Flood Protection With Sandbags

[ExpatOilWorker]

I don't see any of the below guidelines applied when throwing together the hastily build sandbag barriers that is suppose to protect Bangkok. No wonder they collapse one after the other.

Anything about 5 feet seem like a mementous task.

Sandbagging for Flood ProtectionAE-626 (Revised), February 2011

Kenneth Hellevang, Extension Engineer

Adobe Acrobat PDF version suitable for printing. (170KB)

A sandbag dike must be built properly to prevent or reduce flood damage.

Managing Volunteers

Since a dike will fail if not built correctly, training people on proper procedures for placing sandbags is very important. In the rush, volunteers will do something, but the result frequently is a dike that performs poorly or fails. Put a high priority on planning and organization. Identifying a supervisor for the project is recommended.

Sandbags

Bags are made from various materials, but the most common is woven polypropylene. They usually measure about 14 inches wide and 24 to 26 inches long. Other sizes of bags also are available, but bags are easier to handle if their weight with filling in them is limited to 35 to 40 pounds.

Sand is the easiest material for filling and shaping sandbags. Silt and clay in bags will form a good dike, but working with those materials is more difficult. Fill sandbags slightly more than one-half full.

Contact your county emergency management office for information on where to obtain sandbags.

Site Selection

When selecting the location for the dike, take advantage of natural land features that keep the dike as short and low as possible. Avoid obstructions that would weaken the dike. Do not build the dike against a building wall due to the forces the dike may place on the building. Leave at least 8 feet to maneuver between the dike and buildings for observation, pumping seepage water and other activities.

Since friction holds a dike from sliding, create a good bond between the ground and the dike. Remove ice and snow since it will melt permitting water to flow under the dike. Remove anything else that is "slippery." If the dike is to be more than about 3 feet high, dig a bonding trench where the dike will be placed if possible. The trench should be about 4 to 6 inches deep and 18 to 24 inches wide.

Stacking sandbags with a base width three times the height

Estimate Sandbags Needed

Build the dike at least 1 foot higher than the projected crest level to allow for fluctuations in the water level. Local experience will assist in determining the amount of freeboard to provide.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers recommends building a dike with a width at the base that is three times the dike height. For example, a 4-foot-high dike would have a base width of 12 feet. The corps indicates that each foot of finished dike length requires one bag, each foot of height requires three bags, and each 2.5 feet of width requires three bags. This results in each bag having placed dimensions of about 4 inches high by 10 inches wide by 14 inches long.

Use the following equation to estimate the number of bags required per linear foot of dike for a dike with a base width that is three times the height.

N = (3 x H) + (9 x H x H) / 2

N -- Number of bags required per linear foot of dike

H -- Dike height (feet)

Example:

Estimate the number of bags required per linear foot for a dike 3 feet tall.

N = (3 x 3) + (9 x 3 x 3) / 2 = 45 bags

The estimated number of bags needed for 100 linear feet of dike is:

1-foot-high dike: 600

2-foot-high dike: 2,100

3-foot-high dike: 4,500

4-foot-high dike: 7,800

A common recommendation is to make the dike twice as wide as its height. This is a minimum width-to-height ratio that should be used. The estimated number of bags needed for this ratio is in the following table. This is based on each bag having placed dimensions of about 4 to 5 inches high by 9 to 10 inches wide by 14 inches long.

The estimated number of bags needed for 100 linear feet of dike that it twice as wide as its height is:

1-foot-high dike: 600

2-foot-high dike: 1,700

3-foot-high dike: 3,000

4-foot-high dike: 5,500

5-foot-high dike: 9,000

Dimensions of a dike that is twice as wide as it is tall.

A cubic yard will fill about 100 30-pound sandbags or about 75 40-pound bags, assuming the sand weighs 110 pounds per cubic foot. Sand weighs 100 to 130 pounds per cubic foot, depending on moisture content and packing. A cubic yard is 27 cubic feet. Each 14-inch by 24-inch bag will hold about 0.4 cubic feet if filled about one-half full. Based on volume, each yard will fill about 67 bags one-half full.

Estimated cubic yards of sand needed per 100 feet of dike length for various dike heights and ratios of height to width. An additional 2 cubic yards will be needed for bags to hold the plastic.

Dike Height (ft.)

