Police warned to cooperate with NHRC in torture probe

KOH TAO: -- A member of the National Human Rights Commission warned today that he would propose the commission to take legal action against police officers responsible for the interrogation of the two suspects in Koh Tao murder case if they do not cooperate with the pane.

Dr Nirand Pitakwatchara, chairman of the subcommittee on civil and political rights of the NHRC, said that his panel had given the police officers until November 24 to give testimonies to his panel regarding their treatment of the two suspects who are foreign migrant workers.

He said that he had clearly explained to the National Police Office that his panel’s investigation had nothing to do with the murder case itself but with the police treatment of the two suspects – whether they were tortured or not.

Dr Nirand admitted that he didn’t understand why the chief of the officers responsible for the interrogation of the suspects didn’t cooperate with his probe.

“We only want to know the police procedure of the interrogation whether there was torture because as long as the court has not ruled the suspects guilty they are still regarded as innocent,” said Dr Nirand.

Source: http://englishnews.thaipbs.or.th/police-warned-cooperate-nhrc-torture-probe

-- Thai PBS 2014-11-17

RTP torture, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apw9r54UijO

It's about time these officers are reined in. Some elements among the RTP seem like a state within the state, doing whatever they please, whenever they please, and not having to respond to any inquiries they don't like for one reason or another.

Well Dr Nirand, if you don't understand why the Chief of Police doesn't want to cooperate with you maybe you're in the wrong job.

Without money changing hands, the RTP are beholden only to the army. i.e. those with bigger guns.

Well Dr Nirand, if you don't understand why the Chief of Police doesn't want to cooperate with you maybe you're in the wrong job.

Oh come on !!! He is in the right job (as shown by his actions) and I am sure that he knows why, but he needs to be careful of what he says or the Chief of Police will play the defamation card.

Thailand should arrest the murderers and sentence to death penalty. Not wast time investigating good government officers.

Sick and so very wrong. This face thing has a lot to answer for. But it seems like the NHRC are barking up the wrong tree anyways, i mean do they expect actual honesty and accountability? What would anybody gain from more delfection and denials... What an appalling smack in the face to all bereaved families & the families of the Burmese suspects.

This is pathetically low conduct, levels beneath contempt

Dr Nirand Pitakwatchara, I'm with you but, I come from the land of "3 strikes and you're out".

You've given these thugs 4.

Just do it...

this is showing the world just how corrupt the boys in brown are , refusing to co operate in the torture investigation really lets us all know exactly how they got the confessions. Maybe they are a bit worried the truth might come out if they actually attend so they are simply avoiding it in the hope it will go away, they are probably worried the donation to find these two guilty will be taken away if the real killer is found out, the police are really scraping the bottom of the barrell now.

Dr Nirand Pitakwatchara, I'm with you but, I come from the land of "3 strikes and you're out".

You've given these thugs 4.

Just do it...

Agreed. Quit pi$$ing around, especially as they obviously have zero intention of cooperating, just file charges against them and be done with it.

Amen

KOH TAO: -- A member of the National Human Rights Commission warned today that he would propose the commission to take legal action against police officers responsible for the interrogation of the two suspects in Koh Tao murder case if they do not cooperate with the pane.

I bet the RTP are seeing NHRC as a right Pane in the arse, I hope they keep being a pain.

Thailand should arrest the murderers and sentence to death penalty. Not wast time investigating good government officers.

Who are you calling "good government officers?" The RTP and the pancake griddle boy?

And just who do you mean by "Thailand should arrest..."? Which Thai? The same Thais who tortured a false confession out of Win and Zaw?

Or the Thais who paraded Win and Zaw around the KT beach in that ridiculous "reenactment?"

Police response to NHRC just in:

(Yes, that is Nomsod's "lawyer". But, hey, the Police and the Tuvichiens may as well use the same guy.)

Wake up call?

Due to Martial law and the removal of the constitution the police are required to investigate themselves, as I understand. Previous to the coup, the police would have had to answer to another level of the Thai judicial system. Therefore they don't have to answer unless the junta tells them too.

However, if you have done the job properly, then there is no reason not to answer the claims? In such a case where the lives of two people are at stake, all diligent means should be used to defend their lives.

"Dr Nirand admitted that he didn’t understand why the chief of the officers responsible for the interrogation of the suspects didn’t cooperate with his probe."

Because they, and many police around the world believe and act as though they are above the law, and have been getting away with these types of behaviors for centuries. So why change now if there are no penalties for their actions?

The stumbling block would be that the RTP are so full of S!!T that you would get a better response by wiping your arse, they would work on the theory that we answer to no one , it is not a save face B/S it is purely arrogance and Power, the RTP has been called for a complete O/haul thousands of times , this Government Department is the most dysfunctional , non compliant , corrupt , dead beats , society could have for a police force, the police Minister should direct the officers concerned to toe the line and co-operate, however that would indicate that the Minister has no confidence in he's officers and neither he should.

These police have avoided turning up to the meeting 4 times already, it is almost as if they have something to hide. Either way, they absolutely must turn up to the next meeting because if they don't then they will be investigated by the police, which must be a huge worry.

Seriously, I do wonder at the outcome of all this. Will region 8 have to give back all the money? Will the real murderers lives and businesses continue as before? Will the goats get the death penalty? Will Prayuth's reputation ever recover from this case that has made him look more corrupt than the bunch that he couped out of power?

A common police phrase .

"If you've done nothing wrong "

" you've got nothing to worry about"

It's about time these officers are reined in. Some elements among the RTP seem like a state within the state, doing whatever they please, whenever they please, and not having to respond to any inquiries they don't like for one reason or another.

I agree. The statement - so typical - is "will propose legal action' IF.... blablabla.

Seriously does Thailand usually - ever - punish/jail "hi so" rulers from police/government/ politicians? More.... gonna do etc. Thailand only TALKS. How about showing ACTION?

Thailand should arrest the murderers and sentence to death penalty. Not wast time investigating good government officers.

" good government officers"......?? .....I believe that is an oxymoron in this country (Thailand)!

Chotthee is a troll best to just ignore his/her comments

Chotthee is a troll best to just ignore his/her comments

Quite right. It's a natural impulse to respond to these preposterous statements, and also natural to get riled up. That is just what an assclown wants, best to just ignore it.

Dr Nirand admitted that he didn’t understand why the chief of the officers responsible for the interrogation of the suspects didn’t cooperate with his probe.

I understand perfectly Dr. Nirand, the police don't know how to answer your questions.

So, they delay and delay...

in hopes it goes away...la, la, la.

One thing keeping the BIB's or RTP who are accused of 'Torture' from coming forward is possibly the fact that Thailand doesn't have a 5th Amendment as we do in the US. Our 5th Amendment states that we can refuse to answer a question as the answer we may give "would tend to 'incriminate' me".....................

says it all about the integrity of this "ahm" lawyer

Police response to NHRC just in:

Lawyer.JPG

(Yes, that is Nomsod's "lawyer". But, hey, the Police and the Tuvichiens may as well use the same guy.)

The problem may be that the "torture" side of stuff just might be normal BiB accepted practice..

Where is the good general on all this, I wonder.