Anti-whaling advocate Paul Watson, founder of the Sea Shepherd and Captain Paul Watson Foundation (CPWF), has been released from detention in Greenland after Denmark rejected a Japanese extradition request. Watson, 74, had been held since July when his ship docked in Nuuk, Greenland’s capital, on the basis of a Japanese warrant issued in 2012. The charges stemmed from a 2010 confrontation with a whaling ship.  

 

Greenlandic police confirmed Watson's release in a statement, noting that the Danish Ministry of Justice ultimately chose not to proceed with the extradition. “He is free. We've just been informed by the Ministry of Justice, he's not going to be extradited,” said Watson's lawyer Julie Stage in a statement to AFP. Watson was officially released at 8:46 AM local time (1046 GMT) on Tuesday.  

 

The extradition request by Japan accused Watson of injuring a crew member and causing damage to the *Shonan Maru 2*, a whaling vessel, during a Sea Shepherd operation. The incident involved the use of a “stink bomb” intended to disrupt the whaling activities. Watson and his legal team, however, have maintained that the charges are unfounded. His lawyers cite video evidence showing that no crew member was on deck when the stink bomb was thrown.  

 

In its reasoning for rejecting the extradition, Denmark highlighted the significant time elapsed since the alleged incident—over 14 years—and the extended detention Watson had already endured. “The decision is based on an overall assessment of the circumstances of the specific case,” the Ministry of Justice stated.  

 

Japan has been under scrutiny for its whaling operations, which it has often justified as scientific research despite international criticism. Watson’s lawyer, François Zimeray, accused Japan of attempting to suppress Watson’s activism, saying, “Japan tried to silence a man whose only crime was to denounce the illegality of the industrial massacre disguised as scientific research.”  

 

Zimeray added that Watson would now return to his environmental advocacy. “He will now be able to resume his fight for respect for nature,” he said. Zimeray further criticized Japan’s judicial system, stating, “In Japan, there is a presumption of guilt. Prosecutors are proud to announce that they have a 99.6 percent conviction rate.”  

 

Watson has been a prominent and controversial figure in the anti-whaling movement for decades. His tactics, often radical and confrontational, were chronicled in the reality TV series *Whale Wars*, which brought international attention to his campaigns. In July, Watson’s arrest came as his ship prepared to “intercept” a new Japanese whaling factory vessel in the North Pacific, an action planned under his CPWF organization.  

 

The decision to release Watson has been celebrated by environmental activists and supporters who view his actions as part of a broader mission to protect marine life and combat illegal whaling. For now, Watson is free to continue his crusade, one that has made him both a hero to conservationists and a target for governments like Japan.  

 

Based on a report by AFP 2024-12-18

 

 

 

1 hour ago, Social Media said:

The extradition request by Japan accused Watson of injuring a crew member and causing damage to the *Shonan Maru 2*, a whaling vessel, during a Sea Shepherd operation.

The killing of whales is a truly vile practice, and should be combated in the same way the slave trade was targeted at sea by the British Navy.

3 hours ago, thaibeachlovers said:

The killing of whales is a truly vile practice, and should be combated in the same way the slave trade was targeted at sea by the British Navy.

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

9 minutes ago, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

 

Exactly. 

 

"Oh but they're so big so I have to save them". What a joke. I bet it's the same type of nutters from Just Stop Oil. 

 

Reminds me of the song when Wales played England in the rugby on the TV, singing along with my Dad to annoy my Gran (his mother in law) who was from the valleys. 

 

Whales, whales, bl****y great fishes are whales,

They swim in the sea,

We eat them for tea,

Oh bl****y great fishes are whales. 

 

Great times 😆.

All a bit rich from the Japanese authorities.

Can't remember reading about the Japanese authorities,  compensating 

 Pete Bethune for the vessel that a Japanese whaling boat ran over and sunk.

whilst having a confrontation with sea Shepard.

 

 

 

 

2 hours ago, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

Whales are intelligent and self aware which is more than I can say for some posters.... I suppose it boils down to what is the cut off line for killing and eating a different species than your own. Far too many people... use them for a protein source

 

3 hours ago, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

 

Just because you can eat them doesn't mean that you should. 

11 minutes ago, Emdog said:

Whales are intelligent and self aware which is more than I can say for some posters.... I suppose it boils down to what is the cut off line for killing and eating a different species than your own. Far too many people... use them for a protein source

 

 

I am starting to think that maybe we don't need to wait for humans to die out - just hand over control to the octopuses now. They surely can't do a worse job. 

 

Scientist predicts octopuses would takeover the world if humans died out

3 hours ago, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

Nice example.

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_bluefin_tuna

54 minutes ago, RuamRudy said:

 

Just because you can eat them doesn't mean that you should. 

Different strokes for different folks. 

 

Every culture has taboos about food. Some places, dogs and rats are delicacies. Others, whale meat is a traditional source of nutrition. No difference. As long as the harvest doesn't endanger the particular species, what is the problem? 

46 minutes ago, stevenl said:

Nice example.

 

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantic_bluefin_tuna

OK. Sardines better?  The point being that it is just food to many people, we don't need to preach or moralize about it for that reason.  

1 hour ago, Emdog said:

Whales are intelligent and self aware which is more than I can say for some posters.... I suppose it boils down to what is the cut off line for killing and eating a different species than your own. Far too many people... use them for a protein source

 

Yeah? If they are so smart and self-aware, how do they let themselves be caught and eaten by humans? 

54 minutes ago, Hanaguma said:

Yeah? If they are so smart and self-aware, how do they let themselves be caught and eaten by humans? 

Seriously? That’s the kind of ‘logic’ and ‘reasoning’ used by 12-year-olds.

