Jump to content

Uruguay defeats tobacco giant in court dispute


rooster59

Recommended Posts

Uruguay defeats tobacco giant in court dispute

post-247607-0-83613200-1468120791_thumb.

The World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) has ruled in favour of Uruguay after cigarette giant Philip Morris International tried to seek compensation from the country.

Philip Morris argued that Uruguay’s anti-tobacco measures hurt its business and had sought compensation.

President Tabare Vazquez’s government banned smoking in public spaces in 2006, raised taxes on cigarettes and forced companies to include large health warnings on their cigarette packs.

“The health measures we implemented for controlling tobacco usage and for protecting the health of our people have been expressly recognized as legitimate and also adopted as part of the sovereign power of our republic,” Vazquez said in a televised speech last week.

In a lengthy decision published on Friday, the ICSID said it had ruled to dismiss Philip Morris’ demand that the regulations be withdrawn, or not applied to the company, or that it be paid $22 million in damages instead.

It ordered the tobacco company to pay Uruguay $7 million and to cover “all the fees and expenses of the Tribunal and ICSID’s administrative fees and expenses.”

Phillip Morris said it respected the tribunal’s decision.

“We’ve never questioned Uruguay’s authority to protect public health, and this case wasn’t about broad issues of tobacco policy,” Marc Firestone, Philip Morris International senior vice president and general counsel, said in a statement.

“The arbitration concerned an important, but unusual, set of facts that called for clarification under international law,” added Firestone.

The tobacco company said that it would like to meet with Uruguay’s government, to explore regulatory frameworks that would enable smokers “in the country to have informed access to reduced-risk alternatives to smoking.”

Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), the oldest anti-tobacco organization in the United States, applauded Uruguay for winning the case, but said Phillip Morris “accomplished its primary goal.”

Phillip Morris “will no doubt shed some public crocodile tears, but their main goal in launching the suit has been realized, six years and millions of dollars have been spent defending a nondiscriminatory law that was intended purely to protect public health,” said Laurent Huber, executive director for ASH.

“This has already resulted in a regulatory chill in other countries, preventing tobacco legislation that would have saved lives,” Huber said.

euronews2.png
-- (c) Copyright Euronews 2016-07-10

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Evil socialistic government regulators. Remember what Ronald Reagan said are the 9 scariest words in the English language: "I'm from the government and I'm here to help."

Scary words indeed. Hurrah for Uruguay its time these nefarious pirates of clean air are brought to heel and pay. This octopus is one of many trying for world domination its nice to see one of its tentacles cut off.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

"low risk alternatives to smoking" ?

Like NOT smoking??

While I fail to see what leg PM was even trying to stand on here, Big Tobacco is what it is purely because of weak, addicted, and in some cases hopelessly irrational individuals who just can't accept responsibility for the damage they do to themselves AND OTHERS around them with their filthy, disease-causing habit. If they want to smoke in private, up to them, but smoking in public, ANYWHERE in public, needs to simply be banned.

Fortunately, most parts of the world are moving inexorably in this direction. Smokers could have headed this off with a little self-discipline, but chose not to do so.

Edited by hawker9000
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you tried to bring this product to market , nowadays you would never be able to sell it, Big Corporations lie.

This product will continue to sell no matter what as there are millions of idiots out there that will continue to smoke claiming "cancer or heart disease have never been proven to be caused by cigarettes".Claiming"How great they taste after eating",Crap if they taste so great then why don't they make an ice cream with a cigarette flavor ? Showing that that cigarette is stronger then millions of "Weak Minded" people.So Puff On Dummies,Puff On.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you tried to bring this product to market , nowadays you would never be able to sell it, Big Corporations lie.

This product will continue to sell no matter what as there are millions of idiots out there that will continue to smoke claiming "cancer or heart disease have never been proven to be caused by cigarettes".Claiming"How great they taste after eating",Crap if they taste so great then why don't they make an ice cream with a cigarette flavor ? Showing that that cigarette is stronger then millions of "Weak Minded" people.So Puff On Dummies,Puff On.
They only taste so great after eating is because they taste great to tobacco all addicts after any imposed 1/2 hour break in their smoking habit including eating a meal.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I smoke however, be careful of so called free trade deals that make it possible for big corporations to sue sovereign governments. No I don't recommend it to others and I try not to be offended by the self righteous wowsers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I smoke however, be careful of so called free trade deals that make it possible for big corporations to sue sovereign governments. No I don't recommend it to others and I try not to be offended by the self righteous wowsers.

If you are over 40 and have a good education and can read medical reports about the results of smoking and are still smoking then idiocracy is the only explanation.Hummm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Teenagers (or even pre-teens) respond to peer pressure, not medical studies. And I think that's when most smokers start. Once it starts, it's an addiction and medical studies matter even less. Less-addicting for some perhaps - the lucky few who can quit - the rest are pretty much hooked absent some pretty exceptional self-control and resolve. And many are just so far gone they're not even aware of how they burden others with their habit when they do it in public. They've rationalized a filthy, lethal addiction into a "right": they actually believe that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.








  • Topics

  • Latest posts...

    1. 0

      17 Arrests Made as Pro-Palestinian Protests Sweep London

    2. 0

      Elon Musk Joins Donald Trump in Rally, Energizes Supporters

    3. 0

      Legal Battle Looms over VAT on Private Schools: Parent’s Fight for Special Needs Education

    4. 0

      The Dark Legacy of October 7 The Terror and Tragedy One Year On

    5. 0

      The U.S. Alliance Dilemma: Hezbollah, Iran, and Russia's Connection

    6. 0

      Could an October Surprise Shift the Deadlocked Trump-Harris Race?

    7. 0

      Putin's Nuclear Threats: Rhetoric or Reality?

    8. 0

      White House Rebukes False Claims Amid Hurricane Helene Relief Efforts

    9. 0

      Spreaders of Conspiracy Theories: Unmasking the Motivations Behind the Lies

    10. 0

      Boris Johnson Suggests Putin Would Have Avoided Invading Ukraine if Trump Were President

    11. 0

      Oklahoma’s Controversial Plan to Purchase 55,000 Bibles for Public Schools

    12. 0

      Menendez Brothers’ Convictions to be Revisited Amid New Evidence & Interest

    13. 0

      India’s Debate on Marital Rape: Government Deems Criminalisation ‘Excessively Harsh’

    14. 0

      Rapid Greening of Antarctica: Scientists Alarmed by Climate Change Impact

    15. 3,549

      President Kamala Harris

×
×
  • Create New...