Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Thailand News and Discussion Forum | ASEANNOW

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

EU Freezes Russia's €210bn for Ukraine Loan Amid Legal Clash

Featured Replies

  • Popular Post

image.jpeg

File photo for reference only

 

European Union governments have decided to freeze Russian assets indefinitely amounting to €210bn (฿8 trillion), immobilised since Russia's comprehensive invasion of Ukraine. The move sets the stage for a potential agreement at the upcoming EU summit to use the assets to back a loan, assisting Ukraine with its military and economic needs. The plan, however, has stirred legal action from Russia, accusing the EU of appropriation, with the Russian Central Bank suing Belgian bank Euroclear in a Moscow court.

 

Russia's assets in the EU, primarily held by Euroclear, have been frozen since February 2022. The EU and Ukraine argue these funds should aid Ukraine’s reconstruction efforts, with EU leaders dubbing them a "reparations loan." While Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky champions this use of funds, legal challenges, particularly from Russia and Belgium, persist. Belgium's Prime Minister Bart De Wever insists on stringent conditions to safeguard his country against potential financial risks stemming from this plan.

 

Belgium remains apprehensive, fearing the destabilisation of international finance, with Euroclear’s chief executive voicing concerns over the plan's implications. The EU is racing to devise a solution that Belgium can endorse by next Thursday's summit. Proposals include tapping into capital markets for funding, though unanimity among EU leaders—opposed by Hungary and Slovakia—poses a challenge. An alternative proposal involves offering Ukraine loans from the Russian assets currently held by the European Central Bank, reported then BBC.

 

Looking to ensure Belgium's cooperation, the EU has proposed guarantees to protect against any losses Euroclear might incur. They aim to neutralise Belgium's legal exposures by indefinitely freezing Russia's central bank assets, circumventing the need for periodic renewal votes. Swedish Finance Minister Elisabeth Svantesson underscored the measure as crucial for increasing support for Ukraine. Despite Belgium’s cautions, the EU persists in traversing a complicated legal and financial landscape to bolster Ukraine.

 

 

 

Key Takeaways

 

  • The EU indefinitely freezes €210bn in Russian assets for Ukraine aid.
  • Belgium seeks protection against financial risks amid legal challenges.
  • EU proposals aim to bridge Ukraine funding with differing member state views.

 

 

image.png  Adapted by ASEAN Now from BBC 2025-12-13

 

 

image.png

 

image.png

  • Popular Post

1. LEGAL CHALLENGES TAKE YEARS TO PLAY OUT? HOW WOULD A CHALLENGE IMPACT THE LOAN?

* A legal challenge would not block the use of the assets while proceedings were ongoing.

* At the ECJ, the average duration of a suit and appeal is more than three years.

* The ECJ's threshold to approve an injunction is very high, dubbed "draconian" by one legal expert, and would involve independent evidence and research.

 

2. WHAT DO LAW EXPERTS SAY ABOUT HOW LEGALLY SOUND THE PROPOSAL IS?

* Legal experts have said the Commission has entered into unprecedented territory, making the outcome of any potential suit hard to predict.

* Experts say Belgium or Euroclear would have a stronger case than Russia to argue against the reparations loan. However, when it comes to sanctions the ECJ tends to uphold foreign policy measures.

* The EU has been careful to bypass outright expropriation and the Commission's plan is to borrow against cash balances from matured securities held by Euroclear accounts.

 

 

3. * Moscow's war has been deemed illegal in international courts because it was an unprovoked attack. It would not be able to challenge the EU's justification to immobilise the assets in the first place as a countermeasure.

* Further, the mechanism is temporary and reversible if Russia stops the war.

* Russia's claim that the assets have been confiscated has not matured. Sanctions override commercial contracts and the question would arise as to whether the assets were actually expropriated or theoretically still available.

 

Explainer-What are the legal risks of EU's 'reparations loan' for Ukraine?

5 hours ago, bannork said:

1. LEGAL CHALLENGES TAKE YEARS TO PLAY OUT? HOW WOULD A CHALLENGE IMPACT THE LOAN?

* A legal challenge would not block the use of the assets while proceedings were ongoing.

* At the ECJ, the average duration of a suit and appeal is more than three years.

