Redshirts beating a Buddhist monk in Nonthaburi [video]

[wolf5370]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Where's the evidence for that?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Buddhist scriptures for a start. They explicityly forbit politics

They do not explicitly forbid asking people to stop fighting and stop damaging things that do not belong to them though do they. You have not even a shed of evidence (nor decency as it appears) and say anything to try and make a group of thugs that even the Redest of members should be denouncing!

[scorecard]

<script type='text/javascript'>window.mod_pagespeed_start = Number(new Date());</script>

Yingluck's peacefull supporters at it again Chalerm will say only they were acting .

Yingluck! Is she still around, haven't seen any reports of her presence or any work to get the farmers paid for at least a week or more.

[xminator]

The yellow armchair brigade raises their flags and fail to read the text.

[wolf5370]

The yellow armchair brigade raises their flags and fail to read the text.

So your logic is that anyone that is disgusted at such events such as a street full of young and middle aged thugs kicking and punching an elderly monk to the ground and wrenching away his alms bowl, must be Yellow. Wow! What does this say for your idea of what the Reds are then? Such an dreadful indictment from you on them!

Personally I would suggest anyone disgusted about this or any such beatings, are normal, well adjust, human beings - those that are not are sociopathic to say the least.

[sweatalot]

This behaviour - this group has to end

[Pimay1]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Thank you for the personal information about this man. How long have you known him? Does he happen to live in the same village as you? How long has he been faking it that he is a monk?

[chotthee]

redshirt scum....anyone going to defend that...

I must be color blaind.

Look like BLACK shirt to me.

Red Shirts were told to wear black to mourn the decision to annul the election. It is not about dress code, but gang membership!

Can I apply on-line?

[Bluespunk]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Wrong on all counts.

[binjalin]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Wrong on all counts.

Right on all counts - not a monk's business and 'impolite'? is THAT a monk's business too? stay out of politics and concentrate on 'betterment'

[northernjohn]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Where's the evidence for that?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Buddhist scriptures for a start. They explicityly forbit politics

Have you some sort of crossed wires or you just plain don't know anything? One or the other which is it? This was not about politics on the Monks side he was trying to stop wanton violence. I do believe that is an OK for a Monk to do. Perhaps you can quote the Buddhist writings where monk is never to try to stop wanton destruction. Are you also posting as rich teacher. Same lack of knowledge.

It was defiantly political on the red shirt side. they were trying to prevent people with different political views than them from legally expressing them. They did it in the only way they know how violently. Well that could be debatable they might have been paid to do it.

Incidentally 0 wise one how do you disrobe a monk if he is not a monk?

[northernjohn]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Wrong on all counts.

Right on all counts - not a monk's business and 'impolite'? is THAT a monk's business too? stay out of politics and concentrate on 'betterment'

Sanctioning violence is against Buddhist teachings he did what a good Monk would he spoke out against it. You know as little of Buddhism as you do democracy.

[BeforeTigers]

Dude. Craziest headline of the month.
And an crazy awesome photo to go with it.
Now we're talkin.

[Rich teacher]

Have you some sort of crossed wires or you just plain don't know anything? One or the other which is it? This was not about politics on the Monks side he was trying to stop wanton violence. I do believe that is an OK for a Monk to do. Perhaps you can quote the Buddhist writings where monk is never to try to stop wanton destruction. Are you also posting as rich teacher. Same lack of knowledge.

'Wanton violence'...seems like you are the one with a 'lack of knowledge' as the article has no mention of violence before the monk began 'berating them for their actions and making other impolite remarks'

[dutchisaan]

This so called monk "approached the Redshirts before berating them for their actions and making other impolite remarks". Where in the monk's code of conduct does it allow berating and making impolite remarks. Reports of monks molesting children, selling drugs, etc. are commonplace in Thailand. This monk was not acting like a monk & therefore was not treated like a monk. I suppose he was a monk from the Luang Pu Issara school of monk hood, i.e. leading a heavily armed group of terrorists to break the law on a daily basis.

So what you are saying that because he was not behaving like a monk than it is ok to beet the sh*t out of him? And where do you get the information that he is a member of a terrorist group?

Sent from my iPad using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

The PDRC have been regularly beating up people, tying them up, throwing them in rivers, .... Buddhists know well that monks get respect because of their commitment to living withing the code of conduct for a monk. Once they step outside that they are looked on with disdain and seen as bringing the monkhood into disrepute, which unfortunately happens often. As with Luang Pu this man's robes are no excuse for his behaviour.

"8. Give up harsh speech, speak words that are devoid of blame and criticism"

"a monk should not be actively involved in partisan politics, which is within the sphere of lay people. At the most a monk may exercise his citizen’s right to vote wisely in the General Elections. If monks actively engage in partisan politics, it will endanger the Sangha (community of monks)."

