Current cost of hip replacement at Suan Dok and Sri Phat hospitals

[Saan]

Has any had hip replacement surgery at either of these hospitals? I'd appreciate any information regarding costs and treatment.

[masuk]

A friend of mine had his hip done by the top joint surgeon in Chiang Mai. I saw the same guy for a knee replacement. I was in Sriphat University Hospital for a week. Excellent medical services, lousy food!

PM me and I'll look up the address of his Practice/office in Thae Pae Rd.

[uptheos]

A friend of mine had his hip done by the top joint surgeon in Chiang Mai. I saw the same guy for a knee replacement. I was in Sriphat University Hospital for a week. Excellent medical services, lousy food!

PM me and I'll look up the address of his Practice/office in Thae Pae Rd.

Was it Dr. Sattaya Rojanasthien who has a clinic near the temple on Thapae Road, not far from P&P travel?

[masuk]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

[uptheos]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

[masuk]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

[uptheos]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

How was it, what was the rehab process like?

[Saan]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

What was the cost of the knee? I have one of those that has run out of warranty too.

[northernjohn]

sorry can't help you with those two hospitals.

Had mine done a year ago Total cost 183,000 baht

Spent 4 days in private room that is one extra.

Was given a pill to take every day for two weeks. I did not as I thought it was just a pain pill. Wrong it had some thing in it to fight infection and help the bone muscle and metal come together. I was told it takes three months to get as good as it is going to get. So even though I felt fine walking at day 13 when he pulled the stitches he said about 400 meters was enough. Mind you I felt good like I could go a lot farther which I occasionally did but it really wasn't helping things.

The Doctor did not know the cost up front. He guessed at 200,000 baht as the hip it self was 60,000 baht. I asked about the Ram and he said yes he could do it there he guessed about 350,000 baht and for Saun Dok about half way between the other two. He had been recommended to me by Dr. Suthee as the best Arthroscopic surgeon in Thailand. At the time I was considering arthroscopic surgery for my knee. But the pain did not disappear but became just a minor nuisance when I started taking MSM. The hip then became the major problem.

Dr Chanakarn Phornphutkul (sports medicine)

Rajavej Hospital, 053 801999 and 053 204545

(Orthodpedic clinic opposite the hospital on the other side of the river)

[masuk]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

What was the cost of the knee? I have one of those that has run out of warranty too.

around ฿170,000 - everything included.

They were excellent and as I have a slight heart flutter, the heart specialist checked me out very thoroughly, and I was given a spinal block anaesthetic and a very light knock out which left no after effects when I came to. I'm usually groggy for days.

A pleasant hospital, everyone seems to speak excellent English and I got friends to bring in some 'cordon bleu' food from 7-11 to heat in the microwave in the room. The cold hamburger and egg from the hospital kitchen was not really appetising.

There is a need to keep an eye on the medications issued at check out. These are important and I was given medication for an older prescription.

[Mapguy]

Every individual is different, but a "standard" estimate would be around 180-190,000 bhat at Sriphat. The government side (Maharaj) would be cheaper. There would be the same surgeon and the same OR, but the facilities and nursing services are not what foreigners from economically rich countries would probably find acceptable. Ask your surgeon about that. Visit an orthopaedic ward in Maharaj and a room in the Sriphat quarters.

[NancyL]

Another consideration on Maharaj vs. Sriphat is the wait time. You'll be in a queue at Majaraj and last time I checked it was several months for an elective hip replacement at Maharaj. Everyone I know who has had one there has had it because of trauma and even then, they often have to wait 3 or 4 days for a hip replacement after an accident. The lowest cost I've seen at Maharaj for a hip replacement after an accident (like a pedestrian slip and fall) was 110,000 baht -- normally more like 140,000, but admittedly the fellows I've assisted often aren't in the best of condition going into the surgery.

The ortho wards at Maharaj are crowded. Designed for 6 beds, but usually have 8 or 9, so you can reach out and touch the bed next to yours. No air con, but wouldn't be so bad this time of year. Food worse than Sriphat. No TV, wifi or privacy. But, the nurses and support staff are great (if you speak some Thai) and much attention with med students coming thru at all hours (of the day and night -- many interested in practicing their English patient interviewing skills)

It could be a good experience if you're flexible and adventuresome because the medical care is good. But the amenities are very, very basic.

Edited December 1, 2014 by NancyL

[Saan]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

Only 15 years for the knee has me worried as I plan to make it to 100. I need a 30 year knee.

[8OA8]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

Only 15 years for the knee has me worried as I plan to make it to 100. I need a 30 year knee.

