Jump to content

Lakegeneve

Member
  • Posts

    1,990
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Lakegeneve

  1. On the free side, it is worth remembering that every BTS extension aside from the Bang Wah last 2 stations opening, has had a period of free rides offered by the BMA as 'compensation' for delayed openings.

     

    In this case, this extension was originally scheduled to open in Dec 2016. 

  2. On 16 November 2018 at 8:41 PM, Just Weird said:

    Yes, but at 8pm the trains come every 1 ½ minutes so the four trains you waited for took about the same time to arrive as one train outside of peak periods!  When one train is in the station at Asoke the lights of the next train can be seen approaching from Nana.

    This is completely incorrect. The most frequent headway the BTS operates is 2.20-2.40min during the middle of the morning and afternoon peak period on the Suk line.

     

    In fact there are only a few metros in the world that operate a 90sec headway, Hong Kong and Shanghai being the most obvious and thats because they have the high frequency signalling to support such a headway. (Note: no one in the world operate less than a 90sec headway). 

     

    At 8pm you are looking at around a 3.5min to 4min headway, adjusting to 6min headway between 8-10pm.

     

    People often mistake headway by viewing at an oncoming train after one has departed, but this is misleading and neglects the dwell time for unloading & loading. You need to time it from the exact same point and the exact same action, i.e., the train stopping or the train departing from the exact same point. 

    • Like 1
  3. On 8 November 2018 at 2:15 PM, flbkk said:

    So what is the latest, when stations beyond Samrong on the Sukhumvit line will open? 

     

    I had to laugh when I read this.....there was literally 3 posts just a few above yours in this same page which gave the opening date! 

  4. 1 hour ago, Nit Noi said:

     

    Can anyone answer the question as to whether the capacity in the core of the system (let's say Phaya Thai to On Nut) is going to be increased with the opening of the extension?  They can increase capacity either through running trains more frequently or adding carriages to the existing trains.  As far as I can tell, the new trains ordered will only cover service on the extension and will not bring more service to the rest of the system.  Surely this new extension will bring in additional riders to the core, which is already jammed in the stations, at the turnstiles, and on the platforms.  What is BTS going to do to accommodate these additional passengers?

    Still aiming for opening on the 5th....not sure where the 6th came from?

     

    Regarding capacity, read the post on rolling stock back 5 or 6 pages for some critical points on this issue. There will still be overcrowding, esp in the early months as most of the rolling stock (factored for future growth) has yet to be delivered. The BTS model is to maximise pax numbers while delaying rolling stock expenditure as long as possible. Wait until the MRT Yellow and Pink lines open, they will be worse. 

     

    It will probably only eventually change if a couple of people die.......On this issue alone, the concession granted to the BTS should not be extended. 

    • Thanks 1
  5. On 10/10/2018 at 5:36 AM, Crossy said:

    It now seems that N9 (outside central Ladprao), the first stop past Mo Chit on the north extension is cited for operation in August next year, a >6 month delay on what was previously thought.

     

    Looking at the status of the civil works even that is likely pushing it.

     agree with your Crossy, the MRTA has been stating that this station will open in March 2019 which I took to mean sometime in the 2nd quarter. I pass there semi regularly and it is patently obvious that a March opening will not be met given that work on the actual station has not commenced and the viaduct is still being built. However, once they do start on the station structure most the civil works are built very quickly given the installation of pre-fab beams etc. It is the fitting out that always seems to take 2-3 times as long as it should, especially with the signalling and electrical systems. 

     

    Late 2nd quarter 2019 is still achievable if everything falls into place. Of course the irony here is that they should be aiming to open up the whole section to Ratcha Yothin intersection first as the 1st Phase rather than just one station. 

    • Like 1
  6. On 4 October 2018 at 4:31 PM, blackcab said:

    @Lakegeneve Do you have any info about the missing S4 Suksa Wittaya station please? Outside AIA Sathorn Tower there is a banner with the words "Sky Bridge Coming Soon".

    It was due to be built from mid this year but the tendered. It seems more like starting in the 1st quarter of next year? It will only take 9-12 months to build and fit out. 

    • Thanks 1
  7. On 27 September 2018 at 4:02 PM, Pepper9187 said:

    Okay thanks.


    Can i ask for your souces ? Not that i don't believe you but i got 3 sources (that i can't quote here) which all give different dates between late 2018 and until 2020

     

    Tx again

    MRTA.

     

    Nothing is opening for this ext in 2018 so ignore that. Dates have (and can/will) change so some of the other places where you are reading this are most likely either out of date or just not reliable for correct info. 

     

    The opening of the 1st section is still just under a year away so don't get too caught up at this stage. Remember, the whole extension was originally due to open in 2016 when construction started in mid 2011. Since 2016, there there have been 4 new different opening dates......

  8. On 23 September 2018 at 12:44 PM, Pepper9187 said:

    Thanks !

     

    I've read on a press website that the section between Tao Poon and Ta phra was sheduled for opening in 2018, the rest will be opened in mid 2019.

    Any idea if it's true ?

    Not correct. This will actually be the second section opening in 2020.

     

    The first section opening in Aug 2019 is the section from Hua lamphong via Tha Phra to Lak Song (along Phetkasem rd). The tunnelled section to Tha Phra has basically been complete since the start of this year and realistically it could most likely open later this year. However, the MRTA likes to open complete extensions/sections rather than opening them gradually. 

  9. 10 minutes ago, josephbloggs said:

    Might be a trick of the lens but some of those stations look really close together!

    Ave is around 1km apart. I'm actually surprised that the lens could film some of the more northern stations up near Lak Si circle. Impressive. (I wonder what/who else the owner is filming from his Suplai condo....?)

