rubberduck Posted July 30, 2013 Share Posted July 30, 2013 Are you one of the TV members who lived in Thailand for several years and went back home or elsewere, and for what reason ? How long have you lived in Thailand, which changes have you noticed during this period ? Has your personal vision changed after you left ? What is your overall vision on the current situation in Thailand from the outside like ? How would you describe the developments you notice in the line of time ? It's interesting. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post benalibina Posted July 30, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted July 30, 2013 Lived for 7 years there. Left 2011. Come to thailand since dec 1994. Reason for leaving; soc and for kids future education in home country. Changes over the years have been the same as in western countries. Modernization, more traffic, more expensive, more greedy, no improvement in services. IMO its all gone to fast in LOS the last 15 years for the average thai. Thais and Thailand are closed, the present openness in the world through internet and social media is something thais have problems to deal with. My personal vision has changed but by joining TV changed again. More balanced i like to think. In the personal problematic situation i am in, most would become a thaibasher. Would like to be 1 as well, but that is too easy. So am not. It all depends on the circles 1 chose to join, knowing or unknowingly. I made a bad choice. So cant generalize. It was me who made the mistake, with huge consequences though. IMO nothing to much will change in LOS. It will be for many generations before 1 will see an improvement regarding the negative aspects of thai society; saving face, lack of empathy, selfishness, educationlevels etc. 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
maccaroni man Posted July 30, 2013 Share Posted July 30, 2013 lived and prospered in thailand for 12 yrs, left one year ago for childrens education and welfare. still have most of my financial ties in los yet i do not know when i will return, TBH as much as i enjoyed my life there i dont miss the madness. the west is easy, I dont have to think about anything, it just clicks along and i like it. my biggest issue is i am getting big, i dont seem to have the free time i had in thailand because i dont have my maid to cook, clean and mind the children. i almost never go to bars and never drink and drive. i spend 1,000 percent more time playing with my children or watching them participate in all types of organzied sports. repairmen and answers are a simple phone call away my wife is thai and can own whatever she like here. Both countries have plus and minus and I am looking forward to some plece different such as a beach in south america. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wamberal Posted July 30, 2013 Share Posted July 30, 2013 "Whom"? 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Lancelot Posted July 31, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted July 31, 2013 Early retired to Thailand in 2003. Returned to the USA September 2011 to help care for an elderly parent. Moved back to Thailand August 2012. Changes I noticed in Thailand: 1 The Thais are wealthier -or perhaps more credit fueled prosperity- noticing many new cars & motorcycles, smart phones and dressing well. 2 The Thais are more "well nourished" and many kids are past being chubby. 3 Fewer smiles and more agressive overall. Not the majority however a significant minority of Thais are itching to remind us that we are not really wanted here. I was happy in the US and really enjoyed the peace and quiet, good manners and not having people try to cut in front of me at stores, etc. In the US for nearly one year and never stopped by the police; back to Thailand for 11 months and stopped at least a dozen times for licenese/tax documents. A lot of inflation in both countries but the US sales distribution is more efficient and there are values to be had. Bought a good pair of jeans at Wall Mart for the equivelent of 300 baht. Paid 500 baht for some Levi's copies at Jatujak market and they fell apart way too soon. I still enjoy life in Thailand, ridingh my bike all year long and the opportunity to meet people from around thw world but I have no qualms about eventually returning home to live. I'll probably always yearn to travel and be out of the USA for two or three months a year, but my home base will no longer be Thailand. Just one guys thoughts and I'm not saying that Thailand is not a good place to live. But its a big world out there and I've barely touched Africa and South America 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post yooyoo Posted July 31, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted July 31, 2013 Lived for 7 years there. Left 2011. Come to thailand since dec 1994. Reason for leaving; soc and for kids future education in home country. Changes over the years have been the same as in western countries. Modernization, more traffic, more expensive, more greedy, no improvement in services. IMO its all gone to fast in LOS the last 15 years for the average thai. Thais and Thailand are closed, the present openness in the world through internet and social media is something thais have problems to deal with. My personal vision has changed but by joining TV changed again. More balanced i like to think. In the personal problematic situation i am in, most would become a thaibasher. Would like to be 1 as well, but that is too easy. So am not. It all depends on the circles 1 chose to join, knowing or unknowingly. I made a bad choice. So cant generalize. It was me who made the mistake, with huge consequences though. IMO nothing to much will change in LOS. It will be for many generations before 1 will see an improvement regarding the