Awww.. its ok... Tolerate them as entertainment in the "Off the Beaten Path" sub-forum. There is a place for contrarian voices. Questioning accepted ideas isn't stupid. Quite the opposite. Science advances because people challenge assumptions, test evidence, and occasionally prove everyone else wrong. That's precisely why dissent should never be silenced. In fact, it's important that those of us who accept established evidence are reminded that society contains everyone, from the merely eccentric to the gloriously detached from reality. Knowing they're out there is part of understanding the world as it really is. And, to be fair, they occasionally perform a valuable service. Every now and then, a fringe argument uncovers a genuine flaw in accepted thinking, exposes bad science, or highlights a question that deserves proper investigation. History has shown that consensus isn't infallible. The problem is that the truly committed cranks never know when they've been beaten by the evidence. When every fact becomes part of the conspiracy, every expert is corrupt, every contradiction is ignored, and every goalpost is wheeled off into the distance, debate ceases to exist. What's left is dogma masquerading as scepticism. We need sceptics. We even need the occasional eccentric. What we don't need are people so intellectually bankrupt that they mistake obstinacy for critical thinking and delusion for open-mindedness. That's the irony. Their original cause may have been the pursuit of truth. Somewhere along the way, it became far more important than the truth itself.
Create an account or sign in to comment