Jump to content

Cherrytreeview

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    977
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Cherrytreeview

  1. 18 minutes ago, chieftan said:

    Yes, Thailand's new case rate is 236/million (7 day r-AV), UK's new case rate is 686/million (almost 3X Thailand), UK's covid death rate is 6X higher than Thailand, (2.23/M vs. .36/M in Thailand-FEB 17/2022)

    Web-source: Death rate, Case rate

    Additionally, UK HSA reports new covid case rates are higher in vaccinated people in all age cohorts except <18 years. web-source

    Reports by Scotland and NSW Au show similar trends for new cases and deaths. The data is becoming so controversial that Public Health Scotland (PHS) will no longer report COVID-19 cases, hospitalisations, and deaths by vaccination status on a weekly basis. The latest report in Scotland shows covid death rates are HIGHER in *fully vaccinated  (2 doses) than the non vaccinated. websource Table 15, pg 47

     

    I don't see any trolling and false data submitted here by a particular poster here who has provided reputable data sources. You seem to NOT want to accept facts as facts.

     

    In closing, consider as an example the exploits of a particular country,  that has some of the the best scientific minds, best medicine, the mRNA vaccines, financial resources... yet, it has over 930K Covid deaths, (16% of the worlds total despite having only 4% of the total world population) still have 2,000+ daily deaths with many break through cases, how does that country compare to Thailand?

    * FYI, US considers two dose vaccine (2 week waiting period after 2nd shot) as "fully vaccinated) and 3rd shot booster as "up to date" web-source link

    Looks like someone is posting more misinformation on a dual account. ????

    • Like 2
  2. 2 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    No, I'm referring to the official expressions of "waves", the second wave came from migrant workers in December 2020, while the third wave originated from the VVIP hi-so amusement area in Bangkok - Krystal Club and Emerald Club - end of March 2021 and escalated from April; which is the one you're thinking of.

     

    4th and 5th wave ware not initially mentioned, but recently referred to Delta variant and Omicron variant.

     

    What WHO may think, might be different from what countries with succesful border control experienced, ask what New Zealand and Australia think about that.

    I would report you for trolling but to be honest i am beginning to feel sorry for you.

     

  3. 6 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    Nothing mentioned about booster, the graphs are correct.

     

    Omicron arrived later in Thailand than Europe, so there is a delay in spread and number of cases compared to Europe. In some European countries the number of new cases hare hitting record high numbers at the moment - rising faster than Thailand, but cannot be easily compared due to number of performed Covid tests and asymptomatic cases - but omicron is less severe according to the experts, so reopening is happening.

     

    Don't forget UK, with about same size of population as Thailand, reported 128 new Covid deaths today, and 34,377 new cases with a total of 1,807,714 active cases. Thailand reported 29 deaths, while number of cases might not be comparable at all due to fewer tests, but the number is lower than UK.

    Your talking nonsense.

    You seem to think writing more flannel makes you right.

    It doesn't. It's rubbish.

    Thailand was appauling at its vaccine procurement and it's vaccine campaign.

    Omicron spread within weeks throughout the globe.

    Thailand still has about 26% of it's population boosted.

    Who's fault is that? The UK's?

    Why you don't accept the facts is beyond me.

    Have another go, your trolling musings are very funny.

     

    • Thanks 1
  4. 1 hour ago, khunPer said:

    That strain of virus in the boxing stadium-cluster was said to come from a Thai migrant worker returning from Italy, which at that time suffered from a new Covid-mutation, different from the original milder Wuham-strain that was already in Thailand...

    However, there were later doubt if the strain from Italy was more dangerous.

     

    The second wave came with illegal migrant workers from Myanmar.

     

    Unfortunately there are not anything better to compare with than official facts, what people believe is a private matter.

    The delta wave started with HiSo clubs in Thonglor.

    Your making stuff up again.

    The WHO think border restrictions are a waste of time.

    Your clutching for straws.

    It is amusing though.

  5. 2 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    The number in statistics are vaccinations, not makes or brands. We are not talking about which vaccines are the most efficient, in Europe and Israel - which is among the leading countries when it comes to Covid-vaccinations - people are having their 4th jab as even Pfizer, which many considers as an excellent vaccine, don't give long term protection. UK based their vaccination program on AZ, which Thailand also did, but until AZ became available they used Sinovac.

     

    The graph is supposed to be up to date based on what the individual countries reports, it shows first jab or "partly vaccinated", and so-called "fully vaccinated" with two jabs. It the same for all countries in the graph; what vaccines do you think are used in China?

    Except fully vaccinated includes a booster jab.

    Telling porky pies again.

    • Like 2
  6. 13 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    Sorry, but I'm not dishonest, I relay statistics from ourworldindata.org. If you have better comparing sources, please share.

    UK total vaccinated first dose in your link is 52,556.789 people of a population of 68,467.516 people, which is 76.76 percent. The percentage of 91,4 shown on the right in your link is of "population aged 12+".

    Your being dishonest.

    Omicron requires a booster dose to be more effective.

    UK nearly 70% boosted, Thailand about 26%.