SUPERB post highlighting the obvious

monks stick with monk-hood - what a disgrace!

I think the disgrace is your reaction to this post by defending these red tugs.

Sent from my iPad using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

[Dogmatix]

I hope the monk has filed charges against his assailants. It shouldn't be too difficult for the police to identify some of them from the video. The red shirts are using the copy book of the former military junta in Burma by attacking Buddhist monks who oppose them peacefully. If it was only one red shirt, he would have run away from the monk. They need a dog pack with hand guns sticking out of their waste belts to feel brave enough to attack a monk. What scum.

Edited March 24, 2014 by Dogmatix

[metisdead]

A contentious post early on in the topic has now been removed as well as the replies. Inflammatory posts have been removed

[siamtwin]

Ditto PBI hopefully.

Sent from my iPhone using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

[irishsmile]

Savage backward uneducated morons! Enough said....

[Just1Voice]

Over the past 6 years, due to circumstances, I've met quite a few of the men in saffron, and can honestly say that I have little to no respect for them. They wouldn't know Buddhism if it slapped them in the face. I'm sure there are some "real" ones out there, I just haven't met them yet.

However, that aside, there is no sense whatsoever for this kind of assault by a mob. Totally uncalled for, and I hope the perpetrators are caught and punished, but I won't hold my breath for that to happen,

[chiangmaiman99]

Last year some school kids dressed like Nazi's, this year some adults act like them.

[Morch]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Where's the evidence for that?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

Buddhist scriptures for a start. They explicityly forbit politics

You're going about it the wrong way. He was beat up by red shirts, ergo not a monk, etc.

There's a certain logic to it: Open your mouth - get beat up, blow a whistle - win a warning grenade.

Speaking of applying logic....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lu5_5Od7WY

Edited March 24, 2014 by Morch

[kannot]

Sickening. I hope this video goes viral all over the world. and bring shame to the perpetrators. They need to realize that this kind of behavior is unacceptable and is not going to solve anything.

Whether u approve or not , violence solves everything, just look at history

[stano1965]

Get someone to translate the conversations and you will see this has nothing to do with politics.

Sent from my iPhone using Thaivisa Connect Thailand

[whybother]

He is not a monk, just a yellow shirt ruining the name of Buddhism, playing politics and wearing a yellow robe. An absolute disgrace.

He shouldnt be beaten though, he should be disrobed, named and shamed.

Wrong on all counts.

Right on all counts - not a monk's business and 'impolite'? is THAT a monk's business too? stay out of politics and concentrate on 'betterment'

Being beaten up for being "impolite"! Is that what you subscribe to? That's as pathetic as Rich Teacher.

[petedk]

<script type='text/javascript'>window.mod_pagespeed_start = Number(new Date());</script>

Yingluck's peacefull supporters at it again Chalerm will say only they were acting .

Yingluck! Is she still around, haven't seen any reports of her presence or any work to get the farmers paid for at least a week or more.

Yes, she's still around.

I just saw a photo of her at the place she belongs ......... the rubbish dump in Samut Prakarn

[Loles]

Tha facts:

- if you are alone don't <deleted> with idiot mob (red or yellow all the same)

- the police officers worked well they managed to avoid bigger problem

- the monks are devalued in TH I can understand whether why

- Thais never feel emberassed if have to bit one person by 2000 idiots.

Edited March 24, 2014 by metisdead
Profanity

[rhythmworx]

The video would have been fun if he was a nam pai chuan monk.

[bigehitewarrior]

redshirt scum....anyone going to defend that...

Actually, there are a number of low-life's that like to troll on here that will probably; soon as they set up a new account.

I was thinking the same thing. You know it's coming. No excuse ever for rat packing a Monk. They get all pumped up about beating an old peace loving man. There is a special place in Hell for all those scumbags. They just better hope if I am there I am not their pitboss.

I like to second that one ...how disgraceful ...

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

[lungmi]

Yes,I was baby monk in Thailand.

But now I stay in a Buddhist Wat as grassroots doctor with traditional medicin.

I know the Vinaya (monks rule), Pali and theTeaching of the Buddha.

This monk did what he had to do!

[Mr Yim]

Unfortunately this is what happens when a minority attempt to impose their will on the majority. Many of us has been saying that the end game would be a red shirt back lash since practically the start of the anti-democracy protests. Unless the Army acts and removes Sutheps mob, it is likely to get a lot worse. As for the incident itself, it is very sad to see a monk being attacked, but those of us who have lived here long enough, know that when violence starts, ethics completely go out the window. Crikey I have seen videos of half a dozen men and women kicking a young woman when she is on the floor. Luckily the monk seems ok. But really monks should not be involved in demonstrations, it is playing with fire.