ourmanflint

This is about Islamism. Nothing else...

Separatism. For ages they've been fighting for the Kingdom of Pattani.

When you say "nothing else" you deny their nationalism. Islam is a big part of it, of course, but there's also a claim to the land, they also have their separate language and their own traditions, and their own version of history.

They don't want to be Malaysians, btw.

I'm sorry but I think you are wrong!!

Why did the insurgents kick off after almost 200 years of relative peace and stability??Why.. because of the likes of Al-Qaeda and Jemaah Islamiyah.

The excuse is the separatism, the reality is Islamism.

Don't be fooled by any other rhetoric.

This is about Islamism. Nothing else...

This isn't very objective either.

Would you care to elaborate?? Just what is this about then??

Things aren't always as black and white as some would have you to believe.

Link to article in the Nation

Mai Krap

I find it hard to tell wether you are genuinely concerned about the the spin being put on the problems in the south by the likes of analyst Dr. Abuza and others, or are you just another yellow belly apologist for the Islamists in Pattani!

You offer much to debate, but really all you end up doing is confusing the issue by clouding disparate problems, and like the islamists you try to make one problem seem to be something else. Your anti-spin of the situation in Pattani seems to come from some innate sense that only you are right and no one outside of the area could possibly see things more clearly and objectively than you yourself. I can't say this is a very wise stand to take, as it often is the case that an objective view is needed more than a "gut" view from those such as yourself. It is all too easy to become entrenched in local everday life to see above the troubles and the effect they have.

I can see from way over here in the UK, that the troubles in Pattani are not getting any better, but they most definitely are polarising, and thay are doing so across religious divides. This is about Islamism. Nothing else...

Islamic factions have had very great success in getting what they want through violence over the past 60 years, and they have learned to be vigilant and never ceasing in moving towards what it is they want, a total Islamic state. Violence in Islam has become an acceptable tool, it has become accepted as the will of god, why else would these Islamists be on such a ludicrous quest.?

If you cannot accept that this violence has it's root in Islam and that a peaceful outcome to this without massive counter violence on the part of the Thai government is possible, then you severely misunderstand the iron will of these Islamists in their determination to bring about the changes they want to impose on all those in the area.

What a fantastic waste of money... and ever so slighly condescending from the British government!

There is absolutely no point in even talking about cyber crimes, when in many of these asian countries actual real crimes against children are happening on a daily basis, even as some posters here have said , right under the noses of the Thai government. The sentiment is right, but the actions are arse about face, places like Bangladesh don't even have a useable internet network so talking about cybercrime is ludicrous.

What the British Government and others really need to do is to track all known child sex offenders in and out of the countries they visit or maybe they should take away their passports for 10 years.

I wish they were serious enough to do something radical!!!

You bitch about Thailand, do us all a favor and go back where you came from. Why are you here to make Thailand just like the place you left, so you can be unhappy here too.

Aloha

same old nonsense from people like yoursef... you think others are pompous whereas it seems you are the one who is behaving like an arrogant fool!!

People who complain about Thailand are generally involved in life here and they complain not because they have to, but because they genuinely want to see things change. Maybe you should stop living in cuckooland and take a look at what is happening all around you.

Oh, but then you didn't even have the nowse to find out if buying land was on the up and up. You just go along with the flow like a turd going out to sea.

well, well....

what a bunch of terrible stories!! It comes as no surprise though as I always suspected that at some point the half wit, half brain mentality of many of these young thai guys would eventiually show itself for waht they really are...

small dick thugs who deserve nothing from anyone, not from farangs returning their ire, nor from those good Thais who helpfully stand around and then disappear when needed to corroborate stories..

What a sad year for Thailand this is turning out to be!!

More bad news....

Attack on Thai school kills three

At least three teenage students have been killed in an attack on an Islamic school in southern Thailand, police have said.

They said explosives had been thrown into the school in Songkhla province before the assailants opened fire on the sleeping quarters.

