1 hour ago, koolkarl said:

Greta is never in school or kicked out, no wonder she joined this flotilla. 

How old do you think that the solo Atlantic rower/sailor (UK to US) who, according to you, should be in school, is?

2 hours ago, koolkarl said:

What makes you such an  expert?  And what was Oct. 7 2 years ago?  Strongly suggest go to Gaza if you believe in them so much.

I'm not an expert, but can read different reports in different languages. Can you? It's a hypothetical question, of course. If you could, you would not ask your derailed questions.

6 hours ago, JonnyF said:

 

That just highlights once again how utterly clueless this little imp is. 

Aaw Jonny. This “little imp” has sooo got under your skin. Calm down dear.

56 minutes ago, Red Forever said:

You really must learn the difference between antisemitism which is hatred of Judaism, and hatred of the genocide committed daily by the Israeli IDF.

 

Because some critics of Israel label IDF military actions in Gaza as genocide doesn't mean these actions are actually genocide.  Making false accusations against the homeland of the Jews and only Jewish-majority nation is one way of attempting to delegitimize Israel and thereby crosses the line into antisemitism.  The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's working definition of antisemitism, which has been adopted by the U.K., E.U. and other countries and organizations, explains it well.

Working definition of antisemitism

https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism

14 hours ago, Evil Penevil said:

Because some critics of Israel label IDF military actions in Gaza as genocide doesn't mean these actions are actually genocide.

No, it's not 'some critics of Israel ', it's many independent human rights observers and all aid agencies involved.

16 hours ago, Red Forever said:

Oh Jonny, Jonny. You really must learn the difference between antisemitism which is hatred of Judaism, and hatred of the genocide committed daily by the Israeli IDF.

 

Anti Israel. Anti Zionist. Two of many expressions the left use to attempt to disguise their hatred of Jews. The world's oldest hatred and synonymous with the left. It's no surprise that of all the terrible conflicts currently taking place around the world it's the cause of the Palestinians that the left are so obsessed with. Why? Because they are trying to eliminate the Jewish people. My enemies enemy is my friend. 

 

16 hours ago, Red Forever said:

This could be your Damascus point, similar to how various posters have stopped you trying to convince us that Nazis were actually “Socialists “.

You're welcome.

 

Perhaps your historical knowledge is not so strong as your opinions. The nazis did indeed come from the National Socialist German Workers Party. Were they truly socialist in the classic sense of the word? Probably not, just as todays "Progressives" are not really progressive and "Liberals" are the most illiberal and intolerant group of people on the planet. A misleading name is probably the least significant thing that the National Socialist German Workers Party share with modern day "Liberals" and "Progressives" though. 

50 minutes ago, stevenl said:

No, it's not 'some critics of Israel ', it's many independent human rights observers and all aid agencies involved.

 

Because many independent human rights observers and all aid agencies involved label IDF military actions in Gaza as genocide doesn't mean these actions are actually genocide.

16 hours ago, Red Forever said:

Oh Jonny, Jonny. You really must learn the difference between antisemitism which is hatred of Judaism, and hatred of the genocide committed daily by the Israeli IDF.

This could be your Damascus point, similar to how various posters have stopped you trying to convince us that Nazis were actually “Socialists “.

You're welcome.

I too was Red until the movement went off the rails. Red leaders of the past would be turning in their graves at how easily so many in the West have been manipulated into anti-western civilisation self loathing, with a lack of historical context (like which civilisation over last 3,000 years was the FIRST to abolish slavery). 

Anyone who writes "genocide committed daily by the IDF" is plain ignorant about what happens in conflict, especially when one side deliberately bases their strategy on fighting amongst civilians, while the other still gets damned for continually warning civilians to move out of harms way. The death rate of civilians to military in this horrid conflict is still low, if you care to look it up. 

Meanwhile trust you're delighted that Peace is underway and the Gazan misery can end. Fantastic news 🤗

20 minutes ago, Donga said:

I too was Red until the movement went off the rails. Red leaders of the past would be turning in their graves at how easily so many in the West have been manipulated into anti-western civilisation self loathing, with a lack of historical context (like which civilisation over last 3,000 years was the FIRST to abolish slavery). 

Anyone who writes "genocide committed daily by the IDF" is plain ignorant about what happens in conflict, especially when one side deliberately bases their strategy on fighting amongst civilians, while the other still gets damned for continually warning civilians to move out of harms way. The death rate of civilians to military in this horrid conflict is still low, if you care to look it up. 

Meanwhile trust you're delighted that Peace is underway and the Gazan misery can end. Fantastic news 🤗

 

Absolutely right.

 

This "Red Forever" poster makes Gary Neville look intelligent, well informed and right leaning. 😄

On 10/9/2025 at 4:43 PM, newbee2022 said:

I'm not an expert, but can read different reports in different languages. Can you? It's a hypothetical question, of course. If you could, you would not ask your derailed questions.

Don't understand why your comments aren't deleted.

1 minute ago, koolkarl said:

Don't understand why your comments aren't deleted.

Understanding is a problem?😂

On 10/10/2025 at 8:20 AM, stevenl said:

No, it's not 'some critics of Israel ', it's many independent human rights observers and all aid agencies involved.

 

    Many of these id agencies have a vested interest in the Gaza conflict , they need there to be  famine in order to justify themselves being there .

  500 000 Children died of famine in Sudan since the Gaza war began , where were the aid agencies then ?

37 minutes ago, Nick Carter icp said:

 

    Many of these id agencies have a vested interest in the Gaza conflict , they need there to be  famine in order to justify themselves being there .

  500 000 Children died of famine in Sudan since the Gaza war began , where were the aid agencies then ?

Deflecting

43 minutes ago, newbee2022 said:

Deflecting

 

    Making a valid point if if the aid agencies wouldn't be in cushy Israel , they would have to relocate to somewhere brutal  like Sudan or Yemen .

   They would much prefer having it easy in Israel

56 minutes ago, newbee2022 said:

Deflecting

Yes, he's deflecting and lying. The aid agencies would much rather not be there.