Circular Saw or Angle Grinder - which would be most useful ?

[Daffy D]

After many years of building, fixing and maintenance, both my circular saw and angle grinder gave up within a short time of each other. 

 

Most of the heavy work round the house has been done so would, hopefully only have small jobs to do in the future.

 

I don't want to necessarily buy two new machines so was thinking that I could manage with just one.

 

With different blades available for both machines, wood, metal and stone the only difference I can see is with the circular saw having guides for cutting straighter lines. A grinder has the tendency wander about a bit. At least it does when I use it. 

 

So which would be better the more versatile and useful machine ?

 

 

[Wobblybob]

Angle grinder all day long, preferably cordless. Very versatile piece of kit.

[OneMoreFarang]

I don't think there is a "better" between those two.

I have both, and many other tools, and I never thought if I should us the circular saw or the angle grinder. It was always obvious which one should be used.

 

I use the circular saw for straight, sometimes precise, cuts in wood.

I use the angle grinder to cut metal, sometimes in places where it would be very difficult to use a saw.

In theory I could also use the angle grinder for stone, but I have no need for that.

 

What you might want to consider is a multitool, with carbide blade. Depending on what you do this might be helpful instead of above tools.

 

 

[Wobblybob]

2 minutes ago, OneMoreFarang said:

I don't think there is a "better" between those two.

I have both, and many other tools, and I never thought if I should us the circular saw or the angle grinder. It was always obvious which one should be used.

 

I use the circular saw for straight, sometimes precise, cuts in wood.

I use the angle grinder to cut metal, sometimes in places where it would be very difficult to use a saw.

In theory I could also use the angle grinder for stone, but I have no need for that.

 

What you might want to consider is a multitool, with carbide blade. Depending on what you do this might be helpful instead of above tools.

 

 

I have every tool known to man and at a guess as an avid diy enthusiast I use my angle grinder 90% of the time compared with the circular saw, but then again I tend to work with steel and concrete, a circular saw would give better and straighter cuts with timber. Maybe that should be taken into consideration before purchase.

[transam]

Angle grinder, so many attachments and blades for the things now...

[sirineou]

 

IMO a circular saw is much more versatile than an angle grinder. 

You can change the blade on the circular saw and cut metal or concrete .

You could but wood with a angle grinder but you won't do a good cut, you can't really make a good straight cut. You cant adjust the depth of the cut and you cant set an angle. 

[Pouatchee]

angle grinder... you can buy mini circular saw blades for them... though they scare the crap outta me to use

[transam]

3 minutes ago, Pouatchee said:

angle grinder... you can buy mini circular saw blades for them... though they scare the crap outta me to use

Yes, I saw those and thought....Naaaaaaaaaah....😬

[Pouatchee]

3 minutes ago, transam said:

Yes, I saw those and thought....Naaaaaaaaaah....😬

 

I actually tried one... it works... maybe too well, Scary as heck. I already had an accident a few years back and almost sliced my hand off with a circular saw from the kickback when you stop and start again without backing up a bit... so I became wary of the small blade... but they do have them...

[transam]

2 minutes ago, Pouatchee said:

 

I actually tried one... it works... maybe too well, Scary as heck. I already had an accident a few years back and almost sliced my hand off with a circular saw from the kickback when you stop and start again without backing up a bit... so I became wary of the small blade... but they do have them...

I know, Mr.DIY has a great selection at silly money...

[Bday Prang]

horses for courses. neither are that expensive, I would buy one of each,as and when required

[Liquorice]

After spending two years renovating an old rural village home, I ask yourself one simple question;

 

Are you likely to be taking the material to the tool to cut, or the tool to the material to cut, in future?
You then have the answer.

[OneMoreFarang]

1 minute ago, Liquorice said:

After spending two years renovating an old rural village home, I ask yourself one simple question;

 

Are you likely to be taking the material to the tool to cut, or the tool to the material to cut, in future?
You then have the answer.

A circular saw is not a table saw.

And circular saws and angle grinders are both available battery powered. 

[frank83628]

if you look at the Maktec, they are actually Makita products, but a fraction of the price. you could buy both saw and grinder for the same price as 1 Makita branded tool. (although no cordless maktec)

Edited March 23 by frank83628

[IvorBiggun2]

6 hours ago, frank83628 said:

if you look at the Maktec, they are actually Makita products, but a fraction of the price.

There's gotta be a reason why.

[sometimewoodworker]

Buy an angle grinder for 300 baht, if it fails, none of mine have, buy another one.

 

then spend reasonable money on a circular saw as that needs to be good quality to do a good job

[Liquorice]

9 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

A circular saw is not a table saw.

Jeez, 40 years in the trade with a garage full of 'Industrial' tools, and you've just enlightened me.   🙄

The point I was making is if you're going to be cutting, timber, steel, or brick/blocks outside the home a circular saw may be more versatile.
If you're going to be doing jobs in and around the home, then an angle grinder will be more beneficial.

 

9 hours ago, OneMoreFarang said:

And circular saws and angle grinders are both available battery powered. 

In Thailand, I've found industrial quality tools hard to come by, all what I would rate as DIY stuff.
Battery powered tools simply lack power or longevity here.
I went through two 12v battery combi drills within 12 months, which were simply not up to the task.

I then brought my Hitachi 18V 3A combi drill from the UK along with my Hitachi 18V 4A SDS drill, and after 10 years and being battered they're still going strong.

 

Personally, after years of using various manufacturers power tools, I wouldn't purchase anything other than Hitachi, although Panasonic are also up there.

