-
Posts
3,317 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Events
Forums
Downloads
Quizzes
Gallery
Blogs
Everything posted by WDSmart
-
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
What is it about the word "negotiations" that you don't understand? -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Not supporting Zionism is not "antisemitism." "Zionism" is defined as "a movement for (originally) the re-establishment and (now) the development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel." I do not support the "..re-establishment and (now) the development and protection of a Jewish nation in what is now Israel." I support negotiations with the native people of that land, the Palestinians, to come up with an agreement on how to share that land. A two-state solution seems the most likely. I am not an antisemite, whether you go with the narrow definition (anti-Jew) or the broader one (anti-Semite - Jew and Arab). -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
"Crystal Ball"! (Which could also be referred to as "intelligent, informed, speculation.") -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Yes, I predicted the hostages would be exchanged for a ceasefire weeks ago. But I specified a PERMANENT ceasefire, with a peacekeeping force put into place to enforce it. So, Hamas and Israel are not quite there yet, but there are still about two weeks left until Ramadan, the date Israel threatens to go into Rafha if the hostages are not released. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
What does it show about you............? Probably......................... It shows this... US says ‘understanding’ reached at Gaza hostage talks but negotiations continue | CNN -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
You must have forgotten about my "crystal ball." I predict many things, and most of them come true. Just watch and see. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
The Israeli hostages are being held by the Hamas militants to be used as bargaining chips. The indiscriminate bombing and barbaric invasion of Gaza by the Zionist-led IDF militants is also now a bargaining chip. I have predicted and expect these two chips to be exchanged, with conditions, in a release/return and a ceasefire agreement. I hope all the hostages are released unharmed, and the ceasefire will be permanent and enforced by some neutral peacekeeping force. And, yes, this whole episode is disgusting, but it's what's happening, and I hope it ends, or at least quiets down some, soon. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
That's what "hostage" means according to the online Oxford Language Dictionary: A neutral term would be "prisoner." -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
"Militant" is defined by the online Oxford Language Dictionary as: "favouring confrontational or violent methods in support of a political or social cause" I think that is appropriate to use in this case, and in the case of the IDF. I think the term you'd most object to would be just a neutral one, like "soldier." I did not use that term to describe the armed forces of Hamas. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Israel's claim to the land began when they arrived in Caanan, somewhere before 1000 BCE, 3,000 years ago. When they arrived in a series of bloody wars, they took the land from the native people living there, the Canaanites, who are the forefathers of the current-day Palestinians. The Occupation of Canaan (1250-1050 BCE) (jewishvirtuallibrary.org) So, the "truth of the matter," if you believe the Torah or Old Testament1 is the people who are now called "Palestinians" were natives of that land before the Jews, now called "Israelites," came and took it from them. There have been fighting and wars there ever since. So, Oct 7 is just one (small) chapter in the entire story of this horrific dispute over what each side considers their "god-given" land. So, don't push your biased SJ on me! 1 I don't believe the accounts in the Bible, Torah, Quoran, or any book claimed to be written by or "revealed" by some "diety." But, I cite this above because I know the Jews and the Muslims do believe what is written there. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
He's a unilateralist, pure and simple... -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
You, too, need to amend your phraseology. I'm not an "apologist"; I'm a "bilateralist." -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
If that could be arranged, I'd be all for it. Of course, that depends on what you mean by "surrender." If by "surrender," you mean a promise to cease all militant activities now and in the future, then yes. If "surrender" means all those who the IDF believes to be Hamas militants are to be arrested and held as prisoners, then no, I wouldn't be for that. And, of course, I'd expect there also would be a condition that negotiations would start on a two-state solution. -
Does that mean all the pizzo I've been paying has just been a scam???
-
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
I believe Hamas wants a ceasefire, too, but only with a guarantee of a PERMANENT ceasefire. And how would they ever be able to get that if they didn't have hostages to bargain with? I say trade the hostages for a permanent ceasefire, one that is enforced by some neutral peacekeeping force, like the UN. Then, start negotiating a two-state solution, even if those negotiations are led by their allies who want an end to this conflict - if that is at all possible. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Who cares about you? This is not about you or me. I care about me and what I think. I also care about what you and others think and post on this and other Forums. I don't always agree with what you post (and for you, that's almost always), but I do care about it. I learn a lot from these posts. Some posts inform me, and some just disappoint me. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
"Israelis overwhelmingly are confident in the justice of the Gaza war..." Well, I'm not; at least, I'm not confident in the justice of how it's being conducted, and that's what's important to me. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Okay, how about this one? There are many online to choose from... Israeli police clash with captives families in anti-Netanyahu protests | Al Mayadeen English -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
By that, I mean the Israeli people are starting to protest against the Netanyahu government. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
I agree with EVERYTHING you've said above, and I would only change one thing. I'd change the "(UK}" in the last line to "(USA)." -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
With Israel it is work in progress, Hamas will be destroyed. It is also a work in progress within Israel... -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
Israelis are getting sick of Zionists... Half a million Israelis join latest protest against Netanyahu’s judicial overhaul, organizers say | CNN -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
If Israel (and Palestine) want to safeguard against any future horrific attacks on their citizens, they should get rid of their extremist leaders (Hamas and Zionists), implement a permanent ceasefire and the return of all hostages (conditional on each other), and start negotiating a two-state solution. -
Opinion: The Case Against Israel Rests on Lies
WDSmart replied to Social Media's topic in The War in Israel
@Wobblybob, and every Palestinian civilian (human shield) that the IDF kills creates 10s or even 100s more Palestinians that now hate Israelis. IDF cannot wipe out Hamas. In trying to do so, they will only create future ones.