1 hour ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   They are waters under Israel's control 

By what legitimate right?

10 minutes ago, vinny41 said:

Incorrect 

It is the State of Palestine that has claimed rights to Gaza’s maritime zones under international law in 2015 and 2019.Footnote27 Gaza is not a disputed territory ‘in which it is unclear who holds rights to the maritime zones in question’.Footnote28 Gaza forms part of a territory of the State of Palestine that is illegally occupied by Israel.Footnote29 Under the law of the sea, Gaza’s maritime zones belong to the State of Palestine.Footnote30 

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/leiden-journal-of-international-law/article/gaza-marine-the-facts-and-the-law/C029A409DC49A37CA47753C48AED5252

UN top court says Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories is illegal

Delivering the court's findings, ICJ President Nawaf Salam said it had found that "Israel's... continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory is illegal."

"The State of Israel is under the obligation to bring an end to its unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory as rapidly as possible," he said.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cjerjzxlpvdo

 

   From your link :

 

"The court's advisory opinion is not legally binding"

 

   We are talking about the legality of it , your link isn't legally binding , its just advisory

24 minutes ago, SpaceKadet said:

Why don't you just let the girl be. At least she's doing what she believes in, unlike the you lot that just hang in bars downing your Changs.

Yes jew hating what a noble cause

6 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   From your link :

 

"The court's advisory opinion is not legally binding"

 

   We are talking about the legality of it , your link isn't legally binding , its just advisory

Under international law, Gaza's maritime zones belong to the State of Palestine, which has the legal right to claim and delimit them. This is based on Palestine's 2015 accession to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). 

There hasn't been a single court case that states Israel has a legal right to  Gaza's maritime zones

2 minutes ago, vinny41 said:

Under international law, Gaza's maritime zones belong to the State of Palestine, which has the legal right to claim and delimit them. This is based on Palestine's 2015 accession to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). 

There hasn't been a single court case that states Israel has a legal right to  Gaza's maritime zones

 

   Israel are now the occupying power in Gaza .

Israel are now responsible for keeping Gaza borders secure 

6 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   Israel are now the occupying power in Gaza .

Israel are now responsible for keeping Gaza borders secure 

Israel claims it is no longer occupying the Gaza Strip. What does international law say?

On October 15, US President Joe Biden cautioned Israel not to “reoccupy” Gaza. This choice of words touched on a core debate: is Israel occupying the Gaza Strip—such that it owes protections to the population there—or is it not?

Israel believes it “disengaged” from Gaza in 2005 when it completely withdrew its military and civilians from the area. With this withdrawal, Israel and the United States—as well as many international legal, military, and foreign policy experts—argue that Israel ceded the effective control needed under the legal definition of occupation, therefore ending the occupation

The status of Israel’s occupation is legally significant, as it determines the legal obligations Israel owes to Gaza. Occupying states have heightened responsibilities to protect local populations and have the basic health and safety supplies they need to survive. Given concerns about Israel’s actions in Gaza—such as possible war crimes, including starvation and the denial of humanitarian aid—Israel would likely be in breach of these obligations.

https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/menasource/gaza-israel-occupied-international-law/

2 minutes ago, vinny41 said:

I

 

   You keep sending me walls of text to read .

I can do google searches myself 

7 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   You keep sending me walls of text to read .

I can do google searches myself 

 

22 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   Israel are now the occupying power in Gaza .

Israel are now responsible for keeping Gaza borders secure 

 

7 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   You keep sending me walls of text to read .

I can do google searches myself 

In a March 27, 2025, ruling, the Israeli Supreme Court, sitting as the High Court of Justice, stated that Israel is not an occupying power in the Gaza Strip

So your statement about  Israel being the  occupying power in Gaza  is factually incorrect given the recent Israeli Supreme Court ruling

1 hour ago, Nick Carter icp said:

I believe that the blockade is legal

 

I believe you and they are wrong.

6 minutes ago, vinny41 said:

 

 

In a March 27, 2025, ruling, the Israeli Supreme Court, sitting as the High Court of Justice, stated that Israel is not an occupying power in the Gaza Strip

So your statement about  Israel being the  occupying power in Gaza  is factually incorrect given the recent Israeli Supreme Court ruling

 

   

The same Court also stated that Israel still has the obligation to control the borders of Gaza, allowing and facilitating goods into the Gaza strip .

   Making it legal for Israel to intercept the flotilla 

 

 

2 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   

The same Court also stated that Israel still has the obligation to control the borders of Gaza, allowing and facilitating goods into the Gaza strip .

   Making it legal for Israel to intercept the flotilla 

 

 

Trying to change the discussion now it was you that stated that 

  Israel are now the occupying power in Gaza

March 27, 2025, ruling, the Israeli Supreme Court, sitting as the High Court of Justice, stated that Israel is not an occupying power in the Gaza Strip

  Occupying states have heightened responsibilities to protect local populations and have the basic health and safety supplies they need to survive. Given concerns about Israel’s actions in Gaza—such as possible war crimes, including starvation and the denial of humanitarian aid—Israel would likely be in breach of these obligations.

