19 hours ago, Nick Carter icp said:

Muslims built their Temple, the Golden domed one, right on top of the Jews Temple of David for the sole purpose of Making Jews not have a Temple .

One day the Temple of David will be rebuilt

This would mean eternal war with the world's Muslims and probably lead to the expulsion of Jewish Israelis for millennia.

13 hours ago, Nick Carter icp said:

Muslims go to Mecca and Medina for their Holy sites , Al Aksa is like third division

Actually Muslims originally prayed in the direction of Jerusalem.

2 minutes ago, placnx said:

This would mean eternal war with the world's Muslims and probably lead to the expulsion of Jewish Israelis for millennia.

How would the Muslims expel Jews from Israel ?

They've been trying to do that for 80 odd years now

2 hours ago, Thingamabob said:

Jews were living in the Holy Land nearly 2000 years before Islam was created. In those days those who we now call Palestinians were known as philistines.

From Google:

The Name "Palestine": The geographic term Peleset found in Egyptian records evolved into Greek (Palaistine) and Latin (Palaestina). The Romans revived the name Syria Palaestina in the 2nd century CE to designate the region.

The ancient Philistines were eventually conquered, assimilated into the broader Levantine population by the Neo-Babylonian and Persian periods, and ceased to exist as a distinct ethnic group.

Modern Palestinians are predominantly an Arabic-speaking population whose ancestry is indigenous to the Levant, drawing deep roots from centuries of mixed populations, cultures, and empires that inhabited the region.

10 minutes ago, placnx said:

From Google:

The Name "Palestine": The geographic term Peleset found in Egyptian records evolved into Greek (Palaistine) and Latin (Palaestina). The Romans revived the name Syria Palaestina in the 2nd century CE to designate the region.

The ancient Philistines were eventually conquered, assimilated into the broader Levantine population by the Neo-Babylonian and Persian periods, and ceased to exist as a distinct ethnic group.

Modern Palestinians are predominantly an Arabic-speaking population whose ancestry is indigenous to the Levant, drawing deep roots from centuries of mixed populations, cultures, and empires that inhabited the region.

Your point is ?

51 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

• The Status Quo: The Israeli government strictly maintains the historical "status quo," which gives the Muslim Waqf administrative control over the Temple Mount and prohibits non-Muslim prayer.

Since 2000 and Ariel Sharon's invasion of the Haram al-Sharif a/k/a Temple Mount, an event that triggered the Second Intifada, successive Israeli governments have increasingly let extremist ultra-orthodox violate the "status quo". After October 7th there have been brutal incidents perpetrated by Israeli government forces, even inside the mosque!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_clashes

5 minutes ago, placnx said:

Since 2000 and Ariel Sharon's invasion of the Haram al-Sharif a/k/a Temple Mount, an event that triggered the Second Intifada, successive Israeli governments have increasingly let extremist ultra-orthodox violate the "status quo". After October 7th there have been brutal incidents perpetrated by Israeli government forces, even inside the mosque!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_clashes

Two different things there .

The Muslim Waqf control the Religion side of things .

The IDF control the security

34 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

How would the Muslims expel Jews from Israel ?

They've been trying to do that for 80 odd years now

We started with your hypothetical of the construction of a Third Temple (presumably after demol;ition of the Al Aqsa Mosque). A lot of opposition would happen before that could take place, and I expect that even many Jews worldwide would object. The more like ly scenario is that the world will force Israel to withdraw to the 1967 borders. The Israeli people will learn to restrain or imprison their extremists, maybe even expel them to their home countries.

4 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

Two different things there .

The Muslim Waqf control the Religion side of things .

The IDF control the security

Your response is a deflection. Everyone insterested should read the Wikipedia entry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_clashes

9 minutes ago, placnx said:

Your response is a deflection. Everyone insterested should read the Wikipedia entry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_clashes

The Religious aspect is different to the security aspect .

The Muslim Waqf still control the religious aspect

If Jerusalem or at least the part that incorporates all the most important religious sites was turned into a holy city like the Vatican City in Rome it just might solve most or at least some of the problems.

On 6/12/2026 at 11:54 PM, Nick Carter icp said:

Yes, ''John" , as I said .

It was originally the Jews Holy site from before Islam became into being . Muslims then came along and built over it and declared it their Holy site ( To stop jews ever reclaiming Jerusalem)

“Peter” the use of real names is forbidden here.

On 6/13/2026 at 12:23 PM, placnx said:

This would mean eternal war with the world's Muslims

It wouldn't be eternal war.

The ratio of Muslims to Jewry is 2000:16

2 billion Muslims against 16 million Jewry. Half of which (Jewry) are soft non-Israelis.

Every Jew on the planet would be butchered. Not one Jew would be left.

On 6/16/2026 at 7:30 AM, Packer said:

It wouldn't be eternal war.

The ratio of Muslims to Jewry is 2000:16

2 billion Muslims against 16 million Jewry. Half of which (Jewry) are soft non-Israelis.

Every Jew on the planet would be butchered. Not one Jew would be left.

I remember one history professor in our Near Eastern department remarking in the leadup to the 1967 war that in around 300 years Israel will be disappeared by a bomb. They had better not mess with the Islamic and Christian sites and not expel Palestinians, either. Those are their shields against immolation. Muslims don't have a problem with Jews per se. It is the Zionist ideologues that have been causing problems for 100+ years.