Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have not heard or read that there has been agressive interrogations for some days now.

Why did they do those interrogations in so aggressive manner during last couple of weeks? In some cases the traveller even could not answer the questions because he was shouted at without no break. In most of the unclear cases it is enough to interview the person and ask whatever documents they want to see. In that way it is easy and fast to get lots of information from the interviewed person.

One reason may be that they tried to make interrogated person angry and then they have good reason to deny his entry because of threatening behavior against official. But why would they want to do that to a random tourist?

Several cases were reported where just very average tourist was grilled for longer time.

Of course there is also cases of overstayers, people with false documents etc. and then more harsh interrogation is understandable.

I hope immigration / border control has got new operational instructions now.

  • Replies 36
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

It's not the Spanish Inquisition you know!!..... You seem to like the word interrogate and its participles......

Posted

all my experiences with immigration have been quite cordial... including once when they followed me home and asked

me about smuggling. very polite and not, in any way, aggressive.

  • Like 1
Posted

Interrogations? For who? Reckon I have been in and out of Bangkok more than 50 times in the last 20 years and the only question I have ever gotten was 'where do you work?" Once.

Posted

They (the immigration officers) expect a truthful answer.

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Thaivisa Connect Thailand mobile app

The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place. — George Bernard Shaw

 

Posted

I seen a few reports of some people being asked about what they were doing here. They have the right to do that.

I don't recall any that described the questioning being aggressive.

Should not the OP post some specifics, date, place, circumstances - otherwise just a rumor.

Also I've noticed some of my own (US) countrymen when dealing with a language problem - seem to think loudness increases the other party's understandability. So they end up being twice wrong. coffee1.gif

  • Like 1
Posted

I can say i have been through thai immigration about 50 times and i have never had a problem.

actually compared to Canada and American customs in thailand they is a cake walk i can honestly say i have been pulled in to canada customs over a dozen times

ok sometimes they dont smile but that is ok because dealing with the people they deal with every day

Posted

I saw a guy getting a hard time at Chiangmai last week, but it was his own stupidity. He had not entered an address in Thailand on the arrival slip and claimed that even though he had been here many times, he did not know his gf's address. He was sent for "further questioning". The officers were only doing their job and I had absolutely no sympathy for him.

Posted

May be immigration officers got sore throat from shouting, so now they just speak

.

Well, the time before last when the Missus was doing my 90 day report at our local Immigration office, the imm. officer mentioned to her his throat was dry and she replied "it's because you talk too much and you talk too loud". He smiled and laughted.

Later in the afternoon when we helped a friend get his report done the officer called the Missus up to his desk to assist her as he was helping another falang. We were out of the office in a flash.

Posted

Last time I left Swampy I had 2 minutes of interrogation... Why did I have 3 Day overstat?

I explained for them that the immigration officer in Phisanoluke refused to give me a 7 day extension because it would be cheaper for me to pay for 3 day overstay!

I know it's not right, bit what should I do/say as it was the truth!

:P

  • Like 1
Posted

Ok I came in on May 22 via swampy no problems and I have over 75 in and outs over the last 3 1/2 years in my passport, this was via the express lane. A aussie friend of mine came in from Cambodia on May 23, very few people in line and he was asked many questions, and they where also checking and going through everyones luggage, threw out some of his prescription medications. He had a APEC card that was expired and the last 3 in and outs where visa exempt, he was questions like what are you doing here etc. etc., nothing rude or out of line but definetly more than the usual, but in country now.

Another Europen friend came in later same day with no problems not a single questions asked and he has quite a few in and outs in the last few years as well. So it looks hit or miss or just depends on your attitude or how polite your are, I once saw an immigration gal get very upset because some gal slammed her passport on the counter because she thought she had been waiting in line to long, those kind of actions and being loud or yelling at someone are considered rude in Thailand.

Also be easy on the Op's, these guys do there very best to give some of us good information, they willingly spend there time to share there experiance and knowledge!

Posted

Have to say I'm impressed with the responses to the obviously provocative O/P. I expected that there would be some further moaning from the usual whiner chorus who have something bad to say about anything & everything in Thailand.

Quite refreshing. And I agree with the majority. All my experiences with Immigrations have been positive. I know I wouldn't have the patience to deal with all the idiots they have to even for one day, let alone day after day.

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't belive the Immigration are agressive and shout at people without a break so they can't answer. People make up stories like this when they are angry or don't like the visa/extension of stay rules.

Posted

I seen a few reports of some people being asked about what they were doing here. They have the right to do that.

I don't recall any that described the questioning being aggressive.

Really ?? I have read multiple in the last few weeks.. The person given a hard time who had been out of the country for 7 months already described in detail how he was accused of working, the way he was spoken to shouted at etc etc..

  • Like 1
Posted

I seen a few reports of some people being asked about what they were doing here. They have the right to do that.

I don't recall any that described the questioning being aggressive.

Really ?? I have read multiple in the last few weeks.. The person given a hard time who had been out of the country for 7 months already described in detail how he was accused of working, the way he was spoken to shouted at etc etc..

Please post a link. I suspect it was just a rant from somebody. I also suspect he was the one that started the shouting.

Posted

Some weeks ago there was reports of long term hold up and questioning by immigration in this forum. I believe those cases were not all fabricated? But latetely no reports like that at all.

Normal fact checking and questioning is ok. In some cases it is good to be questioned, it makes clear what info is needed to prove everything is ok.

Thai newspapers tells that 90% of visa runners actually work illegally in Thailand. That news I dont believe. But many thais believe because it is from normally reliable news source. And maybe some immigration officials believe that news also?