9 hours ago, Tug said:

Kinda a fools errand to expose one’s self in that crucible of violence but I do admire her courage and heart. certainly willing to put herself were her mouth is.

 

Are you in love?

 

 

2 minutes ago, vinny41 said:

Trying to change the discussion now it was you that stated that 

  Israel are now the occupying power in Gaza

 

 

   The discussion is about whether Israel has the legal right to police the Gaza border and to intercept the flotilla.

   Whether Israel is an occupying power or not is actually changing the subject of the thread topic .

 

3 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

   The discussion is about whether Israel has the legal right to police the Gaza border and to intercept the flotilla.

   Whether Israel is an occupying power or not is actually changing the subject of the thread topic .

 

No its not I have seen you do this many times when you get yourself into a catch 22 

the Title of the thread is 

Greta Thunberg Among Activists Detained by Israeli Navy

And the legal position and responsibilities are different for  an occupying power compared to Israel not being an occupying power in the Gaza Strip

1 minute ago, vinny41 said:

No its not I have seen you do this many times when you get yourself into a catch 22 

the Title of the thread is 

Greta Thunberg Among Activists Detained by Israeli Navy

And the legal position and responsibilities are different for  an occupying power compared to Israel not being an occupying power in the Gaza Strip

 

    Israel occupies Gaza according to international  law

Israeli laws disagree with that .

Israel are responsible for policing Gazas land/sea borders

Both International law and Israeli laws agree with that .

 

11 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

    Israel occupies Gaza according to international  law

Israeli laws disagree with that .

Israel are responsible for policing Gazas land/sea borders

Both International law and Israeli laws agree with that .

 

I think forum rules state that you have to backup your statements with a valid supporting link therefore until you do your statements are incorrect

7 hours ago, JonnyF said:

Get a proper job.

 

Oh that's right, the only thing you know how to do is be a professional nuisance.

 

Six months in an Israeli jail alongside her beloved Hamas should be enough to deter a third attempt. 

 

While occupying a jail if & when ,run the  video  of the OCt 7  terror attack on a continuous loop feed. Greata needs a life

5 hours ago, Hamus Yaigh said:

In short, it isn't "pathetic" for highlighting Hamas's barbarity or Israel's right to fight back—those are valid.

What's flawed is treating the retaliation as beyond question as comments like this do, as if civilian lives on the other side don't count in the moral math. If peace talks like the recent Trump-proposed ceasefire gain traction, that could be a start, but I won't be holding my breath.

The problem is the people in Palestine have been brainwashed and dont want peace, all they want is for Israel to not exist.  

Watch this reporter speaking to normal people on the street in Palestine and how they feel about Israel. 

 

2 hours ago, angryguy said:

Yes jew hating what a noble cause

Maybe not Jew hating, but definitely Israel hating. There is a difference, you know.

5 hours ago, billd766 said:

Oh Good. My first thumbs down from the rent a moron brigade. They are so brave as anonymous keyboard warriors.

 

At least she is DOING something.

She's delusional and all she is doing it performing... If she really wanted to make a difference she would be working on speaking to politicians who decide what happens, not trying to

bring supplies to a place she knows will never get them.

 

Just like her first protests, I  hate the world so I'm going to protest and tell everyone they are wrong and I'm right and everyone should stop using fossil fuels. 

It's all just a show for her, just like her whole life.  A rich girl that didn't want to go to school because the world is dying and she had no future because of us.

 

She never stopped to think about the house she lives in, Aircon, heating, food etc all provided for her by fossil fuels.

If we didn't have fossil fuels we would all be still living in houses burning wood with horses pulling things around.   

 

as for Palestine there could be peace tomorrow, Unfortunately there will never be peace as the Palestinians dont want peace. 

3 hours ago, nick supreme said:

You hate a strong woman.

she's not a women, not even sure she is a she.  

4 hours ago, Sir Dude said:

Nice sentiment... buy why is this always anti-Jewish, not anti-China or anti-Russian, or anti-North Korean who are all far worse offenders?

Guess being anti-semitic is easy and fashionable these days as it's a safe option for these wannabe internet protesters, like it was in Germany in the 1930s, not much different.

Did China, Russia or N Korea intercept the fleet, or was it only Israel on its own that did it?

 

Is China, Russia or N Korea invading Gaza or just Israel?

 

FYI I am not antisemetic or anti Jewish. I am however anti Zionist and it is the Zionists who are the problem in Israel. It is they who are running Israel, they who are co-ordinating the genocide of the Palestinian men, women children and babies. It is the Zionist who are depriving the Palestinians food water and medicine.

 

It is the Zionists who are murdering Palestinians and stealing their land for illegal settlements.

3 hours ago, SpaceKadet said:

Go do your research first before posting BS. Her parents are independently wealthy, and if you believe she has a money sponsor, do post a link and educate us all.

yes, she's a rich kid that doesn't have to get a job and just goes around telling everyone they are bad because she's right and everyone else is wrong.