My knee's have already reached 50 years service and I was hoping for them to last at least another 50, in the event that they don't last I'm concerned as to what the correct legal route is to make a claim on the original supplier/manufacturer. Edited December 2, 2014 by 8OA8

[Saan]

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

Only 15 years for the knee has me worried as I plan to make it to 100. I need a 30 year knee.

My knee's have already reached 50 years service and I was hoping for them to last at least another 50, in the event that they don't last I'm concerned as to what the correct legal route is to make a claim on the original supplier/manufacturer.

You'll be dying to get to him.

[masuk]

my knee lasted 75 years. The final straw was a few weeks in China at 4C, and the fact that all their subways have escalators almost to street level, and suitcases etc must be carried up the last section of 50 or so stairs.

[8OA8]

my knee lasted 75 years. The final straw was a few weeks in China at 4C, and the fact that all their subways have escalators almost to street level, and suitcases etc must be carried up the last section of 50 or so stairs.

I'd like to think that bybthe time my knees are 75yrs old, my faculties would still be intact and be advising against going to China. I'm hoping that I don't get any memory problems and start forgetting this important piece of advice to self.

Joking aside, did everyone manage to get the knee replacement done on their medical insurance? And if yes, can you please advise what annual policy costs are including any excess.

[bob strutt]

just had a the right hip replaced at the kings hospidal , sirajah, at bangkok, i am 67 and was in terrible, suicidal pain for 5 years, took every pill and needles available. all the best prothesis that is now available was used, the doctors were in a leauge of there own, the hospidal staff and the private room was 5 star, i was up walking, 2 hours after waking up, 4 days finished, at bumengrad i was quoted 700000 bart but could of been more, at sirijah , i was quoted 450000 bart, the total bill as i walked out of the hospidal was all up 425000 bart, the result of the op is amazing, i was back driving after 2weeks, and back on the golf course after 5 weeks, i am now laying concrete and tiling again, i have not been back to see the doctors at sirijah but have seen my local doctor at A E K udon thani, i would have waited at least 2 to 3 years in australia, and then would have to be totally imobalised, privately in aus 50k aus dollars i can thoughly reccomend SIRIJAH hospidal, i am totally pain free and my life is back in order, i am so happy that i finally got up the courage to get it done, good luck bobs

[Strangebrew]

Went in for knee replacement came out minus left nut and wallet.

[connda]

sorry can't help you with those two hospitals.

Had mine done a year ago Total cost 183,000 baht

Spent 4 days in private room that is one extra.

Was given a pill to take every day for two weeks. I did not as I thought it was just a pain pill. Wrong it had some thing in it to fight infection and help the bone muscle and metal come together. I was told it takes three months to get as good as it is going to get. So even though I felt fine walking at day 13 when he pulled the stitches he said about 400 meters was enough. Mind you I felt good like I could go a lot farther which I occasionally did but it really wasn't helping things.

The Doctor did not know the cost up front. He guessed at 200,000 baht as the hip it self was 60,000 baht. I asked about the Ram and he said yes he could do it there he guessed about 350,000 baht and for Saun Dok about half way between the other two. He had been recommended to me by Dr. Suthee as the best Arthroscopic surgeon in Thailand. At the time I was considering arthroscopic surgery for my knee. But the pain did not disappear but became just a minor nuisance when I started taking MSM. The hip then became the major problem.

Dr Chanakarn Phornphutkul (sports medicine)

Rajavej Hospital, 053 801999 and 053 204545

(Orthodpedic clinic opposite the hospital on the other side of the river)

Does the doctor do knees also? And where did you have your surgery done?

Edited December 2, 2014 by connda

[northernjohn]

sorry can't help you with those two hospitals.

Had mine done a year ago Total cost 183,000 baht

Spent 4 days in private room that is one extra.

Was given a pill to take every day for two weeks. I did not as I thought it was just a pain pill. Wrong it had some thing in it to fight infection and help the bone muscle and metal come together. I was told it takes three months to get as good as it is going to get. So even though I felt fine walking at day 13 when he pulled the stitches he said about 400 meters was enough. Mind you I felt good like I could go a lot farther which I occasionally did but it really wasn't helping things.

The Doctor did not know the cost up front. He guessed at 200,000 baht as the hip it self was 60,000 baht. I asked about the Ram and he said yes he could do it there he guessed about 350,000 baht and for Saun Dok about half way between the other two. He had been recommended to me by Dr. Suthee as the best Arthroscopic surgeon in Thailand. At the time I was considering arthroscopic surgery for my knee. But the pain did not disappear but became just a minor nuisance when I started taking MSM. The hip then became the major problem.

