Chris.C

Not inside Israel, they are a lunatic state. 82% of Israelis want to expel Palestinians from Gaza; 47% want to kill every man, woman, child https://geopoliticaleconomy.com/2025/05/30/poll-israelis-expel-palestinians-gaza-genocide/

They a have been slaves in a concentration camp for years, watch the video

I'm with the no 1 academic on Gaza regarding this. This US Jewish professor says it better than me. Hamas attack was akin to a slave revolt.

He did the same with me lol. Pathetic.

Israel can do no wrong according to right wing Jews. You’ve won’t condone ethnic cleansing. You won’t condone policies by Smotrich or Ben Gvir. Frankly, there are a few like you here that are openly supporting, ney cheering Genocide. This is the most islamophobic forum I’ve been on, is there no moderation to stop these vile comments and lies by you and your mate yagoda?

“The Arabs invaded first, so Palestinians caused their own Nakba.” Lu true. Before any Arab armies entered, over 200,000 Palestinians had already fled or been expelled. The Deir Yassin massacre and Haganah offensives triggered mass panic before May 15, 1948. Saying Arab states were “finishing what Hitler started” is not only false - it’s inflammatory. The 1948 war was a tragic, complex conflict, not a genocide. The claim that Palestinians “left because Arab leaders told them to” has been debunked by Israeli and international historians. Yes, some fled voluntarily - many were forcibly expelled. The Nakba was not just about war - it was about the destruction of over 400 villages and the permanent denial of return. 700,000 people lost homes and land. Comparing this to Jewish refugees from Arab countries? Different situation: Jews were absorbed into Israel. Palestinians were barred from return, stuck in camps, and denied compensation. Justice isn’t zero sum.

It’s not worth engaging with right wing fundamentalist. They are brainwashed

This was the plan all along, it’s disgusting how some support it.

At least my god can be spoken/pronounced, yours can’t as it’s spelt YHWH

Interesting, especially for the Americans. I neither condemn nor condone Hamas, for the record. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3kR6596DZo

No, you called others antisemitic when they criticized Israel. You misread my post.

It was a lie, read what you wrote

Well thanks for identifying what you are. im sure you know exactly what they said.

That’s a laugh after your antisemitism rants. Do you mean the Hamas, that only 5% of UN countries call terrorist? Stop reading the Times if Israel

This is also to @Nick Carter icp but he doesn’t have a pair to answer. If you continue to prolifically support far‑right Israeli politics, you’ll need to be honest about your background – otherwise, you’re hiding behind anonymity to push an agenda. That is not just evasive – it is cowardly. If you’re not Jewish, just say so and set the record straight.

Do you condemn what Jewish extremists Ben Gvir, Smotrich say about cleansing Gaza of Palestinians? Btw that is a war crime.

I studied this subject at Leeds University. Unlike you, I have no bias. In 1947, the United Nations proposed a Partition Plan (Resolution 181) to end British rule in Mandatory Palestine by dividing the territory into two states - one Jewish and one Arab. According to this plan, Jews - who made up about one-third of the population and owned roughly 6-7% of the land - were allocated 55% of the territory, including much of the fertile coastal plain. The Arab majority - around two-thirds of the population - were to receive just 45% of the land, most of it in less desirable areas. To Palestinians and Arab states, this was a deeply unfair arrangement. They saw it as a plan that legitimized the dispossession of the native Arab population to accommodate a largely European Jewish immigrant population, many of whom had only arrived in the preceding decades. Beyond the disproportionate land allocation, Palestinians rejected the plan for ideological and political reasons. The very idea of partition - of dividing their homeland to create a new state for another people - was perceived as a colonial imposition that ignored Arab self-determination. The memory of centuries of local rule, the influx of Zionist settlers under British protection, and fears of further displacement all contributed to Arab opposition. Though the Zionist leadership accepted the plan - as a strategic step toward statehood - Arab leaders rejected it on principle, believing that it violated their rights and sovereignty. The rejection led directly to the 1948 war following Israel’s declaration of independence - a war that resulted in over 700,000 Palestinians becoming refugees and the permanent failure of the proposed Palestinian state.