negative aspects of thai society; saving face, lack of empathy, selfishness, educationlevels etc. I have been visiting Thailand regularly for the past 10 years.. Own a house with my partner in Bangkok .. I agree in general with the view above. A Thai graduating with a bachelor's degree from a local university is not able to speak English... The Thai PM and senior members in government are not able to converse or conduct an interview in English... Thais are extremely insular and isolated in their thinking. Most of them are driven by money and will do virtually anything to extort it from unsuspecting tourists and foreigners. Once you have broken through the veneer of the smile they are actually unscrupulous and a devious culture. Saving face in my opinion is often a simple reflection of the lack of emotional intelligence most Thais suffer from. As a regular driver in Bangkok and frequently long distance to Phuket and Krabi etc.. I find their behavior on the road appalling.. white lines separating lanes have no meaning, emergency lanes are used by normal traffic.. weaving through the traffic on the highway at high speed creating risk for the lives of all the motorists that are passed is normal practice. Slow moving heavy trucks and busses occupy the right hand lane and refuse to let traffic through. It is not out of the ordinary to witness a number of incidents that will result in the suspension of a driver's license in Europe, UK, Canada or US...The risk of driving in Thailand is supported by the recent bus accidents in which dozens of tourists were killed. Thais are selfish and poorly disciplined and in generally lack ethics. Thailand is spoiled by the influx of millions of tourists whom quite often receive shoddy service and end up paying for poor quality. Given the increase in attacks on tourists in Patong and elsewhere in Phuket, I can only urge visitors to not drop their guard and be aware of the underlying risks. It won't happen overnight but the tourists will eventually learn to appreciate the risks exposed to and once that happens numbers will decline. 14 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
banned1000 Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 I have been visiting Thailand regularly for the past 10 years.. .. <blah blah blah> It won't happen overnight but the tourists will eventually learn to appreciate the risks exposed to and once that happens numbers will decline. except for you of course, you will still come. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StreetCowboy Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 My vision has improved a great deal with this new pair of specs. But I think that the inadequacy of the previous pair, that I bought in Thailand, was due to a deterioration in my eyes, rather than any incompetence on the part of the optician. I went to a local optician in KL, and his eye test was very thorough professional, while the eye test in Bangkok a few years back was competent, but no more. SC 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
amykat Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 Yooyoo, Very good first post! Thank you! 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Felt 35 Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 My vision has improved a great deal with this new pair of specs. But I think that the inadequacy of the previous pair, that I bought in Thailand, was due to a deterioration in my eyes, rather than any incompetence on the part of the optician. I went to a local optician in KL, and his eye test was very thorough professional, while the eye test in Bangkok a few years back was competent, but no more. SC Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post simon43 Posted July 31, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted July 31, 2013 Back on topic.... I came to Thailand (north Phuket) in 2002 and established several small businesses there. Last year, I spent 12 months working in Myanmar and now I'm on a 12-month (minimum) stint in Laos. In both cases, there was no suitable work for me in Phuket ==> the salary was lower than what I earn in Myanmar or Laos. I enjoy a quiet life, and both Myanmar and Laos suit me fine. But both lack decent hospital care, which is something that needs to be considered as you grow older. I can see my self returning to live in Phuket for the long term because my airport hotel businesses can provide me with a decent income well after retirement age - there's little chance of Phuket airport being closed Thailand has changed, and the corruption and incompetence of almost everyone who's in a position of authority is beyond belief. When I'm in Phuket, I avoid the tourist areas and restrict myself to the local area where many Thais know me. Simon 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
benalibina Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 (edited) Lived for 7 years there. Left 2011. Come to thailand since dec 1994. Reason for leaving; soc and for kids future education in home country. Changes over the years have been the same as in western countries. Modernization, more traffic, more expensive, more greedy, no improvement in services. IMO its all gone to fast in LOS the last 15 years for the average thai. Thais and Thailand are closed, the present openness in the world through internet and social media is something thais have problems to deal with. My personal vision has changed but by joining TV changed again. More balanced i like to think. In the personal problematic situation i am in, most would become a thaibasher. Would like to be 1 as well, but that is too easy. So am not. It all depends on the circles 1 chose to join, knowing or unknowingly. I made a bad choice. So cant generalize. It was me who made the mistake, with huge consequences though. IMO nothing to much will