The US indictment of former Cuban president Raúl Castro has intensified speculation over Washington’s next steps towards Havana, as the Trump administration increases pressure on the island’s Communist government.
Get today's headlines by email 
Castro, 94, has been charged with murder over the 1996 downing of two civilian aircraft by Cuban fighter jets, an incident that killed four people. The move comes amid severe economic hardship in Cuba, where fuel shortages, blackouts and food scarcity have deepened public frustration.
President Donald Trump has said he does not believe “escalation” will be necessary, but senior US officials have continued to warn against the presence of a hostile government close to US territory.
Analysts say three broad scenarios could emerge as tensions rise between Washington and Havana.
Capture of Raúl Castro
One possibility is a direct US operation targeting Castro himself.
The indictment immediately prompted comparisons with recent US action in Venezuela, where American forces captured President Nicolás Maduro earlier this year and transferred him to New York to face criminal charges. Observers have also pointed to the 1989 US invasion of Panama, which led to the arrest of former ruler Manuel Noriega.
Several Republican lawmakers have publicly suggested similar action could be taken against Castro. Florida Senator Rick Scott said Washington should not rule out such a mission.
Security analysts say an operation to detain Castro would likely be possible from a military standpoint, despite the extensive protection surrounding him. However, they warn that the political consequences could be far more complicated.
Experts also question how much impact Castro’s removal would have on Cuba’s current leadership. Since stepping down as president in 2018, he has largely been viewed as a symbolic revolutionary figure rather than a central decision-maker.
Negotiated leadership change
Another possible outcome is a negotiated political transition involving elements of Cuba’s existing leadership.
Trump has repeatedly hinted that some Cuban officials are seeking US assistance as economic conditions worsen on the island. In a post on Truth Social earlier this month, he said Cuba was “asking for help”.
Shortly afterwards, CIA Director John Ratcliffe met Cuban officials including Castro’s grandson, Raúl Guillermo Rodríguez Castro, and Interior Minister Lázaro Álvarez Casas.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio later said Washington preferred a “negotiated agreement” with Havana rather than a violent confrontation.
Analysts say the administration may be looking for reforms that stop short of dismantling the Cuban state entirely. Possible US demands could include economic liberalisation, increased foreign investment and reduced Russian or Chinese influence on the island.
However, experts note that Cuba lacks a clear alternative figure capable of taking over leadership in the way Venezuelan officials emerged during that country’s crisis. Cuba’s political system is also viewed as more centralised and tightly controlled.
Economic collapse and migration
A third scenario is that Cuba’s worsening economic crisis could place further strain on the government and trigger wider instability.
The island has faced prolonged power cuts, fuel shortages and shortages of basic goods as economic conditions deteriorate. Trump recently described Cuba as “falling apart” and suggested authorities were struggling to maintain control.
Even so, specialists on Cuba argue that the country’s security structures remain intact despite the economic turmoil. They say there is an important distinction between the weakness of the economy and the continued functioning of the state.
Analysts also warn that any broader collapse could lead to a major migration crisis, with large numbers of Cubans attempting to leave the island.
Florida would likely be the main destination because of its proximity to Cuba, although some migrants could also head towards Mexico. Experts say the worsening shortages of food and healthcare would normally be expected to drive even larger numbers of people to flee.
Join the discussion? 
Already a member? 
Adapted by ASEAN Now. Source 22 May 2026
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment