Persecuting the peacemakers: A dismal tale from the Thai South

[webfact]

Persecuting the peacemakers: A dismal tale from the South
Don Pathan
Special to The Nation

The systematic harassment of men like Artef Sohko has shut down grass-roots activism and blocked the path to lasting peace in this contested region

BANGKOK: -- Artef Sohko says he is fed up with being constantly harassed by unnamed government or pro-government entities, but he's not sure what he can do about it.

Since 2007, when he became the first ethnic Malay to be elected president of the Student Federation of Thailand, Artef says Thai security agencies have routinely persecuted him because of his outspoken demands for justice and equality for ethnic Malays in the historically contested deep South.

The year 2007 saw a peak in violence as allegations of rape and torture were made against security forces in the region. Artef and other student leaders felt they had enough and they decided to seize the Pattani Central Mosque in protest.

"There were allegations that a [Paramilitary] Ranger had raped a woman in front of her mother in [Yala's] Yaha district. We also heard about other rape incidents, but the victims and their families were too ashamed to speak out," Artef said.

Senior military commanders agreed to set up a joint working group to look into the allegations. But like every other ad-hoc committee set up by authorities in this region, it slowly slipped from the agenda and out of the minds of government officials.

Meanwhile relations between ethnic Malays and Thai Buddhist communities in the South took a nosedive as innocent bystanders became the targets - often as part of tit-for-tat vendettas between security forces and insurgents.

International watchdogs such as Amnesty and Human Rights Watch have condemned actions on both sides, but they consistently criticise Thai security forces for a "culture of impunity" and have urged the government to punish wrongdoers. But such requests have fallen on deaf ears and quickly slipped from public consciousness - even in high-profile cases like the beating to death of Imam Yapa Kaseng. A full seven years after the Muslim religious leader's killing, the National Anti-Corruption Commission last week suggested that the accused, Army Sub-Lieutenant Sirikhet Wanitbamrung, face disciplinary and criminal action.

Artef says he has never been tortured, but he describes how a security official once beat a person in front of him as a way of demonstrating his unrestrained power.

"The idea was to demoralise me. He wanted to show what he could do and that there was not a thing that I could do about it," he said.

The persecution also took on a devious, personal angle. An elaborate flowchart was faked-up showing him, his wife and her father linked in a crime syndicate and drug trafficking ring. It was released via the social media, making it difficult to trace without help from the authorities. But given that no Thai government in the last decade has taken legal action against an official in the deep South, Artef said it would be a pipe dream to expect help in this case.

"The attitude of many Thai officials is you are either with us or you are with the insurgents. And if you're with the state, you shouldn't criticise us even when the conduct of an official is wrong or illegal," Artef said.

He is not the only activist to face harassment. Others both in and outside of his network have faced similar trouble, being detained or having their DNA taken on flimsy pretences, or have their residences searched without probable cause or warrant.

Zawawee Zawawee Jujur, a 26-year-old local activist and former member of Media Selantan, a Pattani-based community radio station, says he has been DNA tested three times already. When he refused a fourth test earlier this year, police threatened him at the point of a gun.

The authorities' action is based, Zawawee says, on the assumption that he will eventually commit an illegal act, at which time "they will already be prepared to charge me".

Security officials even visited his village in Narathiwat's Tak Bai district and told the headman there to keep an eye on this "young man who has joined an anti-state organisation".

Artef's outspokenness has won a great deal of support not just from the grass roots in this majority-Malay Muslim region but also from foreign governments, who have often sought his insights into the ongoing conflict and the peace process. He doesn't think very highly of the latter, explaining that the participants lack any real influence over the insurgent combatants.

Thailand's approach to peace has always been very short-sighted, usually seeking quick gains while avoiding asking the central question of how the two sides can coexist peacefully and with mutual respect.

On the public front, Artef is often the key speaker at the Bicara Patani, a political rally that draws crowds of up to 10,000, mostly villagers - which gives an idea of his popularity with local people.

Many of these events are documented by Wartani, a grass-roots media organisation run by local Patani Malay activists closely associated with Artef. Wartani reporters say that they too have been harassed by Thai security officials.

Artef refuses to tar all Thai officials with the same brush, though, explaining that many have a great working relationship with him and the youth network.

Yet many others in authority continue to insist that Artef and his activist colleagues are either part of the separatist movement or inspired by the political wing of its umbrella group, the Barisan Revolusi Nasional (BRN) - a claim he vociferously denies. But he does admit that Thai authorities, both security and political, have asked him to act as a go-between with the BRN and other separatist leaders.

"It's a fine line to walk and the best way to go about it is to maintain your integrity. I don't take sides or support any particular [separatist] organisations," Artef said.

When asked if his agenda includes independence for the Malay-speaking region, Artef said: "It's not my decision to make. It's up to all the people of this region. But I do want to see peace and justice for all sides."

Artef says that though he is often followed by plainclothes officials, the authorities can never pin anything on him because he hasn't done any wrong. "Nevertheless, it is still irritating," he adds.

In the aftermath of the May 2014 coup, security officials suggested that he leave the country for about three years, which he did. For everybody's sake, he decided to leave his wife and three-year-old son behind and live in India, where he studied English. "The cost of living was affordable," he said.

The low point came late last week when a hooded man in black broke into the home of his mother-in-law in the middle of the night in Narathiwat's Joh I Rong sub-district and took all the printed documents from the bedroom where his wife and his son normally sleep.