change in LOS. It will be for many generations before 1 will see an improvement regarding the negative aspects of thai society; saving face, lack of empathy, selfishness, educationlevels etc. I have been visiting Thailand regularly for the past 10 years.. Own a house with my partner in Bangkok .. I agree in general with the view above. A Thai graduating with a bachelor's degree from a local university is not able to speak English... The Thai PM and senior members in government are not able to converse or conduct an interview in English... Thais are extremely insular and isolated in their thinking. Most of them are driven by money and will do virtually anything to extort it from unsuspecting tourists and foreigners. Once you have broken through the veneer of the smile they are actually unscrupulous and a devious culture. Saving face in my opinion is often a simple reflection of the lack of emotional intelligence most Thais suffer from. As a regular driver in Bangkok and frequently long distance to Phuket and Krabi etc.. I find their behavior on the road appalling.. white lines separating lanes have no meaning, emergency lanes are used by normal traffic.. weaving through the traffic on the highway at high speed creating risk for the lives of all the motorists that are passed is normal practice. Slow moving heavy trucks and busses occupy the right hand lane and refuse to let traffic through. It is not out of the ordinary to witness a number of incidents that will result in the suspension of a driver's license in Europe, UK, Canada or US...The risk of driving in Thailand is supported by the recent bus accidents in which dozens of tourists were killed. Thais are selfish and poorly disciplined and in generally lack ethics. Thailand is spoiled by the influx of millions of tourists whom quite often receive shoddy service and end up paying for poor quality. Given the increase in attacks on tourists in Patong and elsewhere in Phuket, I can only urge visitors to not drop their guard and be aware of the underlying risks. It won't happen overnight but the tourists will eventually learn to appreciate the risks exposed to and once that happens numbers will decline. What you write in reference to the touristtrade is not specific to Thailand/Phuket alone but is a worldwide phenomenen. In 2nd and 3rd world countries more apparant though than in the western countries. West is a guiltbased culture while LOS is a shamebased 1. The saving facepart not only comes from lack of emotional intelligence but as well of a lack of selfreflection. For the latter 1 needs to be able, fck difficult for anybody, to think and accept 1's fallibleness. The insular way this society has formed itself makes it a longlasting struggle. Can only be achieved by righteouss and charismatic leaders. Top down. Our societies are more bottom up so ......... Who are we though to enforce change on the Thais ? Edited July 31, 2013 by benalibina 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Chittychangchang Posted July 31, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted July 31, 2013 People who don't have kids are informed enough to comment Back on topic- left Thailand in 2003 to raise family in U.K, best decision ever! Children's education and security comes first, these basic qualities are lacking in Thailand. To be honest the "majority" of adults who don't won't children have done their potential offspring a favour. CCC Yes, so you agree those that don't want children are not selfish. But as they are 'potential offspring' that will never eventuate then it can be hardly considered doing them a favour. What is selfish is those that have children that cannot provide without govt support. Those that don't want children are the same as those that do want children, both are living the lifestyle they have chosen, for better or worse. I wouldn't use the word selfish, more self-centred. Selfish is having children for the sake of having children to tick another box on life's to do list, then throwing money at them or not as the case may be. Anyone who has not had children and is happy and content with their choice, that is their choice and i hope they don't live to regret the decision because having your own family is imho is the meaning of life and they are missing out. CCC 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MAJIC Posted July 31, 2013 Share Posted July 31, 2013 Luckily I will never have kids and a reason to leave... Luck is defined differently for a lot of people. I, however, would never consider being sexually impotent as something "lucky". I have trouble understanding why never having or perhaps wanting children = sexually impotent. True, selfish also comes to mind.Sorry for off topic, carry on.. Sent from my LG-E612 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app Better an admission to be not cut out for child rearing,even if it's a selfish motive,than struggling to bring up unwanted children! who would want Parents who didn't want them? 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Thai at Heart Posted August 1, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted August 1, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MrWorldwide Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. TaH, can I ask for some clarification, pls - were the long-standing 'friends' who let you down Thai or Farang, and are we talking Bangkok or elsewhere in Thailand ? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteeleJoe Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 Early retired to Thailand in 2003. Returned to the USA September 2011 to help care for an elderly parent. Moved back to Thailand August 2012. Changes I noticed in Thailand: 1 The Thais are wealthier -or perhaps more credit fueled prosperity- noticing many new cars & motorcycles, smart phones and dressing well. 2 The Thais are more "well nourished" and many kids are past being chubby. 