Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:12 PM, oldcpu said:

 

Indeed.  I was here 25 years ago (as a digital nomad then) and people were saying that re:taxation.

 

But it was also at that time wrong in terms of tax law - rather it represented what was practically in place.

Expand  

 

Thats how it was described to me. Whether it was right or wrong, I have no idea. 

 

Looking into taxation over the last 18 months or so, I was never a tax resident ( 180 days ) anyway.

 

I still think it was a case of who gives a monkeys, but that is changing.

  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:16 PM, The Cyclist said:

 

Looking into taxation over the last 18 months or so, I was never a tax resident ( 180 days ) anyway.

 

Expand  

 

Ok ... then why did you go to the RD office?

 

When my wife talked to the RD on my behalf, the VERY FIRST thing they asked, was I a tax resident?  Had I been in Thailand for 180 days or greater?  Then they asked, what were the source(s) of my income.

 

I am surprised an RD official took the time to fill in a draft tax form for you, given that you are not a tax resident.

.

  • Agree 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:12 PM, The Cyclist said:

 

I would suggest that anyone who has a Thai bank account is already on the RD's radar

Expand  

 

That should not be a worry if people follow Thai law.

 

Compared to Canada (and for that matter Germany), Thailand has a pretty nice tax law.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:18 PM, SHA 2 BKK said:

The RD Lawyer states that if you have no assessable income there is no need to get a TIN and no need to file a return.  

 

As I only remitted pre 2024 income last year (end of year 2023 Bank Statements to prove), my Australian Government Service Pension is specifically excluded under the DTA (not the Australian Aged Pension) and I held an LTR for the duration of 2024, I am very comfortable in not getting a TIN and filing a return. 

Expand  

 

I am mostly in the same situation.   I even had a Phuket RD official tell me (via my wife) not to file a Thai tax return (nor would he give me a TIN).

 

But things can change - and so I try to understand the current tax regulations.  

 

  On 1/21/2025 at 12:18 PM, SHA 2 BKK said:

But this is not a one size fits all situation.  Everyone has different circumstances.  But it made it clear again to keep or have access to paperwork especially if you are only bringing in pre 2024 income.

Expand  

 

Indeed.  A very good point.

  • Like 1
  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:19 PM, oldcpu said:

Ok ... then why did you go to the RD office?

Expand  

 

Because the period I was talking about, from around 2009 through to 2020, I was never a tax resident.

 

From 2021, I have been a tax resident ( Over 180 days )

 

Jeepers creepers, did you think you had tripped me up or something ?

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:25 PM, The Cyclist said:

 

Because the period I was talking about, from around 2009 through to 2020, I was never a tax resident.

 

From 2021, I have been a tax resident ( Over 180 days )

 

Jeepers creepers, did you think you had tripped me up or something ?

Expand  

 

You had me wondering. Your post was ambiguous.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:28 PM, The Cyclist said:

 

There was nothing ambiguous about ' 15 / 16 years ago, when I first came here , I was told '

Expand  

 

i won't get into semantics.

 

I do recommend you go back to the tax office and get another assessment before you file any 2024 tax return, if the DTA with your country states only your country can tax your pension ,and if you have no Thai income and if you remitted that DTA specified non-Thai taxable income into Thailand.

 

As I typed before, if you do not double check this with an RD official who does not make a mistake (like the last one) you could end up being taxed on income that is tax exempt.

 

This is your call obviously - but I fear you are headed down the wrong path. However you don't seem to be concerned - so obviously, feel free to adopt your own approach.  For others thou, i don't recommend your approach (if their income is noted in a DTA as only being taxed in the source country, which is not Thailand).

  • Thanks 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:12 PM, The Cyclist said:

 

I would suggest that anyone who has a Thai bank account is already on the RD's radar

Expand  

 

You are of course correct.Those bleating about the dangers of obtaining a TIN don't understand the process involved in "getting on the radar." I don't for a moment believe that TRD will be hunting down miscreants who have a TIN but haven"t filed.There are many legit reasons why a TIN holder might not need to file in any year - having no assessable income for example.

 

Having said that many foreign banks are pressurizing their clients to obtain a local tax number.

  • Thumbs Up 1
Posted
  On 1/16/2025 at 5:24 AM, Briggsy said:

It is slightly more complex than that. SA 106 is supplementary to a UK tax return. If you are completing an SA106 you are completing a UK tax return.