"They didn't take any of the valuable stuff. Perhaps it was an indication of things to come," he said.

Don Pathan is a Yala-based freelance security and development consultant and a founding member of the Patani Forum (www.pataniforum.com).

Source: http://www.nationmultimedia.com/opinion/Persecuting-the-peacemakers-A-dismal-tale-from-the-30269798.html


-- The Nation 2015-09-30

[deckape]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

[clockman]

What justice? Justice is a distant bell. Rarely heard in Thailand.

[MZurf]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

And I'm increasingly convinced that Thainess is at the root of most Thai problems, or at least what the rulers want Thainess to be.

[GarryP]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

And I'm increasingly convinced that Thainess is at the root of most Thai problems, or at least what the rulers want Thainess to be.

I think both of you are right.

What doesn't surprise me is the lack of interest in this thread by other TV members. If it was the northeast, the north or even central Thailand, they would be up in arms about the unfairness of it all. But because it is the deep south they are disinterested. I think this would apply to most Thai too. Sad really.

Edited September 30, 2015 by GarryP

[Lorn]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

And I'm increasingly convinced that Thainess is at the root of most Thai problems, or at least what the rulers want Thainess to be.

I think both of you are right.

What doesn't surprise me is the lack of interest in this thread by other TV members. If it was the northeast, the north or even central Thailand, they would be up in arms about the unfairness of it all. But because it is the deep south they are disinterested. I think this would apply to most Thai too. Sad really.

I prefer talking about things that have a possible solution. They want or will in the future want full independence. Thailand won't give it to them as it would decrease the coastline and access to fishing resources etc. dramatically. Nothing will change.

[anon4546543]

Throughout history, "revolutionaries" have always attacked the police and security forces. But these chaps also kill teachers, medical staff, the educated, indeed any intellectual. These are the actions of an extreme terrorist organisation with a religious agenda. And they seem to be receiving funding and training from an outside country or individuals with the same agenda. If this area did receive independence, it would almost certainly result in a blood bath to Buddhist Thais and the destruction of their temples and cultural locations. And possibly more killing of teachers and medical staff because being educated and intelligent is anathema to this version of a religion. Sell it back to Malaysia? Use the money to exit all Thais loyal to The Kingdom. Or make it semi autonomous. Maybe, but I think that attacks on any security forces and educated would continue no matter their religious affiliation. (I also think that Malaysia does not want a country that practices extreme radical religion on its border.) So I don't think you can negotiate with the radicals, the problem is insurmountable and no one except the US who like to preach to every other government really wants to know about what is going on.

[Srikcir]

"usually seeking quick gains while avoiding asking the central question of how the two sides can coexist peacefully and with mutual respect."

No. It's about the Thai military avoiding to implement the solution - autonomy for the Malay-Thais.

But that requires giving up Thai absolute sovereignty over the Malay-Thais and Prayut has stated that will not happen.

[GarryP]

"usually seeking quick gains while avoiding asking the central question of how the two sides can coexist peacefully and with mutual respect."

No. It's about the Thai military avoiding to implement the solution - autonomy for the Malay-Thais.

But that requires giving up Thai absolute sovereignty over the Malay-Thais and Prayut has stated that will not happen.

There is also the fact that the deep south is an excellent money spinner for the military. Military budget allocations, including black budget or more exactly the secret budget (an annual Thai military budget that is not open to scrutiny), for investment in equipment and military activities (think bomb detectors and dirigibles) for supposed deep south activities, are massive. The military has a vested interest in keeping the south in turmoil or at least the generals have.

As has been suggested time and time again by people and organizations with experience in matters such as this, the army needs to get out, or at least limit its role to a minds and hearts operation. This will never happen though. Too much money is at stake.

[Doc46]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

And I'm increasingly convinced that Thainess is at the root of most Thai problems, or at least what the rulers want Thainess to be.

I think both of you are right.

What doesn't surprise me is the lack of interest in this thread by other TV members. If it was the northeast, the north or even central Thailand, they would be up in arms about the unfairness of it all. But because it is the deep south they are disinterested. I think this would apply to most Thai too. Sad really.

So you think that Us down here in the Dark south don't Care ? W<>T<>F You know ,Whatever you say on TV or Do is not going to make a Feckun Difference at all to the matter of people killing each other or the invasion of the Muslims,Don't speak for us just shut up.

[GarryP]

The rule of law needs to be brought to this place. I am increasingly convinced the Thai justice system is at the root of most Thai problems.

And I'm increasingly convinced that Thainess is at the root of most Thai problems, or at least what the rulers want Thainess to be.

I think both of you are right.

What doesn't surprise me is the lack of interest in this thread by other TV members. If it was the northeast, the north or even central Thailand, they would be up in arms about the unfairness of it all. But because it is the deep south they are disinterested. I think this would apply to most Thai too. Sad really.

So you think that Us down here in the Dark south don't Care ? W<>T<>F You know ,Whatever you say on TV or Do is not going to make a Feckun Difference at all to the matter of people killing each other or the invasion of the Muslims,Don't speak for us just shut up.

I think you need to take a course in reading comprehension. That's what I think. Where did I say I was speaking for you? Do you have anger management issues?

[RubbaJohnny]

A tragic situation with religeous overtones,until such myths are no longer popular I see little prospect of change,as others comment the hiatus and instability is also a money spinner for people and oil smugglers.Religeous psychosis is gradually departing in enlightened places, the salfist financed submission is still in its 1430s medieaval phase,There are radical solutions but no wlll