Antisemitism in Ireland ‘Blatant and Obvious’ Says Former Cabinet Minister Alan Shatter

[Social Media]

 

In the ever-changing landscape of international relations, few areas are as complex and nuanced as the relationship between Ireland and Israel. Recently, this relationship has come under increasing scrutiny, with allegations of antisemitism and political tensions dominating the discourse.

 

At the heart of this debate is the outspoken voice of Alan Shatter, a former member of parliament and Minister for Justice, Equality, and Defense in Ireland. Shatter, a prominent figure within Ireland's Jewish community, has been a vocal supporter of Israel throughout his political career. However, he now finds himself at the center of a heated debate over the state of Irish-Israeli relations.

 

Shatter's concerns about the rise of antisemitism in Ireland are not unfounded. In recent months, he has observed a worrying trend towards hostility towards Israel, culminating in what he describes as the "most hostile state towards Israel in the entire EU." This shift in attitudes, Shatter argues, is driven by a combination of factors, including political alliances, historical ties, and a growing trend towards anti-Israel sentiment in Irish society.

 

One of the key factors contributing to this hostility is the close relationship between Sinn Fein, a nationalist political party in Ireland, and Palestinian militant groups such as Hamas. Sinn Fein's support for the Palestinian cause has led to a normalization of anti-Israel rhetoric within Irish politics, with calls for boycotts and diplomatic sanctions becoming increasingly common.

 

However, the issue goes beyond mere political posturing. Shatter highlights the pervasive influence of anti-Israel sentiment in Irish society, with universities, media outlets, and public figures all contributing to a culture of hostility towards the Jewish state. This, he argues, has led to a climate of fear and intimidation for those who dare to speak out in support of Israel.

 

But perhaps the most troubling aspect of this debate is the lack of understanding and empathy for the Jewish community in Ireland. Despite their long history in the country, Jews in Ireland are increasingly marginalized and ostracized, with their concerns often dismissed or ignored by the political establishment.

 

Shatter's own experiences are a testament to this. Once a prominent figure in Irish politics, he now finds himself marginalized and vilified for his support of Israel. His attempts to raise awareness of antisemitism in Ireland have been met with hostility and indifference, reflecting a broader trend of apathy towards the plight of the Jewish community.

 

As Ireland grapples with these complex issues, there are no easy solutions. The rise of antisemitism and anti-Israel sentiment poses a significant challenge to the country's reputation as a beacon of tolerance and diversity. If left unchecked, it threatens to undermine the values of inclusivity and respect that Ireland holds dear.

 

Ultimately, the future of Irish-Israeli relations will depend on the willingness of both sides to engage in honest and open dialogue. Only by confronting the issues head-on and addressing the root causes of hostility can Ireland and Israel hope to build a more positive and constructive relationship moving forward.

 

14.03.24

Source

 

[Neeranam]

Nonsense, it's not antisemitism. If Israel was predominantly rastafarian or Sikh, the world would still despise what they are doing. 

Anti Israel is not antisemitism. 

[jak2002003]

Yep. It's any Isreal concerning the war on Palistine. It's not about being anti Jewish people who live in Ireland. 

 

 

[Nick Carter icp]

2 hours ago, Neeranam said:

Nonsense, it's not antisemitism. If Israel was predominantly rastafarian or Sikh, the world would still despise what they are doing. 

Anti Israel is not antisemitism. 

 

   I really do not think that it would.

Where are all the World street protests against Myanmar ?

Myanmar did worse things than Israel did , as did numerous other Countries 

[thaibeachlovers]

On 3/14/2024 at 11:21 AM, Social Media said:

One of the key factors contributing to this hostility is the close relationship between Sinn Fein, a nationalist political party in Ireland, and Palestinian militant groups such as Hamas. Sinn Fein's support for the Palestinian cause has led to a normalization of anti-Israel rhetoric within Irish politics, with calls for boycotts and diplomatic sanctions becoming increasingly common.

Indeed. Given that israeli oppression and land theft in Palestine echoes the Irish experience with the English occupation and oppression, it's not surprising that the Irish support Palestinians.

 

It's not anti semitic, despite desperate attempts to claim it so by certain individuals, it's anti zionist.

 

I hope that Ireland boycotts israel and imposes sanctions if the US continues to cover for israel in the UN.

[retarius]

Allan Shatter indeed. I bet he had a nice time at boarding school with that name.

When I lived there, there was no antisemitism that I saw, or heard or otherwise witnessed. Jews weren't a factor in anything. I think in the 50 and early 60s when the Church ran everything in Ireland, Jews might have had a hard time. The only place known for a jewish Community was Cork as far as I know. 

[beautifulthailand99]

They fought an anti-colonial struggle to get the colonists from their land. They support the underdog. Haganah widely admired the IRA terror campaign against the British and made linkages with them during WW2. Indeed, Haganah terrorist later PM Menachem Begin had Michael Collins as his password !

 

https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2003/may/23/guardianletters