RETRACTED: Civil court agrees to lift emergency decree

[webfact]

Civil court agrees to lift emergency decree

NOTE: This story has since been withdrawn and deleted from Thai PBS newsfeed. /Admin

BANGKOK: -- The Civil Court late this afternoon agreed to lift the state of emergency declared by the caretaker Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra on January 22.

The call for the lifting of the emergency decree was made by a PDRC core member Thavorn Senniem against caretaker in a petition to the Civil court.

Thavorn said the declaration of the state of emergency by Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra, the Centre for Maintaining Peace and Order director Chalerm Yubamrung and Pol Gen Adul Saengsingkaew, deputy director of CMPO, was unnecessary and invoked unlawfully.

Full story: http://englishnews.thaipbs.or.th/civil-court-agrees-lift-emergency-decree/


-- Thai PBS 2014-02-18

[winstonc]

at last i small piece of common sense..

[Katipo]

If the decree is lifted due to being unlawful, all those arrested under it will therefore have to be released. Oooops.

Chalerrrrrm, oh Chalerrrrrrm

Edited February 18, 2014 by Katipo

[DLock]

Bit late for that dead policeman trying to take back the protestors sites under the Emergency Decree ordered by Chalerm today.

Keep them guessing Suthep.

Winning.

[MobileContent]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

[ggold]

The storm clouds are gathering, could it be that PTP days are numbered. wonder how many are thinking of packing their bags and going on shopping trips. The end game is starting.

[gemini81]

interesting that EC lift it immediately after 3 police are allegedly dead by the hands of the demonstrators. It was not needed and unjustified clear back last month.

Well orchestrated by Thaksin- I know such organization of playing martyr cannot be done by his little show pony sister, nor Chalerm.

They're still on the streets at the government house.

All well set up via skype. Not too badly planned, compared to the rice scam and the other PTP graft.

Edited February 18, 2014 by gemini81

[ggold]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

really pathetic, You don't like what you read so the courts are biased! I guess it would piss you off if some one said they are independent and probably know the law better than those in charge over at CMPO or PTP.

[whybother]

interesting that EC lift it immediately after 3 police are allegedly dead by the hands of the demonstrators. It was not needed and unjustified clear back last month.

Well orchestrated by Thaksin- I know such organization of playing martyr cannot be done by his little show pony sister, nor Chalerm.

They're still on the streets at the government house.

All well set up via skype. Not too badly planned, compared to the rice scam and the other PTP graft.

I read that it was 1 policeman and 2 civilians.

edit: now 2 police and 2 civilians.

Edited February 18, 2014 by whybother

[spirit47]

If the decree is lifter due to being unlawful, all those arrested under it will therefore have to be released. Oooops.

Agree, 100%, and dont must fear deportation...

[Robby nz]

Does that mean that Chalerm and Tarit have to pull their heads in ?

Could it mean that what they are doing right now is illegal ?

It could well be as they are claiming to be working under the SOE. Possibly it will be illegal from the moment the court lifted the SOE.

Will also mean that the media are no longer working under threat.

[bkkjames]

not a good day all around for team red it appears.

[AleG]

I don't think the crackdown being launched the same day the verdict was scheduled is a coincidence. The government wants the SoE to stay.

Least we forget the SoE was first declared following the grenade attacks against the anti-government protestors, the justification being that the protest had turned violent. Yes, there's something very wrong about that scenario.

[DLock]

Where is the old Mongolian proverb for this?

[ETatBKK]

'Thavorn said the declaration of the state of emergency by Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra, the Centre for Maintaining Peace and Order director Chalerm Yubamrung and Pol Gen Adul Saengsingkaew, deputy director of CMPO, was unnecessary and invoked unlawfully.'

what is the case now ? it was unnecessary and invoked unlawfully ? ? ?

then all CMPO done, were considered unlawful from Jan 22 to today. then the arrest warrant will be VOID, those been arrested today need to be free immediately ?

[Just1Voice]

Amazing Thailand. You have gun battles in the streets, with grenades and other explosions, people on both sides being injured and killed, and there is "no emergency" as stated by the courts? What country are the Judges living in?

[LadPhrao123]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

really pathetic, You don't like what you read so the courts are biased! I guess it would piss you off if some one said they are independent and probably know the law better than those in charge over at CMPO or PTP.

If you don't think they're biased you haven't been paying attention. CC is in the bag. Same for the EC dragging it's sorry ass all over Thailand handicapping the elections. Also a great deal of the media.

