New Yorkers Divided but Lean Toward Supporting Trump’s Deportation Plan

[Social Media]

 

A recent Siena College poll has revealed that a majority of New Yorkers are in favor of President-elect Donald Trump’s controversial proposal to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, a plan that was a central theme of his presidential campaign. This includes an unexpected finding: nearly half of Latino respondents and a significant number of self-identified liberals support the measure.

 

The survey, conducted between December 2 and December 5, involved 834 registered voters and has a margin of error of approximately four percentage points. The results indicate that 54% of respondents across the state believe New York should align with Trump’s deportation agenda, while 35% think the state should oppose it. The data underscores a deep divide across demographic and political lines, with support reaching surprising corners.

 

Among Democrats, 38% expressed approval for the deportation plan, compared to a whopping 87% of Republicans and 54% of independents. Gender also played a role in shaping opinions, with 61% of men backing the plan versus 49% of women. Opposition among women stood at 38%, slightly higher than the 31% of men who opposed it. Racial differences were less pronounced, though still notable, with 56% of white respondents, 51% of Black respondents, and 47% of Latino respondents showing support. Additionally, a striking 30% of self-described liberals expressed agreement, defying expectations given Trump’s often polarizing policies.

 

The context for these numbers may lie in the strain the ongoing migrant crisis has placed on New York City. Since the spring of 2022, more than 224,400 migrants have entered the city’s intake system, creating a financial burden estimated at $6.1 billion. Although the pace of arrivals has slowed, with 11 emergency shelters closing over the past six weeks, over 56,000 migrants remain in the shelter system as of late November.

 

Mayor Eric Adams has also adopted a tougher stance on immigration in recent months, particularly when addressing migrants who have been accused of crimes. Speaking last week, he stated, “My position is people who commit crimes in our city, you have abdicated your right to be in our city, and I am open to figure out the best way to address that. Those who are here committing crimes, robberies, shooting at police officers, raping innocent people, have been a harm to our country.”

 

Adams’ comments reflect growing frustration among many city residents and officials as they grapple with the challenges posed by the influx. The poll results suggest that this frustration may be fueling broader support for more stringent immigration policies, even among groups typically resistant to Trump’s rhetoric.

 

As the state continues to navigate these tensions, the poll highlights the complexities of public opinion on immigration—a deeply divisive issue with implications that reach far beyond party lines.

 

Based on a report by NYP 2024-12-12

 

 

 

[jippytum]

Illegal is illegal. Support Trump and get rid.

I wish most European politicians including the UK had some of his resolve regarding illegal immigration

[Grumpy one]

A quick look at the headlines and I thought they wanted to deport rump

Silly me, must cut back on alcohol and open eyes

[Denim]

Saying and being able to do are worlds apart.

 

A few hundred , maybe . Millions ? ...I doubt it.

[Cryingdick]

It doesn't matter what New Yorkers think it is a matter of federal law.

[Eric Loh]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:11 AM, Denim said:

Saying and being able to do are worlds apart.

 

A few hundred , maybe . Millions ? ...I doubt it.

Expand  

He is not going to do it as it will wreck the economy and it is just too expensive an agenda. All hype just like his wall. Mexico will pay for it and by only a small fraction built during his tenure. 

[jas007]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:51 AM, Eric Loh said:

He is not going to do it as it will wreck the economy and it is just too expensive an agenda. All hype just like his wall. Mexico will pay for it and by only a small fraction built during his tenure. 

Expand  

He may not be successful for various reasons, but I'm pretty sure the people he will be deporting don't do much to help the economy, in any event.  They're costing the taxpayers big money.  

[impulse]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:11 AM, Denim said:

Saying and being able to do are worlds apart.

 

A few hundred , maybe . Millions ? ...I doubt it.

Expand  

 

All he'd have to do is quit feeding and housing them (on my dime), and millions would have no choice but to Remigrate.  Which seems to be a thing in Europe now...  Remigrate.

 

[Cryingdick]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:51 AM, Eric Loh said:

He is not going to do it as it will wreck the economy and it is just too expensive an agenda. All hype just like his wall. Mexico will pay for it and by only a small fraction built during his tenure. 

Expand  

Watch the wall get built again after Joe sold it off for pennies on the dollar. 

[mokwit]

When is NY going to hold the people who created this sanctuary city problem to account?

[Cryingdick]

As Homan said if you don't let ICE arrest them at the jail in custody which would be the safest conditions. That ICE officers will find them at large and anybody harboring them will be arrested.

[Lacessit]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:57 AM, Cryingdick said:

Watch the wall get built again after Joe sold it off for pennies on the dollar. 

Expand  

During his first presidency, Trump added 64 km of wall to the existing 1044 km. Biden then added another 30 km by closing gaps.

 

The total length of the border between Mexico and the USA is 3145 km.

 

Thanks for my laugh of the day, with your daft fantasies.

[Woke to Sounds]

Just send the illegals north to Canada. It will welcome them.

[Cryingdick]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:08 AM, Lacessit said:

During his first presidency, Trump added 64 km of wall to the existing 1044 km. Biden then added another 30 km by closing gaps.

 

The total length of the border between Mexico and the USA is 3145 km.

