Jump to content
Essential Maintenance Nov 28 :We'll need to put the forum into "Under Maintenance" mode from 9 PM to 1 AM (approx).GMT+7

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'd like to buy a portable hard drive in Bangkok (the one that powered by a USB lead not the one with its own power source. I dont need too much space 300 Gig or 500 Gig would be enough as I don't want to put too much stuff on one drive in case it malfunctions. Can anybody suggest a cheap to mid ranged product, how much it is and where I can acquire one? Thanks

Posted

Hi, any IT mall with have them. Where are you in BKK? You can get 300 but might as well go for 750 or so, just a couple hundred Baht more. Should cost you a couple thousand Baht tops.

Posted

My experience with the USB powered units is that they work when hooked directly to my computer, but not when hook to a powered hub. (The hub has it's own power cord to plug into the wall.)

That might just be my hub, but it's worth knowing that when I got my first one, I thought it was defective until I tried moving it from the hub to the computer.

Posted (edited)

My experience with the USB powered units is that they work when hooked directly to my computer, but not when hook to a powered hub. (The hub has it's own power cord to plug into the wall.)

That might just be my hub, but it's worth knowing that when I got my first one, I thought it was defective until I tried moving it from the hub to the computer.

I'm also some electrical engineer

this can cause mainly by 2 reasons

1: the power cord you plug into the wall (I call a power supply.) not have enough current(Amp) capability.

2. cause by internal electrical characteristic of hub.

reason 1 is easy to understand.

What interesting is reason 2.

When you buy a USB hub you think it'd be better if the hub can also take power from external adapter right?

but it has cons

The hub with external adapter slot has no switch for user to select which power source to use (from USB or from external source)

instead it'll select for you automatically (ease of use)

The problem is in the component they use to make it switch automatically.

Actually it's just diode. all type of diode introduce voltage drop. Silicon one would drop around 0.5~1 V.

The diode type using in USB hub usually be low voltage drop one called "Schottky diode".

Although Voltage drop across Schottky diode is small the output voltage is guarantee to less than 5 V

(It also depend on quality of diode.) that why some device may not work with this type of hub.

(USB hub that can't take power from external source doesn't have this diode.)

.

poor PCB design in USB hub can cause problem too; as the current flow to control harddisk's motor can interfere with data signal. (D+, D-)

Edited by HaveFun

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Announcements




×
×
  • Create New...