Manchester United

[rijit]

Sorry. Can't resist it:

'If Everton were playing at the bottom of the garden, I'd pull the curtains.'

Bill Shankly.

tbh i was a bit like that with everton last season , you never know things might get better under martinez

[SinglePot]

I don't think Shanks would have signed Moysey.

[MrRed]

Shankly was a good manager,but he is not comparable to what Ferguson has won ....that is just a Liverpool dream.

How many trophy's did he win? 8?

[SinglePot]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

[MrRed]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

Just use Ferguson or me.

[SinglePot]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

Just use Ferguson or me.

Would You have chosen Moyes?

[rixalex]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

Just use Ferguson or me.

Would You have chosen Moyes?

To turn that question around, would you have chosen Ferguson?

[rixalex]

Deleted multiple post.

Edited July 10, 2013 by rixalex

[rixalex]

Deleted multiple post.

Edited July 10, 2013 by rixalex

[SinglePot]

irrelevant and impossible to answer.

Would You choose Moyes?

[rixalex]

irrelevant and impossible to answer.

Would You choose Moyes?

It's not irrelevant at all, and why is it impossible to answer? Imagine yourself in 1986, looking for a manager who would be capable of bringing over two decades of unprecedented success to a club. Would you have gone for Fergie? Yes or no?

If the answer is no, how well placed do you think you are to judge what Moyes will do?

As for whether i would have chosen Moyes, i had three or four possible right men for the job, and Moyes was one of them. He wasn't the only person i would have been happy with, but he was one of them.

[carmine]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

Just use Ferguson or me.

Would You have chosen Moyes?

To turn that question around, would you have chosen Ferguson?

With all respect Ferguson had already worked wonders at Aberdeen. No comparison can be drawn to those of Moyes

[SinglePot]

up to you buddy

I didn't know ferguson in 1986

[SinglePot]

"As for whether i would have chosen Moyes, i had three or four possible right men for the job, and Moyes was one of them. He wasn't the only person i would have been happy with, but he was one of them."

Sounds like a kop out and a recipe for failure.

My regard for united is rapidly dwindling.

[carmine]

"As for whether i would have chosen Moyes, i had three or four possible right men for the job, and Moyes was one of them. He wasn't the only person i would have been happy with, but he was one of them."

Sounds like a kop out and a recipe for failure.

My regard for united is rapidly dwindling.

I would stake a guess that the potential first choice is now the incumbent at Bayern Munich

[SinglePot]

and if they pi** all over united I will be laughing.

[rixalex]

"As for whether i would have chosen Moyes, i had three or four possible right men for the job, and Moyes was one of them. He wasn't the only person i would have been happy with, but he was one of them."

Sounds like a kop out and a recipe for failure.

My regard for united is rapidly dwindling.

I would stake a guess that the potential first choice is now the incumbent at Bayern Munich

Not for me. Still much to prove and not a man i can see hanging around at a club more than three of four years. Five at max.

[SinglePot]

I'll leave this little matter in your capable hands carmine.

Make sure spurs p*** all over them too.

[rixalex]

With all respect Ferguson had already worked wonders at Aberdeen. No comparison can be drawn to those of Moyes

In this day and age, and with the budget he had, I think Moyes worked relative wonders at Everton. Minor wonders perhaps, but wonders none the less.

With regards Fergie, yes he had done well at Aberdeen, but based on that, are you saying that were you back in 86 right now, you'd be predicting him to go on at United and win all that he did?

[carmine]

"As for whether i would have chosen Moyes, i had three or four possible right men for the job, and Moyes was one of them. He wasn't the only person i would have been happy with, but he was one of them."

Sounds like a kop out and a recipe for failure.

My regard for united is rapidly dwindling.

I would stake a guess that the potential first choice is now the incumbent at Bayern Munich

Not for me. Still much to prove and not a man i can see hanging around at a club more than three of four years. Five at max.

Oh i couldn't agree more he's a lot to prove! However, he's been successful, he's young and he promotes the type of football that most if not all like to see.

[rijit]

Fair point.

I merely use Shankly as the epitome of truth without bull sh**.

Just use Ferguson or me.

Would You have chosen Moyes?

To turn that question around, would you have chosen Ferguson?

At the time yes no doubts I would have picked ferguson, he did total wonders at Aberdeen

[rixalex]

Not for me. Still much to prove and not a man i can see hanging around at a club more than three of four years. Five at max.

Oh i couldn't agree more he's a lot to prove! However, he's been successful, he's young and he promotes the type of football that most if not all like to see.

Yeah but look at what he has had to manage.

And as for the young thing, i don't see that as an advantage, at least not in terms of long term stability. Young guys don't tend to stick around for the long haul.

[rixalex]

At the time yes no doubts I would have picked ferguson, he did total wonders at Aberdeen

The pick of any manager from around the world, and you are saying you would have gone for Ferguson?

[SinglePot]

Happy Christmas Mr Moyes.

With supporters like you he's got every chance.

[rijit]

With all respect Ferguson had already worked wonders at Aberdeen. No comparison can be drawn to those of Moyes

In this day and age, and with the budget he had, I think Moyes worked relative wonders at Everton. Minor wonders perhaps, but wonders none the less.

With regards Fergie, yes he had done well at Aberdeen, but based on that, are you saying that were you back in 86 right now, you'd be predicting him to go on at United and win all that he did?

did he do wonders at everton ? he wasn't exactly starved of cash, the money he had, IMO, was a fair reflection of where he finished with them

he had a lot larger transfer kitty than say some relegated teams and not so large as the champion league teams, never short of 5 -10 mill or touch more like fellaine, he just used to whinge and whine A LOT that he was restricted, he just had to be careful, no harm in that though. as i said so a mid to top 6-10 finish was about right, Personally didnt like the style of football he used at everton, perhaps with better players he can change that.

[rijit]

At the time yes no doubts I would have picked ferguson, he did total wonders at Aberdeen

The pick of any manager from around the world, and you are saying you would have gone for Ferguson?

it was a diferent era, as a rule of thumb, top european managers didnt come to england and top english managers didnt do abroad

and yes out of what was avaibible at the time he would have been one , if not, the top, preferred choice

[SinglePot]

stop pussying about rij

He hasn't got a cat in hells chance in Europe.

premier league? Top 6 if he's lucky.

[rijit]

just for the record,,scholar,had agreed, /shaken hands on a deal with fergie , only for his mrs to say she wouldn't move to London.!!!!!

[SinglePot]

You've lost me

[rijit]

stop pussying about rij,

He hasn't got a cat in hells chance in Europe.

premier league? Top 6 if he's lucky.

I cant really be so categorical on it single, 2 major things that go in his favor is that he's got the players and the budget , so who knows, ,but tbh its his to fuc up .