rooster59 Posted January 5, 2019 Share Posted January 5, 2019 Moscow says FBI arrested Russian a day after it detained ex-U.S. Marine By Maxim Rodionov and Barbara Goldberg Paul Whelan, a U.S. citizen detained in Russia for suspected spying, appears in a photo provided by the Whelan family on January 1, 2019. Courtesy Whelan Family/Handout via REUTERS MOSCOW/NEW YORK (Reuters) - The Russian Foreign Ministry said on Saturday the United States had detained a Russian citizen, a day after Moscow arrested the former U.S. Marine Paul Whelan on suspicion of spying. Whelan was taken into custody by Russia's Federal Security Service on Dec. 28. His family have said he is innocent and that he was in Moscow to attend a wedding. The ministry said the United States detained Russian citizen Dmitry Makarenko on Dec. 29 on the Northern Mariana Islands, a U.S. commonwealth in the Pacific Ocean, and had transferred him to Florida. "... Makarenko, born in 1979, has arrived on Saipan Island with his wife, underage children and elderly parents. He was detained by FBI personnel at the airport right after his arrival," the ministry said. The U.S. Embassy in Moscow could not immediately be reached for comment. A State Department spokesman in Washington referred a request for comment to the Department of Justice, which did not immediately respond. Papers filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida show Makarenko was accused in June 2017 by federal prosecutors of conspiring with another man, Vladimir Nevidomy, to export defence articles including night-vision scopes from the United States to Russia without U.S. approval. Makarenko, who was listed as a resident of Vladivostok, was declared a fugitive from U.S. justice in Jan. 2018. Nevidomy, a resident of Hallandale Beach, Florida, pleaded guilty in June 2018 and was sentenced to 26 months in prison, the court papers showed. The accusations from both sides could further complicate a strained relationship between Moscow and Washington, despite the professed desire of Presidents Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin to build a personal rapport. U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said this week that Washington had asked Moscow to explain Whelan's arrest and would demand his immediate return if it determined his detention is inappropriate. Britain cautioned Russia on Friday that individuals should not be used as diplomatic pawns. Whelan also holds a British passport. The Russian ministry said in its statement that Moscow diplomats had not been able to reach Makarenko in Florida and said Washington had yet to explain his detention. Before Moscow gave details of Makarenko's detention, experts had speculated that Moscow could exchange Whelan for Russian nationals held by Washington. Commenting on that possibility, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on Saturday: "I see no reasons to raise this issue in context of exchanges. We should undergo all the procedures needed in this situation," Interfax news agency quoted Ryabkov as saying. Whelan's Toronto-based twin brother David Whelan told Reuters on Saturday that U.S. embassy officials met with his sibling on Wednesday and would visit him again next week. "He seemed as well as can be expected in a Russian jail. He was missing a lot of personal necessities, like toilet paper, that aren't provided," David Whelan said in a telephone interview. "So the State Department has helped us set up an account ... so that he can buy the supplies that he needs." -- © Copyright Reuters 2019-01-06 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
stevenl Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 Wouldn't surprise me. If China's detention of 2 Canadian's is connected to Huawei's arrest, then this must surely be connected as well. Unless someone thinks the US has the moral high ground? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Credo Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 6 minutes ago, stevenl said: Wouldn't surprise me. If China's detention of 2 Canadian's is connected to Huawei's arrest, then this must surely be connected as well. Unless someone thinks the US has the moral high ground? I think the difference is that a civilian judge will be overseeing the charges. A tit-for-tat won't work so well in that case. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tug Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 Are we regressing back to the 17th century Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. So question is why only US demanding his release and only US officials visit him ? Why UK and Canada are rather passive about the issue Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
stevenl Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 3 hours ago, BestB said: Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. So question is why only US demanding his release and only US officials visit him ? Why UK and Canada are rather passive about the issue Most likely this means he entered Russia on his US passport. Hence the US is involved, and not the other countries. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Redline Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 Ummm, that’s how it works ???????? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Srikcir Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 7 hours ago, rooster59 said: Moscow says FBI arrested Russian a day after it detained ex-U.S. Marine If Putin was implying some kind of unfair quid pro quo related to Russia's arrest of Whelan, it doesn't work. Russian citizen Makarenko was indicted, arrested and pleaded guilty in the US. Thereafter, he fled, an arrest warrant was issued and apprehended in US sovereign territory Northern Mariana Islands. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 48 minutes ago, stevenl said: Most likely this means he entered Russia on his US passport. Hence the US is involved, and not the other countries. Sure, only 2 other passports in his possession as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