    • Like 2
  10. 16 hours ago, melvinmelvin said:

     

    I am also a fan of mass transit systems. But I have some serious doubts re the wisdom of what they are doing in BKK ++.

    I am reasonably sure they will strongly regret this within 10 years.

     

    Several new transport systems are being designed and built, all incompatible,

    electric light

    skytrain

    mrt-underground

    srt

    monorail

    and I am sure there are more

     

    If you look at BKK, you do not need to go far from the city centre before you find large areas of undeveloped land,

    can be used for housing can be used for business or both.

    When that happens a major shift in transport requirements will surface. In order to cater for that you need flexibility

    in the transport network. You dont have that. Too many incompatible systems.

    Many have written on this exact issue including moi over the years. (If you go back a few years into this thread you'll find a few posts that I wrote on this exact issue).

     

    I have been especially critical of the private concessionaire model used in Bangkok which I regard as flawed and which has lead to many of the problems we have experienced especially in relation to overcrowding and the delay of integrated ticketing. The lack of integrated ticketing is particularly appalling given the long delays and that it is the norm nearly everywhere else for decades. 

     

    The general lack of integration and interoperability is a big problem has it limits future options and has a complete lack of operational logic most highlighted by the SRT commuter red line plans. Heavy rail lines changed to monorail (Yellow and Pink) will have long term problems which I've mentioned numerous times.

     

    However, after years of delays and constant govt changes interfering with the process, we basically have to accept what is being built now and be happy that many lines have finally progressed to the point where we will have a basic, decent network in a few years. Major remedies will be required in the future to improve the network. However, when you look at major highway construction, new airports or other transport infrastructure built in Thailand that has always been the case (and most likely will continue to be so). 

    • Like 1
    • Thanks 1
  11. On 6/5/2018 at 1:23 PM, Lakegeneve said:

    ARL update:

    The Eastern HSR tender is out and the expectation is that a winning bid will be awarded by July/August with work commencing by the end of the year ....if all goes smoothly - which it never does! http://www.railway.co.th/download/2561/Invitation-to-Tender-HSR3Airports.pdf

     

    The Transport Ministry has decided that whoever wins the bid to build and run the Eastern HSR will also take over operating the ARL. The SRTET will be abolished and a new SRT entity will be established to manage the 4 planned HSR lines.

     

    I now estimate that any new rolling stock for the ARL will not be available until 2022 at the earliest unless the previously mentioned leasing plan come to fruition - knowing the SRT it probably won't.

    Quote

    I read in the news this week that soon also one new MRT train will arrive. Followed by more next year.

    It's been quiet about ARL purchases. The last news I heard that they plan to change some express line trains to commuter trains. Are those the missing trains that had some problems about the maintenance contract?

    CLW, no change to what I posted a few months ago. Expect not to see any new rolling stock before 2022..............

    • Thanks 1
  12. On 9/23/2014 at 11:06 AM, Lakegeneve said:
    Blue Line extension - Tha Phra station

     

    A great pic here of Blue Line extension Tha Phra station construction site. It will be built above the intersection of Phetkasem rd & Charan Sanit Wong rd (Inner Ring rd) which has a flyover.

     

     

    Tha Phra station is unique as it is an interchange station for the same line - very rare in the world. Both levels serve the Blue Line, which is a fake loop line. The design also means that the Blue line can be extended further south along the Inner Ring rd in the future if required. (See the following post regarding the Grey line).

     

     

     

    Although, an extension west further along Phetkasem rd is currently being evaluated and will the first priority for any possible future extensions of this line once this extension is complete.

     

     

     

    gis62.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    summary-_0083.jpg

     

     

     

     

    %E0%B8%AA%E0%B8%96%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%99%E0%

     

     

     

     

    Quote

    How will this station Tha Pra work as an interchange station? It has three blue lines merging on it. Does everyone get off and change trains to proceed? Is one line a through line (and if so, which one?)?

    Crossy already answered you, but I have quoted an old post which shows the station design and render which may also help.

     

    There is also this recent MRTA PR video filmed at Tha Pra station which starts with a still of a birds eye view of the station;. Thankfully, the music is a little better than normal too;

     
     

     

    • Thanks 1
  13. My understanding is that that small mall with all the clothing shops is eventually being demolished to make way for a much larger center in preparation for when the BTS stations opens given that it can provide a direct connection. (Assuming that we are talking about the same place?).

     

    An added bit of information, all of that land west of Phahon Yothin rd  that Central occupies is SRT land which Central leases.

     

    Up until 2008 they were paying an absurdly cheap amount of around THB30-40m a year. Thereafter, with the new lease the SRT charged a more appropriate market rate of around 1 billion THB a year for the next 30 yr lease. (Similar to BMA paying 20m a year for the previous Chatuchak market lease when the SRT is now making over 1 billion THB a year.)

     

    This is one of the reasons why the SRT is so debt ridden.

    • Like 1
  14. The MRT station map will help with your exit options, https://www.bangkokmetro.co.th/map.aspx?Lang=En&Menu=8&Sid=10

     

    The other option you have if you want to bus it and save walking it or a motorbike/taxi fare is to exit at Huay Kwang station, exit 2 https://www.bangkokmetro.co.th/map.aspx?Lang=En&Menu=8&Sid=11, and walk the 100m south to the bus stop in front of Swissotel Hotel.

     

    Then catch the BMTA #36 bus (red, non aircon and not #136) which runs south along Ratchada then aorund to Meng Jai along Pracha Uthit rd and directly past the Cambodian Embassy . (Don't catch the #36 orange aircon bus as that doesn't do this route). It does exactly the same route shown on the map above from CW Tower onwards and take all of 10 mins max.

     

    You can take the reverse journey to end up back at Huay Kwang station.

     

     

     

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...