Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Thailand News and Discussion Forum | ASEANNOW

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chiang Rai cave: Nosy media faces flak for intrusive coverage of search operation

Featured Replies

Nosy media faces flak for intrusive coverage of search operation

By THE NATION

 

8aec4f25e7e1e92835f8bdeac06d55c2.jpeg

Media flocking at the Tham Luang Cave to report progress of the mission

 

THE MEDIA coverage of the rescue mission to find 12 missing boys and a football coach trapped in a Chiang Rai cave has come under severe public scrutiny, and also earned flak for possibly causing unnecessary difficulties for the search operation.
 

The News Broadcasting Council yesterday issued a statement asking fellow-reporters to remain within a safe boundary and not cause any inconvenience or interruption to the life-saving operation that began last Saturday.

 

Public criticism was strong after provincial governor Narongsak Osotthanakorn, who heads the search operation, asked the media not to try and blend in with rescuers attempting to get into the cave, for the sake of news. The governor said that for safety reasons the rescuers count the number of heads who enter and leave the cave. Reporters sneaking in without permission had caused confusion for the already stressed rescuers.

 

A well-known TV reporter, Thapanee Ietsrichai, who has been following the incident closely, was singled out for criticism. But she later denied the allegation, saying she had been with another unit searching for other entrances to the cave, and the operation allowed a couple of reporter teams to accompany them.

 

Earlier, Thapanee had faced criticism for allegedly blowing the cover of SEAL members assisting in the operation by showing their faces in a photograph and video clip posted to her social media accounts when their identity should have been hidden because of their secret security missions.

 

The media, especially in recent years, have fallen in the eyes of the public. Some among the public are starting to perceive reporters as aggressive go-getters, who are not considerate of victims or of people involved in difficult situations.

 

Since the situation at Tham Luang has unfolded and caught the public’s attention, all media have flocked to the scene with the hope of being able to broadcast live and report on the progress of the mission. However, because the media traffic could hamper Internet and telephone networks crucial to the rescue mission, the watchdog – National Broadcasting and Telecommunication Commission – asked reporters to take photos or short video clips so as to avoid any disruption to the rescue operation.

 

The public have given vent to their feelings online, accusing the media of giving more importance to their own gains over the humanitarian mission.

 

Besides major concerns about the media operation that might trouble the rescue mission, netizens also expressed worry over the media’s questions to the relatives of the missing footballers.

 

“I saw on the TV just now. A reporter asked the mother of one of the boys how she felt about the incident,” one comment on the popular online forum Pantip read. “I mean her boy is missing. How do you expect her to feel? What a stupid question.”

 

Netizens also expressed strong dissatisfaction over talk-show host Phakkapong Udomkayarak of the Channel 8 show “Joh Praden” (“Hitting the Point”) asking during a phone-in interview with the mother of a missing boy “if the boys had appeared in the parents’ dreams during these past days”.

 

The question is connected to the Thai superstition that dead people usually come in the dreams of their family to try to communicate. Members of the public censured the host for asking an inappropriate question that disheartened the parents while they still had hopes that the boys were alive in the cave.

 

Reacting to the criticism, Phakkapong apologised for asking the question of the mother. He posted a note on his Facebook page, saying he was sorry his question had made people uneasy.

 

Source: http://www.nationmultimedia.com/detail/national/30348925

 
thenation_logo.jpg
-- © Copyright The Nation 2018-06-29

 

  • Replies 39
  • Views 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • No media center, no operational room, no spokesman, no one in charge of whole operation. Totally chaos. Pray for the kids. 

  • As I pointed out in another related thread, it took over two weeks to locate the 33 missing Chilean miners in 2010. That was in a man-made, deep hole in the ground that had multiple known points of ac

  • Expatthailover
    Expatthailover

    Tragic event pounced on by the unhappy brigade. Amazing how many on here are using every opportunity to either criticise the thai rescue efforts, thai politicians for being there and thai people

Posted Images

It's a bandwagon that the media and various "vip's" are jumping on when the only priority is finding these kids.

  • Popular Post

No media center, no operational room, no spokesman, no one in charge of whole operation. Totally chaos. Pray for the kids. 

11 minutes ago, Eric Loh said:

No media center, no operational room, no spokesman, no one in charge of whole operation. Totally chaos. Pray for the kids. 

You would think that any of the handful of Thai military officers that are supposed to leading the rescue effort would have had basic emergency response training (with the exception of the Pokémon Go! Brigade that is (below)). 

Edit: just read that an unknown number of rescuers victim of electrical leak. 

Hoping that this rescue effort doesn't turn into one giant tragedy.  

unnamed.jpg

Edited by InfinityandBeyond
Amendment

7 minutes ago, InfinityandBeyond said:

You would think that any of the handful of Thai military officers that are supposed to leading the rescue effort would have had basic emergency response training (with the exception of the Pokémon Go! Brigade that is (below)). 

