File photo courtesy of BC News

 

Zohran Mamdani, New York City's Democratic mayoral nominee, issued a controversial statement on the second anniversary of the October 7 attacks. He expressed sorrow for Israeli victims and hostages still held by Hamas while criticising both the US and Israeli governments for their roles in the ongoing conflict. The remarks have prompted a harsh response from the Israeli Foreign Ministry.

 

Mamdani described the 2021 attack by Hamas as a "horrific war crime," acknowledging the loss of over 1,100 Israeli lives and the kidnapping of 250 others. However, his comments took a critical turn as he accused the US government of being "complicit" in what he termed a "genocidal war." He cited the toll of more than 67,000 deaths and widespread destruction in Gaza, calling for an end to the conflict.

 

In response, Israel's Foreign Ministry rebuked Mamdani on social media, accusing him of echoing "Hamas propaganda." The Ministry contended that his statement legitimised terror and fostered antisemitism, claiming he only stood with Jews posthumously.

 

The ongoing conflict in Gaza has become a focal point in New York City's mayoral race due to its significant Jewish population, as well as a notable Arab community, including Palestinians. This week, Mamdani interacted with families affected by the conflict, further emphasising his complex stance on the issue.

 

Despite his criticism of the Israeli government, Mamdani supports Israel's existence as a state offering equal rights. His comments have sparked opposition from segments of New York's Jewish community, prompting discussions with both supporters and critics. Mamdani has reiterated his opposition to antisemitism and committed to ensuring synagogue security if elected.

 

 

Key Takeaways:

 

• Zohran Mamdani's statement on the October 7 attacks has elicited strong backlash from Israel.
• He criticised the US and Israeli governments, referencing significant death tolls in Gaza.
• Mamdani’s views have implications for New York’s mayoral race given the city's diverse community.

 

  Adapted by ASEAN Now from CNN 2025-10-08

 

 

An apparently radical Musim communist is going to be the next Mayor of New York. 

 

How great is that? 

1 minute ago, Yellowtail said:

An apparently radical Musim communist is going to be the next Mayor of New York. 

 

How great is that? 

it's going to be awesome to watch.   Check out the race in Minneapolis, there are 15 candidates and rank choice voting. 

2 minutes ago, Mike_Hunt said:

it's going to be awesome to watch.   Check out the race in Minneapolis, there are 15 candidates and rank choice voting. 

Where's @spidermike? I think he's a New Yorker, he must love this guy.