Jump to content

British grandfather facing 360 lashes in Saudi Arabia for making wine


webfact

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 138
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Note to self: Respect culture and rules while a guest in another country. wub.png

You should you are 100% correct.

However, for someone who is not a muslim and does not recognise (or fully understand) their laws this seems ridiculously brutal for making some wine.

Ok, he deserved to be punished but 14 months inside and now 350 lashes is absolutely barbaric and in my opinion has no place in the modern world.

I hope he is released and allowed to go home safely to his family..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He play he loose

It's very pity but alcohol is a very sensitive issue for Saudi cleric. Zero tolerance.

If this britain would drink alcohol why did you not do it like Saudi: cross the bridge of shame between Saudi Arabia and bahrain

death wish.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats the one country I wouldnt mind ISIS invading.................

You would be willing to give ISIS access to the fortunes of the Saudi oil fields because some guy screwed up and got caught carrying wine in his car?

He's the one that made the wine, he's the one that was drinking it and he's the one that got caught up in it.

My guess is he will serve some jail time and then be deported PNG to a life of drinking his wine legally.

I would be surprised if he ever receives one lash.

I have to wonder how well you know the Tragic Kingdom. one westerner got hundreds of lashes and deportation afterwards, for having a one-year supply of Xanax without a prescription.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Note to self: Respect culture and rules while a guest in another country. wub.png

I would expect the Muslim communities in the UK and Europe to do the same. Sharia patrols in Muslim areas is outside European law yet it is tolerated. Here is a clip from 60 minutes a US investigative news program like the UK's Panorama.

The people conducting these so called patrols are breaking the law, are arrested, are tried and are imprisoned.

For example: Muslim vigilantes jailed for 'sharia law' attacks in London

Furthermore, they are condemned by the local Muslim community.

For example: Muslims condemn behaviour of Islamic vigilantes

Of course, the various hate sites are happy to highlight the patrols and try to convince the gullible that such things are the norm: but they always totally ignore the response to these illegal acts by the police, courts and local community.

The reason for that is obvious.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Note to self: Respect culture and rules while a guest in another country. wub.png

You should you are 100% correct.

However, for someone who is not a muslim and does not recognise (or fully understand) their laws this seems ridiculously brutal for making some wine.

Ok, he deserved to be punished but 14 months inside and now 350 lashes is absolutely barbaric and in my opinion has no place in the modern world.

I hope he is released and allowed to go home safely to his family..

I agree that the punishment is barbaric; but it is the law in that country and as said before by others he has lived in Saudi long enough to know the law and the consequences of breaking it.

We expect foreigners in our countries to abide by our laws and to suffer the consequences if they break any of them.

Whether or not the Saudi authorities will show clemency due to his age, we will have to wait and see. I hope that they do.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Note to self: Respect culture and rules while a guest in another country. wub.png

You should you are 100% correct.

However, for someone who is not a muslim and does not recognise (or fully understand) their laws this seems ridiculously brutal for making some wine.

Ok, he deserved to be punished but 14 months inside and now 350 lashes is absolutely barbaric and in my opinion has no place in the modern world.

I hope he is released and allowed to go home safely to his family..

I agree that the punishment is barbaric; but it is the law in that country and as said before by others he has lived in Saudi long enough to know the law and the consequences of breaking it.

We expect foreigners in our countries to abide by our laws and to suffer the consequences if they break any of them.

Whether or not the Saudi authorities will show clemency due to his age, we will have to wait and see. I hope that they do.

That's just the trouble, we don't, there is always a PC apologist making excuses for their ''different culture'' and we should understand the primitives

Edited by soalbundy
Link to comment
Share on other sites

better stay in the western world nowadays to avoid the savages .

Why do people in this day and age still work or go on holiday to a Muslim country?

Their brains did not even reach the airport.

Because not every Muslim country is as strict as Saudi Arabia.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

david cameron is busy housing syrians and handing them out benefits to help his fellow countryman

Yes the great humanitarian. Someday this will come back to bite him in the posterior. Not that he will care he will collecting his generous government pension in some out of the way place.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just bear in mind that many Saudis would be quite happy if they could drink in their own country.

It is the ruling family that forbid it and enforce it with madmen because they are desperate to control every aspect of their citizens' lives.

So don't be so hard on all of them.

I saw one in Pattaya at the magic roundabout in Ramadhan and these two Indonesian muslim fellers came up to him and started berating him for drinking.

He very calmly, and politely, in English, explained to them that his relationship with his God was none of their business and that they should go and harass someone interested, which they did.

Then he carried on getting blitzed.

Subsequently transpired that he was Western educated of course.

I also watched another Saudi with a wicked sense of humour serenade some of his countrymen in a Gulf Bar. It was Karaoke with the band night, and he taught them the chords then belted it out, much to our amusement and their confusion. The song?

biggrin.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This man has brought this problem onto his own head.