Edit: just read that an unknown number of rescuers victim of electrical leak. 

Hoping that this rescue effort doesn't turn into one giant tragedy.  

unnamed.jpg

Almost a week since the alert was sounded and I am still wondering who and which Organisation is in charge. It’s the governor or the Interior Minister Anupong. Who is coordinating all the foreign teams who seem to be doing their own thing. By far the military should be in charge as they are better trained and not the governor. I can imagine the chaos there with various uncoordinated teams and equipments and not forgetting the crowd, families and those there for the optic. Who is controlling the crowd? Why the government not stepping up and take control of the situation. Pray for the kids. 

26 minutes ago, Eric Loh said:

No media center, no operational room, no spokesman, no one in charge of whole operation.

So you've been there and checked it out? Or are you hoovering up your 'insights' from the local media?

 

16 minutes ago, InfinityandBeyond said:

You would think that any of the handful of Thai military officers that are supposed to leading the rescue effort would have had basic emergency response training

You have evidence that they are devoid of 'basic emergency response training'? Do you have some recommended reading for us?

3 minutes ago, NanLaew said:

So you've been there and checked it out? Or are you hoovering up your 'insights' from the local media?

 

You have evidence that they are devoid of 'basic emergency response training'? Do you have some recommended reading for us?

Are you saying things are going according to plan and they have found the whereabouts of the kids? You see any progress after almost a week? Or you there to see progress? What insight you got. Please share. 

  • Popular Post

unfortunately thai media is not the best, they lack the incentive to report facts instead of their own made up crap and are more interested in promoting themselves. They have no idea of the requirements of the jobs they are doing at all, showing faces of the US seals is a good example, any trained journo knows that is a no no. If they were capable of sticking to the facts and researching their stories a lot better we might see an improvement but I doubt it, that isnt as exciting as the made up crap they do

Who allowed them into a cave system in the Rainey season, is this just another lapse of caring which is huge in Thailand, really hope they find the boys etc alive and well!

 

Sent from my SM-G610F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app

 

 

 

 

  • Popular Post
56 minutes ago, Eric Loh said:

Are you saying things are going according to plan and they have found the whereabouts of the kids? You see any progress after almost a week? Or you there to see progress? What insight you got. Please share. 

As I pointed out in another related thread, it took over two weeks to locate the 33 missing Chilean miners in 2010. That was in a man-made, deep hole in the ground that had multiple known points of access and ventilation as well as known dimensions and depths. Two weeks.

 

I have no insight except for a good handle on exploration geophysics, experience of working in jungles, the resilience of kids and an appreciation of human nature. But for every single loathsome person here sneering at the locals for hoping and praying for their loved ones, there's at least two others who are simply hell-bent on bashing the locals for apparently being unable to respond fast enough. Notably, they tack on their wishes for a successful rescue almost as an afterthought... but only after making facile and irrelevant comments and stupid suggestions first. Thus the well-wishing comes across as grossly insincere.

 

This is an event that is so infrequent, so remote and so dynamically changing due to the rain, even the best equipped rescue divers, engineers and military would be challenged to address it any faster.

28 minutes ago, Badrabbit said:

Who allowed them into a cave system in the Rainey season, is this just another lapse of caring which is huge in Thailand, really hope they find the boys etc alive and well!

 

Sent from my SM-G610F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app

 

It is NOT 'another lapse of caring' and thus it is not 'huge in Thailand.'

 

Here's one for you, cultural ignorance. google it.

 

Thanks for slipping in the good wishes at the end though... much appreciated.

I get sick of everyone complaining. 

Without the media we wouldn't even know about this situation. We are all holding onto our seats waiting for news. Any news. People use the media when it suits their purpose and abuse the media when it doesn’t. 

Everyone up there is under immense pressure from all around. The kids probably can't be saved. 

It's done. 

I get sick of everyone complaining. 
Without the media we wouldn't even know about this situation. We are all holding onto our seats waiting for news. Any news. People use the media when it suits their purpose and abuse the media when it doesn’t. 
Everyone up there is under immense pressure from all around. The kids probably can't be saved. 
It's done. 
There is always hope! more than 20yrs in the emergency services makes you never give up, cave rescues are incredibly difficult in good conditions let alone heavy rains, good luck to all who are searching for the boys etc!

Sent from my SM-G610F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app

Just now, Badrabbit said:

There is always hope! more than 20yrs in the emergency services makes you never give up, cave rescues are incredibly difficult in good conditions let alone heavy rains, good luck to all who are searching for the boys etc!

Sent from my SM-G610F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app
 

Bless. 

7 minutes ago, Badrabbit said:

There is always hope! more than 20yrs in the emergency services makes you never give up, cave rescues are incredibly difficult in good conditions let alone heavy rains, good luck to all who are searching for the boys etc!

Sent from my SM-G610F using Thailand Forum - Thaivisa mobile app
 

Glad my life's not hanging on for the negative belief of some posters. 