That’s a lie.

Hamas cannot be defeated. You extremist Jews know this, and as your buddy Smotrich says, “returning the hostages is not the most important thing”. You want all Palestinians out of Gaza and you don’t condemn West Banknsettlements, do you.

Jews could find refuge because Israel existed. You argue, “Jews could find refuge.” That’s right, that’s precisely the point. Jews from Arab countries were absorbed into Israel (and the West) because they had a state willing to take them in and integrate them. Palestinians do not have a state. They've been stateless in many places, living under occupation, blockade, or discrimination in host countries. Now Israel are ethnically cleansing Gaza and the West Bank. So the success of Jewish resettlement doesn’t prove Palestinians were treated equally, it shows the asymmetry of power and protection. Its well documented why Arab countries don’t accept Palestians, it’s horrid to suggest that is because they are lower than Jews. Do you admit, as a Jew, that most Jews feel superior to Palestinians?

Surely you can see the difference with Palestians. The right of return is consistent with international law and not unique to Palestinians. Palestinians are still recognized as refugees by the UN. Hindus displaced from Pakistan are not, because they’ve been resettled and given citizenship in India. Palestinians remain stateless and under military occupation in many areas. Jewish refugees from Arab lands at least found refuge and citizenship in Israel or other countries. Germans expelled after WWII became citizens of Germany. The injustice facing Palestinians persists in ways that other historical examples do not parallel as directly.

What a despicable, vile, islamophobic post.

He’s a far right Jewish fundamentalist, it’s clear from his posts.

stand with Israel because I believe the Jewish people have a right to a homeland and refuge where they can live without persecution. A Jewish-majority sovereign state is the best way to ensure another attempt at exterminating the world's Jews won't take place or fail if it does. A militarily and economically strong Israel is the best defense against the antisemitism Jews have suffered since Roman times. Six million Jews. roughly 40% of the world's Jews and two-thirds of Europe's Jews, lost their lives between 1939-1945 and national governments, even in the Western democracies, did very, very little to save them. Jews cannot depend on others to protect them; they have to do it themselves. Never again is now. I am not Jewish but I have in the past lived and worked in Israel. I have a profound respect for the country, its cultural, religion and people. I also believe the best way for non-Jews to fight antisemitism is to stand with Israel. Israelis have stood against enormous odds and all attempts to destroy their country since 1948. The least I can do is to say I stand with them and speak out against antisemitism whenever and wherever I Thanks for replying. I understand now if you’ve lived in Israel. Supporting Israel as a state does not require uncritical endorsement of all its actions or policies, particularly when they impact others' rights and lives. The tragedy of Jewish persecution over centuries, culminating in the Holocaust, undeniably justifies the need for a safe haven for Jews. However, the creation of the modern State of Israel in 1948 also involved the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians, many of whom remain refugees to this day. That reality is not erased by Israel’s democratic or cultural achievements. If “Never Again” is a moral imperative, it must apply universally,not only to Jews, but to all people. Antisemitism is a vile hatred that must be opposed everywhere, but criticizing the policies of the Israeli government, especially those that violate international law or perpetuate occupation and inequality, is not antisemitic. Many Jews, both inside and outside of Israel, are critical of their government's policies, particularly with regard to the occupation of Palestinian territories and the treatment of Palestinians. Do you stand with Ben Gvir - “Occupation, settlement, and encouragement of emigration. Only in this way can we solve the problem of Gaza. To occupy all the land. To settle in all the land. And of course, to encourage the voluntary emigration of as many [Palestinian] people as possible to other countries.” Do you stand with Smotrich? “Returning the hostages is not the most important thing.” “If the hostages…and the dead, are not returned… Israel will expand the agricultural areas… into the perimeter area of the Gaza Strip… this land will remain in our hands forever.” “There is no such thing as the Palestinian people … The Palestinian people is an invention that is less than 100 years old.” “It’s time to stop fearing the word occupation. We are conquering Gaza to stay … There will be no more temporary maneuvering.”

This leading Jewish professor’s parents survived concentration camps.