Report Controversy as Red-Whiskered Bulbul Faces Delisting in Thailand

[snoop1130]

Photo courtesy of Bangkok Post

 

In a controversial move that has sparked alarm among conservationists, Thailand’s Committee on Preserved and Protected Wildlife is considering removing the red-whiskered bulbul from its protected species list. Critics argue that this decision could lead to increased hunting and potentially push the bird towards extinction.

 

The committee, part of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, convened for the first time in two years to discuss this issue. Proponents of the change suggest reclassifying the bird as an "economic animal" to support local communities through bird breeding initiatives. However, the committee has sought further research, tasking three subcommittees to evaluate the proposal before a final decision is made.

 

Dr Kaset Sutasha, a veterinarian and researcher from Kasetsart University, has expressed strong opposition to the proposal. He claims the move is politically motivated, aiming to gain favour ahead of upcoming elections. "Turning natural resources into political tools undermines Thailand’s reputation in global conservation circles," Dr Kaset stated. Many countries are, in fact, moving towards stronger wildlife protection laws, which he sees as the correct path.

 

The red-whiskered bulbul, or nok krong hua jook in Thai, has seen its numbers dwindle, especially in southern Thailand where it is popular as a caged bird. This bird is highly valued for its vocal abilities, often featured in singing contests which boost its market value significantly.

 

A troubling practice has emerged where wild-caught birds are bred with those in captivity to enhance their songs, leading to ongoing illegal captures. Despite approximately one million bulbuls in captivity, only a small fraction—about 1%—are bred in these conditions; most are taken from the wild.

 

Dr Kaset also highlighted the growing issue of poaching in northern and northeastern regions, where declining wild populations are hunted to supply demand in the south. Reports point to diminishing numbers in key areas like Doi Inthanon National Park in Chiang Mai and various provinces in Isan.

 

"It is unjust to exploit the country's natural resources to serve some group of people," Dr Kaset remarked. He emphasised that the ministry’s responsibility should be focused on protection and preservation.

 

As the subcommittees conduct their studies, the future of the red-whiskered bulbul hangs in the balance. The decision will not only impact the bird's survival but could also shape Thailand’s conservation policies in the eyes of the world. The financial implications are considerable; a move away from protection could affect local economies, converting the birds into commercial assets.

 

Conservationists continue to urge for a science-driven approach, warning that the decision could set a dangerous precedent. Should the committee proceed with delisting, it might transform not only economic opportunities but also ecological responsibilities, reflecting broader challenges in the balance between conservation and commerce in Thailand.

 

  Adapted by ASEAN Now from Bangok Post 2025-07-21

 

 

[MarkBR]

Scientific advice should guide whether this bird is endangered & needs legal protection.

[KhaoHom]

5 minutes ago, MarkBR said:

Scientific advice should guide whether this bird is endangered & needs legal protection.

 

Except this bird is very commonly kept in Thailand and prized for it song. If they take it off the endangered list it's very possible that it will end up right back on it practically the next year.

 

The Chinese in the Muslims down south are absolutely mad about songbirds

[flaming dragon]