Academics express serious reservations about state enterprises bill with NLA

By   WICHIT CHAITRONG  
THE NATION 

 

 

ACADEMICS have expressed concerns over the state enterprises bill which is currently being vetted by the National Legislative Assembly, even as trade unions demand withdrawal of the bill fearing its passage would lead to privatisation.

Nualnoi Treerat, director of the Institute of Asian Studies, yesterday said that those who had drafted the law may have good intentions to improve the efficiency of the 56 state enterprises but the drafting process did not include public participation.

 

She made her comments at the seminar hosted by the Thailand Development Research Institute.

 

The bill, if approved by the NLA, will lead to the creation of a holding company similar to Singapore’s Temasek Holdings. 

 

The so-called super holding company will supervise 11 commercial state enterprises with combined assets valued at around Bt 6 trillion. The rest of the state enterprises will remain subject to their current specific laws.

 

Nualnoi said the bill gives too much power to the board of the holding company, as they could borrow money, which could automatically turn into public debt.

 

She was also worried about the selection of the board of directors, which may not prevent political intervention. 

 

The bill gives too much power to the State Enterprise Policy Office. “It is like a blank cheque,” she said.

 

Deunden Nikomborirak, an economist at the TDRI, shared Nualnoi’s view saying there is no guarantee to have qualified board members for the super holding company and state enterprises.

 

She suggested that a third party should be allowed to recruit board members in order to ensure transparency in the appointments. She also said that the qualifications for the board members should be stated in the law.

 

She said the bill does not incorporate strong checks and balances to prevent or curb corruption. She suggested that a third party should be assigned to scrutinise the performance of state enterprises. 

 

She also wanted representatives of |trade unions to be on the board of directors |of state enterprises and be represented in |the super holding company.

 

Former finance minister Sommai Phasee also expressed his concern about the bill, saying it gives too much authority to the prime minister and senior officials who sit at the State Enterprise Policy.

 

Meanwhile, representatives of trade unions demanded that the bill must be withdrawn from the NLA debate. They said the bill would pave the way for privatisation.

 

Ekniti Nitithanprapas, the director-general of the State Enterprise Policy Office, said the bill aims to tackle corruption issues by making the management of state enterprises more transparent. 

 

It will also lead to more information disclosure that will allow the public to scrutinise the state enterprises, he added.

 

Source: http://www.nationmultimedia.com/detail/Economy/30331249

 

-- © Copyright The Nation 2017-11-10

Sadly there is no such thing as an independent 3rd party here. In most cases all it would be is another layer of skim off the top. 

 

If she is concerned about the apointment of the board which could be influenced, the exactly the same could be said of the 3rd party overseeing them.

Just another layer of useless and incompetent upper-crust bureaucracy where jobs will be filled by general's mates and friends and relations. An extra carriage of freeloaders on the already overloaded gravy train created under the pretext of transparency and prevention of corruption. In reality it will be just a cover to prevent the public finding out about the scams and creaming that already goes on within the public service hierarchy.

Edited November 9, 20178 yr by Cadbury

Most state enterprises should be privatised....governments have been hopeless at managing these businesses and there are always massive losses, with taxpayers footing the bill.

Unfortunately, selling them off would likely see many of these businesses shut down, depriving the public.....

 

Most state enterprises should be privatised....governments have been hopeless at managing these businesses and there are always massive losses, with taxpayers footing the bill.
Unfortunately, selling them off would likely see many of these businesses shut down, depriving the public.....
 

...of nothing much really!

Sent from my KENNY using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app