3 Fewer smiles and more agressive overall. Not the majority however a significant minority of Thais are itching to remind us that we are not really wanted here. I was happy in the US and really enjoyed the peace and quiet, good manners and not having people try to cut in front of me at stores, etc. In the US for nearly one year and never stopped by the police; back to Thailand for 11 months and stopped at least a dozen times for licenese/tax documents. A lot of inflation in both countries but the US sales distribution is more efficient and there are values to be had. Bought a good pair of jeans at Wall Mart for the equivelent of 300 baht. Paid 500 baht for some Levi's copies at Jatujak market and they fell apart way too soon. I still enjoy life in Thailand, ridingh my bike all year long and the opportunity to meet people from around thw world but I have no qualms about eventually returning home to live. I'll probably always yearn to travel and be out of the USA for two or three months a year, but my home base will no longer be Thailand. Just one guys thoughts and I'm not saying that Thailand is not a good place to live. But its a big world out there and I've barely touched Africa and South America You've been stopped a dozen times or more in 11 months?! That is astonishing. I haven't reached anywhere near that total in decades... 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
farang000999 Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 Thailand - Good food, bad police, bad traffic. Great if you are single, difficult if you have children. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
farang000999 Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 (edited) Thailand - Good food, bad police, bad traffic. Great if you are single, difficult if you have children. Why is it difficult to have children here? Edited August 1, 2013 by farang000999 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thai at Heart Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. TaH, can I ask for some clarification, pls - were the long-standing 'friends' who let you down Thai or Farang, and are we talking Bangkok or elsewhere in Thailand ? Thai friend, of 16 years. Behaving in a way that friends should never act towards each other. I am sure they are completely oblivious to it, believing that the farang is not smart enough to work out that they have treated someone with contempt. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Time Traveller Posted August 1, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted August 1, 2013 (edited) I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. Thailand is the same as every other country. The elite who own the wealth and have controlled the country for centuries live in fear of the proletariat who will one day overthrow them. The only two ways to hold on to power is through an iron fist to any dissenting opinion and secondly through creating a fear in minds of the masses over an imagined enemy, who the elites then come to be the hero when they save the proletariat from this enemy. Foreigners and minority groups are an easy scapegoat. Your disillusionment is because you want to be part of the club that doesn't want you as a member. Edited August 1, 2013 by Time Traveller 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SteeleJoe Posted August 1, 2013 Share Posted August 1, 2013 Thailand - Good food, bad police, bad traffic. Great if you are single, difficult if you have children....many of us would also object to the 'good food' myth.. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean that no one does - to say the food is good (as many do) is not a "myth", it's an expression of an opinion. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Thai at Heart Posted August 1, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted August 1, 2013 (edited) I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. Thailand is the same as every other country. The elite who own the wealth and have controlled the country for centuries live in fear of the proletariat who will one day overthrow them. The only two ways to hold on to power is through an iron fist to any dissenting opinion and secondly through creating a fear in minds of the masses over an imagined enemy, who the elites then come to be the hero when they save the proletariat from this enemy. Foreigners and minority groups are an easy scapegoat. Your disillusionment is because you want to be part of the club that doesn't want you as a member. Well, there are other issues beyond this. Just read the headlines. Foreigners stabbed to death for not getting off a stage in a beach bar, for example. It is getting increasingly out of control. Education is a massive problem here, and I feel i would be doing my kids a diservice. Nationalism that is being pumped into my kids heads, which is genuinely disgusting to me. But yes, I don't doubt that there is an element of not wanting foreigners to get to integrated into society. But I really have to say, and I will probably get shot down for it, but the Thai Chinese already run this country, and the people are being absolutely lied to. They are being conned, and have essentially become little more than bodies to feed profits to oligarchy. I have bent my way over backwards, and largely enjoyed my time here, and attempted to integrate as much as possible, but at the end of the day, it isn't to be. So be it. I will leave, and there will be some tears from some other genuine Thai friends, but there is a growing resentment towards "farangs" and I really don't like it. That is their perogative, but at the end of the day, it will not do Thailand one bit of good, there will be a net loss. I feel very fortunate that I have an