    Your twisting facts again, something you seem very apt at.

    It would be amusing if it wasn't so pathetic.

    The UK's boosting campaign is why we are going back to normal.

    Meanwhile, Thailand's cases are on the rise.

    You seem to live in a parallel universe.

    https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n3079

    This is why Thailand, Hong Kong etc are so far behind.

    The developed world got boosted.

     

    • Like 1
  7. 4 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    Or it's closed borders that matters, look at New Zealand and Australia, and Thailand's neighbors Cambodia and Vietnam, they also performed well.

     

    Thailand had the first reported Covid case outside China back in January 2020 and closed the borders in March. It was people from outside that brought the new stems of Covid in from July  and mainly migrant workers at the end of 2020.

     

    It's indeed the total numbers that show the result of a pandemic.

    Even in your fantasy world of Thai success real hospitalisations have quadrupled since the start of the year.

    Your idea of success is pretty warped.

     

     

  8. Just now, khunPer said:

    I presume this thread is about Covid-19; I got no idea why influenza in UK comes into the picture?

     

    The Thaiger-articles is from July last year with main focus on vaccine rollout, it's little outdated now.

     

    Number of tests does not show the impact of Covid-19. Serious cases in hospital, death and excess mortality rate shows that. However, a high rate of tests might help preventing spread of virus, but so might other precautions like closed borders.

     

    Accumulated test rate per 1,000 people...

    full-list-cumulative-total-tests-per-thousand-map.thumb.png.e917fceb32836fab2d2cd3e512708223.png

     

     

    Excess deaths per 100,000 people for same countries...

    excess-deaths-cumulative-per-100k-economist.thumb.png.e7b3d49ea9a003fc69858f5ce608ccd1.png

     

    Thailand should do extremely bad here, if tests are the important factor.

     

    So let's look compare with Thailand's neighbors and Australia, that has performed quite well, but with both high test rate and closed borders...

    1670029247_full-list-cumulative-total-tests-per-thousand-map(1).thumb.png.e395d35375f8f7a23e95ce91154a407a.png
    And excess deaths per 100,000 people for same countries, please note it's not only Thailand, which has lower deaths than UK that has excess death over 200 (see above graph)...

    618337871_excess-deaths-cumulative-per-100k-economist(1).thumb.png.37c0767e1f0792c94f7e8046dbcb1f93.png

     

    My point in my first comment is that even if some may not fancy khun Anutin - and even he sometimes makes some odd statements - then statistics talks in his favor here, Thailand has not performed that bad during the Covid-pandemic, when it comes to health and deaths...????

    Closed borders are an irrelevance when a virus is wide spread within a country, just as it is in Thailand.

    Think horse, stable door, bolted.

    You keep repeating Thailand's numbers but you don't seem to understand that i think they are total and utter nonsense.

    If you really do believe Thailand's numbers, then real hospitalisations have trebled in the last few months.

    A poster has detailed this on the Thailand daily covid thread.

    Every aspect of Thailand's response since Delta first surfaced has been pretty much useless.

    Sorry.

  9. 33 minutes ago, khunPer said:

    Number of performed tests are useless for comparison, try to compare UK with Denmark.

    Your just deflecting.

    There was hardly any influenza in the UK because of restrictions.

    You believe Thailand's published facts, most of us think their incomplete BS.

    Live in your fantasy world.

    Thailand ranked third to last.

    Absymal vaccine rollout and. economic support 

     

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/flu-cases-covid-england-phe-latest-b1805124.html

     

    https://thethaiger.com/coronavirus/thailand-ranked-3rd-to-last-worldwide-on-covid-19-handling

     

     

     

     

     

    • Like 1
  10. 1 hour ago, ed strong said:

    There are more people fully vaccinated in Thailand then in the UK.

     

    Africa as a continent has less around 80 % of vaccinations than the UK and Thailand. Yet they have far fewer cases and deaths, when i mean far fewer i mean around 70% less.

     

    Just examples that don't add up, Countries seem to just make it up as they go along or get influenced by their bigger brothers, in terms of how the control the data and what gets released.

     

     

     

     

     

     

    https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/

     

    Suggest you actually get your facts straight.

    It's percentage of population that matters.

    Your posting misinformation.

     

    • Thanks 1
  11. 3 minutes ago, connda said:

    Can you attribute your statement to a published, scientific study that backs your assertion?
    No, not CNN told me..
    No, not "my doctor told me." 
    No, not I read it in the Atlantic.

    Can you provide a link to a study published in a well known scientific or medical journal which conclusively proves via statistical significance that 'vaccine immunity is better than natural immunity.'

    Just link one study from a major journal like The Lancet published in the last 6 months supporting 'vaccine immunity is better than natural immunity.'
    <insert link here>  ????

    The problem with your natural immunity theory is you have to get the disease first, with no vaccine, and know one knows how that's going to work out.

    Severe disease, long covid etc.

    The vast majority of medical evidence would suggest meeting the virus having been triple jabbed.

    Global morgues are full of people who did their own research and went the natural immunity route.

     

    • Like 2
    • Confused 1
    • Sad 1
×
×
  • Create New...