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.5

4.5

5.0

Cubic Yards of Sand

Width

3 x H

7

15

25

38

54

73

95

119

145

Width

2 x H

6

11

18

27

38

50

65

82

100

This volume is calculated based on a center section that is 9 inches wide and the remainder is in a triangular shape.

Filling Sandbags

Fill the bags about one-half full and tie the bag near the top, if it is tied, which permits the sand to move easily in the bag to create a good dike. Overfilled bags and bags tied too low leave gaps in the dike, which allows water to seep through. Sandbags do not need to be tied unless they are transported. Filling sandbags usually is a two-person operation. One member of the team holds the bag on the ground slightly in front of his or her spread feet and the second shovels the sand into the bag. Use gloves to protect the bag holder's hands. The use of safety goggles is desirable, especially during dry and windy days. For large-scale operations, filling sandbags can be expedited by using bag-holding racks, funnels on the back of dump trucks used for sanding operations and various power loading equipment. However, the special equipment required is not always available during an emergency.

Stacking Sandbags

Lift bags using your legs and limit twisting of your back. Gently hand the sandbag to the next person in a sandbag brigade or line.

A triangular or pyramid shape for the dike is not necessary if the height will be 1 foot or less. Support the wall of sandbags with "clusters" of bags every 5 feet to stabilize the sandbag wall so it does not tip over from the force exerted by the floodwater.

Place the first layer of bags lengthwise on the dike (parallel to the flow), lapping the bags so the filled portion of one bag lies on the unfilled portion of the next, with the tied or open end of the bag facing downstream. Offset adjacent rows or layers by one-half bag length to eliminate continuous joints, similar to what is done laying bricks. Compact and shape each bag by walking on it to develop dike strength and create a tight seal. Continue to walk on the bags as succeeding layers are placed.

Plan of bottom layer

|

Place bags parallel to the flow of water

|

Lapping sandbags

The base of the dike should be about two to three times as wide as the dike is high to provide adequate strength and friction surface area. Water exerts a tremendous force against the dike. Estimate the pressure on the dike base by multiplying the water depth by 62 pounds. For example, the pressure that 5 feet of water exerts on the base of a dike is about 310 pounds per square foot. The force of 5 feet of water on a vertical wall is about 775 pounds per linear foot of wall. Flowing water striking the dike exerts even more force on the dike. A triangular-shaped dike permits the weight of the water to push down on the dike to help hold it in place.

Sealing the Dike

The finished dike should be sealed with a sheet of plastic to improve water tightness. Spread a layer of soil or sand 1 inch deep and about 1 foot wide along the bottom of the dike on the water side. Lay polyethylene plastic sheeting so the bottom extends 1 foot beyond the bottom edge of the dike over the loose soil or sand. The upper edge should extend over the top of the dike. Poly sheeting at least 6 mils thick is preferred. It generally is available in 100-foot rolls from construction supply firms, lumberyards and farm stores. Do not put plastic sheeting under the bags since that will increase the potential for the dike to slide.

If more than one sheet of plastic is used, the poly sheeting should be placed from downstream to upstream and the next sheet upstream overlapped by at least 3 feet. Overlapping in this direction prevents the current from flowing under the overlap and tearing the poly loose.

Lay the plastic sheeting down very loosely. The pressure of the water will make the plastic conform easily to the sandbag surface. If the plastic is stretched too tightly, the water force could puncture it. Place a row of sandbags on the bottom edge of the plastic to form a watertight seal along the water side. Place sandbags to hold down the top edge of the plastic. Avoid puncturing the plastic with sharp objects or by walking on it.

Sealing the dike

Controlling Seepage

Use a sump or skimmer pump to remove water that permeates through the dike. A 5-gallon pail with numerous holes drilled in the side and placed in a hole dug into the ground can be used as a sump to collect seepage water. Use ground fault circuit interrupters on circuits or extension cords to reduce the risk of electrocution.

Disposing of Used Sand

Floodwater is generally considered as polluted, so sand from bags exposed to flood water should not be used for children’s sand boxes. It can be used for typical construction applications.

This material is based upon work supported by the National Institute of Food and Agriculture, U.S. Department of Agriculture, under Agreement No. 2009-41210-05965.

The NDSU Extension Service does not endorse commercial products or companies even though reference may be made to tradenames, trademarks or service names.