I have not had problems with thai immigration. One year ago I was last time in Poipet. Immigrations on both sides were ok but the "fake immigration" offices were harrassing to visit this and that office and pay fees. I walked past and they walked after me.

Sorry for my english, I may have used wrong terminology. I will practice my english more by readint Pattaydailynews :-)

  • Like 1
Posted

It's not the Spanish Inquisition you know!!..... You seem to like the word interrogate and its participles......

Ah but no-one knows if it is or is not the Spanish Inquisition, because nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!

Their chief weapon is surprise...surprise and fear...fear and surprise.... Their two weapons are fear and surprise...and ruthless efficiency.... Their *three* weapons are fear, surprise, and ruthless efficiency...and an almost fanatical devotion to the Pope.... Their *four*...no... *Amongst* their weapons.... Amongst their weaponry...are such elements as fear, surprise..........

  • Like 1
Posted

As a frequent traveller all over the world, I've noticed there's something peculiar about Thailand wherein every person here seems to feel some kind of need to absolutely prove that they know more about Thailand than anyone else. And it's generally not true. Basically, if anyone has a slightly different experience than others, posters here just freak out with denials and accusations towards the OP. Here's one little fact about Thailand that seems to be missed by the 'experts' here at TV: Thai people are individuals, and individuals react differently than each other sometimes. Shocking, I know.

I can say that I've seen BOTH happen since the crackdown: Some people ARE being interrogated in a very harsh manner even when there is no real ciminal suggestion about them from their stats - and yes, that is unusual in Thailand. Other people on the same day, same line, virtualy identical in most ways are sailing right through with a smile, as usual.

Some officers in the crackdown do seem to be behaving very aggressively towards tourists you wouldn't normally expect to see get difficulty. One reasonable sounding man wrote of being detained for hours. Another with a child in his arms being only given 7 days instead of 30 days - many of those strories, actually. For my own example I entered Suwanabhumi (US passport) on May 8 and was totally shouted at by a female officer, and I was shocked. No, not 'entitled', and no I don't have dreadlocks and blah blah - I was just shocked because I've never seen a Thai person behave so angrily before. I'd been in Europe for 7 months, so it wasn't back to back. I've never worked in Thailand. But yes, I've also been here a ton on tourist visas / extrensions for 5 years. In my case, she spotted a very old overstay of a month from years ago (after clearly just looking for whatever she could), and zero'd in: all the things the OP stated: very aggressive, wouldn't wait a moment for answers, I was calm but she was clearly trying to goad me into losing my temper (which I never do with a Thai person, generally speaking). She was so angry and non stop I just eventuall gave up and stared at her as politely as I could. And yeah, she let me in. But it was a scary moment to be sure.

The next day, my friend from Canada also came through Sawanabhumi, and he said they were extra polite and welcoming. Similar number of times in Thailand over the years, etc. So, why me and not him? I don't know. We dress similarly, I'm probably a little more polite than him in truth. So...

I think the real answer is that some officers are getting incredibly aggressive at this time, and it's smart to be extra prepared, compared to the past. And others are the same as always somehow. I do think it's an unusual time in Thailand, despite many posters wanting to pretend otherwise. And I think that you kind of take your chances now when you encounter any agent. That's not paranoia, or an 'agenda' (the absurdity of posters here accusing anyone who disagrees with them of having 'an agenda'...talk about paranoid). The truth is that things in Thaialnd are not completely different, but not business as usual at this time. Be a little extra prepared, and have an exit plan ahead of every move, just in case.

  • Like 2
Posted

I also posted a report of a contact of mine who went to an Isaan immigration to get a tourist visa 30 day extension..

They grilled him over source of funds, told him (not asked) he was working here.. And finally gave him the extension but told him not to come back he couldnt have any more. Thats on a legit tourist visa at an immigration not a border.

I fail to see how that fits any of the 'this is only about visa stamps' 'this is only about border entries' statements at all.. Legit visa, extension here..

  • Like 1
Posted

I was not aware that Thai immigration officers new how to talk

Never heard thyey say a word, never been asked question and have come and gone over 100 times

A lady at lad prao did ask my Thai GF a question in Thai when we went for our last extension

Something to the effect "what kind of work does he do?" ...

they were just trying to trip us up, but that is part of their job

I guess the OP recently got rejected entrance to the kingdom for all the right reasons

Posted

For OP: "aggressive" <---- are u crazy ???

They just do their job. Do u think they are very kind people if they don't stop no-one? Man, it's time to wake up, and check around other countries immigration officers, like USA, Israel, etc.

One-time I was almost undressed to my pants under machine-gun points in Egypt/Israel border cause I had a solder-like short hair and they thought I'm a soldier.

I was in a diving trip in Egypt (Sinai half-island, Dahab) and just wanted to eat an ice-cream in Israel at Sunday. Was a mistaken plan.

Many people cry here about Thai immigration officers but they are kind and friendly above average.

Posted

To answer the query in Post #23 as to why his friend was better treated than he (without repeating the long post), most likely because:

Your friend was a Canadian traveling with a Tourist Visa isuued in Canada.

You were an American traveling with a Tourist Visa not issued in USA.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Topics

  • Popular Contributors

  • Latest posts...

    1. 0

      Thailand Live Monday 30 June 2025

    2. 36

      Bangkok's Formula One Ambitions Face Potential Financial Deficit

    3. 4

      Big Pharma and the Media are at it again - Pushing faulty tests and harmful drugs

    4. 54

      Greek Man Stricken by Mysterious Illness Left Without Treatment as Funds Run Dry in Rayong

    5. 25

      The US dollar is sinking like a rock

    6. 13

      New help measures for elderly people

  • Popular in The Pub

×
×
  • Create New...