Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ASEAN NOW

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Aussie Murder Suspect Faces Thai Compensation Talks

Australian truck driver Simon Carman, 45, could receive a substantially reduced prison sentence if he is convicted of murdering Thai teenager Tunchanok Donhomla, 17, in Pattaya and reaches a compensation agreement with her family under Thai law. Carman is being held at Pattaya Remand Prison after being charged with murder following the discovery of the teenager’s body, concealed in a suitcase left in long grass near railway tracks.

Get today's headlines by email image.png

Carman, from Perth’s southern suburbs, was arrested at Bangkok’s main international airport, while police alleged he was preparing to leave Thailand on a flight to Australia. He denies murdering Tunchanok, known as Cake, and claims he acted in self-defence. Police have said their investigation remains ongoing.

According to police sources cited by the Daily Mail, discussions over financial compensation for the victim’s parents, Thongchai Donhomla and Oradee Bussarakum, are expected to form part of the legal process. The sources stressed that compensation does not prevent prosecution, but may be considered by the court alongside a guilty plea and expressions of remorse when deciding any sentence.

One police source said the family could be asked what level of compensation they would accept, with negotiations continuing until an agreement is reached. The source gave one million baht, about AU$43,000, as an example figure, noting it represents around eight years’ wages for someone earning the provincial minimum wage per day.

IMG_6340.png

The same source claimed that a guilty plea could reduce a sentence by 50 per cent, while a compensation agreement accepted by the victim’s family could carry significant weight during sentencing. They suggested that, in such circumstances, a convicted offender could potentially be released after as little as seven years. Under Thai law, however, compensation alone does not guarantee a reduced sentence, with the final decision resting with the court.

Prison officials told the Daily Mail that Carman has shown no visible emotion since his arrest and has not received visits from family, friends or members of the local expatriate community. He has been transferred to the hospital wing of Pattaya Remand Prison and is being housed separately from the main prison population for safety reasons.

The Daily Mall reported that authorities said Carman can be held at Pattaya Remand Prison for up to 84 days while detectives continue gathering evidence. Police have stated that he is cooperating with the investigation.

IMG_6338.jpeg

Pictures courtesy of Daily Mail

Related story

Australian-arrested-at-Bangkok-airport-over-Pattaya-murder

Join the discussion? image.png

Already a member? image.png

image.png Adapted by ASEAN Now Dailymail 4 July 2026

User Feedback

Recommended Comments

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member

From the linked abc.net.au article above:

"The full circumstances surrounding Ms Tunchanok's trip to Pattaya, and what she had planned to do there, remain unknown." Beaches& Islands

All they would have to do is read aseannow.com and they could find out.

Bday Prang Star Member

Bday Prang

Advanced Member
4 minutes ago, KhunHeineken said:

News of this case has gone global. If the family take money for a reduced prison sentence, it shows to the world the Thai justice system can be circumvented by paying money. Not a good look.

Well i'll tell you something else that is "not a good look" A Foreign mob criticising a recently bereaved Thai Family , based solely on reports of might or could possibly happen. Nothing in the OP says they are actively seeking, or would even accept compensation yet the sanctimonious warriors cannot control themselves

2 hours ago, JerryM said:

"Even though I am poor, I will not trade my daughter's dignity for money," Mr Thongchai said.

"I love my daughter so much."

So in view of the above quote would anybody else like to take this opportunity to apologise for their insensitive comments ?

Bday Prang Star Member

Bday Prang

Advanced Member
8 minutes ago, What to do now said:

So with the compensation, the family is basically saying it will be okay for this P.O.S. to possiblybe free in 7 years and kill again.

But......The family have said nothing of the sort

2 hours ago, JerryM said:

"Even though I am poor, I will not trade my daughter's dignity for money," Mr Thongchai said.

"I love my daughter so much."

did you miss that bit , or just choose to ignore it, in your haste to stick your knife in to a poor grieving family, ?

OneManShow Silver Member

OneManShow

Advanced Member

Once I was approached by a girl who looked under age (in Chiang Mai), but she insisted that she is 18. I asked her if she has an ID. She said that her ID is with her grandma. I told her to go and get it.

She never showed up.

This is the way to avoid such situation that could end up stupid and regretful.