option to get my kids out of here, because, as talented as they may or may not be, to deny them the chance to a better quality education would be extremely selfish on my part. They deserve better than the level of education that they are being provided, and believe me, they aren't in some cheapy government school. And then corruption. It is truly on an epidemic scale at the moment, and literally everyone is at it. It doesn't matter how good a product you sell, how good a service you provide, how beneficial what you do may or may not be, there is little or no way to get ANYTHING done without paying, and I cannot play that game. All this fake love of one's country, fake pride, fake nationalism comes down at the end of it, to "what is in it for me". It is too much, and I will go and play my game in a part of the world where it is not the norm to have to give away 30% of something to someone simply because they hold a stamp. Many a great civilisation has been brought down by corruption, Thailand will inevitably tear itself to pieces one day over this issue alone. I really worry where this place is going, and I have argued that Thailand won't implode financially as in 97, but what is going on now, is truly approaching excess in terms of borrowing and construction. The rising political tensions and the muppets that are in this government are I fear going to cause this country to explode, and I don't want to be holding the financial baby if it all goes wrong. I will sell up, depart, and try to reminice about a time when I did enjoy living here more than I do today. Edited August 1, 2013 by Thai at Heart 10 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
farang000999 Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 Thailand - Good food, bad police, bad traffic. Great if you are single, difficult if you have children. ...many of us would also object to the 'good food' myth.. You can object all you want but it is just your opinion. What are your complaints about Thai food? While not important, the general consensus amongst travelers is that Thai food is extraordinary. Personally, I have to only pity someone who dislikes Thai food. It boggles my mind. What kind of food do you like? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jpeg Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 If the 'elites' feared the proletariat, they would've kept them stupid. Would have ?! 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MrWorldwide Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 farang999, no shortage of TVers who claim to dislike Thai food - I dont get it either, as it's one of the country's biggest drawcards IMO, but they are out there. I even recall one TVer referring to Thai food as 'roadkill' and saying he far preferred Farang food. Horses for courses (no pun intended ..), but a few nights in Laos or Cambo and I guarantee that most will soon realise how much better Thai food is at street level. Malaysia is in a class of it's own - so many influences converging in a single 'cuisine' - but that's a discussion for another thread. I'd probably rate Indian and Italian slightly above the Thai food I've had, but all three stomp anything from the 'meat and 3 veg' school of culinary excellence IMO. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wprime Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. Thailand is the same as every other country. The elite who own the wealth and have controlled the country for centuries live in fear of the proletariat who will one day overthrow them. The only two ways to hold on to power is through an iron fist to any dissenting opinion and secondly through creating a fear in minds of the masses over an imagined enemy, who the elites then come to be the hero when they save the proletariat from this enemy. Foreigners and minority groups are an easy scapegoat. Your disillusionment is because you want to be part of the club that doesn't want you as a member. Sorry but you have no idea what you're talking about. The proletariat is only knowledgeable enough to think about change because of the royal initiatives undertaken since the reign of King Rama V to develop the education system. If the 'elites' feared the proletariat, they would've kept them stupid. The internal conflicts Thailand has experienced over the past 80 years are struggles between certain groups (or families) using the proletariat against the existing establishment. The elites have always encouraged the slow but steady growth and development of the proletariat. Hmmmm, on your last sentence....... Because of ? Reason for ? What is in it for them ? If the elites feared the proletariat they would have kept them stupid, you write. Hmmm again, please explain ? Almost all improvements to the education system over the past 100 years started with royal initiatives. The elites follow the will of the monarchy and it is the role of the Thai monarchy to help Thailand develop (it's part of the oath the Kings of Thailand must take before acceding to the throne). The reason the monarchy of Thailand has so much support is because the Kings of Thailand have dedicated their lives to the proletariat. The opposition to the establishment in Thailand comes from a few small individuals among the elites - have a look at every major political incident since 1932 - they weren't initiated by the proletariat [unless the definition of proletariat has been broadened to include everyone from off-shore educated elites (1932 revolution) to billionaire private jet flying fugitives (red shirts)]. It is these individuals and their supporters who are using the proletariat to bring legitimacy to the conflicts they start. Stupid is a relative term, the average Thai person is a lot smarter and more worldly than the average Thai of 100 years ago. