Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I’m looking to formally study Thai at an intermediate level at a school in Pattaya, Hua Hin or Bangkok. Probably Pattaya. I can speak and read at intermediate level and write at a basic level (I have lousy spelling). I want to improve my vocabulary, reading and writing skills. The school should be very good at assisting with an education visa and I will be applying for the visa abroad in my home country. The course should last 3 to 4 months. Price is an issue but not the most important one. 
 

thanks

Posted

I think you're going to find that the only quality schools are the ones using the Union method, and are all based in Bangkok.  They are Union, Piammitr, AAA and TLA.  I have been told that UTL, which used to be a good option, is closing down.  Personally I'd avoid Union because of the large number of god-botherers.

 

Chulalongkorn University also runs an Intensive Thai Program which may also be worth looking into.

  • Like 1
Posted

There are really only two options for quality instruction in Thai, by which I mean equivalent to the level of teaching at an American university.  I have studied at both schools.

 

Intensive Thai Program Chulalongkorn University. http://www.arts.chula.ac.th/CTFL/intensivethai

 

This program is indeed intensive since the curriculum calls for learning at least thirty new words per day.  The teachers are excellent.  Many of them either have PhDs or are working on them.  It is a team teaching approach in which they rotate the teach every few days, so that the student adjusts to the individual teachers' slightly different way of speaking.  The teachers follow such a well-laid out schedule that no disruption results from switching teachers so frequently.  They do something else which is quite remarkable.  The pace that the teacher speaks Thai to the students starts slow in level one and then notches up a little in level two and so on for each level.  The extraordinary thing is that the teachers all adjust their speaking pace in unison.  

 

Classes were a little smaller in my day.  I understand that average size now is about fifteen.  Students are highly motivated and very diverse.  The full course runs nine levels and takes about a year.  

 

Sumaa Institute for Language and Culture.  http://www.sumaa.net/

 

Sumaa was founded by three teachers who had started the Intensive Thai Program at Chulalongkorn.  However, unlike the Chula program, most instruction is one-on-one rather than classroom, the advantage of which is that you get a lot more correction which is essential.  The teachers are highly qualified, several having master's degrees as described on their website.  Sumaa has a distinguished roster of former students who have gone on to work with the Thai language including business people, academics, military, and diplomats such as the past or present ambassadors of the US, the UK, Germany, Australia, Ireland, and probably others I don't know about.  Teaching at Sumaa may be either in person or online.

 

I am currently continuing to study at Sumaa.

 

Compared to other schools in Thailand, Sumaa and Chula are expensive, but compared to the cost of equivalent education in Europe or the US, they are cheap.  

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

Walen is a good school.  They have branches around Thighland.

 

They do all your visa paper work too.

Edited by johnray
  • Sad 1
Posted
On 8/8/2020 at 8:08 AM, cmarshall said:

There are really only two options for quality instruction in Thai, by which I mean equivalent to the level of teaching at an American university.  I have studied at both schools.

 

Intensive Thai Program Chulalongkorn University. http://www.arts.chula.ac.th/CTFL/intensivethai

 

This program is indeed intensive since the curriculum calls for learning at least thirty new words per day.  The teachers are excellent.  Many of them either have PhDs or are working on them.  It is a team teaching approach in which they rotate the teach every few days, so that the student adjusts to the individual teachers' slightly different way of speaking.  The teachers follow such a well-laid out schedule that no disruption results from switching teachers so frequently.  They do something else which is quite remarkable.  The pace that the teacher speaks Thai to the students starts slow in level one and then notches up a little in level two and so on for each level.  The extraordinary thing is that the teachers all adjust their speaking pace in unison.  

 

Classes were a little smaller in my day.  I understand that average size now is about fifteen.  Students are highly motivated and very diverse.  The full course runs nine levels and takes about a year.  

 

Sumaa Institute for Language and Culture.  http://www.sumaa.net/

 

Sumaa was founded by three teachers who had started the Intensive Thai Program at Chulalongkorn.  However, unlike the Chula program, most instruction is one-on-one rather than classroom, the advantage of which is that you get a lot more correction which is essential.  The teachers are highly qualified, several having master's degrees as described on their website.  Sumaa has a distinguished roster of former students who have gone on to work with the Thai language including business people, academics, military, and diplomats such as the past or present ambassadors of the US, the UK, Germany, Australia, Ireland, and probably others I don't know about.  Teaching at Sumaa may be either in person or online.