NDSU encourages you to use and share this content, but please do so under the conditions of our Creative Commons license. You may copy, distribute, transmit and adapt this work as long as you give full attribution, don’t use the work for commercial purposes and share your resulting work similarly. For more information, visit http://www.ag.ndsu.edu/agcomm/creative-commons.

For more information on this and other topics, see: www.ag.ndsu.edu

AE-626 (Revised), February 2011

Flood Protection with Sandbags.pdf

[Semper]

It is a science - not applied in Thailand

Are you surprised? BTW. interesting article.

[Fookhaht]

OK, now for a translation to Thai so I can give this to the village fathers? I think their sandbag dikes violated every single guideline in the article. And, of course the village flooded anyway (waters seeping right through the dikes or toppling them over). You'd think with a village flooding every year, there would be some expertise built up in this science at the local level. Apparently not.

If we had a translation of this in Thai, I'd photocopy it and have it distributed anonymously to all the sandbag sites, and the local city hall. Wouldn't dare hand it over myself, as everyone knows a farang can't give advice to those who insist it must be done "The Thai Way."

[robanywhere]

OK, now for a translation to Thai so I can give this to the village fathers? I think their sandbag dikes violated every single guideline in the article. And, of course the village flooded anyway (waters seeping right through the dikes or toppling them over). You'd think with a village flooding every year, there would be some expertise built up in this science at the local level. Apparently not.

If we had a translation of this in Thai, I'd photocopy it and have it distributed anonymously to all the sandbag sites, and the local city hall. Wouldn't dare hand it over myself, as everyone knows a farang can't give advice to those who insist it must be done "The Thai Way."

FloodTip_Sandbag_TH.pdf

[BKKdreaming]

Here is a shorter one

http://ladpw.org/wmd/homeowners/sandbags.cfm

but interesting that this one says

1 Sandbags will not seal out water.

2 Sand and soil filled burlap sandbags deteriorate when exposed for several months to continued wetting and drying. If bags are placed too early, they may not be effective when needed.

3 Sandbags are basically for low-flow protection (up to 2 feet). Protection from higher flows require a more permanent type of structure.

so even the "experts" do not agree !

[Fookhaht]

OK, now for a translation to Thai so I can give this to the village fathers? I think their sandbag dikes violated every single guideline in the article. And, of course the village flooded anyway (waters seeping right through the dikes or toppling them over). You'd think with a village flooding every year, there would be some expertise built up in this science at the local level. Apparently not.

If we had a translation of this in Thai, I'd photocopy it and have it distributed anonymously to all the sandbag sites, and the local city hall. Wouldn't dare hand it over myself, as everyone knows a farang can't give advice to those who insist it must be done "The Thai Way."

Khop Khun Krab!

[vediovis]

I regret this very good article wasn't posted before. Someone could print it and try to give it to a maximum of concerned people, it would have been great help for a lot of volunteers or people simply trying to protect their house. Now it's quite late as the barriers are already tentatively constructed...

[gennisis]

I regret this very good article wasn't posted before. Someone could print it and try to give it to a maximum of concerned people, it would have been great help for a lot of volunteers or people simply trying to protect their house. Now it's quite late as the barriers are already tentatively constructed...

Properly laid sandbags will certainly provide a barrier to the ensuing water....but..after seeing last night on TV the 'Bags' of large stones being laid,I cant see the reasoning for them....with large spaces between the stones the water will simply go through,although at a reduced rate I suppose. The filling of these net bags and transportation must be an expensive process. I know such barriers are used on beaches to 'break' the force of the waves but as a waterproof barrier I just cant see it.

[Fookhaht]

I regret this very good article wasn't posted before. Someone could print it and try to give it to a maximum of concerned people, it would have been great help for a lot of volunteers or people simply trying to protect their house. Now it's quite late as the barriers are already tentatively constructed...

Properly laid sandbags will certainly provide a barrier to the ensuing water....but..after seeing last night on TV the 'Bags' of large stones being laid,I cant see the reasoning for them....with large spaces between the stones the water will simply go through,although at a reduced rate I suppose. The filling of these net bags and transportation must be an expensive process. I know such barriers are used on beaches to 'break' the force of the waves but as a waterproof barrier I just cant see it.

I think the proper answer to your post is buried in your post. The news articles said that the "bags of large stones" were to reduce the rate of flow of flood waters, not to "waterproof" downstream.

[manarak]

Remove ice and snow since it will melt permitting water to flow under the dike.

I think they got that part right.