Harmonica. It has been ages since your last post. Come on. I want to know what happened to this guy and why!!

I think we already know.

The guy was a doctor and removed the others' arms to eat, when they were shipwrecked.

They made an agreement that when they survived, the doctor would also remove his arm.

He didn't and tried to pay them off, so they killed him.

But where is harmonica to confirm this?

Harmonica.  It has been ages since your last post.  Come on.  I want to know what happened to this guy and why!!

You're right. Sorry I was gone all day -- it was tiring answering so many qts till late last night. Unanticipated!

Go on back to the original thread and its all there right to the conclusion. You came up with some good questions. Thanks!

If its not clear I'll revisit and post.

Harmonica.  It has been ages since your last post.  Come on.  I want to know what happened to this guy and why!!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You're right. Sorry I was gone all day -- it was tiring answering so many qts till late last night. Unanticipated!

Go on back to the original thread and its all there right to the conclusion. You came up with some good questions. Thanks!

If its not clear I'll revisit and post.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

he has been amongst us all his time

have you not been reading the forum?

so you are saying Harmonica is armless Neeranram??