Seven other students were wounded in the attack late on Saturday, which the police blamed on Muslim separatists. BBC here

Hadn't seen this posted here yet.... I really hope all the do gooders are happy sipping their beers while all these kids die!!

having returned to the UK recently, news like this makes me very sad. There are a lot of disparate events in Thailand which are conspiring to making it more and more unattractive as a place to plan your annual holiday.

There cannot be a peaceful soultion to this debacle in the south, as that would result in Thailand ceding Pattani to Malaysia, which is not an option. The only alternative therefore is to remove the problem at source, and yes unfortunately that does mean operations similar to those performed by the British Army in Ireland and elsewhere. Simply put, the Thai gov't need lots of surveillance and then decisive action in the form of snatch and kill squads.

Those that believe there are other ways out of this are deluding themselves and putting the lives of the Buddhist population of Pattani in the front line of danger, whilst they sip their beer and smile to themselves that they have it good.

Very sad...

Can someone just explain to me how this happens under everyones noses???

I don't believe there aren't lots of people who know about this yet do next to nothing about it!

Where do these girls come from?

Oh I see. Ourmanflint got it from another thread that was dated to 2006-08-24. Guess he was too excited to see news which may or may not mean Thailand "slowly sliding into the mire" that he forgot to look at the date.

That's not the first time I've been caught out by someone dredging up an old story... sorry about that!

It was at the top of the pile I tell ya!!!

You may be interested to learn that a bird not seen anywhere in the world for over 150 years, the long billed reed warbler, it was recently rediscovered at a water treatment plant just outside Bangkok!!

Funny old world eh??

Thailand tells Canberra its bombing warning overstated

BANGKOK: -- Thai Deputy Foreign Minister Sawanit Kongsiri on Friday said that the ministry had informed the Australian government that the situation in Thailand had not worsened to such a level that it was necessary to warn Australian residents and visitors to Thailand -- tourists and businesspersons -- of possible bombings and other violence here.

He said the ministry had already explained to Canberra that the situation in Thailand was not as bad as suggested in its warning.

but ...

A suspected car with bomb found nearby PM's residence

Police arrested the person who hid a TNT explosive in a car parked near the residence of Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra. Roads around the site were temporarily closed during the rigorous investigation.

It's not as bad as Canberra suggests it is far bloody worse, and people who constantly deny the slow slide of Thailand into the mire, are deluding themselves.

As seen from afar this little powerplay from the "temporary" government smells of foul play. What benefit is there to appoint these miltary officers to all provinces unless it is to thwart any rumblings of another coup, by an increased miltary presence throughout the country, or by splitting up groups of officers who may themselves be a threat to the CNS.

Whatever the reason, it seems like one more little step towards big trouble in Thailand.

Doesn't this just mean that the taxi stands will not be allowed on the footpaths... it says nothing about them actually riding on footpaths.

Remember to always look both ways when you step out of that 7-11..

Womble..

I agree with almost everything you've said and it never occurred to me that the gov't would be playing the futures market, but it seems so likely I can't beleive I never thought of it before.

And yes the elite of Thailand are greedy thugs who care very little for their own country.

From the Bangkok Post:

Minister cool on IT

Speaking at the opening of the exhibition, the minister said that it was wrong of Thai people to admire modern technology, which was not developed by Thai people. "It is a fake development because the country is now getting worse as almost everything at the exhibition here is imported and nothing is made by Thais," he said.

The minister stated that "Thai computers" should mean Thais producing component parts, not just assembling, and that they should also design the products.

"It is sad that today we cannot find any Thai products. The technology show here provides foreigners an opportunity to take money from Thai people. To be truly proud, it should show technology that has been developed by Thais," the ICT Minister said.

It seems to me that the minister was indicting the Thai people for being "lazy" and relying too heavily on foreign imports, which is certainly true and can only be a good thing if in the future it leads to improvements in the Thai economy through internal investment.

Thailand is a massive consumer of IT and a negligible producer of IT products, but this is also the case for 90% of the countries in the world, there are very few nations which are volume producers of IT products.