* The ECJ's threshold to approve an injunction is very high, dubbed "draconian" by one legal expert, and would involve independent evidence and research.

 

2. WHAT DO LAW EXPERTS SAY ABOUT HOW LEGALLY SOUND THE PROPOSAL IS?

* Legal experts have said the Commission has entered into unprecedented territory, making the outcome of any potential suit hard to predict.

* Experts say Belgium or Euroclear would have a stronger case than Russia to argue against the reparations loan. However, when it comes to sanctions the ECJ tends to uphold foreign policy measures.

* The EU has been careful to bypass outright expropriation and the Commission's plan is to borrow against cash balances from matured securities held by Euroclear accounts.

 

 

3. * Moscow's war has been deemed illegal in international courts because it was an unprovoked attack. It would not be able to challenge the EU's justification to immobilise the assets in the first place as a countermeasure.

* Further, the mechanism is temporary and reversible if Russia stops the war.

* Russia's claim that the assets have been confiscated has not matured. Sanctions override commercial contracts and the question would arise as to whether the assets were actually expropriated or theoretically still available.

 

Explainer-What are the legal risks of EU's 'reparations loan' for Ukraine?

 

I think that the two most important paragraphs are:

 

1. "Legal experts have said the Commission has entered into unprecedented territory, making the outcome of any potential suit hard to predict.

 

2. Belgium seeks protection against financial risks amid legal challenges"

 

I would rephrase 2 with, 'Belgium is effectively looking for cast-iron guarantees against financial risk' and won't budge easily as it is, unfortunately, in a dire state both financially and socially.

 

The string that holds the coalition government together is fraying rapidly. Almost unbelievably, the PM is a person who doesn't even support Belgium's existence: He's a Flemish nationalist! The capital, Brussels, has not had a regional government for 2+ years. The country's finances are a mess. There is a growing gun problem in Brussels concerning rival  drug gangs and there is general social unrest throughout the country.

 

Against a backdrop like this, it may take a long time to convince Belgium to move its position re Euroclear and Russian assets.

33 minutes ago, RayC said:

 

The string that holds the coalition government together is fraying rapidly. Almost unbelievably, the PM is a person who doesn't even support Belgium's existence:

 

Sounds like the UK under Starmer. I don't think he supports our existence either judging by his words and policies.

 

Anyway what a mess the EU has become. Thank goodness we left. 

 

Just need to replace Labour with Reform now. 

 

 

1 hour ago, JonnyF said:

 

Sounds like the UK under Starmer. I don't think he supports our existence either judging by his words and policies.

 

Disagreeing with government policy, believing that it will have negative effects and demonstrating logically the reason(s) for that opinion is perfectly acceptable, normal, rational behaviour: Suggesting that the PM is a traitor without any evidence to support that belief is another thing and is not the behaviour of a rational person.

 

Do you really believe this nonsense or are you just trying to constantly antagonise and get a reaction?

 

1 hour ago, JonnyF said:

Anyway what a mess the EU has become. Thank goodness we left. 

 

Belgium is one of 27 sovereign, member states of the EU. As expected, some member states are performing better than others. Belgium is currently one of the poorer performers.

 

Yes, thank goodness that we have arrived at the 'sunlit uplands' and are experiencing all the promised benefits of having left the EU. Oh, hold on ....

 

1 hour ago, JonnyF said:

Just need to replace Labour with Reform now. 

 

 

Yes. Let's replace a government with a confused economic agenda with a government with a non-existent one, that'll work.

 

TBF Reform have belatedly recognised that their initial proposals were economically illiterate and incoherent. All they need to do now is formulate a new set of economic policies which won't send the markets into a tailspin if implemented. Don't hold your breath waiting for those to appear.

These unelected trough-snufflers should think through this poking of the bear!

  • Popular Post
Just now, philipsharpe said:

These unelected trough-snufflers should think through this poking of the bear!

Perhaps they don't have your fears...........🤫

On 12/13/2025 at 4:00 AM, webfact said:

The plan, however, has stirred legal action from Russia, accusing the EU of appropriation

If there is one thing Putin's Russia knows, it's how to appropriate foreign sovereign lands. 

Quid pro quo EU.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.