Chat GPT 4o recommended this reply: (refusing to use my suggest term 'Luddite'........lol)
"Ah, a classic blend of conspiracy theory, techno-skepticism, and coal nostalgia. Thanks for your well-researched insights. I’ll be sure to consult my wind turbine next time I plug in. 🙄"
DeepSeek R1 was a little bit more nuanced:
'Acknowledge Concerns & Provide Context:
Thank you for raising these points—it’s important to discuss the nuances of EV sustainability. While the carbon footprint of electric vehicles (EVs) depends on energy sources, the broader picture reveals meaningful progress.
1. Grid Decarbonization is Key:
Even in regions where grids rely on coal, studies show EVs often have lower lifetime emissions than gasoline cars due to greater energy efficiency. For example, a typical EV on a coal-heavy grid emits about 20-30% less CO2 over its life than a comparable ICE vehicle. Moreover, grids globally are transitioning to renewables—solar and wind now make up 80-90% of new electricity capacity added annually. As grids decarbonize, EVs inherently become cleaner.
2. Chinese EVs and Global Progress:
China, while still using coal, is the world’s largest investor in renewables, accounting for over 50% of global solar and wind installations in recent years. Its EVs are part of a strategy to reduce urban pollution and oil dependence. Many Chinese-made EVs also use batteries produced with cleaner energy (e.g., CATL’s Sichuan facility runs on 100% hydropower). Manufacturing emissions are a challenge industry-wide, but innovations like recycling and localized supply chains are addressing this.
3. Systemic Change vs. Individual Action:
No single solution will fix climate change, but EVs are a critical piece of the puzzle. Pairing them with grid decarbonization, renewable energy plans, and policy shifts amplifies their impact. Even without personal wind turbines, choosing a green energy tariff or supporting utility-scale renewables accelerates the transition.
4. Efficiency Matters:
Coal plants convert energy to electricity more efficiently (~33-40%) than gasoline engines convert fuel to motion (~20-30%). This means EVs on fossil grids still use energy more effectively, reducing per-mile emissions.
Closing Thought:
Transitioning to sustainable transport is a journey. While today’s grids aren’t perfect, EVs provide a scalable pathway to cleaner air and lower emissions as renewables expand. Let’s continue pushing for systemic changes while celebrating incremental wins!'
And here is another challenging bit for context: Thailand power generation relies only for 20% on coal.