Allegedly he has lived/worked in Saudi for 25 years so he should know what the "rules" are.

The Saudis are remarkably tolerant of Western lifestyles as long as it is kept within the gated compounds where most expats live.

By transporting alcohol he knowingly broke Saudi Law.

Well done - defending Laws dated back to the stoneage ... Its wine for God sake, its not like he forced a 9 year old girl to marry him ... ups, forgot thats okay in Saudi sick.gifsick.gifsick.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Saudis usually ignore westerners making alcohol for their own consumption. The severity of the sentence and the fact that he had lived there for 25 years leads me to conclude that he was making alcohol to sell. Why was it in his car if he wasn't not delivering it?

Thrash him, I say. He should respect the laws of the country he chose tho live in. Sorry I can't be sympathetic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats the one country I wouldnt mind ISIS invading.................

You would be willing to give ISIS access to the fortunes of the Saudi oil fields because some guy screwed up and got caught carrying wine in his car?

He's the one that made the wine, he's the one that was drinking it and he's the one that got caught up in it.

My guess is he will serve some jail time and then be deported PNG to a life of drinking his wine legally.

I would be surprised if he ever receives one lash.

I don;t think he was transporting wine in his car. He was making wine and selling it to Saudis which is a whole other thing. Saudis don't mind westerners drinking and making home brew in their compounds, but they draw a line at selling it to Saudis. This guy has been there for 25 years. He is past working age and is making lots of money brewing and selling alcohol to Saudis. He knew the risks and took them to make large amounts of money. If you can't do the time, don't do the crime. I live here in Thailand, I respect the laws of the country whether I agree with them or not. No-one forced me to live here. Same with this guy, who does he think he is flouting the law then complaining when he's caught. Thrash him hard, I say.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats the one country I wouldnt mind ISIS invading.................

You would be willing to give ISIS access to the fortunes of the Saudi oil fields because some guy screwed up and got caught carrying wine in his car?

He's the one that made the wine, he's the one that was drinking it and he's the one that got caught up in it.

My guess is he will serve some jail time and then be deported PNG to a life of drinking his wine legally.

I would be surprised if he ever receives one lash.

I have to wonder how well you know the Tragic Kingdom. one westerner got hundreds of lashes and deportation afterwards, for having a one-year supply of Xanax without a prescription.

How about a link to that. I found a couple of Aussies receiving lashes after they were caught making and selling sid but nothing about a Xanax caper.

Over the years a couple of my employees were caught for the same thing, arrested, sentenced to lashes, spent some time in prison and then sent packing without being lashed.

But that's just my experience.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This man has brought this problem onto his own head.

Allegedly he has lived/worked in Saudi for 25 years so he should know what the "rules" are.

The Saudis are remarkably tolerant of Western lifestyles as long as it is kept within the gated compounds where most expats live.

By transporting alcohol he knowingly broke Saudi Law.

But their own go to farangland to do what they can't do in their own country...Even hi-so's..........coffee1.gif

So what's your point (if any) Transam? They go outside to partake of things illegal in their own country but LEGAL in "farangland" as you call it. Unfortunately this man was doing something ILLEGAL...does that make it clear for you?

I think he is saying that the Saudi's are hypocrites which they are

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This man has brought this problem onto his own head.

Allegedly he has lived/worked in Saudi for 25 years so he should know what the "rules" are.

The Saudis are remarkably tolerant of Western lifestyles as long as it is kept within the gated compounds where most expats live.

By transporting alcohol he knowingly broke Saudi Law.

But their own go to farangland to do what they can't do in their own country...Even hi-so's..........coffee1.gif

So what's your point (if any) Transam? They go outside to partake of things illegal in their own country but LEGAL in "farangland" as you call it. Unfortunately this man was doing something ILLEGAL...does that make it clear for you?

I think he is saying that the Saudi's are hypocrites which they are

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This man has brought this problem onto his own head.

Allegedly he has lived/worked in Saudi for 25 years so he should know what the "rules" are.

The Saudis are remarkably tolerant of Western lifestyles as long as it is kept within the gated compounds where most expats live.

By transporting alcohol he knowingly broke Saudi Law.

Well done - defending Laws dated back to the stoneage ... Its wine for God sake, its not like he forced a 9 year old girl to marry him ... ups, forgot thats okay in Saudi sick.gifsick.gifsick.gif

There seems to be something missing in many of the posts and that is they have laws and they enforce them. Most of the posts appear to be taking the line "it is just drink". How many of the people posting here know the reason for alcohol being banned in Saudi? I bet not many if any and it has nothing to do the Sharia law

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hideous inhumane country but if you live there you should know the risks and not do what you're not prepared to suffer for. I feel for this guy and his family but if you want to play with vipers expect to get bitten!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.











×
×
  • Create New...