Experts disagree on authenticity of new Van Gogh sketches

[webfact]

Experts disagree on authenticity of new Van Gogh sketches

 

PARIS (AP) — Art experts are disagreeing as to whether a book of previously unpublished drawings reported to be by Dutch master Vincent Van Gogh is authentic or fake.

 

The book, "The Lost Arles Sketchbook," collated by eminent Canadian art historian Bogomila Welsh-Ovcharov, is being published internationally after reportedly being found in the southern French city of Arles near a hotel where Van Gogh used to stay.

 

Welsh-Ovcharov said the sketches appeared in an account book belonging to Mister and Missus Ginoux, owners of the "Cafe de la Gare," to whom Van Gogh gave numerous works.

 

"I started to look through all the drawings and each one had his fingerprint," she said, calling it an "OMG moment" at Tuesday's press conference in Paris.

 

According to the University of Toronto website, Welsh-Ovcharov has taught art history for 25 years and has created several Van Gogh exhibitions, including one at the Musee d'Orsay in Paris.

 

However, Amsterdam's Van Gogh Museum Director Axel Ruger says its experts have been aware of these drawings since 2008 and after examination they have repeatedly concluded that the previously-unknown sketches are complete fakes.

 

The museum said the drawings don't reflect Van Gogh's development at the time. He says the drawings use original brownish ink when Van Gogh used only black or purple ink that only later appeared brown because of age.

 

The museum also said its experts deemed the drawing style "monotonous, clumsy, and spiritless" with basic topographic errors.

 

-- © Associated Press 2016-11-17

[boomerangutang]

let's see the sketches.

 

I've read many chronicles of art works attributed to famous artists.  It's darn tough to get something which surfaces now, to pass muster with experts.   There was a British-based TV series which also dealt with that issue.  It was true-life people, not fiction or actors.  I found it fascinating.  One segment had an English couple which had a small Monet landscape.  Even though the half hour TV segment showed several strong reasons why the painting should be declared authentic, the faceless experts in Paris wouldn't agree.

 

Similarly, there are Van Gogh-attributed  painting hanging in galleries and in rich peoples' homes which certain knowledgeable 'experts' claim are fakes.   

 

[ddavidovsky]

Fingerprints should swing it.

[optad]

Like to see that author's name on the spine of the book. It's like a war of consonants and vowels. 

[ddavidovsky]

56 minutes ago, optad said:

Like to see that author's name on the spine of the book. It's like a war of consonants and vowels. 

 

Like Van HGHOUGHGH?

[stevenl]

Sounds to me like wishful thinking on the part of Welsh-Ovcharov.

[Retiredandhappyhere]

I know they are not genuine as I drew them all when I was at primary school.