
Sent from my SM-A730F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app
No insult to you, but how idiotic can they get? What the xxxx is the letter from the the bank for for then? If it wasn't your money the bank wouldn't write the letter with your name on it. This nonsense is getting old very fast. My plan was to put the money and a slight cushion in the bank and leave it there until I'm ready to leave this place. Like most pensions mine can only be deposited into a bank in my home country and I pull it out here by ATM. (yea I know expensive but convenient)
-
On 11/6/2018 at 5:31 PM, john smith said:
I just returned from huahin immigration. I was informed that for a non marriage retirement visa renewal only B800,000 in the bank will be accepted if there is no embassy letter confirming income. The officer stated this quite clearly and repeated it when asked again
Unless there are on-going discussions or considerations, Immigration would be doing those affected a favor by clearly announcing this now officially and for all offices. That would at least give those affected more time to dispose of possessions that cannot be shipped elsewhere and make other plans. This silence is doing no one any favor.
The flip side is one if going to feel very foolish if he or she sells their car, motorcycle and other possessions in Thailand, then learns there is a way for them to stay there.
One has to wonder how many suicides are going to result from this, 10 year plus Thailand residents with no where to go.
President Trump is getting justifiably slammed for deporting illegal alien Mexicans who came to America as children and are essentially American though with illegal immigration status. This is far worse, changing the rules for people who settled here legally. Not telling them as early as possible is only going to make it worse.
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
21 hours ago, the guest said:I think Thailand has every right to expect money in the country if you living as a non-tourist. Obvious things like insurance where many foreigner choose not have to have any will cover any burden on the country in the event something goes wrong.
Try getting in Europe without proper insurance or a good income !
Sure, but you don't let people settle here under one system, have them give up their homes abroad and acquire possessions here only to suddenly have the rules changed arbitrarily and be asked to leave. Trump is catching a lot of deserved criticism for the deportations in America, but those are all people who entered illegally. Forcing people with homes, possessions, cars, pets who settled here legally to leave because of an arbitrary rule change is downright evil.
- 2
- 1
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
^ ^^ I solved my problem tonight in a way I didn't think possible; the California Bank which receives and processes my pension checks every month approved a $25000 online loan request in less than 2 hours. I then called them and all is good. I didn't think they would approve it with me in Thailand but they did and are even letting me sign the loan papers electronically by e mail.
I feel so relieved. Those on pensions may want to check with their banks at home as a possible source of all or some of the required sum.
- 4
- 1
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
There's no reason to think Burriram or Immigration in general are going to back down from the 400,000/800,000 in the Thai bank requirement. I don't blame them in a way, anything else is too easy for the scammers to fake but it was imposed too suddenly. I'm 60 and didn't even have a savings account until I opened one at a Thai Bank last week. (at 60 what do I have to save for?)
I'm desperately trying save cash as quickly as I can, and hope to get one more year under the old system by getting an income verification letter on the last day (31st December at America Embassy). You may want to do the same at your embassy if buying more time will help.
Sad, my income from a police retirement works out to 129,000 Baht a month, nearly twice the requirement but scraping 800,000 Baht together with 5 months notice is nearly impossible. It's not what they did, but how suddenly they did it with no notice that is going to wreck many people's lives.
- 10
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
3 hours ago, Acharn said:So, the embassies say they are going to stop issuing the income letters (affidavits) because Immigration has told them they will not accept them without verification by the embassies, which the embassies cannot do. The head of the Phuket office says, of course they will not accept the income letter because the embassies are not going to issue them. ONE way you can prove you have the money is to provide a bank statement showing you have the funds on deposit (in a Thai bank). I'm waiting for the Chief of Immigration to issue a comprehensive policy statement explaining exactly what they will accept. I think they have to accept the monthly income, because it's part of the law, but they can make it difficult or impossible depending on what they demand as proof of the income. It would probably take me eight to ten years to accumulate the lump sum of ฿800,000. so I may very well be screwed.
I think many of us fit that description; yea we have the 65000 Baht a month required but scraping together 800,000 Baht to deposit in a Thai bank account will be difficult and unpleasant.
- 3
Why are modern movies so bad?
in ASEAN NOW Community Pub
Posted
I thought it was to stop piracy, make <deleted> not worth stealing, though Midway was a damn good movie.