Dr Chanakarn Phornphutkul (sports medicine)

Rajavej Hospital, 053 801999 and 053 204545

(Orthodpedic clinic opposite the hospital on the other side of the river)

Does the doctor do knees also? And where did you have your surgery done?

Yes he does. The surgery is at Rajavej but he can do it at the others. The prices he gave me where estimates. He also travels to give lectures. He was recommended as the best arthroscopic surgeon in Thailand. He did 4 years of practice in Michigan and speaks excellent English. His clinic hours are 5:00 PM at night to about 8:00 PM. Best to call.

I will inbox you some information.

[masuk]

just had a the right hip replaced at the kings hospidal , sirajah, at bangkok, i am 67 and was in terrible, suicidal pain for 5 years, took every pill and needles available. all the best prothesis that is now available was used, the doctors were in a leauge of there own, the hospidal staff and the private room was 5 star, i was up walking, 2 hours after waking up, 4 days finished, at bumengrad i was quoted 700000 bart but could of been more, at sirijah , i was quoted 450000 bart, the total bill as i walked out of the hospidal was all up 425000 bart, the result of the op is amazing, i was back driving after 2weeks, and back on the golf course after 5 weeks, i am now laying concrete and tiling again, i have not been back to see the doctors at sirijah but have seen my local doctor at A E K udon thani, i would have waited at least 2 to 3 years in australia, and then would have to be totally imobalised, privately in aus 50k aus dollars i can thoughly reccomend SIRIJAH hospidal, i am totally pain free and my life is back in order, i am so happy that i finally got up the courage to get it done, good luck bobs

That sounds an incredible cost! As I said, my knee was more complicated, and cost around ฿170,000.

Great that your experience was so ositive.

Someone asked about insurance. Not feasible outside of one's home country if you're 75!

[uptheos]

Personally, I think Dr' Chanarkan in Chiang Mai is value for money regarding hips and knees.

Plus if you opt for Rajavej there is the bonus of a very competent physio dept.

[marquis22]

Re the cost: I had a minor operation at Ram hospital Khon Kaen 3 years ago and I saw a sign saying hip replacement at 200,000 baht

[jobin]

Masuk. Are you talking about your original knees, the ones you grew or artificial knees now 75 years old? The former very believable, the latter ...NOT.

[masuk]

Masuk. Are you talking about your original knees, the ones you grew or artificial knees now 75 years old? The former very believable, the latter ...NOT.

HAHA! My original was 75 before it gave up. I had osteo arthritis.

My replacement knee was January this year.

sorry about the confusion....

[Jimbolai]

<script type='text/javascript'>window.mod_pagespeed_start = Number(new Date());</script>

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

Could you say what the cost was and what it included v/s 1/3 the cost in OZ? Thank you

[masuk]

close to ฿176,000. Things will have changed a little, no doubt.

[masuk]

yes, that's the one.

open weekdays after 17:00. about 100metres up from Soi 3.

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

How was it, what was the rehab process like?

Sorry, I missed this one. Well, I'm told that a new knee is a lot more involved than a new hip/femur.

It took me a few weeks of rest before being allowed to go upstairs again. Slowly increased the length of my walks.

However, the muscle above the knee had to be worked on, and I've been using an exercise bike the past couple of months. It's going to be a year before I think it's all ok. But far better than before the operation, having the thing aching most of the time, locking up, painful to go upstairs. I doubt that I could have managed another cold spell.

Just a problem with aging I guess. Thankfully my hearing is very good, but there are times when the dogs or the renovations above me could be turned down!

[Saan]

I've heard good things about him.

The total cost for my new knee, including a week in the hospital and 'meals' was about 1/3 the current cost in Oz. The duralium and HD Poly knee is top of the market. Only good for 15 years though, so got to go back when I'm 90! Durn!!

How was it, what was the rehab process like?

Sorry, I missed this one. Well, I'm told that a new knee is a lot more involved than a new hip/femur.

It took me a few weeks of rest before being allowed to go upstairs again. Slowly increased the length of my walks.

However, the muscle above the knee had to be worked on, and I've been using an exercise bike the past couple of months. It's going to be a year before I think it's all ok. But far better than before the operation, having the thing aching most of the time, locking up, painful to go upstairs. I doubt that I could have managed another cold spell.

Just a problem with aging I guess. Thankfully my hearing is very good, but there are times when the dogs or the renovations above me could be turned down!

The knee is a real bugger compared with the hip. After having the hip replaced the first thing usually noticed is absence of pain. After a knee replacement first thing noticed is pain, lots of it. I am not aware of the hip but I am of the knee.