Does that mean that all of our countries should be as ashamed as the Minister is of the Thai people?? Of course not, it's a ridiculous statement from someone who has virtually no understanding of how the IT economy works globally. It does not matter who makes and designs the components, what matters is what is done with these components, how they are used and assembled to create devices that everyone wants.

Certainly companies like Apple and Microsoft mostly use off the shelf components in their products, this does not stop them from innovating. In fact their innovations closely follow breakthroughs from other manufacturers. Thailand could very easily do exactly the same thing if they had the will to do so. There is no need to actually design and develop component parts. The Minister does not seem to understand this basic concept.

As for software, well, here there is no reason at all why Thailand cannot compete, I'm sure there are very many talented Thais residing in Thailand who could create from scratch world class products, yet they do not. Why?? Because there has been no incentive, Thailands economy is a smash and grab style, there is virtually zero forward planning and/or long term strategy that does not involve shaking down foreigners as they step off the plane. This is as far as the fat cats can see, it's easy money.

Thailand is in a mess and it will not move forward one step until such time as the powers that be turn their focus onto the long term future of Thailand, one that is not almost wholly reliant on the cascade effects of mass tourism.

I also think the Minister should reconsider when he says things like "The technology show here provides foreigners an opportunity to take money from Thai people", a truly gobsmacking idiotic thing to say!!

Had this in Chiang Mai recently next to the night bazaar.... and it was fantastic, one of the best things I've tasted in a long while. I tried it again around town , but nothing was quite as good as that first one which was a much darker colour than the others. It had this incredible aftertaste, something I sort of know but can't put my finger on.

Looked on the internet and they all look a bit anaemic, anyone got a good recipe for me??

What is it, Flint?

It's a rich Burmese style curry.... I need my fix!!!

Ourmanflint,

I just read the other translations and I agree that the feel is quite different and I too prefer the use of the word blessing....when protection is used I kept wondering what I was being protected from.

Also, in reading this Sutta it seemed to me that the Buddha's response has a progression to it...it starts by saying to not associate with fools and finishes up with the attainment of Nibanna.....inbetween these two it seems that the Buddha is layingout a likely path of stages in life that one might go through when one is progressing through the Dhamma....what do you think? is this plausible?

Chownah

Nice idea... it does read like a guide to life doesn't it?? It seems quite logical now you've said it.

Had this in Chiang Mai recently next to the night bazaar.... and it was fantastic, one of the best things I've tasted in a long while. I tried it again around town , but nothing was quite as good as that first one which was a much darker colour than the others. It had this incredible aftertaste, something I sort of know but can't put my finger on.

Looked on the internet and they all look a bit anaemic, anyone got a good recipe for me??

Hey Chownah

I like your view of the life of purity, and of course my interpretation is just that, my own take on things.

The sutta is the same one, but for some reason the translation you picked gives it a completely new twist, I can't see how "protection" and "blessing" are interchangeable, it feels like a different sutta altogether. If you look at the other translations, the sutta takes on a whole new feel, this is ther version I was referring to.

I'm having to leave Thailand quicker than expected, so am looking for someone to take over my lease which runs out on 1st May 2007.

The studio is in a very nice and quiet condo complex on Soi Ari 4. Approx 28 sq metres. Fully furnished and comes complete with 2mb Wi-Fi ADSL courtesy of Buddy Broadband.

Rent per month is 11,000 Baht and there is a one monthe deposit required.

Soi Ari is a vibrant little community and a great place to live, I'm gutted I have to leave, but have had a job offer in the UK I can't refuse, apartment is 10 minute walk from Ari BTS, and has swimming pool and small gym. English speaking manager also.

Available as of February 1st.

Please contact me if interested

Very good Chownah

I do appreciate your much greater knowledge of the scriptures. I can see how " a life of purity" can be easily interpreted as promoting the secluded life.