 

I am currently continuing to study at Sumaa.

 

Compared to other schools in Thailand, Sumaa and Chula are expensive, but compared to the cost of equivalent education in Europe or the US, they are cheap.  

 

 

 

I see that Sumaa also offers online teaching. At least I got that message when I first loaded their homepage.

Posted

I believe that course is only three hours per day. You can choose between a 3-hour morning session, or a 3-hour afternoon session. Here's a copy paste from the site:

 

COURSE DURATION :
from Monday to Friday(9:00-12:00 or 13:00-16:00) for 6 weeks including the examinations
(100 hours : (5 days x 3 hours x 6 weeks)+ 10 hours for Extra Activities)

 

Looks interesting, but I have doubts that I'm capable of learning 30 new words per day as a previous poster states. I could probably do it short-term, but over the long-term to learn that many new words every day, plus remember all the words I learned before, seems more than I could handle. For every three new words I learn, my crusty old brain deletes five previously learned words automatically. But I think I'm making progress.

  • Like 2
Posted
46 minutes ago, ColeBOzbourne said:

I have doubts that I'm capable of learning 30 new words per day

Nobody can.  Research has shown that people can typically learn 7-9 new words per day.  30 words/day is very much a case of "throw 'em up against the wall and see which ones stick."

 

A well designed course will periodically recycle lexis, so what doesn't stick the first time might stick on the 2nd, 3rd ... nth time around.

  • Like 1
Posted
50 minutes ago, Oxx said:

Research has shown that people can typically learn 7-9 new words per day.

 

Actually, I should have said "adults", not "people".  Young children can pick up new words faster than adults.

Posted (edited)

Most learn Thai courses are badly designed. They are designed for Thai students as a first language and not second language.

 

They focus on writing rather than speaking and grammar. They also focus on formal words that is never used by average Thai people.

 

That's why most of us can't understand what the average Thai say beyond the beginner level after learning the language for several years.

 

i.e. if you don't have a wife or girlfriend that function as your personal teacher of informal words.

 

If you know of a school that stress on spoken language (real Thai) and grammar rules, please inform me.

 

I don't want to learn Thai that most people don't use like those Indic words.

 

Edited by warcy
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
On 8/8/2020 at 8:08 AM, cmarshall said:

There are really only two options for quality instruction in Thai, by which I mean equivalent to the level of teaching at an American university.  I have studied at both schools.

 

Intensive Thai Program Chulalongkorn University. http://www.arts.chula.ac.th/CTFL/intensivethai

 

 

 

I am currently continuing to study at Sumaa.

 

Compared to other schools in Thailand, Sumaa and Chula are expensive, but compared to the cost of equivalent education in Europe or the US, they are cheap.  

 

 

Does any of these schools stress on correct Thai grammar and speaking? You didn't really tell us what they teach. 

 

Many schools just teach vocabulary and not on how to form sentences with these words. Thai grammar is very different from English grammar.

 

Edited by warcy
Posted (edited)
On 8/9/2020 at 11:14 AM, johnray said:

Walen is a good school.  They have branches around Thighland.

 

They do all your visa paper work too.

Walen is NOT a good school. I have looked at their book. They stress on Thai writing like most schools.

 

Most of us foreigners don't write Thai very much except for the basics. We speak Thai more often when buying things and arguing with someone.

Edited by warcy
Posted
On 8/9/2020 at 12:14 PM, johnray said:

Walen is a good school.  They have branches around Thighland.

 

They do all your visa paper work too.

Is Walen still operating or is it just in name only with new owners.

 

i thought he ran off after his investment courses where shown up as a dud.

Posted
On 8/12/2020 at 3:40 AM, Oxx said:

Nobody can.  Research has shown that people can typically learn 7-9 new words per day.  30 words/day is very much a case of "throw 'em up against the wall and see which ones stick."

 

A well designed course will periodically recycle lexis, so what doesn't stick the first time might stick on the 2nd, 3rd ... nth time around.

What is clear that the higher you aim, the more you will accomplish.  For anyone who does enroll in the Chula program I recommend using the Anki flashcard system for memorizing vocabulary.  Vocabulary "sticks" more the more you practice it.

