That's one way to describe the end of the United States. Its literally the end of Law and Order. A thought experiment might be that the November elections are declared null and void, due to suspicions, specious or otherwise, about tampering, corruption, whatever. Which Governors decide they no longer have legal representation in Washington. Governors can't withhold federal tax. But a state can refuse to cooperate with the federal government in some circumstances. That's the principle behind the federal anti-commandeering doctrine: Washington generally cannot simply order a state government to administer a federal program for it. But they can say they are no longer collecting taxes for Washington, forcing Washington to directly collect taxes themselves. This isn't provoking a constitutional crisis when a constitutional crisis already exists. President: "The November election is cancelled because of alleged corruption." States: "The president has no constitutional authority to cancel an election. We recognise the existing Congress." Federal government: "You must comply with federal executive orders." States: "We won't use state employees or resources to implement them." Federal government: "We'll enforce the laws ourselves." States: "We won't obstruct you, but we won't assist you." It then ratchets up if a State says federal officials are not permitted to enforce federal law within their territory. If it goes to the Supreme Court, which if it sides with the President, could lead the states to declaring they no longer recognise the Supreme Court. A few more steps, and secession is on people's lips. Or states issue a statement to the effect: We remain part of the United States, but we do not recognise the authority of a federal government that has abolished constitutional representation. Meanwhile the federal government has run out of money. Its all rather Hollywood. The movie "Civil War" opens with a civil war happening, involving a California-Texas axis. They don't really go into the circumstances, except that the unnamed President holed up in a heavily fortified White House has just been elected for a 3rd term. The clever bit about the film is that you don't know who's in the "right". And that's why civil wars are particularly ferocious compared to conventional conflict. Its improbable, maybe impossible. But I wasn't expecting Yugoslavia to fall apart because of a few union meetings.
Create an account or sign in to comment