Report Thai Schoolboy Allegedly Uses AI to Create and Share Nude Images of Classmates

[Cameroni]

4 minutes ago, simon43 said:

  How you can defend his position is beyond my understanding

 

Because it's not child porn!!! It's just fantasy art! It's not real!

 

I'm aware of the legal position, but the law is obviously wrong in this case. It's creating a fake construct for policy reasons.

 

AI images are not real. How can it be "child porn"?  It's fake!

[TimBKK]

1 hour ago, Cameroni said:

 

Because it's not child porn!!! It's just fantasy art! It's not real!

 

I'm aware of the legal position, but the law is obviously wrong in this case. It's creating a fake construct for policy reasons.

 

AI images are not real. How can it be "child porn"?  It's fake!

I think we found the AI kid’s dad

[NoDisplayName]

15 hours ago, Cameroni said:

How is this a "disturbing" incident? The images are not real. It's FAKE. It's not like he forced the girls to do the acts depicted in the FAKE photos.

 

Again, these are FAKE images. Not real.

 

Are we going to send people to prison for fantasy and FAKE images now?

 

Do me favour.

 

South Korea has the answer.

 

Johnny Somali Guaranteed Prison Time in South Korea After AI Deepfake Scandal

The controversial American live streamer, notorious for his brazen antics and public disruptions, is now guaranteed to face prison time in South Korea. A fifth and most severe charge violating the country’s Special Act on Sexual Violence Crimes has obliterated any remaining hope for leniency.

..

Prosecutors revealed that Somali is now facing charges for violating South Korea’s Special Act on Sexual Violence Crimes. The charge stems from an AI-generated deepfake video that depicted popular Korean streamer BongBong in fabricated intimate scenes with Somali.

Under South Korean law, the creation, distribution, or possession of non-consensual AI-generated explicit content is classified as a sexual crime. Legal experts have confirmed that this offense carries a mandatory prison sentence of up to seven years.

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/johnny-somali-guaranteed-prison-time-222406985.html?guccounter=1

[richard_smith237]

5 hours ago, Cameroni said:

 

Obviously fake.

 

But it doesn't matter how realistic they are. Fake is Fake! It's not real!

 

You would punish someone over pixels? That depict things that are not real?

 

Seriously?

 

Yes........ we already do with slander and libel...    

[Celsius]

Remember how 10-15 years ago, many of your family and friends swore they'd never post anything on Facebook?
 

You thought they were really odd, but here we are. The criminal Zuck owns all that you ever posted including your kids and pets. Be ready for those images to be harvested by AI.

[Purdey]

I agree with some who understand these are fake photos, created as the result of a fetid child mind. Put him into psychiatric care for a few months but not prison, where worse criminals will abuse him physically.

[Freddy42OZ]

11 hours ago, simon43 said:

You really have no idea of how realistic images can be when created by AI.

 

Tell me, is this image of a 20 year old female tennis player real or fake?

 

 

Fake

[gravity101]

23 hours ago, Presnock said:

I am not sure what you mean as there can only be one sided against the kid producing the photos/videos and still doing it and showing no remorse.  

Well that's the whole point isnt it. That's one side of the story by it's very definition. Who said he had no remorse? Who said he carried on doing it? Hell we dont even know how old he is! Hey I'm not defending him by any means, but kids are kids and we dont know the other side at all.

[Cameroni]

6 hours ago, richard_smith237 said:

 

Yes........ we already do with slander and libel...    

 

Only if it is shown that they caused harm.

[Cameroni]

7 hours ago, NoDisplayName said:

Under South Korean law, the creation, distribution, or possession of non-consensual AI-generated explicit content is classified as a sexual crime. Legal experts have confirmed that this offense carries a mandatory prison sentence of up to seven years.

 

Lol, this is is insane!

 

The world is turning mad. 

 

How are fake AI images a "sexual crime"? They depict scenes that are not real. 

 

We can't distinguish between reality and fantasy now?

 

Surely this is a clear sign the world has gone mad.

[simon43]

"How are fake AI images a "sexual crime"? They depict scenes that are not real"

 

The important point is that fake AI images are often believed by the viewer to be real images - the image-creation software is so good.

 

If you see a 'photo' of President Trump fighting a T-Rex dinosaur, then you know that it is fake.  If you see a 'photo' of a clearly-underage naked girl, does it matter if it's made by AI or a genuine photo? It's still child porn and therefore illegal in many jurisdictions.

[richard_smith237]

2 hours ago, Cameroni said:

9 hours ago, richard_smith237 said:

 

Yes........ we already do with slander and libel...    

 

Only if it is shown that they caused harm.

 

And you think posting a lifelike naked AI photo of a school child is not going to cause any harm ???

 

... The damage to their mental well being can be devastating...   plenty of harm caused.

 

The little cretin bulling girls like this needs to be dealt with now... 

[richard_smith237]

2 hours ago, Cameroni said:

Lol, this is is insane!

 

The world is turning mad. 

 

How are fake AI images a "sexual crime"? They depict scenes that are not real. 

 

We can't distinguish between reality and fantasy now?

 

Surely this is a clear sign the world has gone mad.

 

No...  but this is a clear sign you are looking at the issue from a myopic perspective. 

 

As mentioned earlier: At a well known school in Bangkok, two girls had their faces photo shopped on a the naked bodies of young women... I've no idea how 'well' this was carried out as I never saw the photo's - however, the photos spread, damaged the reputations of the girls... Mud sticks whether its accurate or not.

The boy was expelled, I think police charges were filed. The girls moved to a different school.

 

 

What's mad to me is any 'adult' not understanding the harm such behavior can do.  

AI produces lifelike images now, and whether an image is genuine or not reputations can be damaged, harm can be caused, and ridicule is the intent...     

 

 

 

Imagine you had a 15 year old daughter and some cretin is using AI to super impose real photos of girls faces onto naked bodies and circulating them on social media - I don't know any father who wouldn't be in that school demanding heads to roll.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[fredwiggy]

2 hours ago, Cameroni said:

 

Lol, this is is insane!

 

The world is turning mad. 

 

How are fake AI images a "sexual crime"? They depict scenes that are not real. 

 

We can't distinguish between reality and fantasy now?

 

Surely this is a clear sign the world has gone mad.

 We all see images of all kinds of women that are legal age posted online, but these are innocent schoolgirls who need a chance to stay innocent, especially when many of their peers are acting the whore for attention. Girls here are attacked in school at one of the highest rates worldwide. It's not that they are fake. It's that the real girl's faces are put on porn images that's illegal, especially if they post them online. Girls have enough trouble here with the second class citizen demeaning, and at those ages, fitting in means everything, and is one reason some take their own lives. This embarrassment can hurt some to the core. Think if this was your daughter how would you feel and react. I know what I would do. Edit: Beat me to it Richard.

[simon43]

2 hours ago, fredwiggy said:

 We all see images of all kinds of women that are legal age posted online, but these are innocent schoolgirls who need a chance to stay innocent, especially when many of their peers are acting the whore for attention. Girls here are attacked in school at one of the highest rates worldwide. It's not that they are fake. It's that the real girl's faces are put on porn images that's illegal, especially if they post them online. Girls have enough trouble here with the second class citizen demeaning, and at those ages, fitting in means everything, and is one reason some take their own lives. This embarrassment can hurt some to the core. Think if this was your daughter how would you feel and react. I know what I would do. Edit: Beat me to it Richard.

Agree with all the above.  My previous comments are from the perspective of a school teacher (and father).  This isn't some minor offence by the boy - it can cause serious and lasting mental harm to those girls.