On the other hand this may be a result that's welcome to you, but you getting your talking point is only that. it's a victory for darkness. Nothing more.

These people are dirty, violent, attempting to overthrow an elected government and insert themselves back in power.

if there was ever proof that an emergency existed you only needed to follow the actions of Suthep and the sedition movement on the streets of Bangkok today. The city and it's people are less safe without the SEO in place and the looneys are empowered.

Edited February 18, 2014 by LadPhrao123

[ikke]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

I agree 100%, if Bangkok is not in a state of emergency, no place in the world would ever be.

Armed protesters killing cops the same morning as the courts lifts the decree, poor judging and even more poor civil court.

[djjamie]

It is well acknowledged that the emergency decree was not needed and for the UDD to compare it to the emergency decree in 2010 is like comparing apples and oranges.

The sad thing is the senseless deaths of the poor policemen and the injuries are now solely on the hands of chalerm and yingluck. Had the emergency decree not been implemented none of this senseless lose of life would have happened.

I look forward to chalerm and yingluck on murder charges alongside Abhisit and Suthep.

[WilliamCave]

Does this mean charlom is going to lose his position?

As the enforcer, ?

When does the lifting take place of the emergencie decree?

[Bocking]

.. allied with the latest news from NACC, regarding YS being summoned to answer charges on 27th February, are we seeing the beginning of a judicial coup?

[gemini81]

Where is the old Mongolian proverb for this?

and where is that ol' pipkins with the new 'dave'..whatever screen name account he's had since the 15th, to tell us how suthep has paid of EC to lift the decree by paying them money he doesn't have..ok, I'll wait, I know its a' comin'.

[Stradavarius37]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

Does that mean you are a kangaroo?

Sent from my iPhone using ThaiVisa app

[Scamper]

This is an enormous victory and a decisive slap in the face to Chalerm. It also happens to be the right and just decision. Chalerm's emergency decree was a sham from start to finish. If anything, the nightly grenade attacks against the protesters became even more brazen and frequent. The police became even more invisible and incapable - though more likely unwilling - of changing any of that. Chalerm's big gambit to stifle the media has now completely capitulated, and has undoubtedly erupted in the spontaneous applause and wild hoots from every television anchor and TV news staff in the country. It means the detentions are gone. It means all arrests made under the name of the emergency decree are gone. It means all charges made against the leaders through the emergency decree are gone. In the words of the court the emergency decree was unlawfully imposed. It means that this administration will finally be charged through the Constitution Court of unlawfully issuing an emergency decree under a caretaker capacity, and within ten days of a national election - a circumstance without historical precedent in the world's free societies, and something that not even Robert Mugabe would have had the gumption to dare.

[haroldc]

.. allied with the latest news from NACC, regarding YS being summoned to answer charges on 27th February, are we seeing the beginning of a judicial coup?

No, we are seeing the beginning of justice being served... long overdue.

Edited February 18, 2014 by haroldc

[ggold]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

really pathetic, You don't like what you read so the courts are biased! I guess it would piss you off if some one said they are independent and probably know the law better than those in charge over at CMPO or PTP.

If you don't think they're biased you haven't been paying attention. CC is in the bag. Same for the EC dragging it's sorry ass all over Thailand handicapping the elections. Also a great deal of the media.

On the other hand this may be a result that's welcome to you, but you getting your talking point is only that. it's a victory for darkness. Nothing more.

And where is your proof? just another sour person who doesn't like what they read.

A victory for darkness! <deleted> what is that supposed to mean? The light of day is shining through at last, hallelujah!

[Nickymaster]

Another point that the courts in Thailand are on the side of the Democrats. Nothing really surprises me about this country which is turning itself in a kangaroo country with kangaroo courts.

I agree 100%, if Bangkok is not in a state of emergency, no place in the world would ever be.

Armed protesters killing cops the same morning as the courts lifts the decree, poor judging and even more poor civil court.

What justified the state of emergency the last 2 months?

In Samut Prakarn a boy from a motor gang killed a cop yesterday. State of emergence worthy?

[haroldc]

.. allied with the latest news from NACC, regarding YS being summoned to answer charges on 27th February, are we seeing the beginning of a judicial coup?

[ikke]

Bit late for that dead policeman trying to take back the protestors sites under the Emergency Decree ordered by Chalerm today.

Keep them guessing Suthep.

Winning.

If you feel like winning when people are shot on the streets. go to your Play Station and come back when you'r grown up.

[winstonc]

Where is the old Mongolian proverb for this?

i believe its dont shit on your own doorstep..