‘Love Destiny’ is more fantasy than nostalgia

[webfact]

OPINION

‘Love Destiny’ is more fantasy than nostalgia

By The Nation

 

FILE photo

 

In its pursuit of ‘thainess’, the government seeks to restore long-discredited values

 

The phenomenon generated by the TV series “Buppesannivas” (“Love Destiny”) has included a fashion fad as Thais dress in period costumes. We believe this might be good for commerce, but it’s politically incorrect.

 

The television soap opera is a massive hit, sparking mania among Thais of all generations, who are flocking to the filming locales in historical Ayutthaya. People have their photos taken in classical costumes, not only at the shooting sites but also for their national ID cards. Restaurants have added dishes to their menus solely because they’ve been mentioned on the TV series.

 

However the military-led government under Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha is wrong to interpret this phenomenon as a revival of Thai nationalism. It wants to exploit it for political gain. The government wants to seize the momentum to promote Thai culture and nationalism as a match for its Bt100-billion “Thai Niyom Yangyuen” (“Sustainable Thainess”) programme launched earlier this year.

 

Government officials have been encouraged to wear clothing made of Thai fabric during work hours, though the move has drawn complaints that those who don’t comply face discrimination.

 

The Culture Ministry and Tourism and Sports Ministry dived into the “creative economy” concept with the goal of celebrating “Thainess”. Anyone wearing traditional Siamese attire was admitted to national museums and historical parks during Historical Thai Heritage Conservation Week, which ended on Sunday. 

 

“Buppesannivas” is set during the reign of King Narai of the Ayutthaya Kingdom. That was three centuries before the concept of a “nation-state” was adopted in this land.

 

The series, which will end later this month, is about a kind-hearted woman named Kedsurang whose soul is transported back in time to the Ayutthaya Period to live in the body of a second woman called Karaked, who is cursed for plotting a murder.

 

While there are some historical scenes in the TV series, “Buppesannivas” cannot be called truly historical. It’s just a love story with Ayutthaya as its backdrop. Hundreds of period films have been produced over the years, but few have found an audience. “Buppesanmivas” became a hit because it’s about ordinary people and there’s little in the line of politics.

 

Scholars have said the soap opera reflects nostalgia, a yearning for the past. Thais have been told for generations that their kingdom was far better in the past than it is today. Education and entertainment have reinforced this mistaken belief, implanting it in the Thai mindset to help the established elite maintain the status quo. The elite always say “Thainess” is preferable to Western ways.

 

However, Prayut and the Culture Ministry – which is planning to co-produce similar historical dramas evoking Thainess –need to realise one thing, that Ayutthaya during King Narai’s time was already westernised in many aspects, notably in its diplomacy and culture.

 

The Thailand of the distant past was no Heaven on Earth. Inequality was prevalent. There were masters and slaves. There were no such ideas as democracy or rights. Women were the property of men. The pursuit of “Thainess” might be a disguised attempt to restore such inhumane values.

 

Rather than talking about “the good old days” and Thainess, the government should remember it has a vision for the future that requires adherence to modern values. There’s nothing wrong with watching soap operas and dressing in traditional costumes for pictures, but it’s incorrect for the government to exploit the current fad to mislead people about a past that never existed. 

 

Source: http://www.nationmultimedia.com/detail/opinion/30342872

 

-- © Copyright The Nation 2018-04-10

[Samui Bodoh]

Promoting a fantasy vision of a Thailand from a few hundred years ago sounds right up Prayut's alley.

 

It is a grand sight; there is no need for pesky things like facts or reality, there is no need for protesters or opponents, there is no need for economic issues or social clashes, there are no questions about political legitimacy or the bother of asking Thais who they want to govern themselves.

 

There is only love and clothing!

 

What a beautiful, delusional fantasy.

 

Now, back in the real world...

 

[YetAnother]

38 minutes ago, webfact said:

In its pursuit of ‘thainess’,

worst thing i ever wanted to know and discovered/resolved

[Odysseus123]

"Never,in the field of human endeavour has so much hogwash been  produced,for so many,for the benefit of so few"

 

General "Big Win" Chuchathanakabaht.

Edited April 9, 2018 by Odysseus123

[Darcula]

1 hour ago, webfact said:

The Thailand of the distant past was no Heaven on Earth. Inequality was prevalent. There were masters and slaves.

 

I havent been out today, but, unless things changed as of 11pm last night this sounds very much like the Thailand of the present.

[JOC]

2 hours ago, webfact said:

The Thailand of the distant past was no Heaven on Earth. Inequality was prevalent. There were masters and slaves

So nothing has changed in 300 years?

[Lupatria]

2 hours ago, webfact said:

However, Prayut and the Culture Ministry – which is planning to co-produce similar historical dramas evoking Thainess

Hey you guardians of Thai culture. I have an idea for a 19-series patriotic soap opera:
"Thailand's Pride & Joy"
A brief history of our unique, and mostly successful coups d'état. The plot will be spiced up with a love story of a poor Isan girl, and an unusually rich manufacturer of period clothing.

[Juan B Tong]

Hmm.

Do a nostalgic show with hi-so celebs in period costumes cleaning up littered beaches and highways.

 

Show them being transported in period carriages and show the drivers going slow and being courteous.  Show traffic incidents ending in wais and apologies all around.

 

 

[clokwise]

I can't force myself to watch the show for more than a few minutes, but my Thai wife is absolutely mesmerized by it. She's playing the soundtrack on her phone constantly, she's rewatching previous episodes on YouTube, and the best part is after the show ends on Thursday and Friday evenings she's all charged up and ready for some hot and romantic fun. I for one will be sad when it's all over.

 

 

[Emster23]

Nostalgia ain't what it used to be.....

[Anak Nakal]

Its TV show, not real.

TV not real!

What matter with Thai people?

[PatOngo]

1 hour ago, JOC said:

So nothing has changed in 300 years?

They have discovered the horseless carriage.......................and look where that's taken them!

[NCC1701A]

" The Thailand of the distant past was no Heaven on Earth. Inequality was prevalent. There were masters and slaves. There were no such ideas as democracy or rights. Women were the property of men."

 

Sounds like Saturday night cosplay at my house.

 

In all fairness we also do role reversal.

[Stargeezr]

How about the ghosts in so many movies, maybe some believe in the spirits

as well.

Geezer

[JOC]

5 hours ago, webfact said:

 

However, Prayut and the Culture Ministry – which is planning to co-produce similar historical dramas evoking Thainess

Wow something to look forward to...More science fiction from Prayut

May I suggest a few tittles:

"Road map to Democracy"

"Elections coming soon"

"The Supreme Savior strikes again"

[starky]

35 minutes ago, Stargrazer9889 said:

How about the ghosts in so many movies, maybe some believe in the spirits

as well.

Geezer

They all believe in spirits. One in particular is worshipped goes by the name of Lao kao 

[Jeremy50]

I wouldn't be surprised to find 'The Triumph of the Will', and other Nazi propaganda films in the general's DVD collection. 

[DM07]

No $4yte, Sherlock!

I am shocked!

[Lupatria]

3 hours ago, clokwise said:

I can't force myself to watch the show for more than a few minutes, but my Thai wife is absolutely mesmerized by it. She's playing the soundtrack on her phone constantly, she's rewatching previous episodes on YouTube, and the best part is after the show ends on Thursday and Friday evenings she's all charged up and ready for some hot and romantic fun. I for one will be sad when it's all over.

 

 

You mean your marriage?