 

You need to have foreign income AND tax needs to be owing on that foreign income. This applies both to foreigners and UK nationals who are resident in the UK for tax purposes. It is irrespective of nationality.

 

If no tax is owing, you will probably find HMRC will de-register from self-assessment and the need for a return if this was the only reason.

 

We are getting very off-topic.

Expand  

True of getting off topic. Anyway, the UK revenue site is clear. If you don't live in UK, have absolutely no assets there (OK maybe just a bank which is fine) you are NON-RESIDENT for tax purposes. There are some other things - your State Pension willl be taxed at  source (25%?)  but that's it. Others may know more..

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 1:36 PM, The Cyclist said:

:cheesy::cheesy::cheesy:

 

Here is Expatthaitax, an RD Official and a Professor of some description

 

 

 

Some people better have a watch and listen, and stop posting crap

 

Especially people like @NoDisplayName  listen carefully towhat it says about

 

Section 40 - Assessable income

 

Part 1 - Pensions

 

How you prove it is not taxable.

 

3 times I counted Carl trying to get an answer on exempt income under DTA's and was given a stiff ignoring.

 

The message appears clear, unless you remit income below the filing thresholds, which are 60k / 120k / 220 k Baht, depending on income or single / joint filing. File and prove how your income is not taxable ( DTA ) or the tax Credit method.

 

Be sure to watch from the 45 minute mark 😀😀 That will give some the 

Expand  

I've been here 17 years and have only paid tax in the UK, I can not afford to pay twice, 

I could manage a small amount so I will use this Expat Thailand to get a TIN it costs 7,000bht which for me will be trouble free so dont mind the cost, all they want is a copy of your passport and visa.

My local tax office wanted documents from the UK in order to get a TIN, they said it can be difficult.

 

  • Sad 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 2:58 PM, Guavaman said:

One of the interesting features of Thai culture is the preferred tendency to maintain wiggle-room, facilitated by the use of ambiguity in communications to allow for flexibility of response as appropriate for diverse and unforseen situations.

Expand  

 

Or used to completely screw with anyone they wish, at any time they wish, it's that "ambiguity" that frightens us foreigners the most.

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 1:36 PM, The Cyclist said:

3 times I counted Carl trying to get an answer on exempt income under DTA's and was given a stiff ignoring.

Expand  

 

The answers did appear to meander around this question and not address it head on. 

 

I note comments are turned off on the video.  That was strange. Clearly they don't want feedback nor more questions.

 

The video jumps around a bit.

 

I skimmed through some of the video and did not watch it all. 

 

From what I could decipher - tax free income is treated as non assessable income (although those specific words were not consistently chosen):

 

- Income from before 1-Jan-2024 is tax free (ie non assessable - my words). Hence this is not to be included on a tax form.  But one should keep records to prove this.

 

- For pension income, it depends on each country (DTA) whether the income is tax free or taxable (ie non-assessable or assessable) - my interpretation of what was being said in the video. 

 

Also the foreign source of the pension income is important if it is taxable or tax free.  If  the income is tax free (non assessable) by Thailand (ie my words: if DTA claims only source country can tax), it does not go on a tax form. At least that is what I deciphered. Draw one's own conclusions from watching.

 

- For foreign pensions remitted to Thailand, if both the foreign country and Thailand can tax the income (per a DTA), then even if one has already paid tax in the foreign country, one still needs to apply for a tax ID and file a Thai tax return. Then the appropriate rebates/credits can take place (that is my wording).  This IMHO is well known and not disputed on this forum.

 

Inheritance and gifts, if remitted to Thailand are not taxable. Personal assets (such as a car outside of Thailand) from before 1-Jan-2024 sold and brought into Thailand, are not taxable.  But evidence is required to prove.

 

Again, the video jumped around, so do not believe what I typed/interpreted.  I recommend do not believe what I typed. Try and watch this one's self.

 

 

  On 1/21/2025 at 1:36 PM, The Cyclist said:

The message appears clear, unless you remit income below the filing thresholds, which are 60k / 120k / 220 k Baht, depending on income or single / joint filing. File and prove how your income is not taxable ( DTA ) or the tax Credit method.

 

Expand  

 

Message is clear for assessable income that is not tax free and not tax exempt. And that is not new news.

 

However most of the discussions on this thread and others is about income made non assessable due to tax exemptions (such as por-161/162 and some DTAs (not all DTAs)).