[impulse]

That's kind of like asking whether I should buy a screwdriver or a hammer.

 

I'd buy the Maktecs, both circular saw and grinder.  I had great luck with Maktec power tools in Thailand.

 

[2baht]

I seem to reacall a lady sitting on a circular saw..........disaster!

[Rimmer]

I have four angle grinders each with a different head/wheel on them but only one circular saw that has to say something....

 

Oh I lied, I also have a Bosch 10" drop cutter

[Dolf]

15 hours ago, Daffy D said:

After many years of building, fixing and maintenance, both my circular saw and angle grinder gave up within a short time of each other. 

 

Most of the heavy work round the house has been done so would, hopefully only have small jobs to do in the future.

 

I don't want to necessarily buy two new machines so was thinking that I could manage with just one.

 

With different blades available for both machines, wood, metal and stone the only difference I can see is with the circular saw having guides for cutting straighter lines. A grinder has the tendency wander about a bit. At least it does when I use it. 

 

So which would be better the more versatile and useful machine ?

 

 

Can you afford to buy both?

[transam]

1 minute ago, Dolf said:

Can you afford to buy both?

Troll post of the day, 9.5 out of 10..................

[Wobblybob]

1 hour ago, impulse said:

That's kind of like asking whether I should buy a screwdriver or a hammer.

 

I'd buy the Maktecs, both circular saw and grinder.  I had great luck with Maktec power tools in Thailand.

 

It's nothing like "should I buy a screwdriver or a hammer". An angle grinder will do most jobs a circular saw will do, but a circular saw wil never substitute an angle grinder.

 

[frank83628]

3 hours ago, IvorBiggun2 said:

There's gotta be a reason why.

the reason is you don't get the different model options,  the catalogue is much smaller. just the basic tools. 
there are 5 different Makita routers, Maktec only 1, the biggest,  it's identical but red, identical specs, 3500bt or 11500kbt
belt sander, 1 option, the biggest, instead of 4, planer, 2 instead of 5, circular saw, 2 instead of 5, 
i have the Maikta versions at home, they are identical. Makita is embossed on the case with Maktec sticker over it.
i think it's just a budget line. i am not sure how good the cordless drill is though. but rest are good cheap tools for home reno or DIY, apart form my cordless drills  & chop saw , all my kit is Maktec.

also Makita spares are readily available. compared to cheapo lazada specials.

Edited March 24 by frank83628

[OneMoreFarang]

2 hours ago, Liquorice said:

Jeez, 40 years in the trade with a garage full of 'Industrial' tools, and you've just enlightened me.   🙄

The point I was making is if you're going to be cutting, timber, steel, or brick/blocks outside the home a circular saw may be more versatile.
If you're going to be doing jobs in and around the home, then an angle grinder will be more beneficial.

 

In Thailand, I've found industrial quality tools hard to come by, all what I would rate as DIY stuff.
Battery powered tools simply lack power or longevity here.
I went through two 12v battery combi drills within 12 months, which were simply not up to the task.

I then brought my Hitachi 18V 3A combi drill from the UK along with my Hitachi 18V 4A SDS drill, and after 10 years and being battered they're still going strong.

 

Personally, after years of using various manufacturers power tools, I wouldn't purchase anything other than Hitachi, although Panasonic are also up there.

In the last two years I bought a couple of Bosch Professional 18V tools. They all have enough power and the batteries last.

 

 

[Daffy D]

Thanks for all your  help and suggestions.

 

I'm leaning toward a cordless angle grinder as it does seem to do most things, except cut straight lines and proper angles but that's down to me. 

 

It's not really a question of affordability of buying two machines, it's a question of how much use they will get.

 

Now that the main work round the property is done chances are that each or both machines will sit on the shelf for months in between use. Better having just one machine sitting round idle.  

[OneMoreFarang]

1 hour ago, Wobblybob said:

An angle grinder will do most jobs a circular saw will do

Maybe I just don't have enough imagination.

How do you make a straight precise cut in wood with an angle grinder?

 

[Wobblybob]

1 minute ago, OneMoreFarang said:

Maybe I just don't have enough imagination.

How do you make a straight precise cut in wood with an angle grinder?

 

Re-read my post, I said most jobs. 

[OneMoreFarang]

1 minute ago, Daffy D said:

Thanks for all your  help and suggestions.

 

I'm leaning toward a cordless angle grinder as it does seem to do most things, except cut straight lines and proper angles but that's down to me. 

 

It's not really a question of affordability of buying two machines, it's a question of how much use they will get.

 

Now that the main work round the property is done chances are that each or both machines will sit on the shelf for months in between use. Better having just one machine sitting round idle.  

 

Does it really matter how many tools are on the shelf?

Maybe you buy now one of them, and in 3 months you would like to use the other one, but you don't have it. Then 3 months later the same situation again. And then? Likely you will buy also the 2nd tool. And then you ask yourself: Why didn't I buy both of them and avoid the headache?

 

 

 

[Wobblybob]

2 minutes ago, OneMoreFarang said:

 

Does it really matter how many tools are on the shelf?

Maybe you buy now one of them, and in 3 months you would like to use the other one, but you don't have it. Then 3 months later the same situation again. And then? Likely you will buy also the 2nd tool. And then you ask yourself: Why didn't I buy both of them and avoid the headache?

 

 

 

Should that occurrence arise the op can do another post on 'oh how I wished I'd bought both tools' instead of the op post of "Circular Saw or Angle Grinder - which would be most useful ?" 😉😂😂