"Lady boy doctor" tells tourist: Come back when you're dying! Google the meaning of ER"

 

video screenshot

 

A tourist who went to the ER department of Bang Lamung Hospital this morning was allegedly refused treatment and told to "come back when you're dying".

 

Furious girlfriend Pornthida Thundee, 25, from Surin, turned to reporters at PattayaupdateNews after she said that she took 28 year old Iranian tourist Mohammad Hassan Forghani to the emergency room.

 

He was suffering with an ear problem.

 

Pornthida said that they registered and waited for over an hour to see the doctor who then allegedly said:

 

"Is he dying?......this is ER unless he is dying don't bother coming".

 

Then sarcastically the doctor is alleged to have said that they should Google ER to find out what an emergency room is for.

 

Pornthida then claimed he was refused treatment though the hospital said he could come back later according to the news report. 

 

"Are these the ethics of a Thai doctor?," asked an agitated Pornthida who took her boyfriend to another hospital where he was seen.

 

The Iranian confirmed himself on video that he was asked to come back "after you die".

 

Though not mentioned in the news report Pornthida said in the video that the doctor at the center of the controversy was male and was a "katoey" or lady boy.

 

PattayupdateNews said that the doctor concerned had gone home and there was no one else available for comment to give the hospital's side of events.

 

-- © Copyright Thai Visa News 2018-04-23

 

4 minutes ago, webfact said:

he was asked to come back "after you die".

that is precious

sounds fair to me

the doc probably seen enough carnage from road accidents  

who goes to ER with an ear ache?

pussy

its not an emergency

Could have gone to a private clinic there' are dozens of them there

and no ladyboys doctors....stingy Iranian....

The DR was right.. ear problem make an appointment go to a clinic.. not an ER. That is not what an ER is for.

Well, I would have to agree that ER is not for ear infections, that's what outpatients is for; and whether the doctor was a ladyboy or not is irrelevant, IMHO. Still, could have been a little more tactful; maybe he/she'd just come off some real emergency, when seeing some guy with a relatively petty problem could cause you to snap, I suppose.

ear ear now don,t come back unless it,s serious......can you hear me

6 minutes ago, nausea said:

and whether the doctor was a ladyboy or not is irrelevant

Yes, but it's always a good laugh how reporters here add "color" to their reports, so keep it up I say.  

43 minutes ago, tingtongtourist said:

sounds fair to me

the doc probably seen enough carnage from road accidents  

who goes to ER with an ear ache?

pussy

I sort of agree but perhaps the doctor could have handled better 

 

 

She/he was unprofessional but perhaps this was Her/His wish?

10 minutes ago, BobBKK said:

She/he was unprofessional but perhaps this was Her/His wish?

Maybe it was just "that time of the month"

What is ER for than to treat ear? People and stupid doctor need to learn English. 

The headline is highly unfair and misleading.... 

 

The Dr. working the ER was right, an ear infection is not an Emergency Case - but the handling of the situation was clumsy in the extreme. 

 

IF at night time and there was no ENT outpatient treatment available then the patient at least needs pain relief.

 

IF in the daytime and ENT Doctors are on duty the patient can simply be re-routed to that department. It's not always clear where to go in the hospitals, especially for visitors. 

Really? ER  personnel from around the world would probably applaud or smile or  say "right on". The hospital is a public hospital and its clientele are typically the poor and disadvantaged.  There was probably one overworked physician on staff and in walks the non emergency farang cheap charlie. If he wanted urgent care he should have gone to a proper hospital where there were multiple physicians available.

 

1 hour ago, smedly said:

I sort of agree but perhaps the doctor could have handled better 

Ahh, but here's the issue; the doctor should not have been presented with this case. In properly managed ERs there is a triage process, where the  patients are screened, usually by a nurse. True emergency cases get priority. Other cases, wait. This is a short staffed underfunded facility. It doesn't have the resources to dispense free medical care to foreigners.

 

47 minutes ago, theguyfromanotherforum said:

What is ER for than to treat ear? People and stupid doctor need to learn English. 

An ER is not intended to treat non critical care cases.

 

Edited April 23, 20188 yr by Rimmer
Quote of rermoved post removed

I think the doctor was right.anyway who dies from ear ache.try wax remover I doubt they've got any in er.

22 minutes ago, richard_smith237 said:

The headline is highly unfair and misleading.... 