stevenl Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 7 minutes ago, BestB said: Sure, only 2 other passports in his possession as well. Doesn't matter, it is the passport he entered on. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ulic Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 7 hours ago, BestB said: Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. So question is why only US demanding his release and only US officials visit him ? Why UK and Canada are rather passive about the issue Apparently, he has an Irish passport as well. From what I have read all countries have protested his arrest but the US is the big swinging dick in the sandbox is taking point. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gillyflower Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 7 hours ago, BestB said: Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. So question is why only US demanding his release and only US officials visit him ? Why UK and Canada are rather passive about the issue He has 4 passports. You forgot the Irish one. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 18 minutes ago, Ulic said: Apparently, he has an Irish passport as well. From what I have read all countries have protested his arrest but the US is the big swinging dick in the sandbox is taking point. Is it even legal to be a a citizen of 4 countries? Dual nationalities are ok, but 4? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 7 hours ago, BestB said: Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. So question is why only US demanding his release and only US officials visit him ? Why UK and Canada are rather passive about the issue The question is based on an invalid premise. The US is not the only country requesting his release and seeking consular access. The UK, US and Ireland have all intervened with the Russians on his behalf and Canada may have done but will not confirm it one way or the other, "Due to the provisions of the Privacy Act ..." Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
from the home of CC Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 This Whelan seems to have the MO of a con man. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 1 minute ago, GroveHillWanderer said: The question is based on an invalid premise. The US is not the only country requesting his release and seeking consular access. The UK, US and Ireland have all intervened with the Russians on his behalf and Canada may have done but will not confirm it one way or the other, "Due to the provisions of the Privacy Act ..." Have not seen any news reports on anyone else but US only , you have any links for other 3 countries seeking his release? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 18 minutes ago, BestB said: Is it even legal to be a a citizen of 4 countries? Dual nationalities are ok, but 4? No country to the best of my knowledge, talks specifically about dual nationality (for instance, as stated on the US State Department website, US Law doesn't mention it) and even if they did, as far as I'm aware the same principles would apply to having multiple additional passports, as to having two. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 14 minutes ago, BestB said: Have not seen any news reports on anyone else but US only , you have any links for other 3 countries seeking his release? Multiple embassies working to help Paul Whelan "At least three countries have confirmed that they have requested consular access to Whelan: The U.S., Britain and Ireland say they're working to support him in detention and ensure his rights are respected." As mentioned, the Canadians will not confirm or deny their involvement due to privacy laws. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 1 minute ago, GroveHillWanderer said: Multiple embassies working to help Paul Whelan Thanks for that, will be interesting to know explanation for having 4 passports where all appear to be genuine. I am certain UK can forget about having access to any information or even access to see him after UK's refusal to cooperate with Moscow previously Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 1 minute ago, BestB said: Thanks for that, will be interesting to know explanation for having 4 passports where all appear to be genuine. I am certain UK can forget about having access to any information or even access to see him after UK's refusal to cooperate with Moscow previously It depends what you mean by the "explanation for having 4 passports." The legal explanation is that he is entitled to four passports because he qualifies for all of them according to the laws of these countries. As to why he personally chose to get four passports, according to a family friend, "There was an ongoing competition with his sister to see who could get the most." Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 6 minutes ago, GroveHillWanderer said: It depends what you mean by the "explanation for having 4 passports." The legal explanation is that he is entitled to four passports because he qualifies for all of them according to the laws of these countries. As to why he personally chose to get four passports, according to a family friend, "There was an ongoing competition with his sister to see who could get the most." Yup, sounds totally legit Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 8 hours ago, BestB said: Only Whelan holds 3 passports , US, UK and Canadian, has worked in Russia for a decade and speaks Russian and has an apartment over looking kremlin. Not sure about that - at least according to his twin brother David, in an interview with the BBC, Paul Whelan does not speak Russian. I also can't find any info that say he has worked in Russia or has an apartment there, only that he had visited Russia several times over the past twelve years or so. Do you have any links supporting those assertions? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 Just now, GroveHillWanderer said: Not sure about that - at least according to his twin brother David, in an interview with the BBC, Paul Whelan does not speak Russian. I also can't find any info that say he has worked in Russia or has an apartment there, only that he had visited Russia several times over the past twelve years or so. Do you have any links supporting those assertions? https://www.rt.com/news/448101-whelan-us-uk-spy-russia/ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GroveHillWanderer Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 4 minutes ago, BestB said: https://www.rt.com/news/448101-whelan-us-uk-spy-russia/ That says nothing about him living there for ten years or having an apartment overlooking the Kremlin. It does talk about him 'reportedly' having a basic command of Russian but that's hardly official confirmation and doesn't necessarily mean he can speak it. I have a basic knowledge of Russian (took it at 'O' level in England many moons ago) but I wouldn't say I speak it. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BestB Posted January 6, 2019 Share Posted January 6, 2019 5 minutes ago, GroveHillWanderer said: That says nothing about him living there for ten years or having an apartment overlooking the Kremlin. It does talk about him 'reportedly' having a basic command of Russian but that's hardly official confirmation and doesn't necessarily mean he can speak it. I have a basic knowledge of Russian (took it at 'O' level in England many moons ago) but I wouldn't say I speak it. It says he has profile on Russian social sites. I am certain I read he lived or worked on/off for 10 years, since 2007 or something like that. Will try to find previous articles later, now on the phone is hard Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.