Phuket Hammered Again: Thai Justice Under Fire

[LivinginKata]

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Phuket hammered again: Thai justice under fire

Phuket needs improvement in the 'marketing' of news overseas. Or is that something we ought not aspire to?

PHUKET: One of the many interesting aspects of being a journalist in Phuket is observing the way that stories we break here are picked up by foreign media outlets – and the spin that these outlets put on them.

Smaller countries often adopt an 'us-against-them' mentality when one of their own gets arrested in Thailand, rushing to defend the suspect and seizing the opportunity to criticize the Thai criminal justice system.

The latest case, of course, is that of the glamorous bar mat bandit, Annice Smoel, arrested for the theft of a bar mat in Patong. Photos and a summary of her agonizing sojourn in Phuket appear here.

Another example is the case of fugitive murder suspect Sam Van Treek. He was arrested in 2004 and charged with the murder of Phuket-based female dive instructor Chompoonut Jeab Kobram, who was stabbed 48 times in Mr Van Treek’s Pattaya apartment.

Van Treek was granted bail and fled to his native Belgium. From there he launched an assault on the Thai criminal justice system that became a veritable feast for the Belgian media, who appeared far more interested in the fugitive's account of how he managed to flee than the extremely serious charges and strong evidence against him.

Almost five years later, he remains at large, despite the efforts of the Attorney General’s office in Bangkok to have him extradited back to Thailand.

The Gazette's latest report on that case is available here.

Foreign media perceptions and treatment of cases like those of Mr Van Treek and Mrs Smoel stand in sharp contrast to the current tale of a German teenager who, for the past three months, has been held in detention at the Phuket Juvenile Observation and Protection Center.

The youth, arrested as a minor, is charged with conspiring to molest young schoolboys with alleged British pedophile Dax Young.

Mr Young allegedly preyed on schoolboys as young as nine years of age – as well as the German youth himself, who appeared in pornographic images that the police found when they searched Mr Young’s residence.

Though the crimes reportedly committed by the pair are of an extremely serious nature, there has been little international press coverage or debate over the German youth’s incarceration, or over the critical issue of whether or not he is, in fact, a perpetrator or just another of Mr Young’s victims. (Our latest coverage, here.)

In comparison, most of the stories in the international press about the Australian woman’s brief stint in a Phuket prison exuded, and often seemed to actively market, sympathy for the mother of eight.

Few indeed questioned why, if the Phuket police are to be believed, she was so insulting and dismissive toward them. Almost none queried why she was able to deride and scoff so openly at Thai law, or why, as a tourist, she should have enjoyed immunity from that law.

So she has departed the stage as a bit of a celebrity, and Thailand’s image as a tourist destination has suffered yet another major blow.

-- Phuket Gazette 2009-05-31 – Dan Waites and Stephen Fein

[Somtamnication]

A case of the pot calling the kettle black?

The other side to this story is PG refusing to write controversial or cases of misconduct by public officials or their advertisers, but the media that they are now castigating actually write about local issues, good or bad for the local image.

[sungate]

A case of the pot calling the kettle black?

The other side to this story is PG refusing to write controversial or cases of misconduct by public officials or their advertisers, but the media that they are now castigating actually write about local issues, good or bad for the local image.

I thought the story was 'right on', like why should Thailand allow tourists to do things Thais would be arrested for? Good question, na? Hmmmmm, I wonder where Mr Somtamnication is from )

[JiveTalker]

A case of the pot calling the kettle black?

The other side to this story is PG refusing to write controversial or cases of misconduct by public officials or their advertisers, but the media that they are now castigating actually write about local issues, good or bad for the local image.

I thought the story was 'right on', like why should Thailand allow tourists to do things Thais would be arrested for? Good question, na? Hmmmmm, I wonder where Mr Somtamnication is from )

I think you missed both the point of the article and the point of the reply. There are many times over the past years when stories or issues have not made the papers (this is not the fault of the Gazette, this is a problem all over Thailand), so as not to affect tourism. This may be the first time something that has happened in Thailand has perhaps been overplayed by the foreign media, and the paper has felt the need to publish this bizarre apology.

[Somtamnication]

Could not have said it better, Jive.

[Ping]

The other aspect, of course, is that had it occurred in Melbourne, she would have been given a caution notice.

I suppose much of the foreign media reaction may be related to the severity of repercussions, in Th, for this type of offence. I'm not condoning it - in fact, I consider that Ozzie penalties are far too wishy washy and offer little in the way of deterence - I'm merely speculating as to at least part of the reason for the foreign press reaction. I understand that the woman may have been a bit mouthy and that she fairly much brought the consequences upon herself. Most of us who are familiar with the way things work in Th would probably hold the same view. Certainly, the foreign press seem to have highlighted the human interest aspect of the story (to sell their papers) more than the cold hard facts and associated background. Should we be surprised?

[makavelithedon]

What actual stories to the PG actually break? The rare occasion I have bought it (and it was the same a few weeks ago as it was 5 years ago) it appeared nothing more than an outlet for advertsing hotels and housing and where 'news' is covered it just replicates other stories already in the media.

There is not an ounce of investigative journalism done ever.

As for the bar mat episode, maybe international media chose to 'defend and spin it' the way they did because 1 day in the local Thai cell was certainly punishment enough for such a pathetic story and episode.