Ralf001 Star Member

Ralf001

Advanced Member
3 minutes ago, OneManShow said:

Once I was approached by a girl who looked under age (in Chiang Mai), but she insisted that she is 18. I asked her if she has an ID. She said that her ID is with her grandma. I told her to go and get it.

She never showed up.

This is the way to avoid such situation that could end up stupid and regretful.

The dead girl was carrying ID that said her age was 22.

Bday Prang Star Member

Bday Prang

Advanced Member

Then just when one thinks that the Thai bashing has finished new depths are reached

3 hours ago, NewGuy87 said:

This is Thailand. They are mostly invertibrates.

A quality comment indeed,

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member
7 minutes ago, Ralf001 said:

The dead girl was carrying ID that said her age was 22.

Any claims regarding a fake ID stating she was 22 are completely absent from verifiable police updates and mainstream investigative reporting.

Ralf001 Star Member

Ralf001

Advanced Member
5 minutes ago, JerryM said:

Any claims regarding a fake ID stating she was 22 are completely absent from verifiable police updates and mainstream investigative reporting.

Best you go whinge to the posters that introduced to the forum the so called fake ID then.

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member
8 minutes ago, Ralf001 said:

Best you go whinge to the posters that introduced to the forum the so called fake ID then.

I remember reading on here that ALL the underage girls carrying fake ID's saying they are 22 so I'll presume that's where you got it.

Ralf001 Star Member

Ralf001

Advanced Member
2 minutes ago, JerryM said:

I remember reading on here that ALL the underage girls carrying fake ID's saying they are 22 so I'll presume that's where you got it.

Was posted in this thread by another forum member.

MeRakThai Apprentice Member

MeRakThai

Member
On 7/4/2026 at 10:59 AM, Bday Prang said:

He might be worth a fortune in Australia though, who brings all there money over here?

He was on a disability pension in Australia. He had screws in his spine due to an accident.Furthermore his wife and daughter call him weird and had nothing to do with him. On top of this his firearms were confiscated by the police and his firearms licence was cancelled in 2023. So that should tell you something of this scum. As an Australian i am sickened by this and hope he is executed or life with no parole and he also pays the parents compensation of millions but as he is on a pension i cant see that happening.

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member
14 minutes ago, Ralf001 said:

Was posted in this thread by another forum member.

Right that was posted as speculation by a forum member along with other speculations.

Ralf001 Star Member

Ralf001

Advanced Member
9 minutes ago, JerryM said:

Right that was posted as speculation by a forum member along with other speculations.

Best you run along and go question those other forum members.

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member
4 minutes ago, Ralf001 said:

Best you run along and go question those other forum members.

I tried to find a credible report that she was carrying fake ID but could not. And I'm going to leave it there.

KhunHeineken Ruby Member

KhunHeineken

Advanced Member
1 hour ago, Bday Prang said:

Well i'll tell you something else that is "not a good look" A Foreign mob criticising a recently bereaved Thai Family , based solely on reports of might or could possibly happen. Nothing in the OP says they are actively seeking, or would even accept compensation yet the sanctimonious warriors cannot control themselves

It's happened in many other cases over the years here, most notably, road deaths. Do you deny this?

It MAY happen in this case, or it MAY not. We'll just have to wait and see.

Bday Prang Star Member

Bday Prang

Advanced Member
6 minutes ago, KhunHeineken said:

It's happened in man, y other cases over the years here, most notably, road deaths. Do you deny this?

It MAY happen in this case, or it MAY not. We'll just have to wait and see.

I don't deny anything . and I have no issues if they do get some compensation,

Indeed it May happen but "We" do not "have to wait and see" anything . You might feel the need to keep yourself informed about the actions of the unfortunate family , Personally I don't ,

KhunHeineken Ruby Member

KhunHeineken

Advanced Member
3 minutes ago, Bday Prang said:

I don't deny anything . and I have no issues if they do get some compensation,

Indeed it May happen but "We" do not "have to wait and see" anything . You might feel the need to keep yourself informed about the actions of the unfortunate family , Personally I don't ,

I read the local news. So do you. If it's in the news, I'll read it, and so will you, as will many others, even people in Australia.

So, we'll wait and see.