 

Again, the video jumped around, so do not believe what I typed/interpreted.  I recommend do not believe what I typed. Try and watch this one's self.

 

Frankly - I am very disappointed with the video as it was not as clear as would have been more helpful.

 

  • Agree 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:08 PM, anchadian said:

Either way, if you indeed obtained a TIN, you're now on the RD's radar.

Expand  

Another poster who fails to read and comprehend.

 

I did NOT obtain a TIN, so please explain how you come to believe that I will be on the TRD radar.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 2:58 PM, Guavaman said:

 

In summary, "non-assessable" is not a concept that appears within the context of the Thai Tax Code; "exempt for the purpose of income tax calculation" is the concept applied in the RD context.

 

Expand  

 

I discovered mostly (but not totally) the same. 

 

I think (re; the tax code) "exempt for the purpose of income tax calculation" means non assessable (in the words of 'non-Thai' expatriates) ... and even just 'tax exempt' is considered 'non assessable' in the view of many (similar in some cases to 'exempt for the purposes of income tax calculation' even if not specifically stated 

 

... which I note,  does appear to be supported by what looks to be a deliberate omission (by the Thai RD) of different categories of common  exempt income that is tax exempt,  as note in Royal Decrees (such as LTR), in ministerial instructions (such as por.161/162) and in selected DTAs.

 

Why would the RD  DELIBERATELY (caps intended by me to make a point) omit an exempt entry field in a tax return form, if  a DTA ,or if a Royal Decree or a ministerial exemption says such can be an exempt deduction?  Why?  IMHO that clearly suggests such exempt income is not to be reported.

 

It disappointing to see the lack of clarity and see the confusion here.

 

I do believe that anyone who reports remitted income that is 100% exempt tax (due to DTAs) on their tax return, or remitted income that is 100% exempt tax (due to por.161/162) on their tax return, or remitted income that is 100%  tax exempt (due to Royal Decree) on their tax return, will still be mistakenly taxed on such because there is no place on the tax returns to list such as an exemption.  This is true for the 2023 Thai tax return in English language and this is true for the 2024 tax return in Thai language. I speculate that those who put such exemptions in the tax return, in the wrong field (and there is no good field), will I believe have such exemptions denied, and will pay tax on income that is tax exempt.

 

Then one is into appeal territory.  And good luck with that.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 3:20 PM, billd766 said:

Another poster who fails to read and comprehend.

 

I did NOT obtain a TIN, so please explain how you come to believe that I will be on the TRD radar.

Expand  

 

I hope that I am on the TRD radar.  I asked they provide me a TIN and they denied me one.  I hope that they remember such.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 12:06 PM, oldcpu said:

 

This is my concern - for those who file a 2024 Thai tax return ... if they put tax exempt income (from income excluded per the DTA) or put exempt remitted income (from pre-1-Jan-2024 savings) into their tax return , they could then be incorrectly taxed on that.

 

Why ? Because there is no place on the tax forms to list such as then tax exempt.

 

Then one is into appeals and it gets messy.

 

So caution is needed here - and I hope everyone pays close attention to this. 

Expand  

However I did not fill in or sign any forms at all in the TRD office, which means that I do not have a TIN.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 2:35 PM, NoDisplayName said:

 

Great find!

 

From 28:00-30:30 they confirmed that if your remittances are not assessable, you don't need a TIN and you don't need to file.  If you remit assessable income over the threshold (60k), then you need to file a return, and may potentially owe tax.

 

At 31:30 they tell us that pensions are assessable if not excluded.  We know US social security is excluded, as are many government pensions, so check your DTA's, boys and girls. 

 

At 38:00 we're told we can take a tax credit on the tax form, but no detail given. ( Appears to be a miscommunication, unless someone can point out just how to take a foreign tax credit.)

 

So this confirms TRD is only interested in assessable income, no need to declare all remittances to include non-assessable income.

 

This is good news.

 

Expand  

But who decides what is assessable and what is non-assessable income and what are they likely to be?

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 3:39 PM, billd766 said:

But who decides what is assessable and what is non-assessable income and what are they likely to be?

Expand  

 

Under the present system, the taxpayer determines which remittances are assessable according to the tax regulations.  Those that are assessable are included in the PIT calculations.  Those that are NOT assessable are NOT included in the PIT calculations.