 

The Dr. working the ER was right, an ear infection is not an Emergency Case - but the handling of the situation was clumsy in the extreme. 

 

IF at night time and there was no ENT outpatient treatment available then the patient at least needs pain relief.

 

IF in the daytime and ENT Doctors are on duty the patient can simply be re-routed to that department. It's not always clear where to go in the hospitals, especially for visitors. 

i once did take my Australian friend to City Hospital.....we had a note in Thai... I wanted to know what it said....I wanted to "jump" the very long queue which I did and asked the Doc what the note said. HIS reply was " I AM NOT A SLAVE TO YOU"

I was livid, so all of you would have been too.

6 minutes ago, essox essox said:

i once did take my Australian friend to City Hospital.....we had a note in Thai... I wanted to know what it said....I wanted to "jump" the very long queue which I did and asked the Doc what the note said. HIS reply was " I AM NOT A SLAVE TO YOU"

I was livid, so all of you would have been too.

How did you get the note ?

Just now, robblok said:

How did you get the note ?

From another Doc at Chonburi hospital....he had wrote in Thai and told me to take to City Hospital 

Just now, essox essox said:

From another Doc at Chonburi hospital....he had wrote in Thai and told me to take to City Hospital 

Yea then I can understand you were angry.. but what made the doctor write something like that.. were you rude or what. I mean.. must be some reason for it. 

1 minute ago, robblok said:

Yea then I can understand you were angry.. but what made the doctor write something like that.. were you rude or what. I mean.. must be some reason for it. 

read what I wrote....there were many people waiting to see that Doc...my question regarding the note from chonburi would have only taken a few minutes to tell me what it said..

An inflammatory generalization slur has been removed

1 minute ago, essox essox said:

read what I wrote....there were many people waiting to see that Doc...my question regarding the note from chonburi would have only taken a few minutes to tell me what it said..

What you wrote is open to multiple interpretations. I thought he said that this was what the note read. But you can also read it as his reply to your request is I am not a slave to you.

 

I think given that you jumped a cue he was irritated. 

32 minutes ago, geriatrickid said:

and in walks the non emergency farang cheap charlie.

 

Did you read the article at all? The guy was an Iranian, NOT a farang!

1 hour ago, theguyfromanotherforum said:

What is ER for than to treat ear? People and stupid doctor need to learn English. 

 

59 minutes ago, geriatrickid said:

An ER is not intended to treat non critical care cases.

 

I'm pretty sure that was a joke playing on "ER" and "ear" sounding similar.

 

Sophon

I don't understand this , it's a hospital , he has an ear infection , why was he sent to the ER and not one of the available doctors in the hospital ? 

I think what normally goes on in ERs is triage. Obviously if you're bleeding out, you get seen ASAP. If you've got a headache, you might have to wait all day or depending on their system told to seek treatment some other place. It's never a perfect system and mistakes are made. It seems to me this "news" story is more about the sensationalism of the characters involved (Iranian clashes with "ladyboy" doctor) than anything substantive or remarkable about the incident.

3 hours ago, tingtongtourist said:

sounds fair to me

the doc probably seen enough carnage from road accidents  

who goes to ER with an ear ache?

pussy

And, Doctor, what if it were a blood clot working its way to the patient's brain?

3 hours ago, tingtongtourist said:

sounds fair to me

the doc probably seen enough carnage from road accidents  

who goes to ER with an ear ache?

pussy

 

Nobody here knows what / where the initial contact took place within the hospital, perhaps they walked in, never been to this specific hospital and the first person they spoke to (possibly looking for guidance) was someone belonging to the ER dept.

 

Perhaps the first person they spoke to at the hospital should have directed them to a general OP area, then contact with the 'come back when you die doctor' would not have even happened. 

 

In any event the doctors comments are way less than acceptable from a medical professional and the hospital should have regulations that no staff can talk to customers in this way, totally not allowed.

 

Was the 'doctor' really a doctor?

 

 

 

 

 

 

30 minutes ago, balo said:

I don't understand this , it's a hospital , he has an ear infection , why was he sent to the ER and not one of the available doctors in the hospital ? 

That's a fair comment because the registration reception points you in the right direction and if out of hours often recommends you to return to see a day doctor if its not a real emergency.

 

Doc was on a short fuse, Surin girlfriend threw an Issan fit and it all landed on the news desk drama lama.