241195_1469957797 Explorer Member

241195_1469957797

Member

Money rules. In Thailand, you can get away with anything if you have enough money. How much does it cost to go free after a murder? Two million baht, when halving the sentence costs one million baht? Disgusting.🤢🤢🤢

Rockyroad Platinum Member

Rockyroad

Advanced Member
37 minutes ago, 241195_1469957797 said:

Money rules. In Thailand, you can get away with anything if you have enough money. How much does it cost to go free after a murder? Two million baht, when halving the sentence costs one million baht? Disgusting.🤢🤢🤢

Where does this theory come from?

thjames007 Senior Member

thjames007

Member
On 7/3/2026 at 7:58 PM, EVENKEEL said:

Don't get the knickers in a twist. You want to take wagers on whether the father takes the compen

On 7/3/2026 at 7:58 PM, EVENKEEL said:

Don't get the knickers in a twist. You want to take wagers on whether the father takes the compensation.

Really? You a bit sick. That father will never see his daughter again.... End of you twisted story..

Bday Prang Star Member

Bday Prang

Advanced Member
6 hours ago, KhunHeineken said:

I read the local news. So do you. If it's in the news, I'll read it, and so will you, as will many others, even people in Australia.

So, we'll wait and see.

you might , it the last day of interest from me.

Pompeygeezer Advanced Member

Pompeygeezer

Member
On 7/4/2026 at 8:27 AM, Bday Prang said:

Why shouldn't they take the money, The daughter s dead and nothing is going to change that, You have no Idea how much the family needs the cash, Its nothing to do with a moral backbone or the lack of one.

Would some cash improve their lives ? yes, without doubt but of course it won't bring the daughter back

Would a harsher sentence improve their lives No not at all and the daughter would still be dead

Time to be pragmatic, Would it be more difficult to grieve with a few million bt in the bank and the debts paid off? not at all

And the Aussie would be free to do it again.

metisdead Legendary Member

A post using a foreign language in the quoted content of a post has been removed as this is an English language forum.

rickudon Gold Member

rickudon

Advanced Member

Some people think that paying money to avoid suffering the full penalty for a crime doesn't happen in the developed world. Of course it does. Maybe not for murder, but it does happen for other crimes. This can be a fine, 'damages', or a negotiated sum with the authorities. My brother was a VAT fraud investigator and in one particular case involving an ethnic minority (a rich minority) the chaps lawyers turned up and just kept offering more money for the case to be dropped - 5 million GBP was the final figure I think. My brother wasn't happy to see the case dropped, but Treasury agreed it.

Artisi Star Member

Artisi

Advanced Member

Seems there is a certain president of a major country paying to have serious criminal acts and side-tracked, so nothing new.

vangrop Silver Member

vangrop

Advanced Member
On 7/4/2026 at 6:00 PM, bdenner said:

The ABC news media have crunched all the numbers and figure he'll get 7 years based on a 1 Mil Baht compensation agreed on and plead guilty to all charges.

This is an extreme travesty of justice IMHO.

Wots the betting?

Very interesting post. That monster will be free in max 7 years and don't forget the royal amnesty. But let us face the facts, the family of the poor girl gets a huge financial compensation. So let us call this a win win situation for both or not? So pathetic.

But now the reality, this guy hasn't a penny, I suppose based on his background his family neither. Whatever crowd fund me operation organised, I doubt who ever would finance it.

jacko45k Star Member

jacko45k

Advanced Member
19 hours ago, Bday Prang said:

So in view of the above quote would anybody else like to take this opportunity to apologise for their insensitive comments ?

Bide your time....... it may even happen and we do not get to hear about it.

Don't be surprised to find cynicism here.

JerryM Gold Member

JerryM

Advanced Member
20 hours ago, Bday Prang said:

So in view of the above quote would anybody else like to take this opportunity to apologise for their insensitive comments ?

How many pages worth of apologies would you be expecting.

KhunHeineken Ruby Member

KhunHeineken

Advanced Member
16 hours ago, Bday Prang said:

you might , it the last day of interest from me.

It was a big story in The Sydney Morning Herald in Australia just yesterday.

People take an interest in the macabre. Example, people slowing down to look at a road accident as they pass by, something I am sure you have done.

TopThai1964 Explorer Member

TopThai1964

Member
On 7/4/2026 at 11:40 AM, JerryM said:

A paltry 1 million baht from whom?

parents in Australia from Murderer

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.