 

She's a 22yr old that missed allot of school to travel around the world to fight climate change and tell everyone they are wrong.

She knows more than everyone else and we need to listen to her?

 

You know she said the world was ending and we need to stop using fossil fuels, however I dont hear anything from her anymore about climate change, is this still an issue and she doesn't care anymore or she found something else to keep her in the spot light.
 

Maybe she gave up on climate change because she likes driving around in cars and flying.

 

3 hours ago, SpaceKadet said:

Go do your research first before posting BS. Her parents are independently wealthy, and if you believe she has a money sponsor, do post a link and educate us all.

Soros’ Open Society has always claimed to support climate activists. It has been proven US$275 million have been funnelled from USAid to the Open Society and now we learn the Obama Library on the verge of bankruptcy is getting a financial lifeline from the Soros organization.

Anyway each time news linking Soros to Thunberg appears in the next hour all the fraudulent fact-checkers call it misinformation, disinformation, untrue or photoshopped pictures.

We know all these leftists “professional” which have been working hard to support all these recent hoaxes (Covid, Green energy, Climate change, etc…) I name Reuters, AP, the Guardian, Poynter, Fact-check.org, etc…are supporting all these demonstrations.

So any links have no value either for or against.

27 minutes ago, Nid_Noi said:

We know all these leftists “professional”

By using "leftist" in your post, I know exactly where to place you. Do you say "Heil Trump!" every morning too?

32 minutes ago, ericthai said:

yes, she's a rich kid that doesn't have to get a job and just goes around telling everyone they are bad because she's right and everyone else is wrong.

 

She's a 22yr old that missed allot of school to travel around the world to fight climate change and tell everyone they are wrong.

She knows more than everyone else and we need to listen to her?

 

You know she said the world was ending and we need to stop using fossil fuels, however I dont hear anything from her anymore about climate change, is this still an issue and she doesn't care anymore or she found something else to keep her in the spot light.
 

Maybe she gave up on climate change because she likes driving around in cars and flying.

 

You know nothing how society works in Sweden. That's for sure. How do you know she missed a lot of school? Just an assumption on your part? And how do you know she's even driving a car. Many people in Sweden don't. We have something called well developed infrastructure, unlike other third world countries.  And if you think that you know more in the area of her expertise, then please do educate us all. Go out and do something to stop this slaughter by the Terrorist State of Israel.

At least she's doing something she believes in, while you just sit on your arse and fight with others with your keyboard and drink Chang.

1 hour ago, ericthai said:

The problem is the people in Palestine have been brainwashed and dont want peace, all they want is for Israel to not exist.  

Watch this reporter speaking to normal people on the street in Palestine and how they feel about Israel. 

 

Truth Bombs all over the place in those interviews! Thanks 

5 minutes ago, SpaceKadet said:

You know nothing how society works in Sweden. That's for sure. How do you know she missed a lot of school? Just an assumption on your part? And how do you know she's even driving a car. Many people in Sweden don't. We have something called well developed infrastructure, unlike other third world countries.  And if you think that you know more in the area of her expertise, then please do educate us all. Go out and do something to stop this slaughter by the Terrorist State of Israel.

At least she's doing something she believes in, while you just sit on your arse and fight with others with your keyboard and drink Chang.

you're correct I know nothing about Sweden.

 

Her area of expertise??? LOL what university did she go to be an expert on climate change? Oh wait she read a study and then told everyone the world was going to end!

Wait, that's not what's she's doing now, it's Hamas so where is her political degree?

 

Also I dont drink Chang, hate that beer and I dont think I'm fighting with anyone on here, just posting like everyone else, but you want to try and make it personal.

 

Just to let you know I'm currently at our house in the USA and when here I'm out helping low income people everyday.

I volunteer at a food pantry, I do beach clean up once a month. So I'm doing things to help my local community.

When in Thailand I teach local kids English for free at the main village building.  You said she's doing something and I'm not doing anything but you're wrong.

 

As for her missing school it's very well known she took 1 year off of school to go around the world and protest.  Maybe if you did a quick google search you would find that out.

 

Lastly for Hamas and Israel I know we wont agree whos right but I dont see either side wanting peace as they both want the other destroyed!!

 

Oh look, the wierdos are obsessing over Gret Thunberg again.

 

 

1 hour ago, SpaceKadet said:

You know nothing how society works in Sweden. That's for sure. How do you know she missed a lot of school? Just an assumption on your part? And how do you know she's even driving a car. Many people in Sweden don't. We have something called well developed infrastructure, unlike other third world countries.  And if you think that you know more in the area of her expertise, then please do educate us all. Go out and do something to stop this slaughter by the Terrorist State of Israel.

At least she's doing something she believes in, while you just sit on your arse and fight with others with your keyboard and drink Chang.

You are absolutely right, and no, I am not Swedish and why posters mentioned her Autism, people with Autism are usually smarter