Let me ask you this. You probably think you’re a pretty intelligent guy. Now imagine this. You’re out on foot on a vast open and flat plain, with nowhere to hide. Then someone in a car appears and starts shooting at you with an elephant rifle, with a view to kill you for fun. How long do you think you will last with all your savvy and intelligence?

And by the way, people are also protein. There’s a reason that hunting down and eating people is frowned upon, isn’t there?

11 minutes ago, rudi49jr said:

Seriously? That’s the kind of ‘logic’ and ‘reasoning’ used by 12-year-olds.

Let me ask you this. You probably think you’re a pretty intelligent guy. Now imagine this. You’re out on foot on a vast open and flat plain, with nowhere to hide. Then someone in a car appears and starts shooting at you with an elephant rifle, with a view to kill you for fun. How long do you think you will last with all your savvy and intelligence?

And by the way, people are also protein. There’s a reason that hunting down and eating people is frowned upon, isn’t there?

Uh yeah, because they are people and not animals. That is a fairly logical place to draw a line. 

 

Your analogy sucks.  You are thinking 2 dimensionally. Whales have 3 dimensions to use. Just dive deep and be safe. And whales aren't killed for fun. They are killed for food. Big difference. 

 

All the brouhaha around whales is just emotion and misplaced sensitivity. 

So many people in authority forget the power of video. Showing no one was on the deck when the stink bomb was visual proof. 

 

On 12/18/2024 at 4:50 PM, RuamRudy said:

 

Just because you can eat them doesn't mean that you should. 

Quite right too.

Japan doesn't even need to eat them. They get plenty of protein from the same farm animals as most of us.

On 12/18/2024 at 1:48 PM, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

People can also be a protein source and are in no danger of being an endangered species. I bet you don't think it would be OK to eat people though.

Anyway, given that humans have almost destroyed the oceans already, there may not be any whales, or fish, left in the future.

 

BTW, do you eat cats and dogs and horses? All yummy protein sources I'm sure.

6 minutes ago, thaibeachlovers said:

Quite right too.

Japan doesn't even need to eat them. They get plenty of protein from the same farm animals as most of us.

 

What's different about killing a whale and killing a cow? Or a pig?

On 12/18/2024 at 1:48 PM, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

I refuse to eat tuna, as well as whale protein.

Just now, JonnyF said:

 

What's different about killing a whale and killing a cow? Or a pig?

A cow or a pig normally gets humanely killed, or as humanely as possible. Whales suffer a lot before they die. How would you like it if someone stuck a dirty great harpoon in you?

2 minutes ago, thaibeachlovers said:

A cow or a pig normally gets humanely killed, or as humanely as possible. Whales suffer a lot before they die. How would you like it if someone stuck a dirty great harpoon in you?

 

It's not very humane in Thailand. Often transported long distances on the back of a truck, crammed in unable to move in searing heat.

 

And that's before they get to the slaughterhouse, often to be clubbed to death.

 

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jun/11/death-by-clubbing-brutality-thailand-pig-slaughterhouses

 

Don't see anyone crying about that as they tuck into their pork ribs or Khao Phat Moo. 

 

2 hours ago, thaibeachlovers said:

People can also be a protein source and are in no danger of being an endangered species. I bet you don't think it would be OK to eat people though.

Anyway, given that humans have almost destroyed the oceans already, there may not be any whales, or fish, left in the future.

 

BTW, do you eat cats and dogs and horses? All yummy protein sources I'm sure.

I have tried two of the three. Didn't care for the taste all that much, but did it for the experience.

2 hours ago, thaibeachlovers said:

A cow or a pig normally gets humanely killed, or as humanely as possible. Whales suffer a lot before they die. How would you like it if someone stuck a dirty great harpoon in you?

Don't stress about it. They use exploding harpoons, much more efficient than the old style ones.  Are you shifting your argument to the acual harvesting procedures and away from a purely anthropomorphic one?

On 12/18/2024 at 8:04 AM, JonnyF said:

On 12/18/2024 at 7:48 AM, Hanaguma said:

Bull cookies. Whales are a protein source, nothing more.  As long as endangered species aren't taken, no different than fishing for tuna. Anthropomorphizing them is foolish. 

 

Exactly. 

 

Aren't whales far more intelligent and aware than tuna?  And don't they hunt them with harpoons with the whale suffering for some time before dying?

 

It is nowhere near the same as fishing for tuna.

2 minutes ago, BangkokReady said:

 

Aren't whales far more intelligent and aware than tuna?  And don't they hunt them with harpoons with the whale suffering for some time before dying?

 

It is nowhere near the same as fishing for tuna.

I dunno. I think hooking a fish through the cheek and dragging it around, or catching it in a net and letting it asphyxiate sounds pretty gruesome to be honest. A quick exploding harpoon to the head might be a lot better!

3 hours ago, thaibeachlovers said:

Quite right too.

Japan doesn't even need to eat them. They get plenty of protein from the same farm animals as most of us.

 

None of us needs to eat any animals.  We can get plenty of protein from plants.  

On 12/18/2024 at 4:31 AM, thaibeachlovers said:

The killing of whales is a truly vile practice, and should be combated in the same way the slave trade was targeted at sea by the British Navy.

For only the second time ever...we actually agree on something❗👍

On 12/18/2024 at 11:49 AM, Hanaguma said:

Yeah? If they are so smart and self-aware, how do they let themselves be caught and eaten by humans? 

WT-FFF⁉️

8 hours ago, JonnyF said:

 

What's different about killing a whale and killing a cow? Or a pig?

Nothing. Or a dog or cat or chicken. It's why I've been a vegan for 35 of my 64 years. 

The Sea Shepard show was awesome and Paul Watson a hero. Good on Denmark❗