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vtjforyou Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 Thailand - Good food, bad police, bad traffic. Great if you are single, difficult if you have children. ...many of us would also object to the 'good food' myth.. You can object all you want but it is just your opinion. What are your complaints about Thai food? While not important, the general consensus amongst travelers is that Thai food is extraordinary. Personally, I have to only pity someone who dislikes Thai food. It boggles my mind. What kind of food do you like? I love Thai food but only rookies think that street food full of cheap ingredients and oil is good for health... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Popular Post Time Traveller Posted August 2, 2013 Popular Post Share Posted August 2, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. Thailand is the same as every other country. The elite who own the wealth and have controlled the country for centuries live in fear of the proletariat who will one day overthrow them. The only two ways to hold on to power is through an iron fist to any dissenting opinion and secondly through creating a fear in minds of the masses over an imagined enemy, who the elites then come to be the hero when they save the proletariat from this enemy. Foreigners and minority groups are an easy scapegoat. Your disillusionment is because you want to be part of the club that doesn't want you as a member. Sorry but you have no idea what you're talking about. The proletariat is only knowledgeable enough to think about change because of the royal initiatives undertaken since the reign of King Rama V to develop the education system. If the 'elites' feared the proletariat, they would've kept them stupid. The internal conflicts Thailand has experienced over the past 80 years are struggles between certain groups (or families) using the proletariat against the existing establishment. The elites have always encouraged the slow but steady growth and development of the proletariat. wprime, the elite to this day do continue to try to keep the proletariat uninformed. How else do you explain their action blocking youtube and other websites, censorship and banning books and simple discussion of ideas and free speech, and of course the draconian sentences for the Lese Majeste offences. Yes it's an elite ruling the country through fear. 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wprime Posted August 2, 2013 Share Posted August 2, 2013 I am planning to return home after 18 years for something similar to those issues as above. However, I am getting completely disillusioned with where the country is going. Things are not adding up financially for the country, and the violence appears to have increased massively in the last few years. The corruption and hoops I have to jump through to run a business here have also got me down in recent times and it just doesn't represent the opportunity it did in my eyes even a few years ago. However, I have been badly let down by some very long standing friends and this has probably hurt more than anything. I finally feel like just any other farang to be used and that is in the end enough. The ridiculously tough immigration and fixed paternalistic business structure has finally driven me nuts. It seems they would rather prevent foreigners getting ahead, than allow us to contribute to building the country. I used to think I clearly understood how Thailand worked. Increasingly, I feel I understand less and less. Thailand is the same as every other country. The elite who own the wealth and have controlled the country for centuries live in fear of the proletariat who will one day overthrow them. The only two ways to hold on to power is through an iron fist to any dissenting opinion and secondly through creating a fear in minds of the masses over an imagined enemy, who the elites then come to be the hero when they save the proletariat from this enemy. Foreigners and minority groups are an easy scapegoat. Your disillusionment is because you want to be part of the club that doesn't want you as a member. Sorry but you have no idea what you're talking about. The proletariat is only knowledgeable enough to think about change because of the royal initiatives undertaken since the reign of King Rama V to develop the education system. If the 'elites' feared the proletariat, they would've kept them stupid. The internal conflicts Thailand has experienced over the past 80 years are struggles between certain groups (or families) using the proletariat against the existing establishment. The elites have always encouraged the slow but steady growth and development of the proletariat. wprime, the elite to this day do continue to try to keep the proletariat uninformed. How else do you explain their action blocking youtube and other websites, censorship and banning books and simple discussion of ideas and free speech, and of course the draconian sentences for the Lese Majeste offences. Yes it's an elite ruling the country through fear. The proletariat of Thailand is far more informed than the average proletariat of Thailand 80 years ago, as I said the development of the proletariat has been slow and steady. There's no point in freeing all this information because they're not educated enough to deal with it - that's what they're working on first. What simple discussion of ideas and free speech are illegal in Thailand yet legal in the western world? Free speech doesn't exist anywhere, you're always limited by defamation laws. As for lese majeste, the King is the country - desecrating national symbols is illegal in almost every western country - yes the sentences seem draconian in Thailand but they are never served - the King has always pardoned individuals for lese majeste. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now