I’d lean toward keeping the emoji/poster names visible for transparency and accountability. When reactions are anonymous, it can create two problems: People can “target” others via PM or follow-up harassment, as you’ve just seen It removes any natural brake on behaviour, because there’s no visible ownership of the reaction If someone knows their reaction is visible, they’re more likely to behave responsibly. It also helps mods spot patterns early if the same accounts are repeatedly involved in disputes. The downside of visibility is potential friction, but anonymity seems to be driving more of the behavioural issues, not less. On the members going after others via PM over reactions — that crosses a line. That’s no longer “forum disagreement”, it’s harassment. IMO that should be a clear warning or suspension, because it undermines the whole community trust. So I’d keep visibility, and deal firmly with any off-platform retaliation.
Create an account or sign in to comment