Posted
On 8/12/2020 at 2:51 AM, ColeBOzbourne said:

I believe that course is only three hours per day. You can choose between a 3-hour morning session, or a 3-hour afternoon session. Here's a copy paste from the site:

 

COURSE DURATION :
from Monday to Friday(9:00-12:00 or 13:00-16:00) for 6 weeks including the examinations
(100 hours : (5 days x 3 hours x 6 weeks)+ 10 hours for Extra Activities)

 

Looks interesting, but I have doubts that I'm capable of learning 30 new words per day as a previous poster states. I could probably do it short-term, but over the long-term to learn that many new words every day, plus remember all the words I learned before, seems more than I could handle. For every three new words I learn, my crusty old brain deletes five previously learned words automatically. But I think I'm making progress.

I was in my 60's when I took the course at Chula.  It is indeed strenuous.  I put in three or four hours a day on homework and review, but that's the nature of language study: the more effort you make the more you learn.  My ability to retain the vocabulary improved as the course went on.  I recommend using the Anki flashcard program to help memorize vocabulary.  Among other advantages Anki shows just how much progress you are actually making, but just for vocabulary, of course.

 

That said, the Westerners generally wash out of Intensive Thai.  By the end of the 9 course sequence it will be all Asians with maybe one Westerner at best.  Still, an excellent start to mastering Thai.

Posted (edited)
8 hours ago, warcy said:

I don't want to learn Thai that most people don't use like those Indic words.

Whilst these words often have informal equivalents, they are widely encountered in written material, from สุรา on signs in the supermarket to ปัสสาวะ and อุจจาระ on the window of the vet.  Your prejudice is misplaced; you will need them.  They are vital if you intend to follow the news on TV or read a newspaper.

 

8 hours ago, warcy said:

Does any of these schools stress on correct Thai grammar

I can only speak for the Union method.  It places enormous stress on sentence patterns (there are hundreds of them across the full course), allowing the learner to substitute words or phrases into the patterns to make grammatically correct sentences.

 

Edit:  To add, consider how foolish/immature/odd you'd look in English if you went to the doctor and said "wee-wee" and "poo-poo".  In many contexts it's expected for one to be able to use an appropriate level of language.  And you can be 100% certain that any educated Thai person would use the formal (Indic-derived) term in such a context.

Edited by Oxx
Posted (edited)
On 8/16/2020 at 6:12 AM, Oxx said:

Whilst these words often have informal equivalents, they are widely encountered in written material, from สุรา on signs in the supermarket to ปัสสาวะ and อุจจาระ on the window of the vet.  Your prejudice is misplaced; you will need them.  They are vital if you intend to follow the news on TV or read a newspaper.

 

I can only speak for the Union method.  It places enormous stress on sentence patterns (there are hundreds of them across the full course), allowing the learner to substitute words or phrases into the patterns to make grammatically correct sentences.

 

Edit:  To add, consider how foolish/immature/odd you'd look in English if you went to the doctor and said "wee-wee" and "poo-poo".  In many contexts it's expected for one to be able to use an appropriate level of language.  And you can be 100% certain that any educated Thai person would use the formal (Indic-derived) term in such a context.

 

LOL. How many westerners actually read Thai newpapers or watch Thai news? They read English news at that level. Please provide video proof of westerners reading Thai newspapers or watch Thai news which he can understand.

 

As for speaking, if one learns only formal words which most if not all schools are teaching, foreigners won't be able to understand ordinary Thai conversation. I took some Thai courses before and wasn't able to understand the informal word for 'dog' at first because the teacher didn't even bothered to teach them.

 

Or do you really think that westerners speak 'this canine' instead of 'this dog' in everyday speech?
 

Canine and dog are both English words but the formal word in Thai is actually an Indian word and not even a Thai word, so how can you compare the two languages? 

 

The amount of informal Thai words that is not taught is staggering which I found out after watching Thai movies with REAL conversation. It is not just one or two words, this is just a simple example.

 

So forget about learning Thai from schools, the most you can get out of it is to order food such as Fried Rice with eggs etc and saying thank you.

 

Once I used all the formal words in a conversation with Thai people and they all laugh at me. They don't use Khun in real life.

Edited by warcy

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...