 

Supporting documentation would be required if audited, but that doesn't seem to happen often.  I am aware of only two forum members subjected to audit; one was running a business in Thailand, the other was employed for years, quit the job and stopped filing returns.

 

No documentation normally needed if filing in person.  The clerk will ask source of remitted funds, you say "prior savings", clerk says "you no file."

  • Thanks 1
  • Agree 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 3:48 PM, NoDisplayName said:

Supporting documentation would be required if audited, but that doesn't seem to happen often.

Expand  

 

This is a significant issue in dealing with filing a tax return.

 

Reports from members who have filed online have said that no financial supporting documentation is required.

 

On the other hand, the RD handout being provided to foreign taxpayers in Item 3 instructs the taxpayer to "Please attach a copy of your bank statement."

 

With this, the RD will see incoming remittances into your bank accounts in Thailand, including both assessable income and income that is exempt from calculation of income tax, such as government pensions, social security, inheritances, etc. If this is done in person, the tax officer could screen out exempted assessable income items that have no place to be reported on a tax return.

 

image.thumb.png.d12d690f483da336fad268e428cb418e.png

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 4:07 PM, Guavaman said:

 

This is a significant issue in dealing with filing a tax return.

 

Reports from members who have filed online have said that no financial supporting documentation is required.

 

On the other hand, the RD handout being provided to foreign taxpayers in Item 3 instructs the taxpayer to "Please attach a copy of your bank statement."

 

With this, the RD will see incoming remittances into your bank accounts in Thailand, including both assessable income and income that is exempt from calculation of income tax, such as government pensions, social security, inheritances, etc. If this is done in person, the tax officer could screen out exempted assessable income items that have no place to be reported on a tax return.

 

 

Expand  

 

Just more paperwork IMHO.  As noted elsewhere in this forum, I won't be filing a Thai tax return for 2024 calendar/tax year per direction of a Thai RD official.

 

But if i did , to pass a Thai bank record, given my massive number of withdrawals, would be close to two dozen pages .  In the case of 2023 (if it were relevant which it is not) at most there would be 2 or 3 large remittances from outside of Thailand.  The other ~20 pages would be many many many local withdrawls for payments in Thailand (as I rarely use cash but almost always use bank transfer).  It would be a PIA for the RD to go through. 

 

I guess if it was me, I would mark up each page with a page number (if not already) and on first page note which pages had the few remittance to Thailand (via an edit) and then flag the remittances with a big red arrow (on the page where the few remittances were). The intent to make it easier for the RD to spot my legal tax free remittances.

 

It would  thou, as I noted,  be a big PIA for the RD official to dig through.

 

Brings to my mind a saying in regards to RD asking for this  .... "Be careful what you ask for".

.

Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 2:17 PM, Badrabbit said:

 

I could manage a small amount so I will use this Expat Thailand to get a TIN it costs 7,000bht which for me will be trouble free so dont mind the cost, all they want is a copy of your passport and visa.

My local tax office wanted documents from the UK in order to get a TIN, they said it can be difficult.

 

Expand  

Cyclist what is the 7,000 baht fee for exactly ?

  • Haha 1
Posted
  On 1/21/2025 at 4:07 PM, Guavaman said:

On the other hand, the RD handout being provided to foreign taxpayers in Item 3 instructs the taxpayer to "Please attach a copy of your bank statement."

Expand  

 

I'm going to bet a bottle of fish sauce that they are asking for a copy of your bank interest withholding statement.  Won't know until someone files and reports here.

 

Filed online 2023, no documentation requested.  Refund refunded.

 

Filed online 2024, also no documentation needed to file and be approved.  But ten days later received a request for a bank withholding statement.  If I submit that, I get a refund.  If I do not submit the form, I don't get a refund.  Either way the return has been accepted and approved.  I assume I can just ignore it, and forego the refund with no repercussions, but wouldn't claim to know for certain.  I'll get a statement next time I'm downtown, still have a couple months to respond.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   1 member





  • Topics

  • Popular Contributors

  • Latest posts...

    1. 50

      Canadian Tourist Fined for Spray-Painting Graffiti on Pattaya Electrical Boxes

    2. 1

      If a president of a superpower wanted to destroy his own country, what steps would he take?

    3. 14

      Luxury Furniture Fuss as State Audit Office Faces Backlash

  • Popular in The Pub

×
×
  • Create New...