Until such times as the

outcome is known, these kids are still alive. 

28 minutes ago, NanLaew said:

It is NOT 'another lapse of caring' and thus it is not 'huge in Thailand.'

Non sequitur.

 

It... does... not... follow. Poor argument. False equivalence.

2 hours ago, Eric Loh said:

Almost a week since the alert was sounded and I am still wondering who and which Organisation is in charge. It’s the governor or the Interior Minister Anupong. Who is coordinating all the foreign teams who seem to be doing their own thing. By far the military should be in charge as they are better trained and not the governor. I can imagine the chaos there with various uncoordinated teams and equipments and not forgetting the crowd, families and those there for the optic. Who is controlling the crowd? Why the government not stepping up and take control of the situation. Pray for the kids. 

I love this country. However, someone the other day on one of the far-too-many threads going on this story commented that he's always impressed that Thais always seem to band together to help each other. And, while that's true, emergencies like this also expose their predisposition to disorganization and chaos and poor coordination.

 

I can imagine that when a society is largely organized by and preoccupied with power hierarchy, it becomes difficult to discern, based on merit, who should be doing what in an emergency situation. 

 

Really hope they find these people! 

The problem is when people start whining about the media, now we get no news. 

13 minutes ago, KiwiKiwi said:

Non sequitur.

 

It... does... not... follow. Poor argument. False equivalence.

There is no such thing as "lack of caring" in Thailand. It is a non-Thai persons perception wrought of cultural ignorance.

 

Since lack of caring doesn't exist in Thailand, it cannot be "huge in Thailand."

 

That cultural ignorance stuff is a bit of a bugger eh?

1 minute ago, NanLaew said:

There is no such thing as "lack of caring" in Thailand. It is a non-Thai persons perception wrought of cultural ignorance.

 

Since lack of caring doesn't exist in Thailand, it cannot be "huge in Thailand."

 

That cultural ignorance stuff is a bit of a bugger eh?

 

It's still a non-sequitur, slice and dice it any way you want, the song remains the same, and I doubt you are qualified or authorised to declare that 'lack of caring doesn't exist in Thailand'.

 

Apart from those (possibly) fatal flaws, you seem to be pretty much on the money.

One wonders if the media backlash has anything to do with the farangs now watching and the recent uncovering of the electricity leaks. We know, the moat important thing here is protecting face. Just a thought. 

Meanwhile in the rest of the world 24000 people died today of hunger.....no media scrum for that abysmal figure.

2 minutes ago, AntDee said:

One wonders if the media backlash has anything to do with the farangs now watching and the recent uncovering of the electricity leaks. We know, the moat important thing here is protecting face. Just a thought. 

Well, as each day passes, the chances of this ending badly increases, so saving face might be the only thing that can possibly be saved in this situation.

4 minutes ago, kannot said:

Meanwhile in the rest of the world 24000 people died today of hunger.....no media scrum for that abysmal figure.

That's abstract to people. But you knew that already. 

A dramatic cave rescue attempt of a group of boys is a story people can get their heads around. 

Edited by Jingthing

  • Popular Post
2 hours ago, NanLaew said:

So you've been there and checked it out? Or are you hoovering up your 'insights' from the local media?

 

You have evidence that they are devoid of 'basic emergency response training'? Do you have some recommended reading for us?

Tragic event pounced on by the unhappy brigade.

Amazing how many on here are using every opportunity to either criticise the thai rescue efforts, thai politicians for being there and thai people for being..well thai. 

 

Edited by Expatthailover

Nosy PM, too!

28 minutes ago, Expatthailover said:

Tragic event pounced on by the unhappy brigade.

Amazing how many on here are using every opportunity to either criticise the thai rescue efforts, thai politicians for being there and thai people for being..well thai. 

 

 

 

 

Edited by AntDee

3 hours ago, Eric Loh said:

Are you saying things are going according to plan and they have found the whereabouts of the kids? You see any progress after almost a week? Or you there to see progress? What insight you got. Please share. 

And el no doubt you will twist and milk this sad situation as far as you possibly can. 

 

Not surprised.

 

Let's all hope there's some positive news very soon.

 

1 hour ago, greenchair said:

I get sick of everyone complaining. 

Without the media we wouldn't even know about this situation. We are all holding onto our seats waiting for news. Any news. People use the media when it suits their purpose and abuse the media when it doesn’t. 

Everyone up there is under immense pressure from all around. The kids probably can't be saved. 

It's done. 

Sorry to disagree, well no, I'm not sorry, reporters and the vast majority of television so called reporters are people I wouldn't give light in a dark corner.

37 minutes ago, overherebc said:

Sorry to disagree, well no, I'm not sorry, reporters and the vast majority of television so called reporters are people I wouldn't give light in a dark corner.

This case really needed international attention. 

The 3 brit had valuable information. It's an honourable and dangerous job. Every year journalists are being imprisoned and killed trying to bring news for you. 

Have some respect. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.