Is a life of purity one of seclusion? maybe, or maybe it refers to purity of spirit, a life without wrong thoughts or wrong actions, it does not necessarily mean seclusion and "purity" as in life without distraction as would be the case of the ascetic.

This makes more sense when the following sentence is spoken... "for the welfare and happiness of the multitude, out of compassion for the world, for the benefit, well being, and happiness of gods and men."

How cutting yourself off has that effect I am not sure, but living a life of purity in the world, well then you would be visible and available and leading by example "for the welfare and happiness of the multitude, out of compassion for the world, for the benefit, well being, and happiness of gods and men."

Also while this quote "As long as the monks see their own benefit in wilderness dwellings, their growth can be expected, not their decline."

certainly ascertains that living the life of the ascetic can have benefit, it also specifically states that it is not for everyone!! and this does make sense. What is right for one person is not neccesarily right for everyone.

The Mangala Sutta states many, ways to live ones life and living the "holy Life" as being of the highest blessing is just touched upon once, barely. It would seem from this that Buddha did not see this as the only way or even the better way to lives one life, in fact the opposite is so clearly evident.

"to reside in a suitable locality" "righteous conduct" "the helping of relatives" many things to be lauded, but nowhere is there seclusion. I have always felt Buddhism to be about the joy of life, it cannot be about self fulfillment and locking ones self away from that very life.

I've never seen a scripture where the Buddha taught that monks should be active in society....seem like he was always saying they should seek seclusion....and that they should continue until the end is reached....the end being the cessation of dukkha once and for all.

Chownah

Then what on earth have you been reading all this time???

Surely one of the central elements of the `Sangha, is that monks should devote their lives "for the good of the many, for the happiness of the many", they can't do that sat on their backsides trying to reach a higher plain of existence.

Seclusion is not supposed to be the be all and end all to attaining a greater level of understanding, why are people so attuned to that particular facet of Buddhist doctrine? Surely you don't belive that is the only way to progress in life??

But if a man lives all his life in solitude, thinking only of his own happiness and salvation, without caring for his fellows, this surely is not in keeping with the Buddha's teaching which is based on love, compassion, and service to others.

Walpola Rahula

Yes, the idea of getting out there and being seen to help people less advantaged than you is a Western thing.

I have never heard either that the idea of helping people is a western thing? Where does that idea come from? One of the main aspects of Buddhism, and one of the reasons I was initially attracted to it, is the idea of selflessness.

Why would Walpola Rahula suggest that the Buddha's teaching is one " based on love, compassion, and service to others " when what I am now hearing from you all is that , no that is a western thing.

I think there is a lot of confusion about what Buddhism is or is not, and using Thai Theravada as a mirror of what Buddhism encompasses, is like saying the only music that exists is that heard here in Thailand.

I think my original question about what a Thai monks duties are has been answered in part, there are many monks who officiate at weddings and house blessings, and shop blessings and car blessings and all those blessings the Buddha so wisely 2500 years ago instructed his Bikkhus to memorise in case they were ever needed.

I think it will take a lot more time to start to change my opinions of the monastic way of life, especially so for those in China and Tibet, which seem to be overrun with those who just see Buddhism and monastic vows as a means to an end and a big belly!!

But I'm glad that many of you at least have positive experiences of the monastic way of life here in sunny Thailand. Maybe I shall visit Sri Lanka next!!

One example of a good monk I forgot to mention is Luangta Maha Boowa. He's been a monk for almost all of his life and is now in his early 90's.

Every day hundreds of people come to his monastery to give food, and every day he teaches and chats with them despite his advanced years, well at least every day I was there.

Not only that but after the economic crises in the late 90's Thailand ended up owing the IMF a lot of money. Luangta Maha Boowa decided to use his celebrity status and started a campaign along the lines of "If every Thai gave 10 baht we'd pay off the IMF". It worked and the money raised was given to the government and the IMF was paid off.

Just one example of how one monk can make a difference in society.

That's what I wanted to hear!! It seems like a rare exception though.