video screenshot

The UK government has vowed to defend its decision to revoke Shamima Begum's British citizenship, as the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) investigates the case. A government source emphasised that British courts have consistently upheld the decision. Due to national security concerns, the government stripped Begum of her citizenship after she left for the Middle East in 2015 and became linked with the Islamic State.

Begum was just 15 when she left London and married an IS fighter. Her lawyers argue that the decision didn't adequately consider whether she was a victim of grooming and trafficking. The ECHR has asked the UK Home Office to address questions regarding these considerations and any obligations owed to her under European human rights laws.

The UK government maintains that the home secretary will prioritise national security by defending the citizenship revocation. Begum has previously been denied the opportunity to challenge this decision by the UK Supreme Court. The ECHR investigation questions the UK's obligation to consider her victim status under Article 4, which prohibits slavery and forced labour.

Lawyer Gareth Pierce, representing Begum, argues that she was lured away as a teenager and criticises her lack of protection, especially since a friend had similarly vanished. Despite these claims, the British government remains resolute, asserting that Begum should not re-enter the UK. Critics, including shadow home secretary Chris Philp, assert she voluntarily supported extremists.

As the ECHR’s enquiries unfold, the UK government is preparing to defend its stance, while Begum’s legal team continues to challenge the decision. The outcome could have broader implications for similar cases in Europe, reported the BBC.

Key Takeaways

• The UK government is committed to defending its decision to revoke Shamima Begum's citizenship.

• The ECHR is enquiring if the UK failed to consider Begum as a potential victim of trafficking.

• The situation poses significant questions on international human rights obligations.

  

Adapted by ASEAN Now from BBC 2026-01-02

 

 

Okay, my 27-year old daughter still thinks I'm an idiot (she may be right). I think Shamima escaped an oppressive family culture as a horny 15-year old who thought she was running to freedom. Only to find, of course, not only was ISIS even more oppressive. Unlike her parents, they beheaded people, captured women for sex slaves aso. She still doesn't know if her two schoolmates are dead or alive.

At 27, one would think one's views have matured, particularly due to the experiences she's had. Shamima's have not. Neither has my daughter's. Even her own parents say she's dangerous. Surely she'd at least try to raise money to support ISIS in the UK.

If she has Bengali citizenship, send her there, if they'll even take her. She's sure to be soliciting for the cause in Bangladesh. Delusion is a powerful force.

Most of the British public don't give a dam what happens to this woman she made her choice to leave the UK so live with it

So no sympathy for her

No doubt 2 Tier Kier will have her back in a moment

Let's see what happens in the future 😱

Send her to Mars.

17 hours ago, koolkarl said:

Send her to Mars.

What did the Martians ever do to deserve her.

On a very 'Sobering' piece of info if true??

The number of UK Muslims males that went to Syria to fight for ISIS is a greater number than has ever signed up for the UK armed services?? If that is bona-fide that should be a concern.

Penalty for fighting against your own Crown Forces were death, losing citizenship should be grasped with both hands if still attached.

4 hours ago, tmd5855 said:

The number of UK Muslims males that went to Syria to fight for ISIS is a greater number than has ever signed up for the UK armed services??

Where did you get that piece of rubbish from?

On 1/2/2026 at 6:31 AM, webfact said:

The ECHR is enquiring if the UK failed to consider Begum as a potential victim of trafficking.

Time to leave the ECHR.

On 1/4/2026 at 1:04 PM, scottiejohn said:

Where did you get that piece of rubbish from?

If you read from the beginning, comment were prefaced with.....

On a very 'Sobering' piece of info if true??

The number of UK Muslims males that went to Syria to fight for ISIS is a greater number than has ever signed up for the UK armed services?? If that is bona-fide that should be a concern.

The other piece below is tinged with "Sarcasm"

Penalty for fighting against your own Crown Forces were death, losing citizenship should be grasped with both hands if still attached.

47 minutes ago, tmd5855 said:

On a very 'Sobering' piece of info if true??

The number of UK Muslims males that went to Syria to fight for ISIS is a greater number than has ever signed up for the UK armed services?? If that is bona-fide that should be a concern.

So you are spreading unverified rumours, hiding behind 'I don't know if true, but if ...'

20 hours ago, stevenl said:

So you are spreading unverified rumours, hiding behind 'I don't know if true, but if ...'

That is a definite maybe, possibly so 🤫

On 1/2/2026 at 1:08 PM, unblocktheplanet said:

Okay, my 27-year old daughter still thinks I'm an idiot (she may be right). I think Shamima escaped an oppressive family culture as a horny 15-year old who thought she was running to freedom. Only to find, of course, not only was ISIS even more oppressive. Unlike her parents, they beheaded people, captured women for sex slaves aso. She still doesn't know if her two schoolmates are dead or alive.

At 27, one would think one's views have matured, particularly due to the experiences she's had. Shamima's have not. Neither has my daughter's. Even her own parents say she's dangerous. Surely she'd at least try to raise money to support ISIS in the UK.

If she has Bengali citizenship, send her there, if they'll even take her. She's sure to be soliciting for the cause in Bangladesh. Delusion is a powerful force.

I like your description of her as a horny 15 year old who thought she was running to freedom. I take issue with the rest of your post. There is no credible evidence that she still holds extremist views. Her father originally criticised her but as a Muslim father would. Her mother and siblings have asked for her return. To suggest she would raise money for ISIS is pure conjecture and given her situation should she return, highly unlikely. On balance I believe a naive 15 year old who has been groomed and radicalised should receive some understanding and given a second chance. Now pile on fellas!

On 1/3/2026 at 3:12 PM, koolkarl said:

Send her to Mars.

With Leon! He's a militant. Aside: Do you think anyone has already had sex in space?

5 hours ago, retayl said:

I like your description of her as a horny 15 year old who thought she was running to freedom. I take issue with the rest of your post. There is no credible evidence that she still holds extremist views. Her father originally criticised her but as a Muslim father would. Her mother and siblings have asked for her return. To suggest she would raise money for ISIS is pure conjecture and given her situation should she return, highly unlikely. On balance I believe a naive 15 year old who has been groomed and radicalised should receive some understanding and given a second chance. Now pile on fellas!

I agree and I support her return. However, she made clear in press interviews in the refugee camp her views toward ISIS have not changed much. And that she would raise money for the Islamic State. Hope Dad comes around.

2 minutes ago, unblocktheplanet said:

I agree and I support her return. However, she made clear in press interviews in the refugee camp her views toward ISIS have not changed much. And that she would raise money for the Islamic State. Hope Dad comes around.

A two faced post!