EU snubs Poland by keeping Tusk in top post

[webfact]

EU snubs Poland by keeping Tusk in top post

By Gabriela Baczynska and Alastair Macdonald

REUTERS

 

European Council President Donald Tusk (R) speaks with Luxembourg's Prime Minister Xavier Bettel at the EU summit Brussels, Belgium, March 9, 2017. REUTERS/Yves Herman

 

BRUSSELS (Reuters) - The leaders of the European Union delivered a withering snub to Poland's right-wing government on Thursday by steamrolling its objections and reappointing former Polish premier Donald Tusk to chair their summits.

 

Tusk's successor as prime minister Beata Szydlo, acting on orders from her party boss and long-time Tusk adversary Jaroslaw Kaczynski, had vowed to stop him securing a second 30-month term. But the other 27 leaders wasted no time in moving to a cold-blooded vote in which she was the lone objector.

 

Warsaw portrayed the issue as one of fundamental principle, in which vital national interests had been ignored by a Brussels machine dominated by "German diktat". Its crushing defeat showed how far the biggest of the ex-communist states that joined the EU after the Cold War appears isolated, even in Eastern Europe.

 

The row, albeit driven by Polish domestic politics, clouded attempts at the meetings in Brussels on Thursday and Friday to forge a common front as Britain prepares to deliver its formal notice that it will exit the bloc in 2019.

 

Kaczynski said the vote showed the EU was run by Germany and was trampling on national interests: "If the EU does not abandon this road, it will be consigned to history," he said in Warsaw.

 

Hours after the vote on Tusk, Szydlo refused to sign off on the official record of summit "conclusions" -- a routine roundup of endorsements and exhortations on economic, immigration and foreign policies. It was signed by the other 27, however, and EU officials said Poland's rejection did not affect the outcome.

 

Szydlo had first tried to get the other leaders to postpone a decision on Tusk but found no backing. They gave her time to repeat her reasons for withholding her support, citing Tusk's criticism from Brussels of her government's policies - policies many in the EU see as a threat to democracy.

 

But Maltese Prime Minister Joseph Muscat, who holds the rotating EU chair, moved swiftly to record a 27-1 vote to reappoint the 59-year-old Tusk.

 

Tusk had left the room during the discussion and was clapped back in by all but Szydlo, according to people who were present. He will play a key role over the next two years in overseeing Brexit negotiations with London. Prime Minister Theresa May was attending her last summit before launching the process.

 

Tusk, who led a centrist government for seven years until 2014, offered an olive branch to Szydlo, telling the Council in broadcast comments that he would work with the leaders "without any exceptions - because I am committed to European unity".

 

He urged Warsaw to be "reasonable" and not "burn bridges" with EU allies and said he would work to avoid its "isolation".

 

EAST-WEST DIVIDE

 

The leaders will meet again on Friday, minus May, to prepare for a "unity" summit to be held in Rome on March 25, the 60th anniversary of the treaty that laid the EU's foundation.

 

The row with Poland has highlighted a deepening split between eastern members reluctant to cede new-found national freedoms to Brussels and the richer western states that want to deepen EU integration in the hope it can boost prosperity and security and thus stem the rise of Brexit-inspired eurosceptics.

 

Talk of a "multi-speed" Europe has intensified in recent months. Germany's Angela Merkel and other leaders say allowing willing states to pull closer together is crucial to the EU's survival, but wary easterners fear they could be left behind.

 

Tusk said leaders agreed to press ahead with free trade pacts despite "protectionist tendencies" elsewhere - a reference to concerns about new U.S. President Donald Trump.

 

They also pledged continued support - and possible EU and NATO membership - to Balkan states where they are worried about growing influence from Russia. 

 

The leaders also reviewed plans to curb illegal migration from Libya to Italy, as numbers crossing rise.

 

(Additional reporting by Lidia Kelly in Warsaw and Philip Blenkinsop, Waverly Colville, Jan Strupczewski, Francesco Guarascio, Julia Fioretti, Robert-Jan Bartunek, Alissa de Carbonnel, Elizabeth Piper, Jean-Baptiste Vey, Andreas Rinke, Noah Barkin and Farah Salih in Brussels; Editing by Noah Barkin and Mark Trevelyan)

 

-- © Copyright Reuters 2017-03-10

[daveAustin]

They don't listen, do they! Any and all protestations to the euro-machine continue to be swiftly countered. They are the true fascists; a bunch of elitist, Etonian-esque, I'm-alright-Jack, old farts. Yuck! Get out, Poland.

[ilostmypassword]

2 minutes ago, daveAustin said:

They don't listen, do they! Any and all protestations to the euro-machine continue to be swiftly countered. They are the true fascists; a bunch of elitist, Etonian-esque, I'm-alright-Jack, old farts. Yuck! Get out, Poland.

Given that the Poles receive massive subsidies from the EU, I doubt that they'll follow your advice.

[Baerboxer]

10 hours ago, ilostmypassword said:

Given that the Poles receive massive subsidies from the EU, I doubt that they'll follow your advice.

 

But isn't that part of the "multi-speed" philosophy Mrs, Merkel now dictates as EU policy? That the subsidies would be cut? 

 

Watch the Eastern nations leave once the gravy train stops. Germany, dragging France along with some others, sees the Eastern countries as a cheap source of labor and products. Hmmm. History certainly repeats.

[Saradoc1972]

On 3/10/2017 at 6:49 PM, Baerboxer said:

 

But isn't that part of the "multi-speed" philosophy Mrs, Merkel now dictates as EU policy? That the subsidies would be cut? 

 

Watch the Eastern nations leave once the gravy train stops. Germany, dragging France along with some others, sees the Eastern countries as a cheap source of labor and products. Hmmm. History certainly repeats.

Agree. I remember how we laughed about Helmut Kohl back here, and when running for a fifth term he definitely had overstayed his welcome. But in retrospect, he definitely had leadership qualities, subtlety, and certainly made sure he treated the smaller states in the EU, east or west, economically or geographically, with the necessary respect to forge and maintain a union of a host of very different nations. Merkel has developed some traits of megalomaniac despot in the last 4-5 years, and Poland will definitely be getting back at the hitherto so-perceived centre of gravity of the EU for this,