Is Trump's Gaza idea possible?

[cdemundo]

It's easy to shoot down controversial ideas but when everything else has failed is this a possibility?

I am not a Trump supporter in general but I wonder if this idea could be a good one.

[Nick Carter icp]

It will take another year or so to finish knocking it all down , then it would take a few years to remove all the rubble , say about five years , then they have to design the whole city, get plans drawn up by architects  , they have to find the funds to finance it .

   Its going to take 30-50 years to rebuild Gaza 

   

[Purdey]

It may be possible, but will the area be full of Trump Tower, Trump Hotel, Trump Casino?

[JBChiangRai]

Moving Palestinians against their will is illegal.

 

If you don't forcibly move them, I would rather see America than Isreal occupy Gaza.  Americans don't hate Arabs, Israeli's do.

[Hamus Yaigh]

11 minutes ago, cdemundo said:

It's easy to shoot down controversial ideas but when everything else has failed is this a possibility?

I am not a Trump supporter in general but I wonder if this idea could be a good one.

Since he is not going to pay for it or put troops on the ground there, besides the international objections, I'd risk a guess and say no.

[Centigrade32]

On 2/7/2025 at 8:00 AM, cdemundo said:

It's easy to shoot down controversial ideas but when everything else has failed is this a possibility?

I am not a Trump supporter in general but I wonder if this idea could be a good one.

 

Do you think this is Trump's idea or someone else's idea?

 

From March 2024:

 

 

[cdemundo]

3 hours ago, Centigrade32 said:

 

Do you think this is Trump's idea or someone else's idea?

 

From March 2024:

 

 

Whoever came up with the idea.

 

Anything seems worth considering since nothing has worked.

[NickyLouie]

On 2/7/2025 at 3:12 PM, JBChiangRai said:

Moving Palestinians against their will is illegal.

 

If you don't forcibly move them, I would rather see America than Isreal occupy Gaza.  Americans don't hate Arabs, Israeli's do.

 

🇺🇸

naw we H8T them also , 

 

 

[Centigrade32]

3 hours ago, cdemundo said:

Whoever came up with the idea.

 

Anything seems worth considering since nothing has worked.

 

Ridiculous. Not only is it reprehensible, but there is also the glaring conflict of interest. 

[Centigrade32]

29 minutes ago, NickyLouie said:

 

🇺🇸

naw we H8T them also , 

 

 

 

Hate them so much but happily taking their money. 

[save the frogs]

3 hours ago, cdemundo said:

Whoever came up with the idea.

 

Anything seems worth considering since nothing has worked.

that's my view.

and even though the people there don't initially go along with it, that still doesnt necessarily mean it's a bad idea.

people are resistant to change.

but their culture will be preserved.

so they may thank trump later on.

 

[tomazbodner]

hmmm...

 

 

[MicroB]

It will be a criminal act. The plan falls down when the US leader says no US taxpayer money will be used. I don't see any pubicly listed bank willing to break international law to loan a developer.

 

The only way evacuation of a population for safety reasons could be considered legal is if the population was transferred to Israel. The act of sending them to a 3rd country is illegal.

[Yagoda]

Anyone got a better idea other than destroying Israel and killing all the Jews? I'm sure that plan would get a ton of votes here.

12 minutes ago, MicroB said:

It will be a criminal act

Based on the tenor your posts, it was a criminal act to have the Nuremberg tribunals.

 

Have you resigned yourself to the state of Jewish and Israeli power in the world yet?

 

[thaibeachlovers]

On 2/7/2025 at 9:00 PM, cdemundo said:

It's easy to shoot down controversial ideas but when everything else has failed is this a possibility?

I am not a Trump supporter in general but I wonder if this idea could be a good one.

Given every Arab country involved has rejected the idea, and none will take them, it seems that it's irrelevant if good or not. Short of resettling them in Israel they are there to stay, though I do not envy them trying to survive in a wasteland. I fear the greatest tragedy is yet to befall them.

[Nick Carter icp]

7 minutes ago, thaibeachlovers said:

Given every Arab country involved has rejected the idea, and none will take them, it seems that it's irrelevant if good or not. Short of resettling them in Israel they are there to stay, though I do not envy them trying to survive in a wasteland. I fear the greatest tragedy is yet to befall them.

 

   Putin has stated that he would be willing to take them in , Palestinians can move to Russia and join the army there 

[JeffersLos]

Make one giant Palestinian state in place of Israel, rehouse any Israelis that would like to leave in various Western countries. 🙂

[Nick Carter icp]

6 minutes ago, JeffersLos said:

Make one giant Palestinian state in place of Israel, rehouse any Israelis that would like to leave in various Western countries. 🙂

 

   So, you do favour a genocide .

I thought that Palestinian supporters  were opposed to genocides