Thorgal

My answer was based on the still living Palestinians in Gaza that are non combatants. Your question didn't specify the group, so I've provided the group I'm worried about. Since then, you try to drag me in the mud as a liar...

Yep, when Bibi comes for a speech in front of IDF troops as PR : no gun magazines allowed.

I think that the CIA told to Israel : "Don't bring in these guys, you will get your hair on fire and you will use your hammer to extinguish".

Every Middle Eastern expert knows who created Hamas and why.

Common, come back. Many IDF soldiers also want to quit the army since march/july 2023 because of the political situation. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2023/07/23/elite-israeli-soldiers-quit-idf-netanyahu-judicial-reform/

#metoo !

Hamas aims Israeli settler hostages for Palestinian prisoner exchanges. These Palestinian prisoners are long term prisoners listed here below and were put in jail long BEFORE 7th of October 2023. https://www.amnesty.org/en/location/middle-east-and-north-africa/israel-and-occupied-palestinian-territories/report-israel-and-occupied-palestinian-territories/

1 million Palestinians murdered in less than 2 weeks : that's bold and far away from reality. Can you explain how you qualify these extra legal bombings from Israel on non combatant civilians?

Here a few of them : https://www.amnesty.org/en/location/middle-east-and-north-africa/israel-and-occupied-palestinian-territories/report-israel-and-occupied-palestinian-territories/

OK, same same like a serial killer gets only accountable on his last murder (maybe)...and his long history of crimes is not relevant to conclude the motives.

Al Jazeera has a team of reporters in Gaza. They've filmed just after the bombing when all the corpses are laying on the parking lot and the gardens and when the medics were trying to make a selection of the wounded. I've these footages but I can't post them online due to disturbing content + some usual posters would report this as non trustable source because these images have been recorded with cell phones. Impact of the "pothole" is pointing to SW by the way. The load didn't came down on 90 degrees angle...The rest is speculation and war propaganda which I won't participate. People even were convinced in the beginning that there was no impact/crater....

I did already : https://aseannow.com/topic/1308598-israel-is-at-war/?do=findComment&comment=18445354

Yes x2

Yes, she's biased. It's not coincidence that she could voice her "international law" perspective...

Quote from link : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_Hamas_attack_on_Israel " Mohammed Deif, commander of the attack, named the operation "Al-Aqsa Flood" in reference to the 2022 Al-Aqsa clashes, in which Israeli police raided the mosque following clashes between Palestinians and police."

The lawyer is considering that the Hamas crime started on 7th of October 2023. Her selective memory has been lost for all IDF extra-judicial military interventions BEFORE 7th of October 2023.

I have the same feeling, and I couldn't summarize it better. Thanks Mojo.

As long as it fits the hasbara agenda...

Many of these non-Hamas Palestinians from Gaza don't want to leave Gaza for Nakbah 2.0. They still remember what happened on Nakbah 1.0. and 1967 with the forced evictions and executions

It is genocide. https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml#:~:text=To constitute genocide%2C there must,to simply disperse a group.

Leaflets are dropped on Gaza telling people that they have to evacuate the area or they will be bombed. The leaflet says also : If they remain they will be seen as combatants and part of Hamas. Looks like we have a leak here on AN.

It's exactly this weak coalition of minorities that was not popular for many Israelis even before the 7th of October attacks. There's enough footage online which shows still today that many Israeli's are against this coalition that cannot combine or unite religious Zionists, secular Zionists and all other non-Zionist Israelis. Previous hostage Ghilad Shalit was released for some 1.000 prisoners. So, yes it's possible to negotiate the release of hostages. Furthermore, if I follow your logic it's completely acceptable to bomb Gaza even if you own people/citizens (199 hostages) are below, mixed with Gaza population. IDF Gaza periphery security system could not be guaranteed. Do innocent Palestinian civilians (outside Hamas franchise) have to pay the price for that to compensate?

It's known that you don't condone IAF for bombing Gaza civilians. Gaza could have been surrounded (like it is now) and let the hostages out by negotiations. All these civilians killings are not needed. It's only for PR of the Israeli government coalition : Likud, Ultra Religious and Ultra Right. If it was a democratic center-left government : no bombings would happen knowing that you reach nothing, except genocide. Showing Jeremy Corbyn and his left view on this war works like kryptonite to most Zionists. Calling him (or me) an antisemite is because he isn't in favor, like me, for this war.

Exactly!

Hamas could capture a few military bases during their 7th of October attack. I suppose that these IDF military bases' stocks and arsenal have been emptied and brought to Gaza in the deepest bunkers.