 

Thanks for my laugh of the day, with your daft fantasies.

Expand  

Trump was opposed then he isn't now. He has taken America by storm. Nobody is going to go to the border and cut razor wire now. Game. Set. Match.

[bamnutsak]

What is the "plan"?

 

Trump and Miller have said a lot of things, but have they offered a "plan", actions, timeline, goals/objectives, budget.

 

 

[Cryingdick]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:17 AM, bamnutsak said:

What is the "plan"?

 

Trump and Miller have said a lot of things, but have they offered a "plan", actions, timeline, goals/objectives, budget.

 

 

Expand  

To start by deporting criminal aliens. Preferably directly from jails.

[Lacessit]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:10 AM, Cryingdick said:

Trump was opposed then he isn't now. He has taken America by storm. Nobody is going to go to the border and cut razor wire now. Game. Set. Match.

Expand  

Are you still dreaming the Mexicans are going to pay for a wall? Where's the money coming from?

[Eric Loh]

  On 12/12/2024 at 2:56 AM, jas007 said:

He may not be successful for various reasons, but I'm pretty sure the people he will be deporting don't do much to help the economy, in any event.  They're costing the taxpayers big money.  

Expand  

Undocumented immgrants contribute Billions to Federal and State taxes each year. 

[Cryingdick]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:23 AM, Lacessit said:

Are you still dreaming the Mexicans are going to pay for a wall? Where's the money coming from?

Expand  

I am not worried about how it is funded. You seem to be concerned that it is going to work,. I guess we cancel transsexual Peruvian studies and things like that. 

[Yagoda]

I cant wait to watch the TV cameras focusing on screaming women and children as they are herded across the border. Watching the Socialist tears will be fullfilling.

 

Not like it hasnt happened before.

 

 

[Cryingdick]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:30 AM, Yagoda said:

I cant wait to watch the TV cameras focusing on screaming women and children as they are herded across the border. Watching the Socialist tears will be fullfilling.

 

Not like it hasnt happened before.

 

 

Expand  

 

That's bound to happen when they release criminal aliens into the community at large. 

[jas007]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:24 AM, Eric Loh said:

Undocumented immgrants contribute Billions to Federal and State taxes each year. 

Expand  

Those are the ones with jobs, correct?  The rest cost everyone big money.  And the country is almost bankrupt as it is. 

[impulse]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:24 AM, Eric Loh said:

Undocumented immgrants contribute Billions to Federal and State taxes each year. 

Expand  

 

Is that why NYC mayor Eric Adams requested $12 billion in federal funds to care for their 110,000 undocumented immigrants?  That's $36K a head, per annum. 

 

That's kind of the opposite of "contributing".

 

[Yagoda]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:33 AM, Cryingdick said:

 

That's bound to happen when they release criminal aliens into the community at large. 

Expand  

That was a kid torn from his family and deported to Cuba under Clinton.

[Lacessit]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:24 AM, Cryingdick said:

I am not worried about how it is funded. You seem to be concerned that it is going to work,. I guess we cancel transsexual Peruvian studies and things like that. 

Expand  

It really is irrelevant to me whether it works or not.

 

I guess a study into the mental health of MAGA supporters needs no funding, that ship sailed on January 6, 2021.

[Eric Loh]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:34 AM, jas007 said:

Those are the ones with jobs, correct?  The rest cost everyone big money.  And the country is almost bankrupt as it is. 

Expand  

Undocumented immigrants can easily find jobs that Americans don't want especially in agriculture and construction. Employers just need to verify the identity and work eligibility. They work and pay tax but not entitled to social secruity and medicare benefits. No the country is not bankrupt as it is but they actually contribute economically. 

[thaipo7]

  On 12/12/2024 at 12:32 AM, jippytum said:

Illegal is illegal. Support Trump and get rid.

I wish most European politicians including the UK had some of his resolve regarding illegal immigration

Expand  

Thank you - Now I don't have to say this.  Illegal is illegal.

[Keep Right]

  On 12/12/2024 at 3:24 AM, Eric Loh said:

Undocumented immgrants contribute Billions to Federal and State taxes each year. 

Expand  

And those billions are used to support the rest of the illegals that do not have jobs and to pay for law enforcement to prevent these illegals from harming the good citizens of the U.S. Its a vicious circle that needs to end. 

[Eric Loh]

  On 12/12/2024 at 6:07 AM, Keep Right said:

And those billions are used to support the rest of the illegals that do not have jobs and to pay for law enforcement to prevent these illegals from harming the good citizens of the U.S. Its a vicious circle that needs to end. 

Expand  

Think you confused. Illegals are deported  and illegals can’t have legit jobs. Think you meant undocumented. Get you facts straight before making silly comments.

[Hanaguma]

  On 12/12/2024 at 4:23 AM, Eric Loh said:

Undocumented immigrants can easily find jobs that Americans don't want especially in agriculture and construction. Employers just need to verify the identity and work eligibility. They work and pay tax but not entitled to social secruity and medicare benefits. No the country is not bankrupt as it is but they actually contribute economically. 

Expand  

Untrue. They find jobs that Americans won't do for the SALARY that the illegals are willing to take. A majority of ag and construction workers are actually American citizens and legal residents.